Log in

View Full Version : Engine Cooling Fan Failure



bfloyd
09-08-2016, 03:33 PM
Moving further discussion of my problem from the "Driving Across the Country" thread to here.

With my impending trip to the Chicago area and to drop the car off at DMC Midwest, upon Dave's advise, I took the car out last night for it's first ever 200+ mile non-stop road trip. The car performed flawlessly all the way out and almost back home before I had some cooling fan issues creep up on me.

I had stopped at a rest area along the interstate for a quick pit stop (maybe 15 minutes), then heading back out on the highway. As soon as I started up the car the "FAN FAIL" lights on the dashboard came on. Ever since I've replaced my air conditioning system, the car displays the FAN FAIL light for about 2-3 minutes (with the A/C turned on) then they turn off by themselves. Same situation last night. Drove for about 2-3 minutes and the lights went off. Then the further I kept going, I noticed they'd come back on for a minute or so then go back out. Never done that before. I turned the A/C off and the FAN FAIL lights would immediately go off. It was a relatively cool evening (10:30 p.m.) so driving with just the vent fans running wasn't an issue for me.

As I pulled off the interstate and back into the traffic of the town where I live, the fan fail lights came back on and stayed on the entire four miles from the interstate to the house. Once home, I left the engine running and got out to check the fans. Right side fan was running, left side fan was not. Turning the A/C on and off made no difference. Got my infrared thermometer out of the garage and shot the temps on the coolant hoses on the left and right sides of the water pump. After almost 4 hours of continuous driving I shot 176 degrees on the right and 196 degrees on the left.

My car has the original blue fan fail module in it as well as all of the original factory relays and circuit breakers. The otterstat was replaced last year with a new one from DMCH, as part of the cooling system hose kit.

Reading through the forums here, it seems I should pull the existing fan fail module and replace it with a jumper. Fused or not... I've seen examples of both here. Today during lunch I went home and did a little testing to see if I could figure anything out. Turned the mode switch to Max A/C, turned the key and the right side fan did come on. Left one didn't do anything. Turned it off and spun both the fan blades by hand. BOTH spun freely. Crawled under the rear of the car and pulled the wires from the otterstat and jumped them together with a piece of wire. Turned the mode switch to OFF and turned the key... NO FANS at all.

Where do I go from here?

Bitsyncmaster
09-08-2016, 03:54 PM
Make up a jumper to replace the fan fail unit. Two 14 AWG wires are the smallest size but better would be 12 AWG. It's hard to find a spade pin to crimp two heavy AWG wires though.

If you had low power fans you could use 16 AWG.

David T
09-08-2016, 08:50 PM
An easier way is to make 3 short pieces of wire and put a spade terminal on one end of each wire.Strip the other 3 ends and use a wire nut to connect all three together.

DMCMW Dave
09-08-2016, 11:16 PM
An easier way is to make 3 short pieces of wire and put a spade terminal on one end of each wire.Strip the other 3 ends and use a wire nut to connect all three together.

Wire nuts in a car are the work of the devil. Whenever I see those in a car it's a sure sign of prior hackage.

Drive Stainless
09-09-2016, 12:20 AM
Lol

bfloyd
09-09-2016, 03:01 AM
Think I got this sorted out. Got home from the theatre tonight and went to work on the car in the garage.

Pulled the carpet away from the parcel shelf to access the fuses and relays, and found a nicely melted blue fan fail module. The socket was not harmed, so I made up a temporary two wire jumper, crimped the terminals on and plugged it in. Turned the key on and set the mode switch to max A/C... still only one fan.

Turned everything off and crawled under the front of the car with my probe tester to see if I was even getting power to the dead fan. Reached up and connected the ground clip to the grounding bolt next to the radiator support bracket, then went to unplug both fans from the harness. Right side was a little bit of a struggle to get out, but when I just barely touched the left side harness connector it just fell out all by it self.
Turned the key back on and probed both connectors and had power to both. Cleaned the terminal pins inside the wires coming off of both fans and plugged them back in.
Both fans now work!

Today I learned that cooling fans work much better when they are plugged in.

Going to order the upgraded relay kit from DMC in the morning and get it installed before we make our way up to Chicago.

Bitsyncmaster
09-09-2016, 07:32 AM
The two pin fan connectors have side latches that hold the connectors mated tightly. Make sure those latches are still there.

iflights
09-09-2016, 08:52 AM
Going to order the upgraded relay kit from DMC in the morning and get it installed before we make our way up to Chicago.

My understanding is that both DMCH relay kits only provide a fused "Y" jumper to replace your fan fail module. My recommendation would be to obtain a solid state fan-fail module replacement from bitsyncmaster.

David T
09-09-2016, 10:40 AM
Wire nuts in a car are the work of the devil. Whenever I see those in a car it's a sure sign of prior hackage.

I agree but to make it easier for someone to put those 3 wires together without soldering them, a wire nut is a quick way. A wire nut is code approved for much higher voltages and currents if properly used.

FABombjoy
09-09-2016, 01:40 PM
Citing the NEC for constructing a fan fail bypass jumper with a wire nut?

https://i.imgur.com/KBNcZ.gif


Edit: Unless you're talking about this style:
https://www.grainger.com/product/IDEAL-Nylon-Closed-End-Crimp-Connector-6LU60
Which is ugly but far less bad and still needs proper tools and technique.

bfloyd
09-09-2016, 06:45 PM
Thanks for all the help folks. I've got a temporary 12 gauge jumper wire in there for now to get me to the car show and back on Saturday. I went ahead and ordered bitsyncmaster's new "Solid State Fan Fail" module and it should be here by middle of the week before we head out on our trip.

Josh
09-09-2016, 07:54 PM
An easier way is to make 3 short pieces of wire and put a spade terminal on one end of each wire.Strip the other 3 ends and use a wire nut to connect all three together.

No David, No.

David T
09-09-2016, 10:20 PM
No David, No.


I should have qualified it and said it is a temporary fix. I also don't like seeing wire nuts in a car but if that's all you can do it will work. The problem is you can't use the proper spade terminals and stick 2 wires into one of them. They aren't made for that. The best way would be to solder the splice together but not everyone can do that. Theoretically there is no reason you can't use a wire nut, it will work. As long as it is in a dry place and is the proper size for the 3 wires.