PDA

View Full Version : I hate insurance companies, a question



Kenny_Z
08-29-2014, 07:56 PM
Nothing happened to the DeLorean. It's my daily driver. I was hit in the ear and shoved into another car. Both other cars in the wreck got off with scratches but my poor Monte Carlo lost a lot of body panels. They're hinting at totaling her. In fact my insurance said they are going to total her, take 1000 dollars from me in my deductible, and then take my car. The other driver admitted fault and I'm waiting to hear what they have to say about it.

https://31.media.tumblr.com/d0b410d858a3ce44fb9ffc4b067f187b/tumblr_naj3yejPUM1rdjq2mo1_1280.jpg
https://38.media.tumblr.com/a0d8500b740d6974ae6478e9641caa3f/tumblr_naj3yejPUM1rdjq2mo4_1280.jpg

First off, I understand she's an old car with 223k worth of miles on her. She's not worth a whole lot and these body panels aren't cheap. There is a minor impact behind the driver headlight. I get it. BUT, earlier this year I dumped a lot of money into this old girl and I drove her home. I've put about 100 miles on this car since the accident just taking her for the required estimates. I love this car. She's my favorite. I would sooner sell the DeLorean and Mustang than sell her. No joke. Alabama salvage laws are insane. I have to put up a bond just to get a license to fix this car. I had no idea I needed to put up a bond to bolt on a new hood. I'm surprised they didn't throw me in jail for stripping the paint off Red.

I'm thinking of telling both insurance companies that they should go take a long walk off a short pier. I don't want their money. I want my car. What am I facing if I width-drawl both claims and just fix her myself? I don't want someone knocking on my door down the road and saying my car is salvaged and I'm not allowed to drive her anymore.

Michael
08-29-2014, 09:20 PM
I didn't realize there was a deductible if the car was totaled. After all they are saying it's not worth fixing, so where does the deductible go?

No offense but did that car with that mileage even book for 1k? Let's say for the sake of argument it doesn't. If someone totals your 800.00 ride and you have a 1k deductible, do you give them 800 bucks AND your car leaving you with nothing but a 800.00 hole in your pocket?

DMCVegas
08-29-2014, 09:55 PM
If the other driver has admitted fault, you shouldn't have to pay a solitary dime to anyone. Their insurance will cover the damage/losses/etc. Now if you invoke your own insurance to cover these costs, THEN you'd pay the deductible.

Now what you can normally do is let them write-off the car, they pay you some cash, and then you can usually buy the vehicle back from them as salvage. Save for a salvage title, this isn't a bad proposition on a car that's worth some money. Like say they totaled the car & paid you $10K for it, and then you buy it back for $2,500. That leaves you with $7,500 and the car. Or perhaps in this case you could get maybe $2,500 for the car, and buy it bad for $500 or so. It just depends. This is something that you'll need to talk to the insurance adjuster about.

Question: How bad is the damage to the frame and supports in both the rear bottom & engine compartment?

Also, even if it has a salvage title, you can still get that either removed or converted to a Rebuilt Title.

NightFlyer
08-29-2014, 10:12 PM
First off - glad you're OK.

Second, sorry about your ride - I definitely feel the pain.

Question - if the other driver is admitting fault, then why did you make a claim with your insurance company at all? Last I was aware, Alabama is an at-fault state, thus the driver who admitted to fault would be 100% liable for your damages. You'd only make a claim against their insurance policy, if they have auto insurance, and you wouldn't be subjected to a deductible at all.

I suppose that you'd make a claim with your insurance company if you had the car comprehensively insured for a declared value because of the sentimental value that the car holds for you, and were intending to use the proceeds from that claim to supplement the compensation received from the at fault party (though you can pursue the full value of the car to you, and not just the fair market or replacement value of the car, against the at fault party / their insurer - but judges/juries tend not to award much over the stated fair market/replacement value of the car and any modifications/customizations, should they contest your claim).

Of course, the only other reason you'd make a claim against your own comprehensive policy is if the at fault driver doesn't have insurance and is otherwise nonrecoverable (even if you obtained a judgment against them, you'd probably never successfully collect on that judgment).

However, whenever any insurance company inspects and assess the damages to a car, they're legally required to report their asserted condition of the car to the state.

You can withdraw your claims and keep the car, after all, it's still your property. But if they've already assessed/inspected the car, that won't stop them from having to report their asserted condition of the vehicle to the state, thus you're still going to have to deal with the state in being able to get it legally registered again after you repair it.

