View Full Version : General Stainless Fasteners
content22207_2
08-11-2016, 09:29 PM
Just spent all afternoon at the summer camp repairing aluminum canoes with stainless fasteners.
For everybody all "Ooo Ooo" about stainless fasteners: be aware -- if the passivated surface layer ever galls off, the fasteners will weld themselves together instantly, using nothing more than simple hand tools. That means the threads have to be absolutely perfect (I was replacing damaged thwarts with electrical conduit, and if a stainless fastener rubbed the conduit on the way through, rolling the threads even minutely, the nut would gall when tightening). Some fasteners come out of the box with less than perfect threads. And be careful not to overtorque the fastener -- that will gall a nut and bolt for sure.
Stainless on carbon is no problem -- they won't weld themselves together (for example, stainless nuts on carbon studs). It's stainless on stainless that galls.
Bill Robertson
#5939
content22207_2
08-11-2016, 09:36 PM
Also, the finer the thread pitch, the more likely stainless fasteners are to gall. This is one application where English/fractional fasteners are better than metric (ie: 1/4-20 versus 6x1mm).
Bill Robertson
#5939
DMCMW Dave
08-11-2016, 09:50 PM
Stainless on Aluminum is even worse. I hope nobody ever brings in an engine with stainless bolts holding the intake on.
Morpheus
08-11-2016, 09:54 PM
So... the fact that I replaced all the screws in my doors with stainless ones was a bad idea?
DMCMW Dave
08-11-2016, 09:55 PM
So... the fact that I replaced all the screws in my doors with stainless ones was a bad idea?
I think so. Unless you never wash the car.
Morpheus
08-11-2016, 09:59 PM
Well dammit. What do you recommend for corrosion resistance then? Black Oxide?
DMCMW Dave
08-11-2016, 10:59 PM
Well dammit. What do you recommend for corrosion resistance then? Black Oxide?
Black oxide is just controlled rust. There is a reason every car engine in the world is put together with zinc plated fasteners.
Stainless fasteners are great on boats where they are screwed into the wood or fiberglass.
Drive Stainless
08-11-2016, 11:12 PM
Do you want it to gall in place or rust in place? Pick your poison. Anti-seize avoids both.
I've had M6, M7, and M8 stainless bolts holding my engine together since 2008, including the oil pan, valve covers, timing cover, intake, exhaust, water pump, alternator, starter, and AC compressor.
content22207_2
08-11-2016, 11:24 PM
Electrolysis/galvanic corrosion (stainless welding itself to aluminum) is a slow process. Takes many years. And it needs moisture as an electrolyte (cooling system for example). If you do any engine maintenance/repair, turning the fasteners, at least once a decade you should be fine.
Galling, by contrast, is instantaneous. Feels kind of like cross threading -- you're turning the fastener no problem, then all of a sudden it puts up resistance. If you try to back the nut off and it won't budge, the fasteners have galled together. Just put some serious torque on the bolt, snap it off, and try again with new fasteners (stainless fasteners aren't strong at all -- you can snap them off with ordinary flat wrenches).
Bill Robertson
#5939
content22207_2
08-11-2016, 11:28 PM
Again, stainless only galls to itself. Stainless on carbon won't gall.
Bill Robertson
#5939
DMC-81
08-11-2016, 11:33 PM
So is the galling of stainless on stainless just a concern during installation? Meaning, once installed, they shouldn't suffer galvanic corrosion as in the case of dis-similar metals like stainless and aluminum.
Galling info and mitigation: http://www.estainlesssteel.com/gallingofstainless.html
Galvanic corrosion info: https://www.fastenal.com/content/feds/pdf/Article%20-%20Corrosion.pdf
I understood stainless on stainless is OK. See the plating compatibility chart in the second link.
:dunno:
content22207_2
08-11-2016, 11:42 PM
Galled fasteners:
45334
Galling happens when stainless' passivated surface rubs off. In the process of reoxidizing the two surfaces weld themselves together. That's why it's so difficult to machine drive stainless fasteners together -- high speed is highly susceptible to galling.
Really the only area this would be a concern for DeLorean owners is things like stainless nuts on stainless exhaust studs (stainless nuts on carbon exhaust studs are fine), nuts & bolts holding the coolant expansion tank, etc. Stainless bolts into aluminum have their own problems, but that takes years, although high humidity environments such as Florida and the Gulf Coast probably accelerate the process. And as stated if you do end up galling your fasteners together, just snap them off and start again.
