Log in

View Full Version : Garage Flooring? Anyone have epoxy / cement alternatives?



Tamir A.
04-17-2012, 06:17 AM
I'm researching different companies that do epoxy / decorative flooring for garages. I was wondering if anyone has had this done and if they can weigh in on which companies were good and what kind of materials you went with, etc?

Does it help with stopping extra moisture that comes up through cement slabs? I want to make sure the DeLorean stays dry and doesn't have unnecessary moisture build up underneath it.

I'm doing this in a new garage in the suburbs of Chicago.

Thanks,
T.

justlooking
04-17-2012, 11:34 AM
Moisture is stopped with a vapor barrier under the slab (code requierrd where i live). Epoxy flooring/stained concrete/paint/etc is for decorative purpose or to make it easier to clean. Trying to use it to stop moisture may work at first, but will be continual maintenance as it loses adhesion.

BTTF-1
04-17-2012, 11:42 AM
I too am thinking about epoxy coating the garage floor. I would like to find a wild color like florescence green maybe with flakes to add sparkle with no luck.


It looks like the tiles would be over 700 dollars and epoxy around 200 - 300 dollars.

ED:headbang:

Spittybug
04-17-2012, 11:54 AM
http://www.por15.com/BASIC-KIT/productinfo/FABK1BE/

Did this a year ago. Awesome stuff. I rented a concrete grinder from Sunbelt (at Lowes) and spent half a day taking the top layer off my greasy, paint covered floor. If your's is new, you won't need to do that. In my case, I didn't want to take any chances of it not adhering well. I went with a rough rather than totally smooth surface since I wasn't looking for a showroom or when wet, an ice skating rink. Applied with a roller but I think you could spray it. Respirator mask absolutely necessary. Nice thing about this stuff is it gets tougher with moisture. I didn't walk on it for a day, didn't park the car on it for a week. Even with "Houston hot" tires I've had no peeling of any sort. I do have a couple of light tire imprints, but that's on top of the paint; that's the tire losing pigment or something. I didn't bother with sprinkles, but could have very easily. This stuff is much tougher than the Home Depot two part epoxy kits. I would do it again in a heartbeat. Very nice to just hose out the garage when dirty and not having to worry about any fluids I may spill on it.

Tamir A.
04-17-2012, 12:44 PM
Yeah, this is what I've read. I did have a vapor barrier under the slab, but still feel like there is moisture coming from the cement a little. Could also be the lack of ventilation as I have the garage where the DeLorean sits pretty air tight (to avoid field mice from getting in), so I'm addressing that air movement as well. Perhaps because the concrete is only a few months old still, it has some moisture left in it that is evaporating.

T.


Moisture is stopped with a vapor barrier under the slab (code requierrd where i live). Epoxy flooring/stained concrete/paint/etc is for decorative purpose or to make it easier to clean. Trying to use it to stop moisture may work at first, but will be continual maintenance as it loses adhesion.

Cory W
04-17-2012, 12:48 PM
Yeah, this is what I've read. I did have a vapor barrier under the slab, but still feel like there is moisture coming from the cement a little. Could also be the lack of ventilation as I have the garage where the DeLorean sits pretty air tight (to avoid field mice from getting in), so I'm addressing that air movement as well. Perhaps because the concrete is only a few months old still, it has some moisture left in it that is evaporating.

T.

That's exactly it. It's technically still curing, and a lack of airflow slows the process down more. Even a fan in there at floor level for a while will help out. Or leaving the door open as much as possible once the weather turns nice.

Dangermouse
04-17-2012, 12:55 PM
iirc DMCHJames started a thread like this on the old .com. I think DMCMW Dave has had some success with a product.

Epoxymaster, I think he used.

Rich W
04-17-2012, 02:25 PM
Hey Tamir,

Check out the Garage Store.

http://www.garage-store.com/

They have some of the best products and they can apply them for you as well.

Later,
Rich W.


BTW: They have in-store sample areas that you can check out, in person.

DMCMW Dave
04-17-2012, 02:33 PM
Polyamide 2-part Industrial Epoxy. Benjamin Moore is good. Available in any color at local high-end paint stores.

Prep is key - the concrete should be 6-8 months old, acid etched etc. Real and follow lable directions.

Jimmyvonviggle
04-17-2012, 07:45 PM
http://www.ucoatit.com/2011web/main.htm

This is the stuff a lot of professionals use.

sdg3205
08-31-2012, 02:11 PM
Jon,

I've got 2 types of degreasers for concrete. One came with the rustoluem product and one is a stand alone that the guy at home depot recommended.

the way I see it, I bought this stuff a year ago so if it all tanks, so be it. the money is spent and I'll do as good a job as I can!

jawn101
08-31-2012, 02:19 PM
Jon,

I've got 2 types of degreasers for concrete. One came with the rustoluem product and one is a stand alone that the guy at home depot recommended.

the way I see it, I bought this stuff a year ago so if it all tanks, so be it. the money is spent and I'll do as good a job as I can!