Even if you pursue a claim with at least one company, and they total it, you can usually buy the car back from the insurance company that takes title upon paying the claim - they'll sell it to you for salvage value (ex: I bought back a '95 Cadillac Eldorado that was hit by a school bus and totaled for $700).

Usually you can contest the reported condition with the state, but it's usually a long and frustrating bureaucratic process.

Or you can file the bond and jump their all their hoops - you'll get the bond money back eventually.

If you wanted to keep the car without the ramifications to the status of the title, then you shouldn't have submitted any claims to any insurance companies.

Probably not what you wanted to hear, but the best answers I have for you.

Best luck :thumbup:

NightFlyer
08-29-2014, 10:17 PM
If the other driver has admitted fault, you shouldn't have to pay a solitary dime to anyone. Their insurance will cover the damage/losses/etc.

Doesn't work that way in no-fault states, unfortunately....

David T
08-29-2014, 11:07 PM
Doesn't work that way in no-fault states, unfortunately....

No-Fault ONLY applies to bodily injury NOT to property damage. If the other driver is at fault 100% your insurance company pays you what your car books at less the deductible. Your insurance company is *supposed* to collect from the other driver's company and if the other driver is indeed 100% at fault his company pays your company the FULL amount. If and when your company gets the full amount they are *supposed* to give you the deductible. As for the car, in States where they have Salvage Titles, once the insurance company totals the car the Title is remarked Salvage. In those States you can no longer register and legally drive that car on public roads. Some States have procedures where you can fix the car and request they change the status of the Title but not all States allow that and it is not a sure thing. You can fix the car up and maybe not be able to fix the Title. Your problem is the kind of insurance you had. It allows the insurance company to set the value according to the fine print. Makes you wonder what you were paying collision for? If the cost to repair is within 10% of the book value the car is theirs, they throw you some crumbs and you are out of a running car! Your only hope is to hire an attorney and sue the other driver. Even then the burden is on you to prove the value of your car. If it is old and high mileage don't waste your time or money.

Kenny_Z
08-29-2014, 11:15 PM
Question: How bad is the damage to the frame and supports in both the rear bottom & engine compartment?


The upper frame behind the headlight is pushed back about 3 inches thanks to the trailer hitch the front truck had. The bottom of the frame is unbent. The rear frame on the driver side has buckled slightly about 6 inches from the bumper mount. The car is still structurally sound and tracks down the road no differently than before. Other than the hood poking up you'd never know she was in an accident. It would have been easier if she had been damaged badly. I would have understood that I needed to let her go. This though, this is mostly cosmetic. A couple of replacement parts and a little time on a frame puller and she'll be back to normal.

Thanks Nightflyer, everyone involved was uninjured which is all you can really ask for. Everyone was telling me to talk to my insurance from the officer, guy that I got pushed into (who was an insurance rep for another company), and my father. If I knew then what I know now I wouldn't have called anyone. I also wouldn't have traveled down that road but hindsight is 20/20.

According to my insurance company the car is worth 2500 with about 5000 worth of damage. Subtracting the deductible leaves me with 1500, no car, and a fight to get my 1000 back from the other insurance company. I'm waiting to see what the other company says. I doubt it will be good news. I'm glad I have a couple of fall back cars. I could imagine trying to get a rental car from these companies would be like pulling teeth.

NightFlyer
08-29-2014, 11:44 PM
According to my insurance company the car is worth 2500 with about 5000 worth of damage. Subtracting the deductible leaves me with 1500, no car, and a fight to get my 1000 back from the other insurance company. I'm waiting to see what the other company says. I doubt it will be good news. I'm glad I have a couple of fall back cars. I could imagine trying to get a rental car from these companies would be like pulling teeth.

You have a legal obligation to use an alternative car if you have one reasonably available to you, as a part of mitigating your damages, which then prevents you from recovering the rental fees that you'd otherwise have to incur had you not had access to a spare/backup vehicle (and yeah, I fully agree that's a rip-off, but that's what it is). Only if you don't have reasonable availability to another vehicle are the insurance companies obligated to pay for a rental.

So, here's what I'd do if I were you:

1) Withdraw your claim with your insurance company - there's no reason for it.

2) Demand $5k from the at fault party (insurance company). If they reject your claim, file a small claims action against them - as they'll pay the money or you'll come to a satisfactory settlement, as they'll want to avoid having to expend funds in defense against such a small lawsuit.

3) Buy back the car from the at fault party's insurance company for salvage value.

