PDA

View Full Version : New Underbodies from Houston?



tjd
09-01-2011, 07:59 AM
http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=4734&d=1314830473

Unceremoniously announced yesterday by James, DMCH is having the 1st new DeLorean underbody made in Louisiana out of modern materials (whatever that means, I wonder if they still have to pay a royalty to Lotus?). It is apparently going to debut at the DMCH open house.

You know I was just thinking the other day, what improved part would I most like to see for my DeLorean? James you must of read my mind how did you know I wanted a NEW underbody? This has got to go right in their with making new reproduction dashboards ahead of new binacles on the list of "best" decisions made by the good folks down in Houston. Way to go!!!

I await with unbridled anticipation for your next new improved part announcement.

sean
09-01-2011, 08:15 AM
Queue Steve's "James where my binnacle at?" quip in 3....2....


:D

Michael
09-01-2011, 08:52 AM
Actually James announced many months ago that they had the molds to make new underbodies, and would probably do so when needed.

tjd
09-01-2011, 09:08 AM
Actually James announced many months ago that they had the molds to make new underbodies, and would probably do so when needed.

True that part of it isn't "new". I thought it was news worthy that it has now been put into motion and this new "improved" part will be shown in Houston at the open house. I'm really feeling with this announcement that DMCH now more then ever has it's finger on the pulse of what us "used" DeLorean owners want in new improved part offerings.

Bitsyncmaster
09-01-2011, 10:43 AM
So would a carbon fiber underbody fix any deficiencies?

thegovernor9912
09-01-2011, 01:57 PM
I would like to see the amount of zeroes that would be on the invoice for a carbon fiber underbody.


I wonder what "modern materials" means..

Farrar
09-01-2011, 02:45 PM
Price notwithstanding, I think a carbon fiber body would be overkill as its strength would mean that you would hardly need a frame -- think of the original prototype; I am guessing that such a drastic redesign of the chassis is not in the cards. Nonetheless, I am excited to see the result!

Farrar

stevedmc
09-01-2011, 02:53 PM
Queue Steve's "James where my binnacle at?" quip in 3....2....


:D

YEAH, how the hell are they going to make new underbodies when they can't even produce a binnacle?

dmc6960
09-01-2011, 06:06 PM
YEAH, how the hell are they going to make new underbodies when they can't even produce a binnacle?

An already constructed mold ready to go?

Farrar
09-01-2011, 06:22 PM
An already constructed mold ready to go?

Bingo!

Farrar

timothymoore
09-01-2011, 06:32 PM
that would be cool if there were seperate panels , as in i need floorboard and dont need the whole tub

Dracula
09-02-2011, 01:19 AM
I'd imagine that left front fenders would be a higher priority than underbodies. After all, one can be repaired by a decent fiberglass shop.

Ryan King
09-02-2011, 02:52 AM
YEAH, how the hell are they going to make new underbodies when they can't even produce a binnacle?

Remind me again why recovering a Binnacle is so hard? I bought one from DMC-CA that was recovered by an outside source, and it is by far better looking and better quality then the originals ever were. They are done up to match the stitching of the center console. I don't see the issue...or maybe its because I am not a purist?

4764

dmc4087
09-02-2011, 05:37 AM
Remind me again why recovering a Binnacle is so hard? I bought one from DMC-CA that was recovered by an outside source, and it is by far better looking and better quality then the originals ever were. They are done up to match the stitching of the center console. I don't see the issue...or maybe its because I am not a purist?

4764

That looks great!

Bitsyncmaster
09-02-2011, 06:14 AM
Maybe they can do the underbodies in a newer material and save a 100 pounds of weight.

Dracula
09-02-2011, 08:03 AM
Remind me again why recovering a Binnacle is so hard? I bought one from DMC-CA that was recovered by an outside source, and it is by far better looking and better quality then the originals ever were. They are done up to match the stitching of the center console. I don't see the issue...or maybe its because I am not a purist?

4764

Some people, myself included, hate the look of the recovered binnacles with the stitching. I don't like it and I don't want it in my car. For me, it's that simple.

john 05141
09-02-2011, 09:00 AM
4765

Mine is recovered. No stiches!! You can see some folds near the lens, but I do not mind at all.

But we're off topic.
I do like that DMC is investing in tooling and updates. There will always be someone not happy with what they are upgrading first but it pleases me new things come alive. I certainly need no underbody or a binacle, but I'm always interested in what's next... You never know what might fail that is no longer available.

John




John

Dracula
09-02-2011, 10:39 AM
Per the topic at hand, how much need is there really for new underbodies? I mean, they're so scarce that DeLorean owners hoard them like spare torsion bars and left front fenders, right? Given the high tendency for the originals to fail, how could we have ever possibly gotten along without them in the last 30 years? Everyone will be beating down their door to get a new one and there's going to be a run on DMCH as soon as they get them in stock. I don't see how a single DeLorean owner WON'T buy one or two.

