PDA

View Full Version : General Door Strut Question



SShaw
09-01-2016, 02:50 PM
I'm looking for some advice related to door struts. If I don't keep a hand on my doors they bounce at the top. Before I go down the path of adjusting the torsion bars I was thinking about replacing my struts with Grady struts. I've read they dampen at the top which could help my problem. Though, if they are stronger than my current struts I imagine it could also make my problem worse. Here are my current struts. I've only had the car for a year so I don't know what kind or how old they are. Thanks for the help.

460914609246093

Jonathan
09-01-2016, 03:03 PM
I don't see any markings that tell me what kind you have. Someone else might know though.

Generally speaking, the door struts work well when the outside temperature isn't too hot or too cold (same goes for the car as a whole). Say about 70 degrees F is the sweet spot. You want to approach doing a torsion bar adjustment in about the same way as you might when considering surgery to fix an injury. If you can get away without setting foot in an operating room and just do rehab or some physio to fix your issue, that's way better. Same with torsion bar adjustments. Consider them a last resort and only after exhausting all other options.

I would gauge the performance of your door struts by how well they do when at this 70 deg F mark. When it is much warmer out, the doors will spring up a lot quicker. When much colder out, they will droop. That's not really strut manufacturer specific, just a general rule of thumb. Some struts claim to be better temperature compensated. I think that compensation is only marginal (from the ones I've seen or bought myself).

Also keep in mind that the weight of the doors is a surprisingly well balanced engineering marvel. If you go into your door and remove the trim and armrest and maybe a bracket or two and definitely once taking out the drop glass, you'll notice how much more they fire up with that weight removed. If you swapped out window motors or door lock solenoids with lighter ones, it can have a similar effect.

Just some food for thought as you're planning your next move.

sdg3205
09-01-2016, 03:30 PM
Have your torsion bars ever been ramped up to compensate for bad struts? Remove the strut and see how the door hangs unassisted, it should only hang out a 4-6" from closed if I remember correctly (vendor can confirm for you).

If your bars are over torqued new struts won't solve the underlying problem.

Elvis
09-01-2016, 07:04 PM
2-4"

SShaw
09-01-2016, 09:30 PM
I don't know if the torsion bars have been adjusted. I would guess not. I'll take off a strut, see where the door sits and go from there.

Any input on which strut has the most dampening? I think it's Grady's.

novadmc
09-01-2016, 10:02 PM
I don't know if the torsion bars have been adjusted. I would guess not. I'll take off a strut, see where the door sits and go from there.

Any input on which strut has the most dampening? I think it's Grady's.

+1 for Grady's.

stabilus struts that my car came with got weak within a year. bought the amazon supplied strongarm struts. they held the doors up fully but were stiff and still required assistance opening the doors the last 1/3 the way.

Grady's are great and open the doors fully with no bounce. would/will buy again when its time (and probably buy his louver struts soon since those are starting to weaken)

DavidProehl
09-07-2016, 11:25 AM
I have Grady's struts and am very happy with the dampening on them. Strong initial lift and soft finish. I've had them for almost a year, and so far so good. On my last set of struts one failed after only 3 months. These seem better built than that.