PDA

View Full Version : Anyone Installed AfterMarket TPMS ?



Dangermouse
11-26-2014, 01:16 PM
Has anyone any experience with aftermarket Tire Pressure Monitoring Systems (TPMS) on their D or other car.

I was recently caught out with a slow air leak in one of my DD (I assumed it had TPMS but it didn't) and I was wondering about retrofitting something like this:

http://www.amazon.com/Schrader-SCH-WRK-4PC-Retrofit-Passenger-Display/dp/B008YQP2NW

which looks like it is installed when getting tires fitted,

or this

http://www.gizmag.com/fobo-bluetooth-tire-pressure-monitoring-system/33754/

which seems to be mounted externally on the valve

DMCMW Dave
11-26-2014, 06:20 PM
If I could remove it from my DD cars I would. Huge PITA and expensive when it fails. I'd rather keep a tire gauge in the glovebox than a bunch of electronics spinning in my tires.

[currently driving around in a Honda with 4 perfectly inflated tires and the "TPMS" light on.]

micmak
11-26-2014, 08:56 PM
If I could remove it from my DD cars I would. Huge PITA and expensive when it fails. I'd rather keep a tire gauge in the glovebox than a bunch of electronics spinning in my tires.

[currently driving around in a Honda with 4 perfectly inflated tires and the "TPMS" light on.]

I totally agree with you, Dave. My daily driver is a Chev Malibu and my TPMS light blinks at me every time I put the key in the ignition, and the Driver Information Center tells me to check my tire pressures, even though my tires are perfectly inflated. And I have searched and searched and I cannot find any way to disable the system. It is a pain in the ass - no question. I check my tire pressures regularly as part of my ongoing maintenance of my cars. I don’t need a stupid light and an annoying text message on my instrument cluster to tell me that I need air in my tires.

......Mike......

Dangermouse
11-26-2014, 09:37 PM
Fwiw, it's my wife's car that I am thinking about...........

I'd rather "there's a light on the dash" than "the tires been flat all day" ;)

vwdmc16
11-26-2014, 09:46 PM
The Globe trotting team being built by "Deloman" in Germany has installed tire monitors in his fleet.

ccurzio
11-28-2014, 03:12 PM
Fwiw, it's my wife's car that I am thinking about...........

I'd rather "there's a light on the dash" than "the tires been flat all day" ;)

If the thing cries wolf all the time, you'll end up with an all-day flat anyway. :)

David T
11-28-2014, 04:58 PM
Many of the new cars no longer have spare tires. What you get is an electric inflator pump with a canister of goo to seal up any small leaks. Once you use it though you ruin the monitor, the goo plugs up the tiny hole in the monitor and they are around $100. The canister of goo is only good for a few years so you have to replace it when it gets old or after each use. They are not cheap. Also on many of the new cars you need a special tool to initialize the monitors so the car knows which one is on which wheel. There are monitoring systems that screw on the valve stem like a cap so it is not inside the wheel. They can get stolen, broken off or leak. Get a good tire pressure gauge and check your tires at least once a month and before a long drive. Remember for every 10 degrees change your tire pressure changes about 1 PSI. It is not unusual to lose 1 PSI per month too. With this cold weather you could be 5 PSI low and that is a lot. Most warning systems do not warn till you are over 10% above-below the target pressure. That's a LOT. Enough to wear your tires badly, decrease your gas mileage, reduce your load-carrying capacity and on cars with a high center of gravity allow them to roll over easier. Bottom line, even if you have TPMS you should STILL check your tires regularly.

micmak
11-28-2014, 11:05 PM
Fwiw, it's my wife's car that I am thinking about...........

I'd rather "there's a light on the dash" than "the tires been flat all day" ;)

I think that was probably the initial idea, Dermot. Sure - there is a light flashing so the tire pressure needs attention. They were/are a good idea in principle, but the fact is that they are not reliable and notorious for breaking or giving false readings. If they could be made to be more dependable and more exact, then they would be trusted and believed more, and accepted more too. In the meantime, I hate mine and I would love to be able to disable them, but aside from the fact that nobody claims to know how to disable them, I hear that it is apparently illegal to do so too!