Sarcasm aside, I know that people from DMCH had commented that new parts can only be produced when people spend enough money on new parts to justify their creation. Remember when they were taking discounted pre-orders of the dashes? They had posted to the extent that these products required large investments in order to generate results and had to have a high enough demand to be worth undertaking in the first place. If that's true, how can they possibly justify the creation of underbodies? I'd have looked into a low-cost frame solution; say, a galvanized one, for those who don't want to spend the nearly $10,000.00 on a stainless one. You can leave a DeLorean sitting in a field for 30 years and the underbody will still be intact, as opposed to the frame. Getting away from a tangent, I'd like to know what sort of projected sales they expect to see from these replacements. I know of several people who have parted out cars, only to be stuck with the underbody because nobody wanted it. It's also a lot of work to swap EVERYTHING over from the underbody and not something that's going to appeal to the vast majority of owners or anyone restoring the car on a budget. Whatever the price is on these things, and I assume it's going to be a lot to offset things like the shipping costs alone, it's not really needed. Though, there's also no mention as to whether or not they'll be compatible with the originals so that you can use them to repair one that's damaged in a crash. If they're not, then I foresee even fewer selling.

The only reason I can think of for them to create these things is as a gimmick for their refurbished cars. Then that brings up the question of what will they do with the originals? Will they sell them off in parts or as whole units? If they do, how do they price them? If they cost less than their new ones, it'd have to hurt sales. If they don't sell them, they take up only slightly less space than an entire car and storage becomes an issue, though, I suppose, they could sit outside under a tarp. Then there's the possibility that they'll shred them up so that there are no alternatives to buying a new one and they don't have to store both the new ones and originals.

Will these new underbodies mean the intentional destruction of originals?

DeloreanJoshQ
09-02-2011, 01:27 PM
If they have complete underbodies to add to new frames, perhaps they have plans to build complete cars using the existing supply of parts in addition to future reproduction pieces.

Maybe we will see left front fenders(along with other current unavailable parts we need) reproduced in the near future??

It would be pretty cool if they can successfully create additional VINd cars....

dvonk
09-02-2011, 01:35 PM
It would be pretty cool if they can successfully create additional VINd cars....

or if they could revive 'dead' VINs from wrecked/parts cars.

stevedmc
09-02-2011, 01:35 PM
If they have complete underbodies to add to new frames, perhaps they have plans to build complete cars using the existing supply of parts in addition to future reproduction pieces.

Maybe we will see left front fenders(along with other current unavailable parts we need) reproduced in the near future??

It would be pretty cool if they can successfully create additional VINd cars....

YEAH, I seriously doubt it. They would have to pay off a lot of people to magically be able to pass the emission and safetly standards of today. A used car doesn't have to follow the same rules as newly manufactured cars hence they aren't having to deal with stuff like that with their REBUILT cars.

Dracula
09-02-2011, 02:18 PM
YEAH, I seriously doubt it. They would have to pay off a lot of people to magically be able to pass the emission and safetly standards of today. A used car doesn't have to follow the same rules as newly manufactured cars hence they aren't having to deal with stuff like that with their REBUILT cars.

I'm glad someone else stated this. That was a big part of why DeLoreans are powered by the PRV to begin with; ZJD saved money by going with an engine that already met US emissions standards in 1981.

The simple fact of the matter is that DMCH will NEVER BE ABLE TO BUILD NEW CARS because of safety and emissions restrictions. They'll never be able to get new VINS generated and the only thing I could see is that they rebuild a car without VIN tags, buy a parts one with it, swap the tags on, and call it a that car, instead, but I suspect that there would be serious legal repercussions. The only way they could build a car with a 2011 VIN is if they use a car built in 2011. Now, if they found a way to make an underbody that goes onto a Pontiac Solstice, oh wait...

Chris4099
09-02-2011, 02:18 PM
When I went to the DMCH open house in 07, they were talking about building new under-bodies. James said something about new fiberglass materials being available that they could make them stronger and about 300 pounds lighter! He also said the number of easily repairable under-bodies was slowing decreasing. Since they still have the factory molds, getting new ones made shouldn't be that difficult.

1Mcfly4u
09-02-2011, 02:24 PM
So I'm guessing they bought the set of molds that were laying out in the field in the U.K.?

SoCalDMC12
09-02-2011, 02:44 PM
When I went to the DMCH open house in 07, they were talking about building new under-bodies. James said something about new fiberglass materials being available that they could make them stronger and about 300 pounds lighter!

Wow... how much do the original the underbodies weigh???

GS450-Junkie
09-05-2011, 07:37 PM
Yeah, let's hear how they got the molds in the first place. That's interesting....

Chris4099
09-05-2011, 10:59 PM
The fiberglass molds didn't get the same treatment as the stainless steel panel molds. My understanding is they went with the rest of the spare parts inventory to Kapac and then eventually with DMCH. I remember seeing a set there at their 07 open house.

