Log in

View Full Version : Hawaii or St. John?



yellowmxwheels23
08-01-2012, 03:25 AM
Planning a vacation and havent decided where to go. It will be mid May 2013.
Never been to Hawaii or the Virgin islands but I just want a nice beach to lounge on.
Has anyone been to St John? What is there to do? I play alot of golf but found there is no course on the island.
I'm finding round trip airfare for $600 on United. You can rent a 1-3 bedroom villa on the beach for around $1000-$1500 for the week.
Hawaii is alot more pricey but only a 5 hour flight compared to an average of 11 hours to get to St. John from San Diego.
Like to get some input from everyone who has been to either.

thirdmanj
08-01-2012, 09:26 AM
Don't bother with the Virgin Islands. Chuck Norris has been there, it's just "The Islands" now.

OverlandMan
08-01-2012, 10:47 AM
I'm going back to Hawaii for the second time (went last year) here in 3-4 weeks. We are staying where we did before on Oahu up on the North Shore at Turtle Bay Resort because it was so nice and secluded. I wasn't a big fan of the Honolulu/Waikiki area (except Pearl Harbor) because it was so crowded.

There are 2 great ocean-side golf courses at our resort (Fazio & Palmer courses) that differ slightly in difficulty. Either one is a gorgeous round though.

I would recommend this to anyone. Cost with airfare and lodging (beach cottage) is about $2,500 per person if I recall.

I've never been to the Caribbean so I can't help you there.

Totally 80s
08-01-2012, 02:20 PM
I recommend Maui.

fnzen
08-01-2012, 11:20 PM
I recomend the Mauna Lani on the Big Island.. the weather is very similar to Southern Cali dry and lower humidity been going there for 10 years its the only place I go now , they have free cabanas on the beach and serve food and drinks (its against the law to drink on beach in Hawaii) but its ok on the Hotel Beach. plus they release turtles there and you can snorkel with them, also the reef of the beach is on of the best snorkel dive reefs on the island boats come all the way from Kona to dive there, also they have great tours of the hotel grounds and the largest petroglyph site is on the grounds..if you like golf its the premier on the island the Francis Brown "skins" game is there

PM me I can send lots of info

http://www.maunalani.com/

pezzonovante88
08-01-2012, 11:46 PM
Planning a vacation and havent decided where to go. It will be mid May 2013.
Never been to Hawaii or the Virgin islands but I just want a nice beach to lounge on.
Has anyone been to St John? What is there to do? I play alot of golf but found there is no course on the island.
I'm finding round trip airfare for $600 on United. You can rent a 1-3 bedroom villa on the beach for around $1000-$1500 for the week.
Hawaii is alot more pricey but only a 5 hour flight compared to an average of 11 hours to get to St. John from San Diego.
Like to get some input from everyone who has been to either.


Hawaii is so far away and I think they have frog problems, or something. I'd go to St. John I think.

TTait
08-02-2012, 01:33 AM
We went to Tahiti a month ago... Big mistake. Turned out that the swimmable beaches were all at private resorts (our resort had a world class pool - but no beach). The rest of the beaches had either too much coral or were presumably unsanitary (the locals would not say that is so many words - but that was the strong implication). Turns out if your going to Tahiti, and you want to hit the beach at any point, you are probably going another 30 minutes over to Bora Bora. The other problem was that there was just not much to do, except lounge by the pool. We can do that at home.

How is this relevant? - its about research and what you like to do. Figure out what each option has to offer before you go.

I have not been to USVI, but I've spent a bit of time in Hawaii - so here's the deal on Hawaii:

There are 5 major islands to choose from:

Oahu - This is where Honolulu, Pearl Harbor and Waikiki are. Its the most populated, As such it has everything any big city has - malls, shopping, clubs, dining, night life, even a water park, as well as many historic sites, pearl harbor, diamond head, polynesian cultural center, sea world type park. Waikiki beach is outstanding - great water, scenery, clean, and full service everything. Walk out of the water, throw on an aloha shirt and go have a world class dinner and countless restaurants (try Roy's or Dukes or Sam Choy's) while the wife window shops at the Prada and Hermes stores. Stay at any number of resorts if you like, or take sunset cruise. On the North shore you will find both killer waves and coves with great snorkeling. Plenty of golf. This island has the most amenities and you can do almost anything here - except see active volcanos. When in doubt - start with Oahu.