......Mike......

Flicky
11-29-2014, 06:07 AM
How about something like these?
http://www.amazon.com/iSaddle-Pressure-Monitor-Sensor-Indicator/dp/B00D8WHI8O/ref=lh_ni_t?ie=UTF8&psc=1&smid=A14W2Y48R6JAGN

They are not electronic. Just little springs that will turn green, yellow, or red depending on air.

I had a flat yesterday on my DD coming back from a 2800 mile trip. Ran over something, 10 seconds later the TPS goes off, 45 seconds later -flop-flop-flop. Luckily I was in GA so there was a waffle house right there for me to stop at and put on the spare.

Shep
11-30-2014, 06:59 PM
I totally agree with you, Dave. My daily driver is a Chev Malibu and my TPMS light blinks at me every time I put the key in the ignition, and the Driver Information Center tells me to check my tire pressures, even though my tires are perfectly inflated. And I have searched and searched and I cannot find any way to disable the system. It is a pain in the ass - no question. I check my tire pressures regularly as part of my ongoing maintenance of my cars. I don’t need a stupid light and an annoying text message on my instrument cluster to tell me that I need air in my tires.

......Mike......Did you check your spare? I just had the light come on in my Mom's car, and all the tires are fine at 32 PSI. Checked the spare, and sure enough, it was 26 PSI. Filled it up to 32 PSI, and the light turned off.

Moral of the story: TPMS isn't always to blame, and raising a red flag is better than no red flags at all :)

EDIT:
Actually Dave, I ask you the same question, since you said "4 perfectly inflated tires" and not "5" ;)

David T
11-30-2014, 10:24 PM
Did you check your spare? I just had the light come on in my Mom's car, and all the tires are fine at 32 PSI. Checked the spare, and sure enough, it was 26 PSI. Filled it up to 32 PSI, and the light turned off.

Moral of the story: TPMS isn't always to blame, and raising a red flag is better than no red flags at all :)

EDIT:
Actually Dave, I ask you the same question, since you said "4 perfectly inflated tires" and not "5" ;)

In many of the new cars there is a message center and it tells you which tire is low. On some cars you can even look at each tire and read the pressure. Not that accurate but a warning is better than no warning. The caps with the little flags in them are OK but you have to actually go to each wheel and look at it. As for your spare, look at the tire label in the driver's door jamb or wherever it is on your car. Unless it is a full size spare you probably need more than 32 psi in it.

Shep
12-01-2014, 08:24 AM
As for your spare, look at the tire label in the driver's door jamb or wherever it is on your car. Unless it is a full size spare you probably need more than 32 psi in it.It was a full-size spare indeed (2013 Toyota RAV-4) Good advice nonetheless! :)

Dangermouse
12-02-2014, 01:58 PM
Maybe it's a function of living in warmer climate, but the TPMS systems I have had on other cars have been pretty reliable, with the notable exception of my 2010 Grand Caravan, which was such a finicky system.

On my X3, you get a ping on the first cold morning of the winter, but it has a simple reset button. On at least two other times, in different cars, the TPMS going off has indicated a nail in the tire, so early detection saved the tire (as well as me potentially ending up in a ditch).

On reflection though, a cheap ebay system is more likely to be unreliable than a warranted OEM version.

The problem is that the wife's car has 45 section tires that disguise low air pressure much better than taller tires, when visually inspecting them, and she's certaoinly not going to check the pressures before every trip.

Guess I'll just have to implement a better monitoring system for her's.

Rich W
12-02-2014, 02:35 PM
Guess I'll just have to implement a better monitoring system for her's.

I have the image below saved on my computer at work and I was on vacation all last week, so I could not post it then.

I thought it was quite appropriate that the wheel in the photo was on a later model Mercedes Benz. Enjoy the photo !!