EdR5150
09-05-2011, 11:27 PM
Are the DMCH molds the same ones seen here? http://www.pjgrady.co.uk/GenericContent.aspx?PageType=Rare_Items&ShowContent=Body_Moulds.html

Patrick C
09-05-2011, 11:33 PM
Are the DMCH molds the same ones seen here? http://www.pjgrady.co.uk/GenericContent.aspx?PageType=Rare_Items&ShowContent=Body_Moulds.html

No

tjd
09-05-2011, 11:52 PM
The decision to produce these makes little business sense to me, like Chad has said the underbodies are not hard to come by, and have little to no demand. Anyone that has parted a DeLorean out can attest to that as they probably still have one collecting dust somewhere. This IMO is another "new" build gimmick. They probably could have bought 20 mint used underbodies for what the shipping of the molds cost alone. Why not put their money toward something more usefull that their core customers would buy instead???

Originally Posted by DeloreanJoshQ
"If they have complete underbodies to add to new frames, perhaps they have plans to build complete cars using the existing supply of parts in addition to future reproduction pieces.

Maybe we will see left front fenders(along with other current unavailable parts we need) reproduced in the near future??

It would be pretty cool if they can successfully create additional VINd cars...."

A New DeLorean based on the original will never exist. Despite the propoganda by DMCH that "donor parts are only required to retain the original 81,82,83 model year" BS there are a whole host of safety and design elements that would never fly with the DOT as a newly produced 2011 model year automobile. The only way around the DOT is if they go the road of selling something as a component (kit) car.

Chris 16409
09-05-2011, 11:54 PM
I don't see these being offered for sale via web or phone order. I mean it's possible but not economically feasible. I think the intent is to use them for the "new build" cars and for cars that have been in accidents. They'd have to be installed at one of the dealer locations. Besides, if you've had an accident, insurance should cover the cost or most of it anyway. Realistically, if this were an "end user" serviceable part, how long would it take to complete the project at your home. I would't want to deal with the hassle of a self install, especially if the labor is on the insurance company's dime. My car is a daily driver, and I think of it as such, in that how long would I want to be without my car. Like I said, if they start to produce these underbodies, the mass majority of them are going to end up in "New Build" cars.

DMC5180
09-06-2011, 02:12 AM
I would put making a new underbody from "modern" materials in the category of part R&D experiment and perhaps at the request of a customer that wants a one of kind Delorean and is willing to pay for it. It would be a win/win for both parties and all of us should the outcome be successful in proving the viability of the molds. From a numbers standpoint it does not work. Since the cost involved would likely be way more than buying salvage car underbody pieces. A modern material underbody is Apples and Oranges by comparison.

This brings to mind the Special LHD car that Martin is working on for a Customer in Australia. That customer paid major $$$$$ just too create the Diecast tools for 17"and 18" OEM style wheels because he wanted a Delorean with OEM Styled cast wheels for todays modern sized tires.

In terms of weight savings, a lot could be done to save weight and stiffen the underbody at the same time. The technological advancements today over what was used 30 years ago is staggering. In the Old days it was Chopped fiberglass mat and Polyester or Vinylester wet lay resin RICH (heavy) process. Todays technology uses modern wooven S or E type fiberglass, Kelvar or Carbon fiber and optimizes resin content ratios with (pre impregnated) or (Prepreg) for short with sandwich foam or Nomex honeycomb core for stiffness and shear strength. The down side of prepreg materials is the need for an oven or hot room to cure it at temps up to 250F. This in itself requires the tooling to be of a high temp stable resin system or a steel tool. Its hard to say what the Original molds were designed for. Seems like I recall the factory using some sort oven curing to help speed the process though.

TTait
09-06-2011, 03:19 AM
I don't see these being offered for sale via web or phone order. I mean it's possible but not economically feasible. I think the intent is to use them for the "new build" cars and for cars that have been in accidents. They'd have to be installed at one of the dealer locations. Besides, if you've had an accident, insurance should cover the cost or most of it anyway. Realistically, if this were an "end user" serviceable part, how long would it take to complete the project at your home. I would't want to deal with the hassle of a self install, especially if the labor is on the insurance company's dime. My car is a daily driver, and I think of it as such, in that how long would I want to be without my car. Like I said, if they start to produce these underbodies, the mass majority of them are going to end up in "New Build" cars.

I have a hard time envisioning an accident that makes the sub body non-repairable yet does not total the car (once you add in the labor for Houston et al to swap everything over). I just don't see an insurance company every ponying up the cost for this... Its got to be a special request by someone with deep deep pockets.

SoCalDMC12
09-09-2011, 02:37 AM
In terms of weight savings, a lot could be done to save weight and stiffen the underbody at the same time. The technological advancements today over what was used 30 years ago is staggering. In the Old days it was Chopped fiberglass mat and Polyester or Vinylester wet lay resin RICH (heavy) process. Todays technology uses modern wooven S or E type fiberglass, Kelvar or Carbon fiber and optimizes resin content ratios with (pre impregnated) or (Prepreg) for short with sandwich foam or Nomex honeycomb core for stiffness and shear strength. The down side of prepreg materials is the need for an oven or hot room to cure it at temps up to 250F.

I'm sure that there have been great advances in fiberglass technology over the past 30 years, but 300 lbs. seems amazing. So does the purported 300 lb. weight savings represent a 20% decrease in the underbody's weight? 50% decrease? Any guesses?

