View Full Version : Radiator Fans, Solar
Bitsyncmaster
08-12-2012, 09:20 AM
This may be of interest to some DIY people because it relates to radiator fans.
Long story short, I'm installing an attic fan to run off solar power. So I'm looking for the most efficient air movement from with 50 watts of input power.
I have a universal 16 inch radiator fan model number RAF-16 that is rated at 12.7 amps, 1730 CFM, 2250 max RPM with 10 blade fan. I also have a 50 watt solar panel rated at about 17 volts at 2.9 amps. I ordered some switching power supplies from china to drop that 17 volts lower and bump up the current. This is just a fun project in learning about fan designs. I looking at getting a way to measure CFM from the fans which would also let me compare the fans we use in our D.
Anyway, my first testing was how much power this fan needed running at different voltages. To my amazement the thing turns (very slowly) with 1.0 volts at 1.1 amps. That's 1.1 watts of power. I recorded a table of power at half volt steps up to 15.0 volts (which made the current at 11.9 amps).
Are more fan blades more efficient than fewer?
Would a lower rated fan motor be more efficient at 50 watts?
Would more smaller fans be more efficient than one large fan?
Spittybug
08-12-2012, 04:12 PM
Funny that you started this thread. I just butchered two old Dell Optiplex computers that had outlived their usefulness. Each had 2 fans for moving air across a beautiful copper finned radiator that was pressed against the processor. These little fans move air! 12 VDC, .35a Don't ask me how I know that they will take a nice little gouge out of a finger. :thumbup:
It got me thinking along the lines of redundancy and having multiple smaller fans instead of just 2 big ones. While I don't think you'd want a bank of these little guys (would probably take about 20 of them total if you could build a frame to hold them - but only ~ 7 amps), but the concept is interesting. Maybe even stage them so that only the minimum number of them that needs to turn on actually do.
I haven't seen an update on the ventilated seats that were being fabricated, but given the air volume and velocity I see from these little guys, I'm more inclined to believe there are fans out there that can do the job.
I'm going to play around with some small solar panels I salvaged from some Chinese walkway lights that I got at HF after they got crappy looking. Maybe cover the top louver with them and use the juice to power fans for when the car is parked in the sunshine. Could probably mount the fans behind the seat belt mechanism and vent via the side vents...hummmm.
Bitsyncmaster
08-12-2012, 06:19 PM
I thought about using a bank of computer fans but think a larger fan blade would be more efficient. I may even put a second fan on the other end of the house that blows in.
I remember seeing those car coolers a while back. You would hang it on your door window and solar power the fan in it. But if you have an internal vent, you could leave it there all the time and just have a solar panel you leave on the dash.
Spittybug
08-12-2012, 07:35 PM
These new flexible solar panels have me thinking. How about covering the entire louvers' surface with them? I'd have to do some math, but that's a fair bit of surface area, thus wattage. Take that energy and push it through an HHO generator to produce hydrogen and oxygen. Pump that into the intake.
There is no contention that HHO is a good combustible fuel. The only voodoo associated with it is when the electricity source is the car's alternator. No such thing as free energy since you had to burn gasoline to generate the power to drive the alternator. However, solar cells providing the electricity is "free" (capital expense obviously not counted). The hydrogen in the resulting HHO stream is more valuable than simply its fuel value; it allows for better flame front propagation during detonation and allows you to adjust the timing a bit, sparking closer to the maximum cylinder pressure rather than having to do it earlier to allow for the flame front to travel through the charge and having a more "extended" ignition event. Like having a very high octane fuel. To obtain a couple of liters output per minute, the test HHO generator I built needed 12V and about 20 amps or 240 watts (P=IV, right?)
HHO cells are simply SS plates separated by small insulated gaskets (like a car battery), submerged in a mild electrolyte solution. IIRC, 1.5 v differential per plate pair is optimal, so low voltage, high current is the preferred electricity profile. At a minimum it would create a very unique and conversational car. It may however actually improve your gas mileage.
Bitsyncmaster
08-12-2012, 08:26 PM
240 watts will take a lot of surface area (with today's technology). If you use that power for the cars electrical when driving, it would save about 1/3 HP from the engine.
Any fuel you add will help the MPG but don't know if one liter a min would be noticed.