Bill Robertson
#5939
Mark D
08-12-2016, 01:00 AM
Just use anti seize when installing stainless on stainless. At my job we use Tef Gel for various applications including stainless bolts with stainless lock nuts. Tef Gel is also great when installing stainless fasteners into aluminum. Not a recommended combination if you can avoid it but it's not a death sentence as long as you don't install the fasteners dry. Lots of stainless fasteners on fire trucks.
http://www.tefgel.com/contain.php?param=tefgel_infor
http://www.westmarine.com/buy/tef-gel--corrosion-eliminator-and-anti-sieze-lubricant--P012222212
DMC-81
08-12-2016, 08:29 AM
Just use anti seize when installing stainless on stainless. At my job we use Tef Gel for various applications including stainless bolts with stainless lock nuts. Tef Gel is also great when installing stainless fasteners into aluminum. Not a recommended combination if you can avoid it but it's not a death sentence as long as you don't install the fasteners dry. Lots of stainless fasteners on fire trucks.
http://www.tefgel.com/contain.php?param=tefgel_infor
http://www.westmarine.com/buy/tef-gel--corrosion-eliminator-and-anti-sieze-lubricant--P012222212
Cool. Thanks Mark. Speaking of fire equipment, I heard about one example of galvanic corrosion recently from my brother in law who is a fire platoon chief. He relayed that they bought a new fire truck and within a year, there was bubbling in the paint near all the fasteners. The manufacturer didn't account for galvanic corrosion, and had to fix it.
I learned something in this thread. I figured out long ago working on my boats that I needed to take my time and install SS fasteners slowly, and I figured it was the relatively soft nature of the metal. Now I know the specifics. I'll remember it this way... "Stainless fasteners have enough gall to want to bind". :)
Mark D
08-12-2016, 02:32 PM
Cool. Thanks Mark. Speaking of fire equipment, I heard about one example of galvanic corrosion recently from my brother in law who is a fire platoon chief. He relayed that they bought a new fire truck and within a year, there was bubbling in the paint near all the fasteners. The manufacturer didn't account for galvanic corrosion, and had to fix it.
I learned something in this thread. I figured out long ago working on my boats that I needed to take my time and install SS fasteners slowly, and I figured it was the relatively soft nature of the metal. Now I know the specifics. I'll remember it this way... "Stainless fasteners have enough gall to want to bind". :)
Any idea what manufacturer they got their fire truck from? Our company has mostly aluminum bodies and cabs.... When bolting through a painted aluminum panel fasteners are isolated with nylon washers and Tef-gel.
Our steel frames are all e-coated (after the holes are drilled) and then then top coated black. All the frame hardware is Magni 575 coated. Once assembled the entire rolling chassis is top coated again.
Hot dip galvanized frame options are also available for even better corrosion protection.
DMC-81
08-12-2016, 08:48 PM
Any idea what manufacturer they got their fire truck from? Our company has mostly aluminum bodies and cabs.... When bolting through a painted aluminum panel fasteners are isolated with nylon washers and Tef-gel.
Our steel frames are all e-coated (after the holes are drilled) and then then top coated black. All the frame hardware is Magni 575 coated. Once assembled the entire rolling chassis is top coated again.
Hot dip galvanized frame options are also available for even better corrosion protection.
No, I didn't hear who the manufacturer was. They are in the northeast (Canada), so corrosion protection is important.
It sounds like your company is doing it right!
Farrar
08-13-2016, 03:36 PM
Really the only area this would be a concern for DeLorean owners is things like stainless nuts on stainless exhaust studs
I used copper (https://www.belmetric.com/hex-with-flange-c-3_51_53/ncf7x11-copper-flange-nut-p-188.html?zenid=iorglro751cim4lipvs5suv104) (on black steel studs). Here's hoping.
Bitsyncmaster
08-13-2016, 04:29 PM
You won't have problems if the threads are not a tight fit. I use 10-32 stainless for the screws on the closing panels in the trunk and you don't need to use any lube on those. The 10-32 is a little smaller than the metric size.
It's also very common to use stainless screws into stainless helicoil with aircraft components and there never is a problem removing those screws.
content22207_2
08-13-2016, 04:49 PM
Stainless can sit in stainless into perpetuity. Galling occurs while fastening. I guess it could happen while unfastening too, but that's never happened to me (I always gall while fastening). As long as it's a fastener into an accessible nut you can simply snap them off and try again.
I use black nylon fasteners in all my access panel rivnuts. If ever necessary you can simply push them out with a punch (rivnut spinning for example). I also supply them with carb conversion charcoal canister blockoff plates.
McMaster sells M7x1mm nuts in a variety of materials for carbon steel exhaust manifold studs (I used stainless on mine, but brass is also an option: http://www.mcmaster.com/#90690a052/=13plk3d)
Bill Robertson
#5939
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.