4) Do whatever's right for you in regards to the car.

djdogbone
08-30-2014, 02:42 AM
My mom was an agent for 30 years, the other insurance pays for everything if it's not your fault as you were not the cause of the accident. Call your local agent. Your agency should be perusing the other agency to pay 100% of damages PLUS.

Who is your insurance company?

Silverbullet
08-30-2014, 04:08 AM
Ok, I know how you feel.... but... If you have a car worth a $1000 and it is $5000 to fix it... you did not suffer a $5000 loss... the insurance will only pay up to the value of the car... You can take the $1000 and put $4000 of your own money to fix it... but it is not a good idea...
just how it works...

Craig

Bitsyncmaster
08-30-2014, 05:24 AM
It gets complicated when you get pushed into another vehicle. They try to say you were following to close. If it were just rear end damage it's no problem the driver behind is at fault. That driver will probably not claim responsibility after he learns how much his insurance goes up.

I got rear ended once making a fast stop for a school buss putting on it's flashing red lights. The young girl who hit me gets out of her car and her cell phone drops on the ground (guess what she was doing). My insurance company said they were paying my repair bill less my $500 deductible. I just said "bull shit, don't send the check" and I never heard or saw any kind of bill for the repair or the two weeks of rental car bills.

You have to be tough with your insurance company and let them know your going to fight.

Flicky
08-30-2014, 08:04 AM
Did they not give you the insurance information for the guy that hit you (the rear-ender)? Get the police report if you do not have his insurance info. Call them, tell them that their client damaged your car, refer them to the police report, then tell them that the damage was estimated at $5,000. They don't get to total your car...only your insurance gets to do that and that isn't applicable here. Once you do get a check DO NOT CASH IT until the repair is done and you are 100% happy with the work. The reason for this is that if more damage is found whilst they repair it and you have cashed the check it makes for an acceptance and then if you have to sue getting your attorney fees back is very hard (you would have to prove them negligent).

More than likely the guy's insurance company will tell you they are sending someone out to estimate the damage. While you certainly can refuse, it plays better to let them do it. Their estimate is meaningless, as it is yours (I would actually get one form a body shop) that counts. Remember that you don't have to take any offer and you can negotiate. oh, and your car is still your car, as I was saying you have no contract with them saying they can total your car. You will always have your car...but be aware that most insurance companies are not beyond tricking you. Also, not that it would be much here, but there is also 'diminished value' that is always available in the case of someone else's fault. Some states, like Colorado, do not let you claim diminished value against your own insurance.

Are you sure your not hurt? When you call his insurance company mention that you have a stiff neck and are going to see a Dr. It doesn't take much today to rack up 10K+ in medical bills and they sure know it. I likely have post-traumatic bystander syndrome from this and should file a claim too.

Kenny_Z
08-30-2014, 10:03 AM
It was a hard stop on my part and I was definitely too close to the truck in front of me for my own comfort. I admitted this much to the police officer but did not get a ticket or anything. I was still in an intersection and it was one of those "look up, light is still green, look down, brake lights." The guy that hit me told everyone he just hung up his phone, put it down, and saw us stopped. He tried to stop but he was just too close.

I'm not hurt, not even sore. I'm too honest for my own good. I can't just say I'm injured just to try to get something from this.

Thanks for the information Flicky. I've already told my insurance that I'm talking to the insurance of the party at fault and will most likely be dropping my claim with them because the 1k deductible is there and it would be stupid to pay it when the other company won't charge me that. My insurance is State Farm and his is USAA. I've taken the car to two body shops for estimates based on who the agencies directed me to.

I understand diminished value and I definitely got my money's worth out of that car from the initial purchase. I don't feel like I've got my money's worth out of the time and money I spent on refurbishing the engine earlier this year though. Sometimes it sucks that I don't take my car to shops. If I had the receipts of what a shop would have charged me to do what I did to that car it would have totaled up to well over the damage estimate.

djdogbone
08-30-2014, 01:45 PM
If you made that admission, then it went into the police report. You burned yourself there.

TheDutchTexan
08-30-2014, 04:17 PM
My wife got rear-ended in a similar situation. There was a turn lane with an unprotected turn. My wife could not go, behind her was another car which was stopped. The lady behind her got nailed by a teen that was probably on the phone. That car pushed the car behind my wife into her bumper. Minor damage. The insurance of the lady behind her did not pay for the damages. It was the one that hit the lady behind her that had to pay up. I was happy it was only minor damage. Both my kids where in the car when it happened!