Dangermouse
08-13-2012, 10:03 PM
Re Daves attic fan:
I asked one of my process engineer buddies about the relative efficiencies of axial fans, and in his opinion, more blades would be theoretically more efficient, but whether you could detect it is another question.
On another note, I would think that two small fan motors would be easier to start on this "limited" electrical system wrt starting spikes. There would also be some redundancy in the event of a failure.
Bitsyncmaster
08-14-2012, 07:11 AM
Re Daves attic fan:
I asked one of my process engineer buddies about the relative efficiencies of axial fans, and in his opinion, more blades would be theoretically more efficient, but whether you could detect it is another question.
On another note, I would think that two small fan motors would be easier to start on this "limited" electrical system wrt starting spikes. There would also be some redundancy in the event of a failure.
Thanks for the info.
I will get more testing done one I get the switching voltage converter attached. So far it's looking like 8.7 volts will give me 45 watts into the fan. That is assuming 50 watts from the solar panel and 5 watts lost in the voltage converter. But that will bump the current up to 5.0 amps.
Bitsyncmaster
08-14-2012, 03:50 PM
It is an interesting document of how to measure CFM. I need to get one of those meters to measure the velocity soon. I'm planning on replacing my radiator in my D so I can do a test on John's fans compared to the OEM fans.
RIUM+
08-15-2012, 05:11 AM
Don't forget that if you're adding a mechanical extractor fan to your attic, you'll need an air inlet in your attic too... You won't believe how many times at work I see people forget the inlet. :rolleyes1:
For pushing air, more blades are "generally" more efficient but it comes down to the blade design & what the fan was optimised for (raw cfm throughput, airflow direction, noise levels, vibration, blade speed, power efficiency, etc). You'll need to either compare datasheets or just measure the end result (eg for a DeLorean, don't measure the airflow after the fans - measure the coolant temperature drop with the stock radiator).
240 watts would be just barely possible if you coated all the louvres in some of the highest-efficiency panels currently on the market. I'm not sure how much benefit you'd actually get though, given the increased vehicle weight... At any point, the performance boost wouldn't be worth the money compared to other potential upgrades. The largest value to adding solar panels to a petrol car is avoiding a flat battery when parked for extended periods, and you only need a tiny foot-long one to accomplish that.
(disclaimer: my day job is a Building Energy Efficiency Assessor!)
Bitsyncmaster
08-15-2012, 07:31 AM
Don't forget that if you're adding a mechanical extractor fan to your attic, you'll need an air inlet in your attic too... You won't believe how many times at work I see people forget the inlet. :rolleyes1:
For pushing air, more blades are "generally" more efficient but it comes down to the blade design & what the fan was optimised for (raw cfm throughput, airflow direction, noise levels, vibration, blade speed, power efficiency, etc). You'll need to either compare datasheets or just measure the end result (eg for a DeLorean, don't measure the airflow after the fans - measure the coolant temperature drop with the stock radiator).
240 watts would be just barely possible if you coated all the louvres in some of the highest-efficiency panels currently on the market. I'm not sure how much benefit you'd actually get though, given the increased vehicle weight... At any point, the performance boost wouldn't be worth the money compared to other potential upgrades. The largest value to adding solar panels to a petrol car is avoiding a flat battery when parked for extended periods, and you only need a tiny foot-long one to accomplish that.
(disclaimer: my day job is a Building Energy Efficiency Assessor!)
Thanks. Here in the US, attics have a vent at both ends, vented soffits and most have vented peak caps.
Dangermouse
08-15-2012, 09:26 AM
Dave,
I have one of those airflow meters at work, but it would probably costs as much to ship it to MD and back than actually buy one.
I would be interesting to bring to a tech session if there were various radiator fans installed to get data.
Bitsyncmaster
08-15-2012, 10:06 AM
Dave,
I have one of those airflow meters at work, but it would probably costs as much to ship it to MD and back than actually buy one.
I would be interesting to bring to a tech session if there were various radiator fans installed to get data.
Thanks. I bought one on EBay. I don't really need accuracy since I will be comparing fans in side by side testing. I think our fans are all the same diameter so the velocity should correlate to the CFM. But like was stated, CFM is not the only thing that determines the cooling of our engines.
stevedmc
08-16-2012, 01:09 PM
Each had 2 fans for moving air across a beautiful copper finned radiator that was pressed against the processor.
I've never head of a computer using anti freeze. Every computer I've seen has a heat sink(s) pressed against the processor(s).
