Log in

View Full Version : More Tire Tales (non-D)



Dangermouse
07-04-2012, 01:17 AM
Some more weirdness from my local tire shop.

I got a set of Bridgestones put on my DD last month at a Firestone shop. As always, I declined the Roadside/Hazard Warranty on the same basis that several D owners don't have a spare- I can't remember the last time I had a flat tire.

So, of course yesterday, the tire pressure light comes on and I find a roofing nail in the rear tire. This explains the metallic click-click I had occasionally heard at the weekend , but which I had put down to a trunk full of tools.

Anyway, so the nail (with 1" washer) has been in there for about a week and is the tire is only going done slowly, so I take the car back to Firestone to get it fixed. I am completely prepared to pay as I declined the warranty.

"Sorry sir, because you didn't take the warranty, we can't help you! We don't repair tires!"

"but you are a tire shop!" says I, in slight shock

"yes, but we don't do plugs or patches, you could try Juan down the street"

He was being very polite and nice about it.

"aha" I say" what if I had taken the Warranty. How would you fix it if you don't do plugs?"

"well, in that case we would have replaced the tire"

So their business model is to simply replace a brand new tire rather than put a plug in. I was astounded.

(and before you ask, the nail is right in the center of the tread - no sidewall damage or anything)

Spittybug
07-04-2012, 01:37 AM
Shop down the road from me advertises $5 flat repairs...... Takes these guys 5 minutes using a cord type of plug, a little glue and an awl with an eye in it for the plug cord. Why on earth a place like Firestone wouldn't repair flats is beyond me unless they've found it to be too expensive from a liability point of view.......damned lawyers probably.

Chris4099
07-04-2012, 04:28 PM
There's a local chain here called Les Schwab that does free flat repairs, regardless of where the tire comes from. They just do it as goodwill so you will consider buying tires from them in the future. Every tire shop here also does free repairs if you buy from them. The extended warranty only covers replacement if the tire is somehow damaged and not repairable.

That Firestone must somehow find it more profitable by only offering the warranty. Me, I would never buy another set of tires from them again!

dmc
07-04-2012, 09:08 PM
A jury last year awarded a very large settlement in a case where an accident resulted from a blown tire.
The tire had been plugged two years previous to the accident.
As a result some dealers now refuse to do repairs.
http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=94933

DMCVegas
07-06-2012, 01:00 PM
They probably just take the damaged tire and then sell it to one of those used tire places.

Best story I ever had about the road hazard warranty on a tire was about 2 weeks before I picked up the D. Needed a new set for a '97 Hyundai Accent. Guy at Discount Tire asked if I wanted to buy the road hazard, I said yes. We drove 8 miles before a nail punctured the tread, hit the wheel, and then exited the sidewall on the freeway. Threw the spare on and arrived back at the shop about an hour later.

I told the guy I needed a new tire and had to take him up on the road hazard. The guy got kinda defensive and said they'll only replace the tire if it can't be fixed (in his defense I'm sure he dealt with morons who probably failed to understand the concept), I told him that the sidewall was gone. I showed him the tire. He was then totally friendly and congratulated me on the shortest distance ever driven before replacing a tire after reading the odometer and checking the serial number.

Always take the road hazard protection.

dmc6960
07-06-2012, 01:05 PM
Always take the road hazard protection.

Unless your ordering the tires online and the automated system cannot sell you road hazard protection because you didn't buy a set of 4 matching tires. I didn't feel like picking up the phone.

DMCVegas
07-06-2012, 01:11 PM
A jury last year awarded a very large settlement in a case where an accident resulted from a blown tire.
The tire had been plugged two years previous to the accident.
As a result some dealers now refuse to do repairs.
http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=94933

In all fairness, there are two key aspects to that story that are glossed over:

1. The tire wasn't dismounted for the repair in order to clean the repair up from behind the tread.
2. Whenever you have a tire that is physically damaged and requires a plug, that invalidates the Speed Rating of said tire, and reduces it to whatever the manufacturer states it to then be. And we have no idea here as to how fast the vehicle was going when tread separation occurred, nor how heavy of a load the tire was carrying either at the time.

http://us.coopertire.com/Tire-Safety/Tire-Safety-TIps/Tire-Repairs.aspx

If a tire dealer is THAT unsure of their own staff that they cannot trust themselves to perform a repair, there is no way in hell I'll let them anywhere near my vehicle. Best set of tires I ever had installed were mounted and balanced by a couple of teenage kids working in their family's tire shop. This kid didn't even need direction from me. He knew exactly where the jacking points on the DeLorean were and got the tires perfectly balanced on one of those old fashioned tire balancers that looked older than their father.

Dangermouse
07-06-2012, 01:13 PM
UPDATE: The fact that the shop wouldn't repair the tire bugged me all yesterday as they didn't explain why they wouldn't. Very possibly it was related to that legal case above.

However, having read up a little on plugs following that article, I became leery of using a local $10 cheapy plug, particularly as this was the family car and the tire is brand new

So I called the shop this morning and got a different guy on the phone. "yeah, sure we repair tires, just bring it in" - WTF ???? Took the car straight over, and after a check that it wasn't in the sidewall, they put in a patch-plug from the inside. This guy told me that they only repair tires properly (with a patch-plug) and only when it is safe to do so.

As usual, different guy, different answer. Charged me $25.

Having driven a few miles on it, the big washer was gone but the nail was still clearly there. I would have swapped it out for the spare, but on these new Caravans, the spare is such an unbelieveable PITA to remove I hadn't bothered.

sphiend
07-09-2012, 09:48 PM
UPDATE: The fact that the shop wouldn't repair the tire bugged me all yesterday as they didn't explain why they wouldn't. Very possibly it was related to that legal case above.

However, having read up a little on plugs following that article, I became leery of using a local $10 cheapy plug, particularly as this was the family car and the tire is brand new

So I called the shop this morning and got a different guy on the phone. "yeah, sure we repair tires, just bring it in" - WTF ???? Took the car straight over, and after a check that it wasn't in the sidewall, they put in a patch-plug from the inside. This guy told me that they only repair tires properly (with a patch-plug) and only when it is safe to do so.

As usual, different guy, different answer. Charged me $25.

Having driven a few miles on it, the big washer was gone but the nail was still clearly there. I would have swapped it out for the spare, but on these new Caravans, the spare is such an unbelieveable PITA to remove I hadn't bothered.

I know it's a bit of a hike for you but next time you are in the market for tires or tire services, might try weaver up in Marietta. I was happy with work and will also seriously consider them for DD.