DMCH James
09-09-2011, 08:48 PM
Interesting reading, wish I could comment on some of the posts, but here's some more photos taken yesterday.

Top photo is the top body half mold opened up and next are some of the molds for the foam inserts that go in door sills, etc along with some of the cutting jigs. The final two photos are more shots of the top and bottom molds opened up.

James

dvonk
09-09-2011, 08:55 PM
those molds are awesome!

Farrar
09-10-2011, 11:23 AM
Beautiful, James! Two thumbs up!

Farrar

Dracula
09-10-2011, 11:32 AM
Interesting reading, wish I could comment on some of the posts, but here's some more photos taken yesterday.

Top photo is the top body half mold opened up and next are some of the molds for the foam inserts that go in door sills, etc along with some of the cutting jigs. The final two photos are more shots of the top and bottom molds opened up.

James

You can comment on anything you want. America still encourages free speech, after all. Besides, we have a few questions, like projected cost and intended customer base. Or my bigger question of, if you're making these new underbodies and frames, then are you just transferring the VIN tags to a different vehicle that's never been safety-tested or certified for road use? There could be quite the lawsuit on your hands if that's the case and I can't imagine that's legal to begin with.

TheDutchTexan
09-10-2011, 12:13 PM
Dracula has a point there. But, if you look at the other end of the spectrum there are muscle-cars out there with aftermarket frames, and I doubt those went trough crash testing.

The body tubs are more of a replacement part I feel. Naturally you would take the vin plate and bolt it over. I would think a 30 year old tub is less safe than one built in 2011 with today's materials and advancements.

But, still. I do wonder what the letter of the law would have to say about that. Insurance companies will OWN your ass if there is any reason not to pay out. Not conforming to regulations makes it real easy for them.

Farrar
09-10-2011, 12:48 PM
The folks in Houston aren't amateurs. I am sure they have all their ducks in a row, including safety testing and the necessary miles of paperwork, before they enter into mass production of a part -- otherwise production would be an unwarranted gamble. Do you seriously think they would invest the money in making a part without calling an expert (probably a lawyer) and saying "So, can we do this?"

Perhaps the reason James doesn't want to comment is because he already has legal counsel (actual legal counsel, as opposed to comment from oiks on the Internet who think they know better). Perhaps the reason he doesn't want to comment is because he's saving the big announcement for the Open House next month. Perhaps he doesn't want to comment because he's simply too busy. There are as many reasons as you could possibly think of and more. At the end of the day, his reasons for not wanting to comment don't matter. DMCH is making a needed product. All of our stupid comments are just farts in the wind. The last thing the folks at Houston need is a bitchy snark-fest from people who will never buy their products, anyway.

...in my humble opinion.

Now have fun guessing why I am not going to comment further on this matter.

Farrar

Dracula
09-10-2011, 12:52 PM
I still say that calling the body tub a "needed product" is, in itself, wrong. Nobody has ever cited a real demand for them. In fact, many have posted to the exact opposite; going as far as giving them away in some cases.

protodelorean
09-10-2011, 12:57 PM
Can't wait to see the new underbodies. I'm sure you guys can do 100 times better in gel coat quality/overall finish. Fiberglass should be a no-brainer. Carbon fiber will be a bit more challenging since these are two-sided molds, they are designed to produce a part of a certain thickness. You wouldn't want/need/afford enough carbon fiber to fill that up. Could do fiberglass core with carbon outer layers.:thumbup:

A Van
09-10-2011, 01:08 PM
Nice wording Farrar

Canon20DFan
09-10-2011, 01:20 PM
Why is everybody jamming DMC about making new underbodies? It's up to them to decide if there's enough of a need to justify pressing a new underbody. I'm glad ANY Delorean part can be reproduced. We can wonder and guess and project what the cost to produce an underbody might be, but DMC knows for sure.

The new VIN discussion is separate from underbodies. Clearly DMC would need to classify new VINs as kit cars as a Delorean will not qualify for a new car by any stretch of the imagination. Air bags alone would require significant re-design of the cabin and electronics. The car would probably fail crash tests, too.

Dracula
09-10-2011, 01:44 PM
Why is everybody jamming DMC about making new underbodies?

Because they kept promising us parts like new binnacles, which there's a waiting list for, and then reveal this sort of thing which primarily serves to make their rebuilt cars seem like they're worth the exorbitant price tag.

AdmiralSenn
09-10-2011, 03:34 PM
The main question in my mind is whether they will have the spare tire well size problem fixed on the new ones.

Dracula
09-10-2011, 03:43 PM
The main question in my mind is whether they will have the spare tire well size problem fixed on the new ones.

I'd guess no, as it seems that they're re-using the original molds.

dvonk
09-10-2011, 03:50 PM
i dont think it would be too difficult to attach a larger sized wheel negative onto the mold... im unsure about the structural ramifications, however.

protodelorean
09-10-2011, 06:42 PM
i dont think it would be too difficult to attach a larger sized wheel negative onto the mold... im unsure about the structural ramifications, however.