Dangermouse
08-16-2012, 01:45 PM
I've never head of a computer using anti freeze. Every computer I've seen has a heat sink(s) pressed against the processor(s).
High end gaming computers can have them
http://umfacts.um.edu.my/Gallery/8700003209.jpg
DMCVegas
08-16-2012, 02:25 PM
I've never head of a computer using anti freeze. Every computer I've seen has a heat sink(s) pressed against the processor(s).
A few years ago Mac Pros had them as well. I've also seen a few Alienware units that come standard with it as well, though those had pumps and separate radiators.
If you really want to blow your mind, you can also submerge the entire assembly in mineral oil. Just like a transformer.
http://www.ls1gto.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=26002&stc=1&d=1135373345
stevedmc
08-16-2012, 02:31 PM
Aren't those called peltzier coolers?
dvonk
08-16-2012, 02:37 PM
Aren't those called peltzier coolers?
youre thinking of a Peltier Junction, which is a thermoelectric cooling unit.
stevedmc
08-16-2012, 03:13 PM
High end gaming computers can have them
http://umfacts.um.edu.my/Gallery/8700003209.jpg
That doesn't look like a Dell computer to me. Spitty said his Dell computer has a radiator in it.
Spittybug
08-16-2012, 09:03 PM
I said: "each had 2 fans for moving air across a beautiful copper finned radiator that was pressed against the processor." There was no liquid involved.
What I called a "radiator", others might call a copper heat sink.
Bitsyncmaster
08-18-2012, 01:15 PM
Got my Harvey fans out of the car. I also got my air velocity meter yesterday. I hope to have some data tomorrow compairing the OEM fans and John's. I've been thinking to get more accurate results I would want to put a long tube the dia. of the fans over the fan exit. That way the air flow would be consistant to measure.
Dangermouse
08-18-2012, 03:06 PM
As you probably know Dave, cold air is heavier than warm, so try and do your comparisons at around the same ambient temp.
Bitsyncmaster
08-18-2012, 04:17 PM
As you probably know Dave, cold air is heavier than warm, so try and do your comparisons at around the same ambient temp.
Will do. Going to do the testing inside. My 30 amp power supply will be fine. These will be tests not mounted on the radiator but I could do that test later.
Bitsyncmaster
08-19-2012, 09:37 AM
I ran the test with each fan not mounted on the radiator and no tube on the exit. I really want to get that tube on the exit to get some real CFM numbers but this test has shown me the Hervey fans are pretty good. Both the OEM and Hervey's fan blade are the same diameter (about 11.5") and each have four blades. But Hervey's blades have a ridge near the blade ends to improve air flow efficiency. The do this same thing on jet wing tips called winglets. Hervey's fans seem to have the best air flow closer to the edge of the blade whereas the OEM blades best is about centered on the blade. You would want to compare efficiency by using the same power input results. So calculate the watts input (voltage times current).
Velocity test was done at 4.75 inches distance from the back edge of the fan blade. This was the distance of the back of the OEM motor. Obviously there is no air flow where the motor blocks the output and no blades of fan there. Voltage and current were measured at my power supply with each fan powered by 3 foot of 14 AWG wire. You should note that there is a large voltage drop in the car harness wires. It would be about twice the drop with OEM fans since those run about twice the current. I had to guess at the average velocity since the digital meter would vary as the reading were taken.
I expect the currents to go up when attached to the radiator. Would guess air flow will be reduced the same with all fans when mounted.
I attached the data so things line up. How do you spell John's last name? I stay at Harvey's when I go skiing so I mix them up
Bitsyncmaster
08-20-2012, 01:39 PM
I bought a four foot 12" tube and it really helps even the air flow a lot. It still is reduced in the center. I also found out not to have the fan sitting on the floor because it will reduce flow on that side of the tube.
I need to get the testing done with John's fans so I can put them back into my car. I will run the test again with the open intake then with the OEM radiator, then with my new radiator (it may be different for air flow).
I can run the OEM fans and OEM radiator later since I will keep those on the self.
We still won't know how much the AC condenser blocks flow.
Bitsyncmaster
08-20-2012, 06:18 PM
I started a new thread for the radiator fan testing here:
http://dmctalk.org/showthread.php?4932-Radiator-Fan-Test-Data&p=69992#post69992
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.