31928

I just happened to receive that photo last month (via message) and I was able to re-use it in less than a month.

Dangermouse
12-02-2014, 02:38 PM
That's too funny, because the wife's car is a...........M-B :shock:

David T
12-02-2014, 03:29 PM
That's too funny, because the wife's car is a...........M-B :shock:

I guess she had those expensive "Run Flat" tires! You run them till they are flat!

Farrar
12-04-2014, 03:12 PM
My folks have a very simple way of checking on their van: tire valve stem caps that are green when properly inflated, and red when low.

Dangermouse
12-22-2014, 04:58 PM
Interesting to note that TPMS only alerts for low pressure, not high.

I am sitting in a tire repair shop with the POS Chevy Cruze that I rented from Alamo. About 20 miles after leaving the rental location I was on the interstate and scrolling through the trip computer and found the TPMS screen. And this car actually has live data : 28, 52, 53 and 83 psi!! That can't be right surely.

Not knowing what the recommended pressures should be, I thought I would pull off and check.

As I was getting to the next intersection, the pressure shown in the RR wheel dropped to 27 and the orange warning came on.

Long story short, there was a nail in the RF ( not RR) and the other pressures were infact accurate. In tires with a stamped max pressure of 45psi. So one tire was at almost double the max pressure but no warning.

Alamo were completely unsympathetic stating that it was my responsibility. Last time renting from them !!!

Shep
12-22-2014, 05:26 PM
Before you blame Alamao, did you check the spare? Most small-size spares have 60 PSI ratings, and rental car agencies will over-inflate it intentionally. Considering their small size, it's quite easy to overinflate them to the 83 PSI measurement you gave.

And as a side note: some TMPS systems are centralized to the car, not to each wheel, i.e. if the tires ever get rotated, their readings go with it unless someone sets it correctly. I'll bet 10 to 1 the tires got rotated before you drove it, and the centralized reading thus thought it was the wrong wheel.

Dangermouse
12-22-2014, 05:50 PM
I physically measured them with a tire station gauge and the four road tires were as the dash display showed them except that RR and RF were switched.

I did not check the spare.

The door jamb sticker recommended that the tires be inflated to 35 which I thought was quite high.

On a not surprising side note, when I deflated the tires to 35, ride quality went up considerably.

While I wouldn't expect Alamo to necessarily spot a nail in a tire, I would expect that their pre-rental checks would include tire pressures.

Anyway the point of my OP was that TPMS should alert drivers to over-pressure in tires as well as under-pressure.

Shep
12-23-2014, 07:39 AM
TPMS should alert drivers to over-pressure in tires as well as under-pressure.Depends on the car. Some systems do, but most don't. Doing a quick google search, the first few results (https://www.google.com/search?q=tpms%20high%20pressure) seem to indicate that they do NOT monitor high pressure, but then there are later results (Bridgestone, eBay, etc.) that seem to indicate this is an OEM-specific issue and there are aftermarket systems that monitor both high and low.

That being said, I just re-read your post, and saw the 52/53 PSI numbers. Misread them as 32/33 before! :8ball: NOW it makes a lot more sense as to why Alamo would be at fault here; if you caught it at 28 PSI and they inflated it to twice that, it may very well have been a nail from the previous driver that caused the issue. My apologies for the misread. Interestingly enough though, I did see a guy who said he overinflates his spare on purpose so that he doesn't set off the TPMS light as often, especially since it's not being used.

Just had a thought though: what if it was the previous driver himself that "topped off" the tires after seeing the warning light come on? That would explain the high PSI, but it's still on Alamo to not notice. I would've taken a picture of the screen and the nail though so you could follow suit with their manager and explain to him that you simply don't want it to happen to anyone else. Hopefully you didn't have to pay for anything the previous driver did...

Dangermouse
12-23-2014, 02:06 PM
You missed the 83 psi number too?

Almost twice the max pressure for that fitted tire. !!!

And, yes I took a picture of the screen, though it had dropped to only 82 by this stage.

32234