View Full Version : DeLorean & Bricklin fact check
Stainless
06-26-2012, 08:06 PM
Attended a local car show this past weekend. As I was pulling in, a guy ran over to me and asked if I wanted to park next to a Bricklin. This guy happened to be the owner of that car. I had seen it at other car shows, but we had never parked next to each other. I thought it would be fun, so I had the DeLorean next to the Bricklin for the entire show. What a mistake! Nothing against Bricklins, but this owner was one of those know-it-alls that spewed of "fact" after "fact" about the DeLorean... some stuff I had never heard before. He kept saying things that sounded like he was trying to make his Bricklin better than a DeLorean, like referencing the DeLorean crash test vs. the SV1 crash test.
Below are HIS statements and some questions, and I need your help in determining whether or not they are true or how to answer them:
1) Bricklin built a prototype car out of stainless steel. That is where John DeLorean got the idea to make his car out of stainless. (I can't find any info to back up his claim)
2) You can still buy a new 1965 Shelby with an unused VIN, so why do the DeLoreans have to use a donor VIN for their cars that they restore? (this was after I informed him that they are not brand new cars, but extensive restorations with original VINs)
3) The car used in the SV1 crash test did so well that they were able to put it back together, and that car is still on the road somewhere.
4) Bricklin used gullwing doors for safety, but DeLorean copied the idea and just liked the doors for styling, not safety.
5) The DeLorean weighs more than the Bricklin (I shut him up when I told him the GVW)
6) The Bricklin is more American than the DeLorean (how do you respond to such a pointless remark? I just took it as another attempt to make his car better than mine.)
He asked if he could sit in my car and take pictures in it and offered to let me sit in his Bricklin. Here's are my personal observations and opinions:
1) Being 6'6", I can't fit in a Bricklin. Can't close the door because of the lack of head room. Have to be a contortionist to get my legs in the door and under the steering wheel. Same process with getting out.
2) Cool looking car. Reminds me of a 70s or 80s Vette, but with big bumpers and gullwings.
3) Can't handle the brown 70s interior. Just too far before my time.
4) Love the power doors.
5) About one third of the body panels have had to be replaced on this particular Bricklin due to fading and cracking. It's gotta be hard to keep all panels matching in color without paint.
6) Neither the Bricklin or DeLorean received any love from the car show judges. The Bricklin owner wanted to be in the same category as my car for all future car shows. He said that it fits best into the "Sports Car" category and acted offended when I suggested that I put my car into an "80's" category.
So my first experience with the Bricklin was tainted by its owner. Feel free to respond to any and all points above.
dvonk
06-26-2012, 08:48 PM
...6) The Bricklin is more American than the DeLorean...
since it was built in Canada?
more "North American" than the DeLorean, perhaps... :8ball:
Stainless
06-26-2012, 10:07 PM
since it was built in Canada?
more "North American" than the DeLorean, perhaps... :8ball:
His reasoning was because of the Ford motor, American Motors parts, etc. vs. the PRV motor, Renault transmission, etc.
bruscreen
06-26-2012, 11:25 PM
1) Bricklin built a prototype car out of stainless steel. That is where John DeLorean got the idea to make his car out of stainless. (I can't find any info to back up his claim)
2) You can still buy a new 1965 Shelby with an unused VIN, so why do the DeLoreans have to use a donor VIN for their cars that they restore? (this was after I informed him that they are not brand new cars, but extensive restorations with original VINs)
3) The car used in the SV1 crash test did so well that they were able to put it back together, and that car is still on the road somewhere.
4) Bricklin used gullwing doors for safety, but DeLorean copied the idea and just liked the doors for styling, not safety.
5) The DeLorean weighs more than the Bricklin (I shut him up when I told him the GVW)
6) The Bricklin is more American than the DeLorean (how do you respond to such a pointless remark? I just took it as another attempt to make his car better than mine.)
I own one of each, and have done a little informal research. I am by no means an expert, and I rely heavily on Wikipedia as a source, but here's how I understand it...
1) I have never heard of a prototype Bricklin in stainless. The original prototype was later dubbed the "grey ghost" so the color may have confused some people?
2) I know nothing of new VINs or Shelbys so I'll keep my mouth shut on this one.