Maui - Smaller, and a little quieter - but there is still a lot to do here. Best magic show I have ever seen, lovely whaling village now turned tourist shopping - multiple zip line options from kid friendly to curl your toes, you can drive to the top of an 11000 foot volcano to watch sunrise, or take a shuttle van up in the wee hours and then they provide you with a bicycle to ride 25 miles all downhill to the coast. Artisan communities, the road to Hana, the blue lagoon where you can swim under a waterfall (ice cold). Eat at Mama's Fish house or one of the great little eateries everywhere. There is also a mall and movie theaters etc if you get sunburned. Take a commercial submarine ride 130 feet down and see sea life and a sunken ship.

Go see a gorgeous hidden valley and drive around the whole island, sometimes on harrowing roads. Great beaches, golf, luaus - the whole 9 yards - just no pearl harbor and no active volcanos.

Hawaii - the big island. #3 in population but the largest island, and still growing. Pretty much everything listed for maui but a little more sleepy, and no bike ride down the volcano. Instead, active volcano. You can tour lava tubes, walk in the caldera of a partly napping volcano, or take one of the coast roads to the point where the lava flow took over a dozen years ago, walking out onto the flow itself - its still 130 degrees to the touch and lava flows under it to the sea. If your boots and bottled water hold up you can make it to a point where you can see lava pouring in to the sea, and the island growing before your eyes... Cool.

Kauai - Sleepy Tropical paradise. Gorgeous beaches and rainforests, cafes and roadside food trucks. Pretty sleepy, but bona fide paradise. Golf? I'm pretty sure yes and outrageously good - but double check.

Lanaii - The whole island was once a pineapple plantation, when that closed the built one resort with mega golf courses - 95% of the residents work at the resort - there is nothing else there basically. I heard they may have now gotten a single stop light - I'm told it just blinks. Spa your heart out and play golf. You can snorkel and go to the beach too.

The good news is that you don't have to stay on one island - go do 5 days on Oahu then take a $100 flight to Maui or Hawaii and see another island for another 4 days.

With Hawaii overall you get the best of both worlds - you are in a different place with its own history, language, culture, food and traditions. At the same time, you are spending dollars, stopping in a CVS if you forgot a prescription, and going to costco to pick up a new book to read on the beach. Hawaii totally rocks because its all there for you, from quiet and quaint to big city. The islands are not so huge that you can't just drive wherever you feel like - just go and have fun.

The other thing to realize is that with Hawaii - you can get room and board cheaper than you think. You can of course stay at the Royal Hawaiian, the Hilton at Turtle bay or Disney's Resort, but there are lots of cheaper choices. If you want to be in Waikiki you should be able to find a less expensive hotel 2 blocks off the beach for $120 a night. For about $140 a night we often get on maui a condo with 1 bedroom and a sleeper sofa in the living room and a free rental car for out stay. We have also gone to friends who own timeshares and purchased accomodations through them - $80 a night for an efficiency condo a block off the beach and our friends didn't use any points or anything - they just gave us the reservation code to use and we paid cash.

We have always found nice inexpensive accomodations - there are deals to be had. We found deals even in the 90's and 10 years ago when tourism was at its peak. Things have dropped off since then so there are even more deals if you shop around a little. We always get stung by booking the accomodations fors tnd then forgetting that flights can be pricey last minute.

We plan on retiring there - some day. If you go to Hawaii and don't have fun - you either got a bad sunburn the first day - or you went to Tahiti by mistake.

Happy to provide more details on any of the above if anyone desires.

Tom
(Aloha)

PS - never had a single problem with any frog... maybe he is thinking go Guam, which is overrun with snakes. Maybe there is a frog thing - but its never come up.

PPS - if thats your Ford GT? in the photo - I'm only a few hours north, I'll be happy to come down and start it up and drive it around the block a few times for you while you are gone.

Totally 80s
08-02-2012, 01:38 AM
Big island is full of VOG.

Virgin Islands have lots of poverty and crime. They are like Jamaica, nice as long as you stay in the tourist areas.

yellowmxwheels23
08-02-2012, 04:38 AM
Don't bother with the Virgin Islands. Chuck Norris has been there, it's just "The Islands" now.

