PDA

View Full Version : Inner/outer door seals



Trstno1
03-06-2015, 04:12 PM
I'm in the market for new inner and outer door seals for my car. I'm also interested in a set with the adhesive backing already on them. What's everyone's opinion on who sells the best set?

OverlandMan
03-06-2015, 04:50 PM
I'm in the market for new inner and outer door seals for my car. I'm also interested in a set with the adhesive backing already on them. What's everyone's opinion on who sells the best set?

I'm getting ready to do mine. I already have the outer seal set (came from the PO). It's my understanding you're supposed to use 3M windshield glue to attach them. I'll get community confirmation of that before I actually do those.

For the inners, I was considering using one of these, as a previous member had used them IIR correctly. http://www.mcmaster.com/#bulb-seals/=w71l6d Or this part # (same site): 1120A232.

PJ Grady Inc.
03-06-2015, 05:16 PM
Urethane is for the windscreen and other glass ONLY and NOT the A & B post seals if you ever expect to remove them again. Also you would have a horrible mess on your hands (literally) by the time it cured.

We like Wurth or Winzer Rubber adhesive as it holds well, removes easily and is forgiving to apply but it's pricey and sold only to vendors.
Interestingly they are competing German companies headed by two brothers. Now that's a sibling rivalry with Winzer holding the edge in pricing.
.
As for the surround seals we've been told by many customers that ours are the best quality and fit they've seen. They are made exclusively for us through Ken Koncelik as we paid for the tooling and he did the drawings.

In the end it's your decision as to whether it's worth the extra cost over the generic McMaster seal.

Rob


I'm getting ready to do mine. I already have the outer seal set (came from the PO). It's my understanding you're supposed to use 3M windshield glue to attach them. I'll get community confirmation of that before I actually do those.

For the inners, I was considering using one of these, as a previous member had used them IIR correctly. http://www.mcmaster.com/#bulb-seals/=w71l6d Or this part # (same site): 1120A232.

mluder
03-06-2015, 06:00 PM
Adding to this... I've been really disappointed in the outer door seals from DMCH. They only lasted a little over a year and a half before they started cracking. Granted that couple be on me for not regularly applying silicone to them but I would expext a good quality one should not require that much maintenance.

I'd be curious to know who offers what and the differing materials and how they hold up.

Cheers
Steve

Trstno1
03-06-2015, 07:28 PM
Urethane is for the windscreen and other glass ONLY and NOT the A & B post seals if you ever expect to remove them again. Also you would have a horrible mess on your hands (literally) by the time it cured.

We like Wurth or Winzer Rubber adhesive as it holds well, removes easily and is forgiving to apply but it's pricey and sold only to vendors.
Interestingly they are competing German companies headed by two brothers. Now that's a sibling rivalry with Winzer holding the edge in pricing.
.
As for the surround seals we've been told by many customers that ours are the best quality and fit they've seen. They are made exclusively for us through Ken Koncelik as we paid for the tooling and he did the drawings.

In the end it's your decision as to whether it's worth the extra cost over the generic McMaster seal.

Rob

How much is the full set that you offer?

PJ Grady Inc.
03-06-2015, 08:11 PM
Our bespoke T-roof, door surround, and A/B post seals will last many years with no maintenance and even more if you bother to apply some type of rubber care product from time to time.

Winzer again has the best product for this and it's called, not surprisingly, "Rubber Care"! We stock it as well as the adhesive in a brush top can.
BTW I started making all of our rubber seals around 1998. We've sold hundreds of these seal kits since then and I've yet to see any of them tear or crack. I can't say your results will unconditionally be the same but the liklyhood is that it will.

Our kit #111666GP ($279.95) includes the surround seals, T-roof seals, and (exactly)pre-cut to fit A & B post seals saving you the hassle of doing it yourself. The adhesive glue and Rubber Care is available separately.
Rob Grady


Adding to this... I've been really disappointed in the outer door seals from DMCH. They only lasted a little over a year and a half before they started cracking. Granted that couple be on me for not regularly applying silicone to them but I would expect a good quality one should not require that much maintenance.

I'd be curious to know who offers what and the differing materials and how they hold up.

Cheers
Steve

BABIS
03-07-2015, 08:39 AM
T-roof seals



do you mean part numbers 106967 and 106968 ?

Chris 16409
03-07-2015, 11:21 AM
I have Martin's silicone rubber outer door seals and I like them quite a bit. Currently I'm using McMaster outer door seals. I'm interested to see Grady's outer door seals though.