3) If you have enough money and patience I suppose you could rebuild anything, but here's crash footage so you can judge for yourself. I'd call the front end a loss... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHNVH6Wo4mo (Update: According the the build history (http://bricklin-sv-1-build-history.com/photo_4.html), Prototype 5, white, was used in crash testing, after which it is presumed destroyed. Prototype 8, originally orange, was also used in crash testing, but was reported seen with a white body in 2010. So there's some truth in this one.)
4) Malcolm Bricklin himself has claimed his car inspired the Delorean, though probably only John Delorean could have told you if it were so. Bricklin did advertise the gull wing doors as a safety feature, along with every other aspect of the car he could think of, but those (originally hydraulic) door lifters would have to be VERY strong to be any help if the car was on it's roof.
5) If anyone asked me which was heavier, I would have to point out that the Bricklin is larger, has a bigger engine, and acryllic is NOT light. Each door on the Bricklin weighs 90 to 100 pounds, and it takes 130 pounds of compressed air to open them (with the popular aftermarket pneumatic upgrade.)
6) I agree with prior posts, that the Bricklin is really only more "North American". I don't think of either as an American car, although I suppose the Bricklin has more parts in common with American made cars than the Delorean does. The Bricklin's frame is AMC, as was the motor in the '74. The first car they made went to Ford for drive train testing and the Ford Windsor 351 replaced the AMC 360 in the '75 model year.
I'm 6'1" and I think I fit OK in both cars, though I haven't been able to drive the Bricklin yet to be sure. The Delorean definitely has the advantage in the "surprise headroom" department.
StainlessBullet
06-26-2012, 11:25 PM
I looked at a Bricklin that a local dealership had for sale a few years ago. It was the first time I had ever seen one in person. I’ll admit the build quality looked rather poor, but I still thought the car was pretty cool. Just another car on my maybe, possibly, probably list of cars for me to own one day.
pezzonovante88
06-27-2012, 12:10 AM
According to ultimatecarpage.com (okay, probably not the MOST credible source) the Bricklin SV-1 weighs 3470 lbs. Whereas, the DMC-12 weighs 2844 lbs.
Bricklins are cool cars, no doubt, but the build quality is pretty nasty, the interiors are kind of gross, and it must be a major pain in the ass keeping the acrylic panels in good shape.
Jonathan
06-27-2012, 12:36 AM
I would chalk it up to no more than the owner of this particular Bricklin was a donkey. There are many of those guys around, you just happened to get unlucky and find one that owned a car "similar" to yours in a few ways.
You know something I heard a long time ago that always stuck with me? Bad mouthing always goes up. The guy with the crap car always has to make himself feel better by grilling you on your car about stupid stuff not worth mentioning. Think of it this way, if you just bought a new Chevy Camaro and are very happy with it, but the next guy over in his new Corvette ZR1 was talking to you about your car, he never tells you you should have got the bigger engine, or I don't like this feature, or I don't like that feature. He doesn't need to bad mouth your car to make himself feel better. Those comments always come from some donkey in a beater Cavalier or something. And more often than not, it's the same idiots that spout off the cocaine comments. Some guys are just built to be idiots no matter what the setting. You can apply this to all kinds of stuff. Watches, cars, houses, just about anything. Most of the time it means token dude is insecure about his own stuff and you were the unlucky recipient he needs to put down to make himself look better in front of his friends, girlfriend, or even just himself.
Keep going to your shows and enjoy them, but maybe steer clear of the Bricklin guy. There are some good guys out there that own Bricklins, and some donkies that own DeLoreans. But ya, I agree too with the others about the build quality of those cars. I'd probably be looking for something to make me feel better too.
Tillsy
06-27-2012, 12:54 AM
why do the DeLoreans have to use a donor VIN for their cars that they restore?
isn't this because the (new) DMC is not a car manufacturer and thus they can only produce overhauled cars not entirely new cars?
Squall67584
06-27-2012, 11:24 AM
I think if they were to make "new" ones with new VIN numbers, then they would be subject to passing all of the government regulations and tests that are done to all new cars. So it would have to pass 2012 crash test standards, even though it was designed to only pass early 80's standards. It would likely need all the other mandatory stuff of today as well.
Dracula
06-27-2012, 01:38 PM
The Bricklin, in my opinion, is a far more American car than the DeLorean; but they're both foreign. The Bricklin gets the title for having a US engine and drive train. In fact, most of the parts are from US suppliers. I love the car to death, but the way I have to describe it is as an amateurly-built Ford-based Corvette kit car. There are fit and finish issues all over; the gauge panel is terrible, the gear selector seems tacked on, etc. However, the parking brake is in a better location for egress, but a poor choice for a predominantly-automatic run of cars. The car is the essence of the 1970s; aesthetically speaking, that is.
