PDA

View Full Version : What to do with a 401k from a previous company?



Kenny_Z
11-26-2014, 12:38 AM
Let me start off by saying I've never actually given much though to retirement and investments. Two years ago the company I worked for went bankrupt and I basically forgot I had a 401k with them. I was contacted and told about the account and what will be done if I don't decide to do something with it myself. Basically they'll roll it into an IRA not of my choosing.

I could roll it into the 401k I have with my current company but they've decided that if I don't move to Miami by March 31st I'm not going to have a job. It wasn't based on any job performance figures. The CEO decided that if an employee isn't under their boss then they are not working. The others in my department at one of the two large offices are having to either move to the other office or lose their jobs too. I'm not moving to Miami. This is the second worst job I have ever had and probably the worst company I have ever worked for. I also don't see much of a future for them if they don't get their act together. I stuck with them because I worked from home for a very good wage. I think leaving them is going to be a good thing for me and not a good thing for the company.

After talking with someone at Fidelity my options are to take a payout of the entire amount minus taxes and a penalty since I'm not over 59 1/2 or roll it into an IRA. Since I am currently job hunting I wanted to make sure I had access to the money just in case I can't find something by the time my company's deadline is up. Seems like with the IRA I have that option without having the massive penalty. It'd just be paying taxes on whatever amount I withdrew.

I have a line on another job so I may not have to access the money. The pay is a lot lower but they haven't given me any final numbers yet. I'm hoping it's enough that I can live on because I would like to work for this new company. I'd really jump ship on my higher paying job to take this other one just because it would drop the stress and stupidity level in my life to much more manageable levels.

There's also a little voice in my mind telling me I should take the payout because even after the penalties 30k could build me a seriously nice garage. It's saying forget old guy Kenny. He can sit in his nice garage in his nice DeLorean eating a nice can of beans during his retirement.

opethmike
11-26-2014, 01:22 AM
Does that can of beans have bits of bacon? In that case, take the beans.

rdarlington
11-26-2014, 02:09 AM
Or just do the smart thing and leave it where it is, and collect unemployment while you find another job.

-Bob

Also, not to be unkind, no heart, etc, but you should probably be talking to a lawyer and keeping this stuff off of dmctalk.

Kenny_Z
11-26-2014, 05:09 AM
I already have actually. One was assigned the case of closing out the plan. They can only give you facts and figures. I find that listening to people that have already been there is a lot more useful. Experience is a much better teacher.

Collecting unemployment never actually dawned on me. I'm sure it would have when the time came but I never considered it an option until now. It never was mentioned by the lawyer either so you're one up on him. ;)

Bitsyncmaster
11-26-2014, 06:21 AM
If you cash out and have already earned a lot for that year, you will take a big tax hit. I have two 401 ks I have left in the old companies and can still move their investments around in what is still offered with those companies.

Take if from my experience, you really should be building your retirement funds as much as you can. I got laid off last year and cannot find a job in my profession because of my age (62) and do not want to relocate. I was planning on retiring after my house was paid off (another 4 years) but that is still a monthly bill that's hurting me now.

You can usually talk to financial adviser who will aid you in moving your funds into a personal IRA. Your bank can probably put you in contact with an adviser who will not charge you anything for his/her advice.

Citizen
11-26-2014, 07:46 AM
I don't usually comment, but since you asked; I think you should NOT cash out and so not to pay that penalty. Remember, the penalty is on top of whatever you would pay for income tax. So, if you were paying 35-38% income tax, add 10% penalty to that, and your at almost 50% of your retirement money going to our government, to do with what they want. You say you're not in the that high tax bracket? Well, take your annual salary for this year, add the gross of your 401k to it, and voila, you're could be paying 38% income tax. Except the 401k money will have an extra 10% added to that.

You can roll your 401k over to just about any other type of retirement, and it will avoid paying that hefty penalty, AND THE MONEY IS STILL THERE LATER IF YOU NEED IT.

(I am not a tax or retirement advisor).

Thomas

...

Jonathan
11-26-2014, 08:19 AM
If this job of yours is indeed the second worst one you've had and the company is the worst you have ever worked for then you know the best thing is to not be working for them. That definitely rules out moving to Miami.

If the lower paying job is something you feel would lower stress and stupidity levels, then take it.

The Canadian tax laws are different, so I won't comment on any rates or additional 10% fees, etc., but my advice would be to have that cash somewhere you can access with relative ease. Ideally it is somewhere with minimal penalties and without having it stuck somewhere until you're a certain age. If you take longer to figure out what you want to do next and where you want to work, having access to that money is better than taking out a loan or some other debt to get by (not always, depending on tax implications, but usually).

I would imagine your tax rates are based on what you earn in a calendar year as they are here in Canada? If that is the case, regardless of what tax bracket you fall into, that resets on January 1st. You could use that to your advantage perhaps depending on the laws. Where I am, if we pull out cash from a registered retirement savings fund (pretty much what your 401k is) it is taxed along the lines of 10% on the first $10k withdrawn, 20% on the next $10k, and 30% on everything withdrawn beyond $20k after that until the end of the year. So you take it out in chunks if you need to to avoid the 30% withholding tax right off the bat.

