Log in

View Full Version : Should Bill Robertson be Un-Banned?



Dracula
06-23-2012, 04:36 PM
Voice your opinion; the answers are private, so you only need answer if you want your opinion to be known?

thirdmanj
06-23-2012, 06:53 PM
Where's the "Don't give a shit" selection?

stevedmc
06-23-2012, 06:55 PM
Where's the "Don't give a shit" selection?

That would qualify as a yes. Place your vote.

82DMC12
06-23-2012, 09:26 PM
No thanks, he won't stop shitting up the DML. Don't need that here too.

Jack
06-24-2012, 12:05 AM
I really don't get the point in banning.
There is always a way around a ban.
The easiest being a new username, with a different email.

thirdmanj
06-24-2012, 12:09 AM
I really don't get the point in banning.
There is always a way around a ban.
The easiest being a new username, with a different email.

Just to get banned again after 3 posts when a mod figures out who you are? Face it, this is the admins little universe and here they are (not to make this a religious discussion) God. That's just the way it is. Play well with others or GTFO. They're really good about warnings here anyway.

ccurzio
06-24-2012, 11:56 AM
They're really good about warnings here anyway.

And Bill was given plenty of them. Too many, it could even be argued.

tyb323
06-24-2012, 01:39 PM
I think we didn't give Bill any more shots that we gave Joey Gowdy/Earl Hickey/the next bozo to come along. At least Bill has productive stuff to add to the carb section.

ccurzio
06-24-2012, 02:02 PM
I think we didn't give Bill any more shots that we gave Joey Gowdy/Earl Hickey/the next bozo to come along.

This is very much not true.

Michael
06-24-2012, 03:37 PM
At least Bill has productive stuff to add to the carb section.

And this is a half truth. The problem was he added his "knowledge" to every single conversation not to help, but just to stir the pot. There would be a thread about headlight alignment or stainless finish and Bill would chime in and steer the conversation to fuel management, and to his discovery of carburetors. However if you were to ask him he has a totally different reason(from his facebook page)


I was thoroughly pilloried on the old DMCTalk.com site for butchering cars so that they could never be converted back to K-Jet. Bullshit -- it's the EFI crowd who are hacking and cutting all the wiring out of their cars. Yet for some reason they are heroes for actually doing what I was accused of doing but never in fact did. Go figure. What a bunch of hypocritical fools.

And just so some of you can relax, he has indeed been "unbanned" (From facebook as well)


Steve just informed me of a new user on DMCTalk who either actually is an experienced hot rodder, or is someone with a lot of book knowledge who has never turned a wrench in real life. Either way, he is not me. I do have a new DMCTalk ID that I'm keeping on the down low, but EarlHickey is not it. Sean's forum software should be tracking his IP address -- it is very easy for Sean to verify that he is not me.

stevedmc
06-24-2012, 06:53 PM
Joey Gowdy

It looks like Joey is a changed man. Maybe he should get another chance too.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQHLA3JW8JA&list=UU8qYLqjiiQW2CAH3iOgPq6w&index=5&feature=plpp_video

tyb323
06-24-2012, 08:34 PM
He never ceases to amaze

justlooking
06-24-2012, 09:45 PM
IRL (or at DCS, for example), if you don't like what someone says, you walk away and move on.

On DMCTalk, if you don't like what someone says, you "Add to Ignore List" and move on.

Grow up already.

There is no reason for Bill to be banned that doesn't also qualify several other users here on DMCTalk to be banned for the same reasons. There are far more users here spreading misinformation, or otherwise offering unqualified/erroneous technical advice than Bill, and yet because Bill is opinionated and provocative, you (the moderatorship/ownership of this site) remove his ability to participate.

Bill's remarks and participation do have value, as much as some of you would hate to admit it. Bill unofficially *OWNS* (as we say in project management) the DeLorean carburetion realm. You would be hard pressed to find another DMC owner who has more experience in that area, and he's polished his conversions to where they can be performed with a known parts list, in a single day, both predictably and repeatably without undue experimentation. Can the same be said of the DMCTalk EFI group? No, but they're the first to put him down, ironically.

I vote yes.

Ryan
06-24-2012, 10:06 PM
It looks like Joey is a changed man. Maybe he should get another chance too.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQHLA3JW8JA&list=UU8qYLqjiiQW2CAH3iOgPq6w&index=5&feature=plpp_video

In batman voice: I release you of that bondage..... SWEAR TO MEEEEE!!!!!

Holy shit, Gowdy is the textbook definition of narcissism.

Ron
06-24-2012, 10:30 PM
Just to get banned again after 3 posts when a mod figures out who you are? Face it, this is the admins little universe and here they are (not to make this a religious discussion) God. That's just the way it is. Play well with others or GTFO. They're really good about warnings here anyway.
+1

Even if they could change the way they act so we couldn't tell who they are it would be a win-win...