Since it's a two-sided mold, it would be impossible without permanently modifying the original mold. On the male side, yes, you could patch a larger well over the original one, but on the female side, you'd have to cut out the original well and graft in a larger one. It would be easier to create a new mold of just the trunk floor with the ledger well. Mold new trunk floors and graft those in in place of the small wells.

dvonk
09-10-2011, 10:16 PM
well, shows what i know... :lol:

Ryan King
09-10-2011, 10:59 PM
Because they kept promising us parts like new binnacles, which there's a waiting list for, and then reveal this sort of thing which primarily serves to make their rebuilt cars seem like they're worth the exorbitant price tag.

Dude. Seriously? The binnacles are coming....

Second off. I love and am 100 percent behind Houston on the reproducing of new Underbodies. Houston runs a very small operation and has to make very cautious business decisions. I sincerely doubt Houston is making more then 5 underbodies. I don't understand why some of you have such an issue with Houston attempting to make our cars better and more modern and making parts more readily available...

If I were to get into a major front end crash, I would probably need to find a donor car and chop it up to replace the front part of my car. I would much rather save a donor DeLorean from being chopped up and buying an aftermarket new, updated underbody from Houston. I just don't see the issue here...

Its not like Houston is making a huge amount of underbodies. I don't see them making more then 5....

Also, Farrar, you rock.

Dracula
09-10-2011, 11:25 PM
Then what do you expect the projected cost of the underbodies to be? $5,000.00? $6,000.00? If they only make 5 or, say, a dozen, they're going to have hefty costs to recoup and that will be passed right on to anyone who purchases one, or, my biggest concern, that they raise the prices of other parts to compensate.

Let's not forget that Houston has a monopoly on DeLorean parts. If they were to suddenly at $20.00 to the cost of every part, with few exceptions, we'd have no choice but to pay it. Though, with that, comes seeking out cheaper alternatives, so they couldn't raise the part on everything, but almost every DeLorean-specific NOS part would be fair game for this.

These underbodies may also directly lead to the chopping up of more originals. If Houston is producing new ones for their cars, then they'd have to store those and originals. If they can sell their newer ones for more money, then who's to say they won't shred the original ones to make space? If Houston doesn't do it, others will. If a car gets into an accident and needs a replacement, but Houston's costs $5,000.00, whereas, a parts car will sell for $4,500.00 and include many other components, which do you think will be purchased and hacked up? I know I'd certainly want to go the cheaper route, especially if I could sell off some of the extra pieces from the parts car to even further lower the cost of the purchase.

My issue isn't making the cars more "modern" and reliable; my primary concern is that DeLorean ownership stays affordable. If this project doesn't bring them money, they will need to make up for it in some way; be it increasing labor rates or parts costs. Those increases affect everyone with a DeLorean because Houston controls the parts supply. It's a law of nature that with use, parts fail. As a result, we're always going to need replacement parts. If prices become too high, the cost of ownership will drive potential owners away and cause an increase in restoration costs. In addition, an increase of sales of the cars will occur because people can't afford to keep and maintain them, so the market price will go down.

I won't put on rose-colored glasses and pretend that Houston is the divine savior of the DeLorean world and incapable of doing no wrong. They are a business and any business will do what it has to in order to keep operating or else it will fail. This, and my other comments, are part of the foundation of economics. I'm not going to be afraid to speak my mind on something that I can see having multiple negative impacts on the DeLorean community just because its Houston that's doing it.

DMC5180
09-11-2011, 02:27 AM
James.

Do you have the structural steel components that were embedded in the Front section of the underbody? The ones I'm referring too are visible in the Jack storage area.

louielouie2000
09-11-2011, 04:18 AM
Dude. Seriously? The binnacles are coming....

Second off. I love and am 100 percent behind Houston on the reproducing of new Underbodies. Houston runs a very small operation and has to make very cautious business decisions. I sincerely doubt Houston is making more then 5 underbodies. I don't understand why some of you have such an issue with Houston attempting to make our cars better and more modern and making parts more readily available...

If I were to get into a major front end crash, I would probably need to find a donor car and chop it up to replace the front part of my car. I would much rather save a donor DeLorean from being chopped up and buying an aftermarket new, updated underbody from Houston. I just don't see the issue here...

Its not like Houston is making a huge amount of underbodies. I don't see them making more then 5....

Also, Farrar, you rock.

You just haven't been in the community long enough to understand many owners frustration with the DMC franchise. We've heard binnacles were coming for a decade now. Just think about waiting 10+ years for a part that you were always promised was right around the corner. It'd make you cranky too.

People are making a fuss about the underbodies for a number of reasons, and again, you probably don't have the wisdom of time to give you perspective here. Like you pointed out, DMC is not a large operation flush with cash. They have to pick one project to reproduce, devote all their resources to make it happen, then wait. Meanwhile, other projects/reproductions get shelved. Like others have pointed out, there really is no practical need for new underbodies. If a DeLorean's underbody is damaged to the point where it needs replacing, the entire car itself is already totaled. And I have totaled a DeLorean, so I know firsthand.