StainlessBullet
06-27-2012, 02:57 PM
The Bricklin, in my opinion, is a far more American car than the DeLorean; but they're both foreign. The Bricklin gets the title for having a US engine and drive train. In fact, most of the parts are from US suppliers. I love the car to death, but the way I have to describe it is as an amateurly-built Ford-based Corvette kit car. There are fit and finish issues all over; the gauge panel is terrible, the gear selector seems tacked on, etc. However, the parking brake is in a better location for egress, but a poor choice for a predominantly-automatic run of cars. The car is the essence of the 1970s; aesthetically speaking, that is.
Do you still own one?
I’ve been interested in them for awhile, but I wasn’t sure what kind of resources are available if I ever did bite the bullet and buy one. Have you had any trouble getting parts for it? Any good dmctalk style forums that I could join?
DMCVegas
06-27-2012, 05:11 PM
1) Bricklin built a prototype car out of stainless steel. That is where John DeLorean got the idea to make his car out of stainless. (I can't find any info to back up his claim)
2) You can still buy a new 1965 Shelby with an unused VIN, so why do the DeLoreans have to use a donor VIN for their cars that they restore? (this was after I informed him that they are not brand new cars, but extensive restorations with original VINs)
3) The car used in the SV1 crash test did so well that they were able to put it back together, and that car is still on the road somewhere.
4) Bricklin used gullwing doors for safety, but DeLorean copied the idea and just liked the doors for styling, not safety.
5) The DeLorean weighs more than the Bricklin (I shut him up when I told him the GVW)
6) The Bricklin is more American than the DeLorean (how do you respond to such a pointless remark? I just took it as another attempt to make his car better than mine.)
*sigh*
This is precisely why I post mini-novels to help educate whenever we encounter highly-functioning retards such as this one.
1. As previously stated, the prototype car was never stainless. Even the history of the prototype by Bricklin International clearly states this. Quick History Lesson: John De Lorean opted for Stainless Steel as both a asteticly pleasing look that he himself preferred, as well as it was a marketing point for corrosion resistance as well as easy cleaning. Malcolm Bricklin before he entered into the automotive business was involved with plumbing supplies. Bricklin's inspiration for the SV-1 were acrylic bathtubs that remained the same color throughout. You could scratch it, and it would be the same color underneath, and Bricklin's own father even branded the first SV-1 with an iron to burn the logo into it at an unveiling.
2. If someone from DMCH wishes to chime in to clarify, that would be great. In the mean time what I believe has been communicated in the past is that with a DMC-12 branded with a build plate from the defunct "De Lorean Motor Cars, Ltd." of Dunmurry, N.I., this exempts DMCH from any possible lawsuits due to engineering issues that may result in an accident. Same thing that Lotus went through famously when they were sued for a heavily modified car, and demaned to be exempt from when they took on the contract for the DMC-12.
3. Just because Bricklin opted to repair a car after an accident doesn't mean that it was better made than other cars that were scrapped. Because the extend of the damage isn't always known, or at the very least a clever lawyer is able to win a case if one of these vehicles were involved in a wreck, said cars are always destroyed for liability reasons at the behest of automotive manufacturers. Here of course is a perfect example:
http://youtu.be/9GNiL8V-vQQ
4. Bricklin opted for gullwings for the same reason that De Lorean did: They're stylish and practical. Door designs do not figure into safety concerns at all.
5. Obviously yes, the SV-1 is much heavier. This of course figures into Bricklin's engineering ethic of simply making somthing as rugged as possible rather than implementing proper crumple zones and engineering for an actual crash.
6. In all honesty, what difference does this make? If we were to go tit-for-tat, both are American cars. The DMC-12 would however have more American engineering involved for it's custom AC Delco instrument cluster and Air Conditioning system than the SV-1's Jeg's Catalog Bonanza of gauges from China and who knows where else...
Now, onto the remaing bullet points...
1) Being 6'6", I can't fit in a Bricklin. Can't close the door because of the lack of head room. Have to be a contortionist to get my legs in the door and under the steering wheel. Same process with getting out.
2) Cool looking car. Reminds me of a 70s or 80s Vette, but with big bumpers and gullwings.
3) Can't handle the brown 70s interior. Just too far before my time.
4) Love the power doors.