DMC5180
03-07-2015, 12:11 PM
I have Martin's silicone rubber outer door seals and I like them quite a bit. Currently I'm using McMaster outer door seals. I'm interested to see Grady's outer door seals though.

Can you post an up close picture of your silicone outer seals along with the shape profile?

OverlandMan
03-07-2015, 01:48 PM
Urethane is for the windscreen and other glass ONLY and NOT the A & B post seals if you ever expect to remove them again. Also you would have a horrible mess on your hands (literally) by the time it cured.

We like Wurth or Winzer Rubber adhesive as it holds well, removes easily and is forgiving to apply but it's pricey and sold only to vendors.
Interestingly they are competing German companies headed by two brothers. Now that's a sibling rivalry with Winzer holding the edge in pricing.
.
As for the surround seals we've been told by many customers that ours are the best quality and fit they've seen. They are made exclusively for us through Ken Koncelik as we paid for the tooling and he did the drawings.

In the end it's your decision as to whether it's worth the extra cost over the generic McMaster seal.

Rob

Thanks for the clarification Rob. Definitely will NOT use windshield glue. So how does one get Wurth or Winzer, through you or another vendor?

PJ Grady Inc.
03-07-2015, 03:52 PM
Hi Jeff,
Yes we stock both products mainly for shop use but we can send you some. I will check pricing and send you a PM when time permits early in the week if you like.
Rob


Thanks for the clarification Rob. Definitely will NOT use windshield glue. So how does one get Wurth or Winzer, through you or another vendor?

PJ Grady Inc.
03-07-2015, 04:29 PM
Yes but with a G at the end of each number. I set up our inventory so that any number that doesn't have a letter at the end of it means the part is either an NOS part sourced from dealer inventories or DMCH. It also could mean it's a DMCH supplied part that is not NOS but rather one of their DMCH approved parts that they had made elsewhere (as in not NOS).

Any part we sell that has a G at the end is a part that we have sourced elsewhere or we have manufactured directly for our own use. So our T-roof seals are #'s 106967G & 106968G which in this case we have made for us. We do this for a number of reasons but the bottom line is our G labeled parts are sourced or made to the highest standards we can meet while still providing a competitive price.

That is usually the case but sometimes you have to pay more for better quality as in the case of our T.L boards. Of course that's a topic for another post if I'm going to stay on track here. I believe that our G designation indicates parts that benefit from my experience in what works best and my efforts to supply equivalent or superiour quality to NOS or OEM parts.

I hope my explanation provides clarity and not confusion but let me know if you have more questions.
Rob Grady



do you mean part numbers 106967 and 106968 ?

Trstno1
03-08-2015, 12:51 PM
Our bespoke T-roof, door surround, and A/B post seals will last many years with no maintenance and even more if you bother to apply some type of rubber care product from time to time.

Winzer again has the best product for this and it's called, not surprisingly, "Rubber Care"! We stock it as well as the adhesive in a brush top can.
BTW I started making all of our rubber seals around 1998. We've sold hundreds of these seal kits since then and I've yet to see any of them tear or crack. I can't say your results will unconditionally be the same but the liklyhood is that it will.

Our kit #111666GP ($279.95) includes the surround seals, T-roof seals, and (exactly)pre-cut to fit A & B post seals saving you the hassle of doing it yourself. The adhesive glue and Rubber Care is available separately.
Rob Grady

Hey Rob-

Do your inner door seals require the retaining clips? Also, I would be interested in finding out how much the winzer and rubber care would cost.

Thanks!

PJ Grady Inc.
03-08-2015, 05:29 PM
Absolutely not and no one else's should either. These clips are redundant on all the cars as the factory saw fit to eliminate them in the middle of the 81 production run without revising seal retention. The seals are an internally metal ribbed press fit anyway and all the clips do is harbor water and rust. This permanently stains the adjacent vinyl and rusts out the seal ribbing causing the seal to fail and fall off the body edges. The next victim is your pants or leg as it slides across the now exposed retaining clips.
When changing the seal remove these clips and throw them as far downwind as possible taking care not to hit anyone or thing as they have sharp edges. Anyone who sells you these to aid in the installation of new seals is just lining their pocket at your expense and should spend at least a week in Delorean purgatory if not hell! I swear to God that both really do exist as I've spent time there for lesser transgressions. ;)

Wurth Rubber Glue #0890100 is $27.39 a can and Rubber Care #0890110 is $19.95. Yes they're insanely expensive, as are most things German, and worth every penny as are some things German. I'm allowed to say this as I am 3/4's German despite my last name.
Rob


Hey Rob-

Do your inner door seals require the retaining clips? Also, I would be interested in finding out how much the winzer and rubber care would cost.