That what I've been saying.
That after I leave the name will have to be changed.

yellowmxwheels23
08-02-2012, 04:46 AM
Thanks for the input everyone.
Golf is a major factor and with the closest course in the Virgin islands on St. Thomas it almost seems like a hassle.
I had a job offer in Hilo bay earlier this year but didn't want to move.
I think it's going to be Hawaii just not sure what part.

The GT isn't mine. It's one of the cars my wife inherited when her dad died.
She also got a 72 Pantera light blue and a newer honda civic hybrid.

fnzen
08-03-2012, 12:41 AM
Hilo is rainy!!

Big Island is not full of vog you just have to stay north of Kona , I have property south of Kona and yes you can encounter vog in the afternoon but thats what makes the coffee so good!

If you want golf there are way too many courses north of Kona starting at: Four Seasons , Hilton Waikola, Mauna Lani (7) , Mauna Kea

If you dont stay in hotel the green fees are high so I would look for a hotel golf package

Oh another thing it does not rain north of Kona on the Kohola coast, less than 6 inches so you will not get rained out like in other places

Totally 80s
08-03-2012, 02:01 AM
Hilo is rainy!!

Big Island is not full of vog you just have to stay north of Kona , I have property south of Kona and yes you can encounter vog in the afternoon but thats what makes the coffee so good!

If you want golf there are way too many courses north of Kona starting at: Four Seasons , Hilton Waikola, Mauna Lani (7) , Mauna Kea

If you dont stay in hotel the green fees are high so I would look for a hotel golf package

Oh another thing it does not rain north of Kona on the Kohola coast, less than 6 inches so you will not get rained out like in other places

Your right about the vog... as long as the wind doesn't change direction.

Kona is great if you want to drive around for three or four hours. Probably the worst beaches compared to any of the other islands though (lots of rocks). I've never heard your theory about vog and coffee before. I assume your kidding?

Morpheus
08-03-2012, 10:57 AM
Big island is full of VOG.



What is VOG?

DMCVegas
08-03-2012, 01:07 PM
I read "St. John" and thought you were planning a vacation to see the old Bricklin factory...

Totally 80s
08-03-2012, 02:18 PM
What is VOG?

Vog is basically volcanic smoke that turns into a kind of low hanging fog that is full of toxins. On windy days in can actually travel to neighbor islands. If the wind stops or changes direction the whole island is covered in this hazy fog that makes some people sick. It really started up strong about 4 years ago or so with the new eruption.

Kukem
08-03-2012, 02:52 PM
I read "St. John" and thought you were planning a vacation to see the old Bricklin factory...

I thought the same thing when I quickly read the headline. Couldn't imagine why people whould want to come up here for a vacation though. lol.

pezzonovante88
08-06-2012, 12:49 PM
The GT isn't mine. It's one of the cars my wife inherited when her dad died.
She also got a 72 Pantera light blue and a newer honda civic hybrid.

THAT is frickin' awesome! Not the death part, obviously, but that is a pretty cool couple of cars and a pretty cool gift left by her father. Are you guys keeping the cars?

Dangermouse
08-06-2012, 01:55 PM
have you looked at Aruba? Tiny island, but has 2 golf courses.

Great beaches, all facing West, so some great sunsets.

yellowmxwheels23
08-08-2012, 01:36 AM
THAT is frickin' awesome! Not the death part, obviously, but that is a pretty cool couple of cars and a pretty cool gift left by her father. Are you guys keeping the cars?

LoL, yea it was awesome to say I owned at GT for a few weeks. We sold the GT and the civic. Was able to pay off our house.
The top of the the motor is off of the Pantera. Not sure what he was doing with it before he died but it was running.
There is just no room in the Pantera. Not that comfy so I havent even started on that project. It's been 4 years. All of the fluids are drained before I stored it.
I'm just in no real hurry to fix it bc I know I would barely drive it. The GT on the other hand was pretty fun to drive but with the oportunity to pay off my house, that and the gas the thing ate and insurance we had to sell it.

Her dad was a Chief Engineer on a boat and was probably home 3 mos out of the year. He left 2 big ass safes full of guns and a few houses here in San Diego. we live in one of them and the others went back to the bank. He had them as rentals but we didn't want the headache.

Maybe one of these days I'll get that Pantera up and running. Thing only has 54k miles on it and is pretty clean.