Sounds like a reasonable enough plan. I am trying to plan out a massive garage overhaul and this is very high on the list. Our house is new and the garage is completely unfinished. I have wobbly plastic shelves for fluids and parts, no work area, bare concrete, untreated drywall, not enough light, etc. I figure I need to get the floors done first, before I start putting in cabinets and such.

Be curious to hear how you make out with the Rustoleum job. I've seen that kit in the store before and it sounds so easy (time consuming, but easy) that I was suspicious :)

sdg3205
08-31-2012, 02:22 PM
Sounds like a reasonable enough plan. I am trying to plan out a massive garage overhaul and this is very high on the list. Our house is new and the garage is completely unfinished. I have wobbly plastic shelves for fluids and parts, no work area, bare concrete, untreated drywall, not enough light, etc. I figure I need to get the floors done first, before I start putting in cabinets and such.

Be curious to hear how you make out with the Rustoleum job. I've seen that kit in the store before and it sounds so easy (time consuming, but easy) that I was suspicious :)

Yeah, I've heard mixed reviews, but when i start looking at another brand, they too seem to have mixed reviews which leads me to believe the end result is only going to reflect the prep work much like anything else.

I think the people that complained are the people that didn't spend enough time degreasing and etching.

Im really leaning towards putting a clear coat or "glaze" on it too. they go a long way to maintain the look and durability of the epoxy.

I'll take some before and after shots. I'm getting excited now and all I want to do it go home and start already.

DMCVegas
08-31-2012, 02:58 PM
Two quick questions:

How well does any of this stuff stand up to rolling jacks around on it, using jack stands, and generally just scraping stuff across it?

Also I've seen custom floor logos. How do you go about getting these and installing them? Is it just vinyl with a coating over it?

sdg3205
08-31-2012, 03:14 PM
Two quick questions:

How well does any of this stuff stand up to rolling jacks around on it, using jack stands, and generally just scraping stuff across it?

Also I've seen custom floor logos. How do you go about getting these and installing them? Is it just vinyl with a coating over it?

Great questions. I've thought a lot about it too since I'm always using jacks, axle stands, dripping caustic fluids etc etc.

By the sounds of it, brake fluid will eat almost any epoxy (don't we all know that?!) so I'll likely still place mats, flattened cardboard and rug under cars I work on just to be safe. I already do since I want to keep the concrete as clean as possible prior to epoxy.

I've heard the clear coat adds a lot of strength, as does additional coats of each product. I'm planning on 2 coats of epoxy and 2 coats of the glaze/clear.

As for logos - I think they are laid over the dried epoxy prior to clear coats, but thats just a guess.

Tamir A.
08-31-2012, 03:20 PM
I ended up going with Floorguard. They did a great job, and I've had good success with the floor handling grease and drops. I went with a sandstone look. 1282912830
They even went up the sides of the edges.

Spittybug
08-31-2012, 04:03 PM
A year and a half later and I'm still in awe of how good my floor looks. The only scratch in it is where my crippled (lower ball joint snap) car had to be somewhat "dragged" into place for me to get it on the lift. I gouged a little concrete, not just paint! I rate it a huge success, worth every penny and ounce of work. If you haven't yet oiled up the garage floor you won't need to grind. A good wash and etch will do the trick.

herbertgibbs
12-08-2012, 12:21 AM
Check out this company: epoxy-coat (search for it on web)

Bitsyncmaster
10-10-2014, 06:59 AM
I wonder if the PERGO laminate flooring would stand up to a garage floor. I just bought some PERGO online for a pretty good price of less than $2 sq/ft with free shipping.

Dangermouse
10-10-2014, 10:31 AM
I would doubt it Dave. Eventually water would get in between the laminate layers and destroy it.

David T
10-10-2014, 10:59 AM
I would doubt it Dave. Eventually water would get in between the laminate layers and destroy it.

Not only would it not hold up, it is a big fire hazard. I have an epoxy floor as well and the main thing is the prep. If you do not have a CLEAN fresh surface you will never get good results. The epoxy does stand up to even brake fluid and gasoline but is mechanically damageable. You need at least 1 coat of epoxy and 1 clear coat. Very smelly for many days till it cures. It is also very slippery when wet.

DMCMW Dave
10-10-2014, 02:39 PM
I wonder if the PERGO laminate flooring would stand up to a garage floor. I just bought some PERGO online for a pretty good price of less than $2 sq/ft with free shipping.

Here's the view from my office. It's fully vinyl stick together fake wood strips from Home Depot. Completely waterproof (designed for basement applications). Obviously not a shop floor, but it's holding up relatively well to walking traffic and moving a car across it a few times a year in nice weather. I'd use it in a garage for appearance but not something I was dropping tools on.

