Log in

View Full Version : Income Tax on Sale of Delorean



lazabby
12-20-2021, 06:41 PM
As you know the price of Deloreans have been going up. Any of you sell your Delorean (or another car for that matter) for more than you bought it for and pay tax on the gain?

Bitsyncmaster
12-20-2021, 08:03 PM
Insist on CASH payment. Just don't put it into your bank account more than $9,999.99 each year.

Rich
12-20-2021, 08:10 PM
Disclaimer: I'm not a CPA or an income tax pro

No, I haven't sold a car for a profit before. It looks like it is subject to income tax if you have a net gain.

When I sell our D I plan to account for the cost of the upgrades/improvements made since purchasing it (not reg. maintenance costs) when determining the gain, as explained here (https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/articles/how_do_taxes_work_on_private_car_sales).

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) considers all personal vehicles to be capital assets. Selling that vehicle for less than your purchase price is considered a capital loss, which does not need to be reported on tax returns.......

Selling a vehicle for a profit is considered a capital gain by the IRS, so it does need to be reported on your tax return. But figuring the dollar-amount of that gain is not as simple as comparing your purchase price to your sale price


More details are in this IRS document (https://www.irs.gov/publications/p544#en_US_2020_publink100072480), particularly the bits about personal use items such as vehicles not used for business purposes. See the notes about Personal Use Property in the Capital Assets section.

The answer might be different for folks who run a business buying low and selling high like BHCC.

Maybe somebody in the stateside community has a better answer for owners, presumably one that will stand up to an income tax audit.

Helirich
12-20-2021, 11:10 PM
As you know the price of Deloreans have been going up. Any of you sell your Delorean (or another car for that matter) for more than you bought it for and pay tax on the gain?

While Delorean’s have gone up, it is very unlikely yours has gone up enough to cover costs of ownership. In reality, very few cars do.

Helirich
12-20-2021, 11:18 PM
Insist on CASH payment. Just don't put it into your bank account more than $9,999.99 each year.

I’m sure you’re referring to the 10k limit is where you must file paper work. What a lot of people don’t know is the bank must file paper work on you every time you withdraw or deposit $3,000. This only applies to cash. So technically, if your trying to stay “under the radar”, you must withdraw or deposit $2999.99. If you’re really doing this, you should research “structuring” as it applies to cash. It is very rarely enforced, but a scary law just the same.

Michael
12-21-2021, 01:18 AM
Insist on CASH payment. Just don't put it into your bank account more than $9,999.99 each year.

Quite possibly the worst advice I could ever think of. Do you really want to walk around with 40k+ in cash waiting to be seized under civil asset forfeiture laws or robbed? Worse yet, find out it's Monopoly money? When you get that cash, how does one deposit that cash while keeping it under 10k per year? Insist on a cashier's check or direct deposit or any type of deposit that ENSURES that your payment is solid and received.

I'm no CPA, and I am sure tax laws vary by state, but selling private property does not fall under income or even capital gains unless you do it as a business. In my state, I believe you are afforded 3 car transactions(sales) per year before any tax issues would arise from business profits.

MrChocky
12-21-2021, 07:16 AM
David T was previously handing out tax evasion advice. Surprised he hasn't commented yet.

Helirich
12-21-2021, 12:26 PM
Quite possibly the worst advice I could ever think of. Do you really want to walk around with 40k+ in cash waiting to be seized under civil asset forfeiture laws or robbed? Worse yet, find out it's Monopoly money? When you get that cash, how does one deposit that cash while keeping it under 10k per year? Insist on a cashier's check or direct deposit or any type of deposit that ENSURES that your payment is solid and received.

I'm no CPA, and I am sure tax laws vary by state, but selling private property does not fall under income or even capital gains unless you do it as a business. In my state, I believe you are afforded 3 car transactions(sales) per year before any tax issues would arise from business profits.

Ummm, it’s 10K per day. But like I said, you should probably deposit in $2500 chunks over many odd days. If you do it for 15 days in a row, you will surly be in violation of “structuring” .