You where the middle man in this one, took most of the hit, and I am sorry to say, but that looks like a 100% total. There is just too much damage. The other insurance will have to cover the damages, or total it and give you the value of the vehicle at time of the accident. I myself am extremely attached to my mustang, and will probably not let it go even with damage like that. But I will let them total it if that means I am in a better financial standpoint to get her back on the road. And, if the damage is too great, and effects the way the car drives, beyond the point of a simple alignment, she's gone forever. I don't ever want that to happen to my 05 mustang GT, but I am realistic when it comes down to that.

TTait
08-31-2014, 06:02 PM
As to fault - there is likely less info in the police report than you may think - a lot of times they check boxes and write 3 words at a time. This is not a capital murder case and a full scale investigations is not socially warranted regardless of how we feel about it personally. At the end of the day there are only three possible determinations - you are 49% at fault or less - you are 50% at fault, or you are 51% or more at fault. This determination is made by the insurance companies talking to each other - and it determines which company pays. it doesn't matter even if you were partially at fault, if the other guy carries the majority of fault - his company is responsible for making you whole - period.

The at fault drivers insurance company must make full payment, deductible does not apply. The only reason to file with your insurance company is if your car may be valued more by their appraiser than the other insurance company, with the deductible figured in.

I chose to work recently with my insurance company and accept the $250 deductible rather than the at fault drivers insurance as my insurance company agreed to a higher value for my car - and it netted out better.

The most important thing to know is that if you stick to your guns you can do better financially, but you may not get everything you want.

Last fall my restored D was hit by another driver - sending me into a $100k Nissan. The at fault drivers insurance company was liable to pay all of my expenses - up to the amount of his coverage. First problem was he had limited insurance and the guys in the Nissan claimed neck injuries and ran up a lot of medical bills. My payment from his company could have been limited if total costs for the accident exceeded his coverage - and then my insurance company would have made up most of the difference less the deductible.

I negotiated with both my insurance company and his to find the best deal. First offer on my car was $20k, I stood my ground and my insurance did their own appraisal and offered $27k. I asked the for their comps - and they could only find unrestored cars (my car had 90k miles and stage II). I asked them for comps for a car of any mileage up to 125k fully restored with Stage II and they couldn't find any - so I found the best comps I could and sent them in, along with receipts for all the work done and parts etc, and video of the car as used in a wedding two weeks before the accident. It took 5 months, but eventually I got an offer of $38k. My insurance company paid and deducted the $250 deductible - but the $250 in my case was nothing compared to the bottom line.

So I got my money, but thats not what I wanted though. The car had less than $38k in damages and I wanted it repaired - the insurance companies would not budge on that point and eventually I had to let them total the car. I bought it back and resold it with salvage title for additional profit.

I wanted my car back - but that wasn't going to happen. The insurance companies understood that if they authorized repairs that might cost less than the payout - things could eventually snowball and cost a lot more. Once they start down the road of repairing the car they have the liability to make the car right. If repairs are estimated at more than 50% of the value of the car - its usually a total loss.

You can, as I did, buy the car back pretty cheap - but there are things to consider there too. To put the car back on the road you now carry the risk of repair costs snowballing beyond expectations. Once it is repaired you will need to have a state inspector check over all the repairs, and then you have to file for a new salvage title. All that takes time and money. Consider how you are going to get the car to the state inspector (often a state police barracks or DMV) if you cannot legally drive the car. I did this once 20 years ago and chose to drive the car in under cover of darkness at 4am and wait till morning for the inspection - but that might have gone badly if I was caught.

Once you chose to drive a salvaged car - you still have issues. If there is another accident, your fault or someone elses - they will look at your salvage title and then offer you $200 for your car that you just put thousands into putting back on the road. This was the nail in the coffin for me repairing my D - I was not going to put $25k into repairs and then risk driving a car that would never be insurable for more than a few thousand.

Finally - if you do get your salvaged car back on the road and you ever injure anyone with it or damage property - what's going to happen when the other guys lawyer finds your salvage title and that you did the repairs yourself? Regardless of a state inspection - it's one more thing to hold over your head in a lawsuit.

The short story is - find out which insurance company will pay you more in the end - likely it will be the other company as your deductible is high compared to the possible value of the car - but do your homework. Then push to get the best possible valuation for your car. I was able to get nearly twice the initial offer but I had to prove it. I found bona fide comps to do that. The final payment should be a fair value for the car itself, covering your rental, plus sales tax and title/registration fees.

Fight for a fair payout, and move on. Most importantly - nobody got hurt.

T

David T
08-31-2014, 06:21 PM
It gets complicated when you get pushed into another vehicle. They try to say you were following to close. If it were just rear end damage it's no problem the driver behind is at fault. That driver will probably not claim responsibility after he learns how much his insurance goes up.