Thanks!

DMC5180
03-08-2015, 06:19 PM
Absolutely not and no one else's should either. These clips are redundant on all the cars as the factory saw fit to eliminate them in the middle of the 81 production run without revising seal retention. The seals are an internally metal ribbed press fit anyway and all the clips do is harbor water and rust. This permanently stains the adjacent vinyl and rusts out the seal ribbing causing the seal to fail and fall off the body edges. The next victim is your pants or leg as it slides across the now exposed retaining clips.
When changing the seal remove these clips and throw them as far downwind as possible taking care not to hit anyone or thing as they have sharp edges. Anyone who sells you these to aid in the installation of new seals is just lining their pocket at your expense and should spend at least a week in Delorean purgatory if not hell! I swear to God that both really do exist as I've spent time there for lesser transgressions. ;)

Wurth Rubber Glue #0890100 is $27.39 a can and Rubber Care #0890110 is $19.95. Yes they're insanely expensive, as are most things German, and worth every penny as are some things German. I'm allowed to say this as I am 3/4's German despite my last name.
Rob

Rob,

Are sure about the mid 81 elimination of those clips. Mine and a buddies oct / nov build cars have the little red rusted bastards on the sills. I like your description of them. 100% correct.

Are your inner door seals different than the current remanufactured DMCH stock?

PJ Grady Inc.
03-08-2015, 06:58 PM
Dennis,

It may not have been till later as in the 82 run come to think of it. Remember I'm an old man of 56 years and too lazy to go out in the shop and check on my "day off".
Yes as I tried to explain all of the seals in my kit are made for us as the letter G at the end of the part # indicates with these three door seal types (Surroud, T-roof, A & B Post).
DMCH has they're own repro of these seals to sell so why would they by mine? I like mine much better and know they'll last longer than "a little over a year and a half" (a lot longer) but of course I sell them so I could be biased. Maybe a customer or two with my seal kit could offer up their experience with them. I could name names but that wouldn't be PC.
I guess I did confuse and not clarify with my explanation...sorry!
Rob


Rob,

Are sure about the mid 81 elimination of those clips. Mine and a buddies oct / nov build cars have the little red rusted bastards on the sills. I like your description of them. 100% correct.

Are your inner door seals different than the current remanufactured DMCH stock?

mluder
03-09-2015, 02:40 AM
Our bespoke T-roof, door surround, and A/B post seals will last many years with no maintenance and even more if you bother to apply some type of rubber care product from time to time.

Winzer again has the best product for this and it's called, not surprisingly, "Rubber Care"! We stock it as well as the adhesive in a brush top can.
BTW I started making all of our rubber seals around 1998. We've sold hundreds of these seal kits since then and I've yet to see any of them tear or crack. I can't say your results will unconditionally be the same but the liklyhood is that it will.

Our kit #111666GP ($279.95) includes the surround seals, T-roof seals, and (exactly)pre-cut to fit A & B post seals saving you the hassle of doing it yourself. The adhesive glue and Rubber Care is available separately.
Rob Grady

Thanks, Rob.

I'm ok on t-roof and inner door seals.
What's the price for just a set (both doors, a and b pillar) trim?

Also, what's the best way to order? It seems your site no longer has full parts inventory - just a few selected items.

Cheers
Steve

MikeWard
03-09-2015, 08:09 AM
I have Martin's silicone rubber outer door seals and I like them quite a bit
The same silicone outer door seals are available for sale via the Eurotec club at an exceptionally good price:
http://www.deloreaneurotec.uk/viewtopic.php?f=66&t=3070

And the topic discussing having these seal's made up for those who are interested:
http://www.deloreaneurotec.uk/viewtopic.php?f=22&t=3041

PJ Grady Inc.
03-09-2015, 02:44 PM
Until I get all of our products on the new website (a large undertaking) the best way is to call toll free #(800)350-7429. For for those who don't care for phones you can fill out your info in the "contact us" with a description or DMC part #'s of what you want and we will get back to you with pricing and availability ASAP. Our website is secure for taking credit card info as well.
The A & B post kit is available in both precut for a perfect fit #108982-9GL for $109.80 and uncut #108982-9GLU for $79.80. They are also available for individual panels in precut and uncut versions. We even have a version with a smaller profile for cars with tight fitting panels.
Rob

don
Thanks, Rob.

I'm ok on t-roof and inner door seals.
What's the price for just a set (both doors, a and b pillar) trim?

Also, what's the best way to order? It seems your site no longer has full parts inventory - just a few selected items.

Cheers
Steve