Laminate (i.e. plasticized wood product) will not hold up to moisture at all.

31080

Ras12
10-12-2014, 12:32 AM
Dave

I believe the product you used from HD was Traffic Master Allure flooring, correct? Awesome product. Used it in many of my commercial projects with high walking traffic and in basements with high moisture and holds up great. Was considering using it in my garage too but not sure about the salty winters here in the Northeast.

As far as moisture, I alway put cardboard under my car which works great as it absorbs any moisture vs getting onto the car. Plus it is easy to see if the cardboard is damp or moist and when it is I change it out.

DMCMW Dave
10-12-2014, 06:54 PM
Dave
I believe the product you used from HD was Traffic Master Allure flooring, correct? Awesome product. Used it in many of my commercial projects with high walking traffic and in basements with high moisture and holds up great. Was considering using it in my garage too but not sure about the salty winters here in the Northeast.
.

Yes. We put it down ourselves. I put red rosin paper under it since the concrete had old glue on it and I wanted to avoid any "snapping". It shows some foot grit scratching, and will not hold up to, say, dropping an impact gun on it, but neither will paint or epoxy. The most foolproof flooring is bare, sealed concrete but that's not the look I was going for.

David T
10-13-2014, 02:02 PM
Epoxy (the good stuff) is about the most expensive way to do a cement floor. Not only is the materiel expensive, the prep work required to do a good job is costly, dirty and time consuming. They use a beefed up floor polisher with a carbide cutter to remove the top 1/16 to 1/4 inch to get to virgin, clean concrete. You also need a dust collection system because it makes a LOT of dust. Even with a dust collector it gets everywhere. Next you patch any depressions or holes. Then you roll the epoxy color. If you choose, at this point before the epoxy dries, they scatter the flecks. The next day you roll the clear. It is dry to walk on in a day but it continues to harden AND SMELL for over a week. Once fully cured it is VERY tough and can take dropping things on it and is impervious to almost anything chemical. I have a 3 car garage and I had it done by Garagefloorcoating.com. It cost over $2K. It is SO much better than bare concrete. It doesn't stain and is no longer so dusty. Spills just wipe up. I have also tried garage floor paint but it doesn't stand up to much although it is a lot cheaper. The other thing some do is ceramic tile. Can't drop anything on that though.

DMCMW Dave
10-13-2014, 02:08 PM
Epoxy (the good stuff) is about the most expensive way to do a cement floor. .

You haven't apparently priced industrial tile. THATS expensive.

Jimmyvonviggle
10-13-2014, 06:43 PM
I think vinyl composite tiles like you find in hospitals might be a cheap and viable option. The advantages are:

Economical at about 90 cents for a 12"x12" tile
Comes in many colors that you can use to make patterns and logos
Easy to install
Durable and water proof
Any damaged tiles can be easily removed and replaced.

I have installed these at many retail stores and they hold up well to foot traffic, and carts and dollies. It's resistance to things like brake fluid I don't know, but like I said they are easily replaceable.

acaciolo
10-13-2014, 06:59 PM
I used this stuff. no prep at all. they just snap together and lay on the floor. they look great. lots of different brands. Think I paid about $2.00 per sf.

http://www.racedeck.com/residentialgarageflooring.html

you can see a little of mine here:

31161

Nicholas R
10-13-2014, 07:07 PM
I used this stuff. no prep at all. they just snap together and lay on the floor. they look great. lots of different brands. Think I paid about $2.00 per sf.

http://www.racedeck.com/residentialgarageflooring.html

you can see a little of mine here:

31161

I like race deck a lot. A buddy of mine is into Porsches and made a low resolution Porsche logo in his garage using red, yellow, and black tiles. I'll bet you could do the same with DMC with grey and black tiles.

acaciolo
10-13-2014, 07:33 PM
lots of sellers on ebay around $2.00 per sf, including shipping for similar products.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/GarageDeck-GRAPHITE-Garage-Tile-USA-made-Garage-Floors-Shop-Flooring-/281460580070?hash=item41885b9ee6&vxp=mtr

a 20x30 garage would be around $1200. and the stuff is easily replaceable if you damage one. I've had it down for 10+ years and it looks brand new.

tony

Mark D
10-22-2014, 05:37 PM
Just ordered a Race Deck floor for my winter storage garage. I ordered direct through Race Deck and got a good deal because I'm a Garage Journal forum member. I also priced out the floor at AutoGeek and it was only slightly more expensive. Right now they're running a 15% off everything promotion if you enter the code SEMA4 at checkout. Sale ends in 2 days.

http://www.autogeek.net/racedeck-diamond-flooring.html

Here's the layout I decided to go with:
http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=31228&d=1414010215