I got rear ended once making a fast stop for a school buss putting on it's flashing red lights. The young girl who hit me gets out of her car and her cell phone drops on the ground (guess what she was doing). My insurance company said they were paying my repair bill less my $500 deductible. I just said "bull shit, don't send the check" and I never heard or saw any kind of bill for the repair or the two weeks of rental car bills.

You have to be tough with your insurance company and let them know your going to fight.

No it doesn't. The last one to the party pays all. Very high bar for them to prove they were not the cause of the entire accident. Bottom line here is collect as much money as you can and move on. An old car with a lot of miles AND NO AGREED VALUE WITH YOUR INSURER equals disposable car. Consider yourself lucky you were not hurt and get over it.

opethmike
08-31-2014, 06:26 PM
Consider yourself lucky you were not hurt and get over it.

Such sympathy. Much compassion. Wow.

Bitsyncmaster
08-31-2014, 07:03 PM
No it doesn't. The last one to the party pays all. Very high bar for them to prove they were not the cause of the entire accident.

My wife was in a seven car pile up. It's not the rear person that has to prove anything. It's what the insurance companys come up with.

TTait
08-31-2014, 07:53 PM
It's not the rear person that has to prove anything. It's what the insurance companys come up with.

Agreed. Years back a Jeep hit me and knocked me into another car - then the jeep fled the scene before we could get a plate. The insurance companies agreed I did not cause the accident, but that I would be considered at fault because they had to have someone to assign the primary liability to and the other guy fled. I did nothing wrong but my insurance went up anyway.

If you are ever in a multi car accident the key question you will be asked is "How many different impacts did you feel?" Lots of different scenarios - but your answer will go a long way toward assigning blame.

David T
08-31-2014, 10:36 PM
I have been unfortunate enough to have been in several mutli-car pileups. In every case the last guy in paid. Yes, the insurance companies DO get together and settle up because many times the same company may be insuring several of the cars involved. When the Police get to the scene it is difficult to ascertain where first contact was made so the default is to blame the last car. We can all agree that it doesn't always happen that way. With all of the red light cameras now it usually IS the last car even though cars are stopping quickly and some may be tailgating. In this instance it does appear the last car was at fault. Typically the fewer cars involved the easier it is figure it out. In any case the sad truth is you are out of a car and it is going to cost you a LOT more than you will be paid to replace it. Insurance companies look at this in a very dollars and cents way with no regard to anyone's feelings or how long or how much you loved your car.

Kenny_Z
09-03-2014, 11:08 AM
I admit, I am tearing up. USAA is letting me keep the car without a salvage title and they're sending me a check. Plus I found two cars yesterday in the up pull it yard with most of the parts I need and they were the same metallic blue so I don't have to repaint right away. I'm feeling very blessed.

David T
09-03-2014, 05:17 PM
I admit, I am tearing up. USAA is letting me keep the car without a salvage title and they're sending me a check. Plus I found two cars yesterday in the up pull it yard with most of the parts I need and they were the same metallic blue so I don't have to repaint right away. I'm feeling very blessed.

Sounds like you were able to negotiate a pretty good deal. Congratulations. Hopefully there is not much hidden damage.Would it be cheaper to buy the whole parts car or just the parts you need?

Kenny_Z
09-03-2014, 06:09 PM
I just bought almost everything I need for the rear. Trunk lid, taillights, bumper cover and bracing, misc little bits, and rear wiring harnesses. The total was about 200 dollars. I still need to get the inner trunk panel. I'm not sure I want to cut one out of the junk yard or get a new part from a GM dealer. It's available from one locally.

I think it's going to be cheaper to just get the parts I need and not an entire car. I enjoyed myself in the junk yard. That's the first time I've gone to one. Usually the cars I work on don't end up in the local yards. The hood may be the hardest part to find. Seems like people like running this car into things. I might have to buy one online but now that I have some money from the insurance it won't be so bad.

Flicky
09-04-2014, 04:36 AM
Looks like there is a blue-grey hood for $100 at Bobby's auto parts in Vance AL...not all that close to you I guess.

I used www.car-part.com

2004
Hood
Chevy Monte Carlo GREY-BLUE 299926 $100 Bobby's Auto Parts USA-AL(Vance) E-mail 205-477-0901 / 205-477-0902

Kenny_Z
09-04-2014, 09:08 AM
Thanks for looking but a 2004 is the sixth generation and a 99 is a fifth. Incompatible body styles.