I love walking around with 40 grand. But you don’t need to walk around with it. Put it in your safe. It’s not like you’re getting any interest in the bank.

Michael
12-21-2021, 12:51 PM
Ummm, it’s 10K per day. But like I said, you should probably deposit in $2500 chunks over many odd days. If you do it for 15 days in a row, you will surly be in violation of “structuring” .

I love walking around with 40 grand. But you don’t need to walk around with it. Put it in your safe. It’s not like you’re getting any interest in the bank.

I was responding to Dave's statement of "per year" but I meant per transaction, not per year or day, but what I'm talking about is having that much money in your car or person or even home at ANY time. You are subjecting yourself to it being confiscated, stolen, lost in a fire and whatever bad things can happen when all you need to do is simply demand a cashier's check which eliminates a lot of those concerns. I have a pretty good safe because I own gold and silver but not everyone has a 4,000 dollar safe. I've been down this debate road before here. Do what you want, make 15 trips to the bank...IDGAS.

Also, if you deposit say 9,999 cash dollars in the bank in one transaction, let alone 4...you are not "fooling" anyone. You are actually painting a bigger target on your head and raising more eyebrows than if you just deposited everything at once.

Back to the OP's original question...no I do not think you are subject to paying any "capital gains" on selling one car. The timeframe that you owned the car may come into play but like I said earlier, state laws may differ. If it were me asking, I would simply check with a local CPA and not a DeLorean group. They will probably answer your question(correctly) for free in email correspondence or FB group.

Rich
12-21-2021, 02:25 PM
....I'm no CPA, and I am sure tax laws vary by state, but selling private property does not fall under income or even capital gains unless you do it as a business. In my state, I believe you are afforded 3 car transactions(sales) per year before any tax issues would arise from business profits.

You may live in a state with income tax rules that differ from U.S. Federal income tax rules. Federal income tax still applies, of course.

It looks like a U.S. seller is obligated to pay federal income tax on capital gains from the sale of a personal use vehicle as detailed in the two linked documents in Post #3. The rule applies generally to property like cars used for commuting or pleasure (not business use) as well as things like jewelry and even home furnishings. See the IRS definition of a Capital Asset in in IRS Publication 544 (https://www.irs.gov/publications/p544#en_US_2020_publink100072480), Section 2. Yes, it's a sale of private property and, yes, the net gain is taxable.

The rules apply to personal federal income tax. If the car is used for business then see Section 3. I think that's outside the scope of this topic.

Agreeing with your suggestion in your later post today if we have any U.S. tax attorneys or CPAs on the forum perhaps they can enlighten all of us on this question.

Mark D
12-21-2021, 02:37 PM
Oh my god, it's better than I thought! An Audi. I'm getting a car!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t8b8JNXANjc

lazabby
12-21-2021, 02:54 PM
I did a little digging and it was as I suspected. If you sell your car for a loss then tough luck. You can't deduct your loss (federal income tax purposes, not state). There may be exceptions if the car was a business asset. The car is looked at as a capital asset and any gain on the sale is a capital gain. You can decrease your gain by any improvement made to the car so it's important to keep those receipts. Check with your tax preparer for taxability as tax rule continually change. Don't try to cheat the US govt. Tax avoidance is legal but tax evasion is not.

Michael
12-21-2021, 03:49 PM
Maybe this and sales tax is why people who own multiple exotics trade a lot. I know one local guy here who always has no less than. 6 or 7 six figure exotics but he never keeps any one car very long. He is always trading. ( perhaps with some personal checks written to cover the difference).

Helirich
12-21-2021, 04:29 PM
I was responding to Dave's statement of "per year" but I meant per transaction, not per year or day, but what I'm talking about is having that much money in your car or person or even home at ANY time. You are subjecting yourself to it being confiscated, stolen, lost in a fire and whatever bad things can happen when all you need to do is simply demand a cashier's check which eliminates a lot of those concerns. I have a pretty good safe because I own gold and silver but not everyone has a 4,000 dollar safe. I've been down this debate road before here. Do what you want, make 15 trips to the bank...IDGAS.