5) About one third of the body panels have had to be replaced on this particular Bricklin due to fading and cracking. It's gotta be hard to keep all panels matching in color without paint.
6) Neither the Bricklin or DeLorean received any love from the car show judges. The Bricklin owner wanted to be in the same category as my car for all future car shows. He said that it fits best into the "Sports Car" category and acted offended when I suggested that I put my car into an "80's" category.
1. JZD was tall, and demanded a vehicle that could fit his frame. Aside from legroom and headroom concerns, the SV-1 is a rolling coffin. Unlike the DMC-12 that has a center console and armrests in the doors, the SV-1 has neither and the window sills are uncomfortably high. It adds to that claustrophobic feeling of being trapped.
2. It has it's good looks, but looks best with the early '74 brightwork that makes the rear end easier on the eyes.
3. Tan & brown, or as my father called it, "shitmuckle", isn't the best choice for a car interior. Granted of course it looks worse over time as the plastic fades and all of the pieces become different colors. But that's not the worst problem with it. The Bricklin is cheap carpet, cheap plastic, mix-matched textures, and if you look behind you it's upholstered in table cloth. You know those padded vinyl table cloths? That's what all the panels behind the passengers are upholstered with. Not to mention that the seats of course are non-adjustable.
4. The pneumatic doors are certainly nice. They go up and come down fast. Much different than the original, slow hydraulic ones. Deadline Auto Theft has a scene where they show the doors opening and closing. It's very painful to watch.
5. The body panels on an SV-1 are not originally painted. They are impregnated acrylic. The front bumper though is painted. When they were brand-new everything matched. However the two surfaces will fade at different rates. Now the thing about impregnated acrylic is that you can't paint it with petroleum-based primers. You have to use WATER-based ones. The thing of it is that when acrylic comes into contact with petroleum distillates, it begins to break down on a molecular level. When this happens the primer separates and causes the top-coats to crack, and thus you have to re-paint. The problem is that once the acrylic comes into contract with the petroleum primer and breaks down, it's a process that cannot be reversed. The body panels pretty much have a sort of cancer that that point and ALL have to be replaced. So big congratulations on this guy for ruining his car.
6. Not all car shows are going to be fun. But if you want to have a better experience, stay away from douche-bags like this. Otherwise it's guilt by association and people will shun you accordingly.
bruscreen
06-27-2012, 06:29 PM
Do you still own one?
I’ve been interested in them for awhile, but I wasn’t sure what kind of resources are available if I ever did bite the bullet and buy one. Have you had any trouble getting parts for it? Any good dmctalk style forums that I could join?
I do still have the Bricklin, and have not started restoration yet. I bought both cars at the same time, and opted to do the Delorean first due to peer pressure. The general public doesn't know / care what the Bricklin is, though I suspect that will change when they see it.
Mechanically, it shouldn't be hard to find most parts, as they are compatible with other AMC / Ford vehicles. The sources I've found so far are bricklinautosport.com (local for me) and bricklinpartsva.com. Acrylic bodies are actually becoming rare, as replacement panels are not easy to come by, and many are being replaced by painted fiberglass. So far the only part I haven't found a source for is my smashed driver's window.
As for Bricklin forums and groups, I would point you to Bricklin.org (the home page of the Bricklin International Owners Club.)
Stainless
06-27-2012, 06:46 PM
1. As previously stated, the prototype car was never stainless. Even the history of the prototype by Bricklin International clearly states this. Quick History Lesson: John De Lorean opted for Stainless Steel as both a asteticly pleasing look that he himself preferred, as well as it was a marketing point for corrosion resistance as well as easy cleaning. Malcolm Bricklin before he entered into the automotive business was involved with plumbing supplies. Bricklin's inspiration for the SV-1 were acrylic bathtubs that remained the same color throughout. You could scratch it, and it would be the same color underneath, and Bricklin's own father even branded the first SV-1 with an iron to burn the logo into it at an unveiling.
This is great. I'll be sure to ask him for proof of this theory when we inevitably run into each other again.
2. If someone from DMCH wishes to chime in to clarify, that would be great. In the mean time what I believe has been communicated in the past is that with a DMC-12 branded with a build plate from the defunct "De Lorean Motor Cars, Ltd." of Dunmurry, N.I., this exempts DMCH from any possible lawsuits due to engineering issues that may result in an accident. Same thing that Lotus went through famously when they were sued for a heavily modified car, and demaned to be exempt from when they took on the contract for the DMC-12. What's the deal with his claim about Ford creating new VINs for the Shelby? Any truth to that? I know virtually nothing about Shelby's. Perhaps a Shelby forum would be a better source of that info...