That being said, what is supposed to happen is whatever taxes you "should" have paid, will get adjusted once you do your taxes in the Spring. When it is all added up, you pay what taxes your bracket for the year said you should have, and if you over paid because you got a paycheck or two or fund withdrawal that made it looked like you earn a lot more than you normally do for a week, the extra taxes deducted will come back to you as a return. Most people would rather have their own money in their own accounts for that portion of the year and not in the governments, but you do get it back regardless.

The money and tax part is the easy stuff. Making the decision to leave a job you hate and start doing something you enjoy is the hard part. Look up Jim Carrey's address to the 2014 graduating class at MuM for some advice on this very subject.

alexwolf1216
11-26-2014, 10:15 AM
We did this 5 years ago when my wife left her company. You will end us losing around 40% after all is said and done after the 20% early withdraw penalty and taxes. Dont do it. We rolled ours over to USAA in an IRA and they have done a fabulous job of managing it. Our returns are really good, around 19% per year.

David T
11-26-2014, 05:58 PM
We did this 5 years ago when my wife left her company. You will end us losing around 40% after all is said and done after the 20% early withdraw penalty and taxes. Dont do it. We rolled ours over to USAA in an IRA and they have done a fabulous job of managing it. Our returns are really good, around 19% per year.

You really should discuss this with your accountant or tax adviser. If you think you are going to die soon take the cash-out. In just about any other case you should roll it over into a personal IRA. The money CANNOT go through your account, it MUST go DIRECTLY into your IRA. In fact, in some instances you need to set up a separate IRA just for these funds, not one you may already have. Again, you need to talk to someone well versed in the tax law and your specific situation. If you cash out early the tax hit is very big unless you meet the exempt uses like medial bills or education. A garage is not one of them unfortunately. If you are elegiabal for unemployment you are entitled to it, you (and your previous employers) paid for it!

Kenny_Z
11-26-2014, 07:37 PM
Thanks everyone. Your comments have helped me figure out what I am going to do. Cashing out was the first thing I thought before talking to the advisor but the tax information and penalty information he gave me shot that down in a hurry. I would much rather keep as much of the money as possible. I understand the need to pay taxes on what I earned but that penalty for early withdrawal is makes the decision easy.

Since I am not planning to be dead for a very, very long time (if ever ;)) I'll need that money to retire. Looking back over my earnings through Fidelity over the lifetime of the 401k I was impressed by the amount of gain they showed so I believe I'll be sticking with them for the IRA. With any luck I'll have a new job soon so I won't have to dip into my savings, let alone the IRA. I went to an interview and I believe it went very well. Didn't hurt that one of the sales ladies walked in on the interview, recognized me, and then began telling everyone in the office how awesome I was and that we needed to hire me immediately. I worked with her years back.

ccurzio
11-27-2014, 11:51 AM
Looking back over my earnings through Fidelity over the lifetime of the 401k I was impressed by the amount of gain they showed so I believe I'll be sticking with them for the IRA.

Earnings have less to do with the company that's holding your investments and more to do with the investments themselves.

Iznodmad
11-27-2014, 12:01 PM
I recently had an issue very similar to this, an old 401k I had forgotten about from an old job. In my scenario, I had to either cash out or roll over. Fees associated with rolling over were about equal to taxes associated with cashing out. So, I decided to just cash out. It was a small amount of $ anyway, so no big deal.

Spittybug
11-27-2014, 01:16 PM
While I am not a professional financial advisor, I did retire from the "career job" at age 48 based on my investment success. It's a marathon, not a sprint. I had 401-K deductions from the very day I was eligible (one year?) in the mid '80's.
Roll it over to a self directed IRA. Personally I use TRowe Price, but as mentioned above, the company is of insignificance as long as they are convenient to use. Use their counsel for a good mix of stocks, bonds, or other investments. Don't be too conservative. Be diversified. Be patient. What goes up does come down, but look at the historical chart of the markets... what goes down, goes back up to higher levels.
Do not take it as a distribution to yourself; the tax man will err on his side and hit you with the penalty even if you re-deposit into an IRA, putting the burden of documentation on you. Have the 401-K administrator write the check to the benefit of your IRA or better yet, direct deposit.
Don't underestimate the power of compounded, tax deferred returns. The bigger the snowball at the top of the mountain, the EXPONENTIALLY bigger the avalanche at the bottom. I have at least 8 more years until I can pull on my IRA without penalty, and that should be enough time to double it. (Rule of 72.....google it).
You WILL appreciate having income to live on when older much more than a garage. Especially if your body starts giving you a hard time and you don't enjoy wrenching so much any more.....


Build a spreadsheet or get someone to help you do so. Track things. Plan. Perform what-if analysis. It all helps to visualize your options. Speaking of options......nah, that's for another time.


