Log in

View Full Version : Strange Letters to the Editor



Notifier
10-05-2011, 06:40 AM
I always love looking at the "letters to the editor" section of the local newspaper. Some of the things people complain about is borderline amusing! This was in the paper the other day:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Recently my daughter took her car to the Department of Motor Vehicles for inspection. She is not a teenager. She’s a 33-year-old mother. She had one tire that failed and smoke coming from her exhaust. I had four new tires replaced, the oil changed and the carburetor adjusted.

She took it back to the inspection lane for these two problems only. She was told there was a little smoke from her exhaust on a damp humid morning and was refused the diagnostic test once again. She was told by a DMV New Castle inspector that it was her problem when she asked what she needs to fix without a diagnostic test performed.

They are state employees paid by our taxes. How can they not diagnose car problems and refuse to inspect vehicles?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My favorite statement is "How can they not diagnose car problems" - because it's NOT THEIR JOB!!! Take the thing to a competent mechanic!

LEVY
10-05-2011, 08:47 AM
I believe that is a commun issue, customers tell their mechanic (thinking it is going to be cheaper) what to fix and what parts to replace instead of allowing the mechanic to evaluate and diagnose the problem. You tell your mechanic what to fix o replace, your mechanic fix and replace whatever you told him, then if the problem still there, who's fault is that?

Regarding the refusal to re-test, don't know in your state but, in Texas if an inspector refuses to test a vehicle for whatever reason, he might loose his license.

Levy




I always love looking at the "letters to the editor" section of the local newspaper. Some of the things people complain about is borderline amusing! This was in the paper the other day:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Recently my daughter took her car to the Department of Motor Vehicles for inspection. She is not a teenager. She’s a 33-year-old mother. She had one tire that failed and smoke coming from her exhaust. I had four new tires replaced, the oil changed and the carburetor adjusted.

She took it back to the inspection lane for these two problems only. She was told there was a little smoke from her exhaust on a damp humid morning and was refused the diagnostic test once again. She was told by a DMV New Castle inspector that it was her problem when she asked what she needs to fix without a diagnostic test performed.

They are state employees paid by our taxes. How can they not diagnose car problems and refuse to inspect vehicles?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My favorite statement is "How can they not diagnose car problems" - because it's NOT THEIR JOB!!! Take the thing to a competent mechanic!

Dangermouse
10-05-2011, 08:53 AM
The way I read it was that the Part I of the test was "not having smoke coming out your exhaust"; Part II is the diagnostic. I assume you don't do part II if you don't pass Part I.

Though it would be nice to do both Parts so you can only make one trip to your mechanic to get all issues fixed.

This is what happens when you have a carb'd engine , though.......:hexer:

Notifier
10-05-2011, 06:36 PM
I guess I should have pointed out that the state itself does the inspections. Not a mechanic.

I just find it interesting that this person thought it was the inspectors job to not only point out what was wrong but also tell them how to fix the issue. For example, if the headlights don't work and the inspector fails that part, all he has to do is say "the headlights don't work", not "the bulbs are blown out", "the switch is bad", or "the fuse is blown". It's the owners responsibility to figure out the issue.


The way I read it was that the Part I of the test was "not having smoke coming out your exhaust"; Part II is the diagnostic. I assume you don't do part II if you don't pass Part I.

I actually live in a different state than this person is from, but when I take my car for emissions testing I know there's a sign right there that states that if smoke is visible from the tailpipe they will not perform the test.