Like I stated before, people are just fed up with DMC taking on these absurd projects like the cartoonish Tonka Truck wheels, the underbodies, etc. They may claim they aren't wasting capital with these, but they're certainly wasting time they could be dedicating to the reproduction of parts which there is a genuine need for. Or they could use all the effort spent on these silly distractions (DeLorean Solstice anyone? :tongue:) to actually get cars through their shop in a legitimate amount of time. It seems if you send your DeLorean to DMCH you'd better be ready for it to be gone on a year long vacation... or more. Then you get your car back filthy, with things on your checklist not addressed, and 10 years later you're STILL waiting on your effing binnacle. You'd be p!ssed too! :giddy:

tjd
09-13-2011, 12:04 PM
Quote by Stephyn Wynne in the debut issue of DeLoreans magazine regarding reproducing parts


As with everything else DeLorean-related, it's a small market and that means that each new idea must have a broad appeal in order to make the numbers work

I don't see how a new underbody meets the broad appeal criteria as explained by Stephyn Wynne. Chad is right, and I too find it worrisome that if this project does not recoup the numbers to justify it's cost that DMCH will simply apply their losses to the stockpile of NOS parts and pass it on an across the board price hike on us all to cover their losses.

Also +1 to everything Louie said ^.

protodelorean
09-13-2011, 01:30 PM
Can someone tell me exactly how much money DMCH has invested in the underbody project? So many people have their panties in a bunch about the money DMCH is potentially wasting on this project, I figure the investment must be both a significant amount and common knowledge that I just missed.

Since Houston already had the molds, isn't it possible that they've contacted a firm that works with fiberglass (potentially a boat builder) and worked out a deal whereby DMCH loans the molds, the boat builder assumes the risk in prepping the molds and producing a prototype/proof, then will split the proceeds of any production orders for underbodies?

In this scenario, DMCH's investment could be next to zero. DMCH's risk if none ever get ordered: also zero. (With the exception of the boat builder maybe being pissed that he invested in producing the proof unit.)

Give the guys in Houston some credit.

tjd
09-13-2011, 02:24 PM
I think that it's quite a stretch to assume the cost to be zero or next too.

There are pictures of two truck loads leaving DMCH on 18 wheelers from Texas to an undisclosed location in Louisiana. Fuel costs for 18 wheelers are upwards of $800+ per fill up for an unknown range, and were talking fuel costs alone for shipping one way on one truck. How much do you suppose the shipping cost to be?

Give them credit? They promissed the binacle project would be complete and new binacles (that many need) would be ready for sale by July 2006, It is now mid September 2011 and we are still being strung along. Now without delivering what they promissed years ago they start into this project that has what appeal? Who has been screaming for a new underbody?

Again the quote by Stephen Wynne the CEO of DMCH


As with everything else DeLorean-related, it's a small market and that means that each new idea must have a broad appeal in order to make the numbers work


What would the material have to be in order for you to completely disassemble your car to install an improved underbody? A part that in practical theory none of us should need to replace. How is that broad appeal? By Stephen Wynnes statement if the item does not have broad appeal the numbers (whatever they may be) will not work.

It is impractical for you to minimise the cost of a project of this scale.

IMO DMCH embarking on a project like this is the equivilant of them playing russian roulette with the gun to our heads as DeLorean owners collectively. Kapac while they didn't innovate reproduction parts they did keep a steady hand and did not risk the stockpile of NOS parts while it was theirs to keep. Because of DMCH's unique position of holding 100% of the NOS parts inventory If DMCH take big chances on projects that make little financial sense they do so at our peril as by owning this car we are forced customers of theirs one way or the other which they will so arrogantly remind you of.

protodelorean
09-13-2011, 03:00 PM
To use your quote from Stephen:

"As with everything else DeLorean-related, it's a small market and that means that each new idea must have a broad appeal in order to make the numbers work..." - Stephen Wynne

I contend this is exactly why the costs/risk associated with this project must be zero or at least very low for DMCH to pursue it. That being the case, Stephen's logic above, holds true.

tjd
09-13-2011, 03:48 PM
I have a different perspective (this all still remains to be seen).

Let me explain, I think they hope it will have a broad appeal not necesarily to us the already DeLorean owner, but to a prospective DMCH "New" Build buyer. If they are able to shave a little more weight they'll have a slight gain in performance (see Josh Q's figures). Personaly out of the four DeLorean clubs I've been active with I know of zero "new" build owners. Maybe they are an anti social group I don't know. But that leads me to question how many of these they've actually sold.

That's where I see the risk, if it needs to be broad appeal to justify the costs (which Wynee says it needs to be) and if this fails to broaden the appeal of their product to the prospective "new" build customer and this doesn't increase those sales who is left to pick up the costs? The costs would be passed onto us through higher NOS part costs in order for them to recoup their losses.

This is just a theory ofcourse, and I hope I'm wrong. But if the underbody wont appeal to us and Wynne says it needs broad appeal. I can only think it's not targeted toward us and that it is instead targeted toward the "new" build customer but we are the ones left holding the bag if it doesn't pan out.