I just read the post above mine.... there should be NO fees associated with rolling your 401-K to an IRA. Beware of any firm that says otherwise.

As an aside, I just had a choice to make. I had a pension accruing at a former employer. They gave me an option to continue to have them administer it and pay me a pension at age X until death, or give me a lump sum today and walk away. If I roll it into my IRA, it won't be taxed. I ran the numbers (NPV analysis) and concluded that I was better off taking the lump sum, investing it (they have to invest in very conservatively by law) and cutting my strings to them. If I do a half way decent job, I should be able to have an annuity stream that would be at least double what theirs would have been.

Kenny_Z
11-27-2014, 03:35 PM
Earnings have less to do with the company that's holding your investments and more to do with the investments themselves.

I used a plan that they generated that was diversified when the 401k was originally set up. It did well so I trust their judgement when designing an investment plan.

The most interaction I plan to have with the IRA is setting up a monthly payment into it after I'm established and comfortable in a new job. I know myself too well. Once I start messing with it and see returns it will steamroll and I'll get obsessed for a year or so while neglecting everything else. That's how I ended up with three project cars and one and a half robots.

rddmc
11-27-2014, 11:21 PM
I agree with others who advised you against withdrawing the funds. You will take a huge hit in penalty and taxes. Seek guidance from an investment advisor in your state.

In most instances you are not able to draw unemployment benefits if you voluntarily quit a job. If you are cut off by your employer you generally can draw benefits for 26 weeks.

Rod
10921

ccurzio
11-28-2014, 10:25 AM
I just read the post above mine.... there should be NO fees associated with rolling your 401-K to an IRA. Beware of any firm that says otherwise.

Yeah I read that too and that seemed very not right to me.

The only fees that would happen are simple account management fees, and those are usually only a couple of bucks.

Jonathan
11-28-2014, 12:17 PM
Penalties suck, no question. Keep in mind though that the tax break of keeping your investments as is benefits you if/when you get to that age.

A couple of life's curveballs can change that if either:

1.) you end up face down in the mashed potatoes before that age, or

2.) you decide to change course yourself and need access to that cash.

The change course piece might help you get to that old age if you recognize the path you're on will put you in the grave before the retirement home.

Our Ontario club saw a tragic example of this earlier in the year and there was no good explanation for it other than perhaps looking back and asking "what was the point?"

My own two cents of advice would be to focus a lot more on the part you mentioned about the job being one of stress and stupidity and less on the cash for the time being. The "costs" associated with some of the very jobs many of us have has much more to do with health than it does tax rates.

Timebender
11-28-2014, 02:48 PM
We put ours into an IRA that's then used to buy stocks in companies like Apple (we've quadrupled our money there), Verizon, Disney, China oil, Exxon/Mobil, and a few other smart tech companies. Everytime they pay a dividend it automatically goes back in the IRA which then automatically buys more stock.

Jedidentist
11-28-2014, 07:23 PM
Whatever you do, don't cash it in (as you've already stated)...and don't ever think about cashing it in until you retire. Too many people think of it as a savings account to use as a last resort...it shouldn't even be considered as that. Sell everything else you own before messing around with that. People WAAAAAY underestimate what they're going to need at retirement and WAAAAAY overestimate they're ability to continue to work (or find work) at an older age.

Bitsyncmaster
11-28-2014, 08:12 PM
People WAAAAAY underestimate what they're going to need at retirement and WAAAAAY overestimate they're ability to continue to work (or find work) at an older age.

+1
When your +60 and loose your job you will probably not find a new job in your profession. And when your that age you really don't want to move (your wife will loose her job if you move).

What you really want in your 401k is to only draw the yearly earnings off of it when your retire. So if you need $50,000 a year you need about $1,000,000.

Remember the market can crash like it did in 2008 and most people lost 40 -50 % of their 401k value. So you need to move it to more conservative investments in later years.

In the long run you will probably get the best earnings with market invested accounts.

David T
11-28-2014, 09:14 PM
+1
When your +60 and loose your job you will probably not find a new job in your profession. And when your that age you really don't want to move (your wife will loose her job if you move).

What you really want in your 401k is to only draw the yearly earnings off of it when your retire. So if you need $50,000 a year you need about $1,000,000.

Remember the market can crash like it did in 2008 and most people lost 40 -50 % of their 401k value. So you need to move it to more conservative investments in later years.

In the long run you will probably get the best earnings with market invested accounts.

The main thing is to have it in YOUR IRA where you can control the type of investment and the level of risk/return. The rules have changed in recent years, you can own things other than stocks and bonds. For instance if you have enough you can buy real estate (like a house) and rent it to earn income. Or you can even buy gold. Now you are getting into where you should get professional advice for your specific situation. In just about every case though you want to get the money into an investment account that YOU control and don't spend it, at least not yet. If you are married whatever is left will go to your spouse tax-free when you pass with the same rules (like paying big penalties if she takes it out early).