3. Just because Bricklin opted to repair a car after an accident doesn't mean that it was better made than other cars that were scrapped. Because the extend of the damage isn't always known, or at the very least a clever lawyer is able to win a case if one of these vehicles were involved in a wreck, said cars are always destroyed for liability reasons at the behest of automotive manufacturers.
I got the feeling that he was just trying to make his car sound better than the DeLorean, as if to say, "Your car would be obliterated in a crash, but I could fix mine up and drive it again." I think he was just being an ass hat.
6. In all honesty, what difference does this make? If we were to go tit-for-tat, both are American cars. The DMC-12 would however have more American engineering involved for it's custom AC Delco instrument cluster and Air Conditioning system than the SV-1's Jeg's Catalog Bonanza of gauges from China and who knows where else... Excellent points.
3. Tan & brown, or as my father called it, "shitmuckle", isn't the best choice for a car interior. Granted of course it looks worse over time as the plastic fades and all of the pieces become different colors. But that's not the worst problem with it. The Bricklin is cheap carpet, cheap plastic, mix-matched textures, and if you look behind you it's upholstered in table cloth. You know those padded vinyl table cloths? That's what all the panels behind the passengers are upholstered with. Not to mention that the seats of course are non-adjustable. Shitmuckle! I don't believe there is a better word for that interior. I did notice that the covering in the rear does look extremely cheap.
Dracula
06-27-2012, 09:02 PM
Do you still own one?
I’ve been interested in them for awhile, but I wasn’t sure what kind of resources are available if I ever did bite the bullet and buy one. Have you had any trouble getting parts for it? Any good dmctalk style forums that I could join?
Yes, I do.
I have a '75 due to the Ford drivetrain. It makes parts orders something that even AutoZone can handle by saying it's a Mustang with the 351 Windsor motor. To-Date, I've had no problems that were of Bricklin-specific parts; so, I'm pleased in that regard.
DMCVegas
06-28-2012, 11:25 AM
What's the deal with his claim about Ford creating new VINs for the Shelby? Any truth to that? I know virtually nothing about Shelby's. Perhaps a Shelby forum would be a better source of that info...
I did a quick search on Google, but couldn't find any information on new tags. Whenever a car builder makes a new car it has to adhere to the specific safety and emissions controls that are currently in place at the time of the current year's manufacturing. Exceptions can of course be made for low-production vehicles. Ferrari is famous of course for abusing this, but ALL manufacturers seek out exemptions. The biggest one being of course for convertibles. Sure they increase the strength of the chassis and subframes, but they just don't perform quite as well in a collision. As such they're made in smaller numbers to meet the exemption requirements and of course cost more as a result... That is why you can't just build a muscle car from spare parts today and get it titled. You do at least need a donor car/chassis/VIN to rebuild that entire car.
As for specifically new tags, well that *could* be answered with coachbuilding. A manufacturer takes a vehicle off the assembly line, but they don't complete it's construction 100%. With trucks this may be where they leave the bed off the back and create a simple cab and chassis, or for some luxury passenger cars, they leave part of the rear interior out. Either way there is no certificate of completion so the vehicle remains "incomplete". As such the vehicle is then sent off to a coachbuilder where the remaining work is complete. Now it might be something as complex as stretching and reinforcing the chassis to make a limousine or a hearse. Or it might be as simple as adding a cargo box or other equipment to the back. Once the work is complete, the coachbuilder then issues the certificate of completion and is then considered the actual manufacturer of the vehicle where they get all credit and assume all liability. U-Haul trucks are a great example of this. They might say Ford, GMC, Toyota, or International on the front, but the build plate inside lists U-Haul as the actual manufacturer of the vehicle. The same would be true with Shelby. Legally they're not modifying Mustangs, but they're building them on their own *technically* because Shelby is a registered car manufacturer, and they're the ones certifying these vehicles for the first time. I can easily see how a mixture of confusion and wishful thinking could easily contribute to thinking that Ford is "creating" new VINs for them.
timothymoore
06-28-2012, 01:46 PM
there not building new vin shelbys' but ford contracted a company and is now building new 65 mustang bodies.
http://autos.yahoo.com/news/ford-reintroduces-the-1965-mustang.html
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.