Bitsyncmaster
09-13-2011, 04:02 PM
Get a fiberglass guy to layup one. He only needs half the mold. No experimentation is needed just a good release agent. That cost would not be to high and they could decide what to do from how well the result is.

Canon20DFan
09-14-2011, 09:57 AM
Good grief - if I owned DMC I'd say none of your &$^! business what my costs are. How many people making judgements about the concept of new underbodies owns and runs a business the size of DMC? Do you expect Stephen Wynne to need your permission to launch a project? If they want to investigate new underbodies, let 'em. If it doesn't work out, DMC loses. If it does, they win. BTW, I've just defined a business...

dmcjohn
09-14-2011, 10:23 AM
I agree - don't see how it's anyone's business except DMCH's if they manufacture a new underbody.

I'm looking forward to seeing the results.

Having been through the process of swapping a damaged underbody out of a DeLorean and replacing everything from that body onto the new one, I have to say it's not a process I'd like to repeat anytime soon - it's a lot of work! But, if a carbon-fiber body was made someday, then I'd consider it - especially for something like an electric DeLorean project.

Dracula
09-14-2011, 11:30 AM
I agree - don't see how it's anyone's business except DMCH's if they manufacture a new underbody.

It's our business because we're their primary source of revenue. If they spend money in one area and don't make it back, then they'll have to find another place to recoup their losses. The easiest thing that comes to mind would be to raise the prices on, let's say, panels.

Here's a breakdown of the prices (pulled from their site minutes ago.):

LFF: $2,000.00 (in good condition, not listen on site.)
RFF: $745.00 (Without antenna hole.)
Hood(Flat): $1,076.44
Driver's Door: $1,000.00
Pass. Door: $1,000.00
T: $486.89
LR: $997.49
RR: $997.49

This brings the total of panels for the car to $8,303.31. It also helps to dictate what a parts car is worth. We all know that you can leave a DeLorean sit outside for years and the stainless won't suffer in the least, barring things falling on it. If you were to sell every panel on the car for half of the DMCH rate, then the parts car alone should be worth at least $4,151.65. The more prices go up on DeLorean-specific parts like the panels, the greater the number of cars that become more profitable to part out. The more cars parted out, the fewer left, overall, and demand for parts goes down. If demand decreases, then the price will have to rise to offset the lower number of parts sold and keep the company profitable. We are a captive audience, in the regard that we have to sit back and pay what DMCH wants for all DeLorean-specific parts if we want them to be NOS. They can, realistically, charge whatever they want for panels, and it will be accepted due to the lack of alternatives. So, should the underbodies fail to have a good return on investment, they can increase the cost of panels to recoup their losses.

I chose the example of panels for this explanation, but any part works just as well.

You'll notice, or at least I have, that they've gone up a bit in the last few years.

DMCH has claimed that they have our best interests and wants as a concern, then they come out with things like this. There is a notable demand for binnacles; often repeated because its the best example, and yet they've been promising them for a decade and constantly hearing us ask about them. In my 5 years of ownership and 8 following the DeLorean itself, I've never heard more than a slight demand for underbodies by owners of these cars who were repairing accident damage or attempted engine swaps, and they always have been able to get what they need. I see them as a self-serving part to help justify the bloated price tag on their refurbished cars and nothing more. Sure, you'll get a few people who by them to hack into possible electric cars or engine swaps, and that's a great thing, but, by and large, they're something Houston made for themselves, not us. Hopefully some more people will see that DMCH isn't there to be our friends, they're there to make money off of us. All businesses are. If you had a roofing company, would you replace the roofs on all of your friends houses for free because you own the company and are friends? No, because of the loss your business would take and the money you'd lose. The same goes for DMCH. If they can't make money off of these underbodies, DeLorean owners will be paying for the process, whether they know it or not.

It's all of our concern as DeLorean owners when a company that we have a vested interest in decides to undertake an expensive project because we'll be paying for it one way or another.

nullset
09-14-2011, 11:49 AM
It's our business because we're their primary source of revenue. If they spend money in one area and don't make it back, then they'll have to find another place to recoup their losses. The easiest thing that comes to mind would be to raise the prices on, let's say, panels.


It's still none of your business……

It's Stephen Wynne's company, it's not publicly traded, so I don't think they care what you or anyone else thinks.

And seriously, the binnacle thing is getting old. Okay, you want one. They don't have them. If you want it so bad and demand is so high, why don't you go off and have reproductions made? If they are good, you'd probably sell millions!

--buddy

AdmiralSenn
09-14-2011, 12:11 PM
Regarding the binnacles, I wonder if the delay isn't because they have to do extensive testing to see if they discolor or crack. If they have to leave one in direct sunlight for a year before finding out whether or not this particular formulation worked, that would add a lot of delays. Even testing every formulation at once still leaves huge swaths of time that are taken up by just waiting.