I think we didn't give Bill any more shots that we gave Joey Gowdy/Earl Hickey/the next bozo to come along.
:hysterical:

Squall67584
06-25-2012, 01:31 AM
So who was this Gowdy person and what did they do? I've read Bill's posts and lived through the Earl Hickey drama but don't know about this Gowdy.

stevedmc
06-25-2012, 01:36 AM
So who was this Gowdy person and what did they do? I've read Bill's posts and lived through the Earl Hickey drama but don't know about this Gowdy.

Gowdy lied to a social worker in order to get on disability for a mental disease he faked having. Shortly after he got on disability he started bragging about stealing money from the government.

Banning him was the patriotic thing to do.

DMCVegas
06-25-2012, 02:34 AM
Gowdy lied to a social worker in order to get on disability for a mental disease he faked having. Shortly after he got on disability he started bragging about stealing money from the government.

Banning him was the patriotic thing to do.

He also claimed to own lots of cars too, and as that turned out his mommy and daddy own a small used car dealership and he was just driving around the inventory until it got sold.



IRL (or at DCS, for example), if you don't like what someone says, you walk away and move on.

On DMCTalk, if you don't like what someone says, you "Add to Ignore List" and move on.

Grow up already.

There is no reason for Bill to be banned that doesn't also qualify several other users here on DMCTalk to be banned for the same reasons. There are far more users here spreading misinformation, or otherwise offering unqualified/erroneous technical advice than Bill, and yet because Bill is opinionated and provocative, you (the moderatorship/ownership of this site) remove his ability to participate.

Bill's remarks and participation do have value, as much as some of you would hate to admit it. Bill unofficially *OWNS* (as we say in project management) the DeLorean carburetion realm. You would be hard pressed to find another DMC owner who has more experience in that area, and he's polished his conversions to where they can be performed with a known parts list, in a single day, both predictably and repeatably without undue experimentation. Can the same be said of the DMCTalk EFI group? No, but they're the first to put him down, ironically.

I vote yes.

Let's clarify a few things here. The EFI group serves up just as much information to everyone, and does it without inciting fights. The problem with Bill is that he can't just say a factual statement and leave things at that. Bill without fail ALWAYS has to troll and start a fight. There have even been a few times when Bill has said something, I agree with him, and he just can't stand NOT having an argument and will then proceed to write ever increasingly inflamitory things until he gets people riled up. He does this in various ways from attacking K-Jetronic on up to the car itself. Then when he gets backed into a corner either A) Throws up a strawman argument, B) Changes the subject entirely, or C) Tries to martyr himself. Shaking a man's confidence simply to make him bend to your own will is one of the lowest things you can do.

The difference between Bill and people like CIS People like me? CIS People try and empower you to take ownership of your car. Bill will simply shit-talk your car until he convinces you to lose confidence in it so that you suddenly wind up kissing his ass and defending him as the defacto source of Carburetion for the DeLorean. Which is clearly not the case, especially when the UK has a whole Renault Alpine club that sells manifolds and carbs, as well as has their own support network, and of course you can still do everything on you own.

Bill has certainly had his fair share of useful information in the past, yes. But he's through. He has nothing more to contribute to the community. The benefits of him reposting any old information does not outweigh the inevitable fights that he purposefully starts with others simply to become the center of attention. Certainly if you're in his corner you don't see it, but the rest of the community here and on the DML that have become fodder for his own childish games do. Ask yourself how and why he pisses-off so many people. That's not normal.

Ron
06-25-2012, 09:23 AM
Gowdy lied to a social worker in order to get on disability for a mental disease he faked having. Shortly after he got on disability he started bragging about stealing money from the government.

Banning him was the patriotic thing to do.Now wasn't that actually part of his then latest mission, to expose government waste and corruption in the welfare system? I remember him saying he was going to use a hidden cam to show the workers telling him what not/to say and do to get the money, and he did.

82DMC12
06-25-2012, 09:40 AM
IRL (or at DCS, for example), if you don't like what someone says, you walk away and move on.

On DMCTalk, if you don't like what someone says, you "Add to Ignore List" and move on.


No, it doesn't work that way. Bill is the kind of cat who has to put his 2 cents into every discussion and as already mentioned, can't ever just say a fact and leave it. He always then tosses in some condescending remark just to be a dick. You can't possibly ignore him on the DML because he makes up a third of all the posts and leaves his mark in every thread. Same thing on DMCTalk. He sticks his nose in everything and soon everyone is talking about it. You can't ignore that much stuff when you are trying to stay current in the threads.

He obviously has a real problem with his social skills and it's no wonder he's single. When this many people say there is something wrong with a guy, there probably is.

opethmike
06-25-2012, 11:38 AM
+1


He also claimed to own lots of cars too, and as that turned out his mommy and daddy own a small used car dealership and he was just driving around the inventory until it got sold.




Let's clarify a few things here. The EFI group serves up just as much information to everyone, and does it without inciting fights. The problem with Bill is that he can't just say a factual statement and leave things at that. Bill without fail ALWAYS has to troll and start a fight. There have even been a few times when Bill has said something, I agree with him, and he just can't stand NOT having an argument and will then proceed to write ever increasingly inflamitory things until he gets people riled up. He does this in various ways from attacking K-Jetronic on up to the car itself. Then when he gets backed into a corner either A) Throws up a strawman argument, B) Changes the subject entirely, or C) Tries to martyr himself. Shaking a man's confidence simply to make him bend to your own will is one of the lowest things you can do.