Also, if you deposit say 9,999 cash dollars in the bank in one transaction, let alone 4...you are not "fooling" anyone. You are actually painting a bigger target on your head and raising more eyebrows than if you just deposited everything at once.

Back to the OP's original question...no I do not think you are subject to paying any "capital gains" on selling one car. The timeframe that you owned the car may come into play but like I said earlier, state laws may differ. If it were me asking, I would simply check with a local CPA and not a DeLorean group. They will probably answer your question(correctly) for free in email correspondence or FB group.

Not trying to bust your balls on this, just giving people facts that I have researched quite a bit. When you say “your not fooling anyone” , you are correct. You are avoiding filling out paper work. The bank still notifys the feds. When you deposit less than $3000, you are not notifying anybody except the teller. The bit about the “structuring” law is only if they are already looking at you and find rythematic deposits. This is a very serious and sneaky law. If you don’t understand it, you should DUck Duck Go it.

As far as “keeping cash”, I find having large cash is handi when something comes up suddenly. Case in point, I got my Delorean at a very, very reasonable price because I was the first one there with cash.

Bitsyncmaster
12-21-2021, 05:59 PM
I had to pay cash for my D. That was back when people were making counterfeit bank notes. I had already got the certified check but the bank understood and gave me the cash. Pretty big wad of $100 bills which would be more these days. I see most of the car shows plop that cash $100,000 on the table to entice the seller to accept.

MrChocky
12-21-2021, 07:40 PM
Circumflex.

Helirich
12-21-2021, 11:27 PM
I had to pay cash for my D. That was back when people were making counterfeit bank notes. I had already got the certified check but the bank understood and gave me the cash. Pretty big wad of $100 bills which would be more these days. I see most of the car shows plop that cash $100,000 on the table to entice the seller to accept.

They still are! One time I ask my bank “what is as good as cash” referring to certified, cashers, money order, bank draft, whatever. Their reply “cash”. If those instruments are drawn on their bank, no problem, but if I walk in with them from some other bank, I’m not walking out with cash unless I have the funds to cover it in my account.

Michael
12-21-2021, 11:55 PM
Not to state the obvious, but you don't release the car or title until funds are 100% verified and secured beyond any doubt, (not reasonable doubt...ANY doubt). The thing with this forum is no matter what detail you leave out(thinking common sense will prevail), someone here will latch onto it and run with it.

Helirich
12-22-2021, 10:50 AM
Not to state the obvious, but you don't release the car or title until funds are 100% verified and secured beyond any doubt, (not reasonable doubt...ANY doubt). The thing with this forum is no matter what detail you leave out(thinking common sense will prevail), someone here will latch onto it and run with it.

Very true! On this subject, my brother sold something and was suspect of the payment. (I think it was a certified check or money order) Anyways, he took it to his bank and told them to notify him when it was clear. The bank told him it would take two days to clear. If he didn’t hear anything from them in two days, it was fine. He released the item. Later, the bank said the check was no good. You would think too bad for the bank, but no, my brother was still responsible for it.

Moral of the story, get cash. If your suspect of the cash, deposit immediately regardless of tax implications. (The bank can’t come back later and say it was counterfeit.)

Mark D
12-22-2021, 11:12 AM
Typically I keep all of my extra cash tucked away inside my mattress, but I've accumulated so much lately that I've run out of space. So I've just been sleeping on the big pile of money.

http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=67717&d=1640185889

MrChocky
12-22-2021, 07:35 PM
Typically I keep all of my extra cash tucked away inside my mattress, but I've accumulated so much lately that I've run out of space. So I've just been sleeping on the big pile of money.

http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=67717&d=1640185889Not impressed unless you're swimming in coins.

NJP548
12-23-2021, 11:58 AM
Not impressed unless you're swimming in coins.

Have we learned nothing?!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viDL2W0HcJw

-Nick

Helirich
12-23-2021, 12:27 PM
Typically I keep all of my extra cash tucked away inside my mattress, but I've accumulated so much lately that I've run out of space. So I've just been sleeping on the big pile of money.

http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=67717&d=1640185889

I guess that’s the definition of inflation.