I'm sure they are working on it, and just wanting to make sure that it's an improved design that won't fall apart or split into a million pieces after six months.

dvonk
09-14-2011, 12:43 PM
Regarding the binnacles, I wonder if the delay isn't because they have to do extensive testing to see if they discolor or crack [...] to make sure that it's an improved design that won't fall apart or split into a million pieces after six months.

i can see how they would want to test extensively before releasing a final product... can you imagine how pissed everyone would be if they didnt last? the new binnacles are highly anticipated, and as anal as the DeLorean crowd is (myself included :lol:), it makes sense to be cautious. as mentioned before, they are running a business and making new products can be a gamble if the clientele isnt impressed.

Dracula
09-14-2011, 12:49 PM
i can see how they would want to test extensively before releasing a final product... can you imagine how pissed everyone would be if they didnt last? the new binnacles are highly anticipated, and as anal as the DeLorean crowd is (myself included :lol:), it makes sense to be cautious. as mentioned before, they are running a business and making new products can be a gamble if the clientele isnt impressed.

You mean like the awestruck reverence that has been exhibited for their new underbodies?

dvonk
09-14-2011, 12:56 PM
indeed... however, i cant claim to know the whole story or how to run a business either. ill leave that up to the professionals. but DMCH has managed to keep themselves in business for this long, ill trust that they might know what they are doing. :wink:

tjd
09-14-2011, 01:07 PM
If all things were equal I'd normaly agree it's not our business what a private company does. If you don't like what they do, do business with someone else. However in DMCH's case they hold a monopoly over 100% of the remaining NOS parts inventory, so those of us that are DeLorean owners have a vested interest in that part supply. DMCH have the ability to charge whatever they want for this asset and we as owners have no alternative but to pay their prices one way or the other. So if they make a poor business decision they can and will pass that loss onto us their captive customer base. Hence the percieved risk in this project, and why I as an owner find it concerning.

What I don't like about the project and DMCH's actions are they seem to be devoting more and more time and resources going after a "new" build customer. It is up to that customer to decide if this new item is appealing and if they want to pay what DMCH is asking for it. If it works out that is great for us as DeLorean owners as DMCH raises more money that they can then invest in more R&D for more improved parts. If it doesn't though that customer walks and leaves us the captive customer to pick up the tab for the companies losses. It will never be their loss, that's not how business works. They will simply pass that loss onto us their remaining customer that has no choice but to enjoy the ride and take it with a smile, or park or get rid of our car if we can't pay what they want.


AdmiralSenn
Regarding the binnacles, I wonder if the delay isn't because they have to do extensive testing to see if they discolor or crack. If they have to leave one in direct sunlight for a year before finding out whether or not this particular formulation worked, that would add a lot of delays. Even testing every formulation at once still leaves huge swaths of time that are taken up by just waiting.

I'm sure they are working on it, and just wanting to make sure that it's an improved design that won't fall apart or split into a million pieces after six months.

I don't care what their excuse for the delay on binacles are, they claimed in writing in Deloreans Vol 2 No.4 (published by DMC Texas) on page 7 that they had already decided on an ABS material and it would solve the problems with discoloring and cracking. They also stated that initial samples where expected at the time to be shown at the DMC Open House on June 10-12 2005, and final production pieces would be in hand sometime in July (2005). In reality for whatever reason the samples where never publicly shown until the DMC Midwest open house in May 2011 and as of now still unavailable for sale.

To me this is not about a binacle, it is about the unreliability of claims made by DMCH about new product offerings and availability, and general dependability and character of the current management there.

stevedmc
09-14-2011, 01:19 PM
I don't care what their excuse for the delay on binacles are

I think DMCH is just presenting the binnacles at the open house events to tease people.

I was thinking about going to the DMCH open house but I'm not going to pay ~$300 + hotel expenses so they can tease me with a product that doesn't exist. I'd rather pay less than $300 to own a new binnacle that does exist.

SoCalDMC12
09-14-2011, 02:02 PM
I wonder what the cost of the new underbodies will be (though I guess we'll know pretty soon). I'd imagine that extracting an underbody from a donor car, then readying it for re-use is a pretty labor-intensive process. Could making a new underbody could be less so?? If this is the case, perhaps the new ones will be competitively priced.

If I was in need of an underbody, I'd probably get a new one if the price was about the same simply because it would not have been subjected to 30 years of use, and because of the implementation of modern materials (which I'd assume to be more durable).

protodelorean
09-14-2011, 10:30 PM
I wonder what the cost of the new underbodies will be (though I guess we'll know pretty soon). I'd imagine that extracting an underbody from a donor car, then readying it for re-use is a pretty labor-intensive process. Could making a new underbody could be less so?? If this is the case, perhaps the new ones will be competitively priced.

If I was in need of an underbody, I'd probably get a new one if the price was about the same simply because it would not have been subjected to 30 years of use, and because of the implementation of modern materials (which I'd assume to be more durable).

Materials will probably be the same. Fiberglass mat and polyester resin. What will probably be better is the finish quality. The originals sucked when it came to inconsistent gel coat thickness, poor coverage and pinholes. I believe it was DMC employees (presumably with no fiberglass experience) that did the original fiberglass work. Having a modern firm experienced with composite manufacturing could yield some really nice pieces.