The difference between Bill and people like CIS People like me? CIS People try and empower you to take ownership of your car. Bill will simply shit-talk your car until he convinces you to lose confidence in it so that you suddenly wind up kissing his ass and defending him as the defacto source of Carburetion for the DeLorean. Which is clearly not the case, especially when the UK has a whole Renault Alpine club that sells manifolds and carbs, as well as has their own support network, and of course you can still do everything on you own.

Bill has certainly had his fair share of useful information in the past, yes. But he's through. He has nothing more to contribute to the community. The benefits of him reposting any old information does not outweigh the inevitable fights that he purposefully starts with others simply to become the center of attention. Certainly if you're in his corner you don't see it, but the rest of the community here and on the DML that have become fodder for his own childish games do. Ask yourself how and why he pisses-off so many people. That's not normal.

ccurzio
06-25-2012, 12:11 PM
Let's clarify a few things here.

This is exactly why he has been banned.

Nobody is disputing that he's knowledgable, but if the price for his knowledge is his endless disrespectful attitude, inciting pointless confrontation, and unnecessary abrasiveness, then that's too high a price to pay for said knowledge.

There are plenty of super smart people on this forum who are helpful AND cordial. That's what builds a community.

Mike C.
06-25-2012, 12:26 PM
I'll clarify this...

If a person gets banned from this site, it takes a LOT to get to that step. Tamir, Sean, and I all had a meeting, and it was decided that we would not allow Bill to continue to throw his bad attitude at everyone, just because he disagreed with their point of view, no matter what it was.

With that in mind, no matter what the poll says, we will not be unbanning Bill. He was banned from .com for the same reason, came over here with a CLEAN slate (as did Joey Gowdy), and still managed to piss off people so much that I have yet to open all the complaints about him in my inbox, because I got tired of reading them.

Problem has been dealt with, move on, not getting reversed.

thirdmanj
06-25-2012, 12:46 PM
I'll clarify this...

If a person gets banned from this site, it takes a LOT to get to that step. Tamir, Sean, and I all had a meeting, and it was decided that we would not allow Bill to continue to throw his bad attitude at everyone, just because he disagreed with their point of view, no matter what it was.

With that in mind, no matter what the poll says, we will not be unbanning Bill. He was banned from .com for the same reason, came over here with a CLEAN slate (as did Joey Gowdy), and still managed to piss off people so much that I have yet to open all the complaints about him in my inbox, because I got tired of reading them.

Problem has been dealt with, move on, not getting reversed.


Thus He has spoken, and it is so written...

protodelorean
06-25-2012, 01:24 PM
...

Problem has been dealt with, move on, not getting reversed.

:yesss:

..and well-said Accipiter.

Mike C.
06-25-2012, 01:35 PM
I fixed the poll too...

tyb323
06-25-2012, 01:38 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bmPbyY54TvA

Mike C.
06-25-2012, 02:04 PM
IRL (or at DCS, for example), if you don't like what someone says, you walk away and move on.

On DMCTalk, if you don't like what someone says, you "Add to Ignore List" and move on.

Grow up already.

There is no reason for Bill to be banned that doesn't also qualify several other users here on DMCTalk to be banned for the same reasons. There are far more users here spreading misinformation, or otherwise offering unqualified/erroneous technical advice than Bill, and yet because Bill is opinionated and provocative, you (the moderatorship/ownership of this site) remove his ability to participate.

Bill's remarks and participation do have value, as much as some of you would hate to admit it. Bill unofficially *OWNS* (as we say in project management) the DeLorean carburetion realm. You would be hard pressed to find another DMC owner who has more experience in that area, and he's polished his conversions to where they can be performed with a known parts list, in a single day, both predictably and repeatably without undue experimentation. Can the same be said of the DMCTalk EFI group? No, but they're the first to put him down, ironically.

I vote yes.

First, Bill wasn't banned for misinformation. He wasn't "provocative", he was being a jerk after numerous warnings, plain and simple. If he was as willing to share his vast knowledge instead of posting jabs at people to prove his self minded superiority, he wouldn't have been banned. I personally PM'd and emailed him NUMEROUS times telling him to cool it, just let bygones be bygones, and he'd be unmoderated at the time... but nooo, he kept on, and actually increased his arrogance and blatant disregard for the RULES of this PRIVATELY OWNED forum. Plain and simple, you don't like the rules, you don't have to be here. Bill has his own forum, feel free to stroke his ego over there. As stated, Bill is not welcome here.


Oh and Bill, I know you have another log on for the forum. Your face book friend ratted you out weeks ago... think about it.

Mike C.
06-25-2012, 02:06 PM
Now wasn't that actually part of his then latest mission, to expose government waste and corruption in the welfare system? I remember him saying he was going to use a hidden cam to show the workers telling him what not/to say and do to get the money, and he did.

That was the tune he started singing after another forum busted him for his scheme...
We're not unbanning him either.