PDA

View Full Version : Most difficult auto repair job you've ever tackled?



Kenny_Z
08-29-2012, 05:02 PM
I don't mean the one that takes the longest, I mean the one that has you throwing tools and screaming at the car. The one that makes you want to hunt down the engineers.

I've worked on a lot of cars. Just recently did I tackle a job that was just so horrible that I never want to go into that area of the car again. Some of you know I recently purchased an 86 Monte Carlo. One of the freeze plugs rusted out so I had to replace it. That was the easy part of the job. The freeze plug was behind the starter. Even the Delorean starter is easier to replace than this one. I seriously considered purchasing headers just so I could get that damned crossover pipe out of my way. I still haven't found all of the wrenches from when I threw my tool bag. Even dropping the 5 pound sledge on my face while knocking out the old freeze plug did not piss me off as much as that starter. Three days later and my bruises from jamming my hand in between the crossover and the lower control arm are still not healed.

I'm just glad that I purchased a brand new starter so I won't have to do that again for a long time.

Stainless
08-29-2012, 05:33 PM
Worst job I've ever done: replace a cracked exhaust manifold on a '99 Jeep Cherokee. After getting everything all back together, I discovered that due to a slightly different intake manifold for that year, the new exhaust manifold didn't fit snugly enough. I had to do the 9 hour job all over again after shaving off part of the intake manifold. That was 3.5 years ago and I want to scream every time I think about it. It makes replacing the slave cylinder on the DeLorean look like a walk in the park.

Runner up: replacing the spark plugs and wires on my father-in-law's 1990 Chevy Astro minivan as a quick favor. I had too many slices in my skin to count from the sharp metal that caught my skin during that horrible job. The motor is accessed underneath the dash in that stupid vehicle. What terrible memories.

Ozzie
08-29-2012, 08:27 PM
Fuel Accumulator on the DeLorean (at least for a garage tinkerer)

..'cause you're on your back, the car on lift puts the under body just above your nose while on your back, you have little leverage in that position, you need to reach up into the frame to access it, AND you need to use either a stubby wrench or get about 1 click on a ratchet wrench to undo the fitting. That's been my benchmark of most challenging auto repair.

...the clutch slave is a close second.

Dangermouse
08-29-2012, 09:10 PM
Changing a pair of cats on a Chevy truck.

In a parking lot.

On a hot summers day.

With just hand tools.

Local "entrepreneur" had "freed " these cats for scrap platinum value no doubt through use of a skillfully wielded sawsall. I had bumped the truck front wheels onto the curb to get good access, but as Ozzie pointed out, I was then on my back on the hot ground trying to loosen exhaust bolts at full reach. And of course there's always one that won't come out.

After two trips to the store for progressively longer cheater bars and home for progressively larger hammers, the remnants were finally off. Which was fortunate as I was hot, tired, bloody and holding a long length of 1" bar and was just itching for that entrepreneur to reappear.

Jacko
08-29-2012, 09:38 PM
This thread should have a poll so we could keep count. My vote is for the storied clutch slave replacement closely followed by the fuel accumulator ... what a bitch! Then there's the seemingly simple job of merely removing the crankshaft pulley. I mean, it's only one nut ... it's right there.:dunno:

Kenny_Z
08-29-2012, 10:25 PM
I've done the accumulator, three times. I would rather do it three more times than that starter once more. The clutch slave in Red was easy so I guess I lucked out. I've done the plugs in my 89 astro and my mom's so I feel you there Stainless. I have the battle scars too. I think that might be the runner up.

This thought of the razor sharp steel on the astro has me thinking about the most painful job I've ever done. It's a toss up between the Mustang's starter landing on my face or the Nova's engine swinging on its crappy engine lift and hitting me. The engine easily had 300 pounds on me so it literally knocked me off my feet and across the garage.

SS Spoiler
08-29-2012, 11:30 PM
How about replacing the pins to line up the tranny while it was in! I replaced the 5 speed before going to DCS Vegas '05. After driving from MN. to Vegas I was chatting with Dave fromDMCMW and Don from DMCCA and I mentioned that I had a tough time getting the starter to quit dragging on the flywheel. Dave looked at Don and said uhoh. Did you put the pins back in from the old tranny? The starter has a machined surface and goes in only one way. Duh...Needless to say I babied the car back to MN. I was'nt looking Forward to dropping it out again for four little dowels. It only has to slide back 3/4". Went to Ace and got longer bolts to replace the tranny/ engine bolts. Supported the motor and tranny and pried them apart enough to slip the pins in. Because the pins were hollow and the boss had small holes, allowed me to push a rod to hold the pins in place. Then slowly drew them together, replaced the original bolts and done!
Ask me about removing a broken head bolt from a 58 ford six cyl. with out pulling the head.....

Shep
08-29-2012, 11:40 PM
The worst one I've ever done (mild by some standards) was trying to disassemble the Quad 4 engine on my '95 Achieva without taking the drivetrain out of the car. It had a blown head gasket, and I was told by our mechanic that it's "very easy" to replace for an Achieva, so I decided to take a crack at it. It sat in my side yard for a month while I took manifolds off (stripped one of only two exhaust manifold screws in the process), removed the engine mounts, disconnected the cooling lines, drained the coolant, and right when I went to take the timing cover off, the bolt holding the engine bracket on simply wouldn't go any further. I loosened it enough that it hit the passenger wheel well. I strongly considered taking a jigsaw to the fender and cutting an access hole to be filled later with bondo, but for some reason decided against it. Instead, I took about 200 pictures of damn near everything thinking that's when it would go to the junkyard.

Then my dad came across some stuff that claims it fixes head gaskets. Usually one application is enough (allegedly), but some people said they needed to add it every 6 months or so. The problem is, it's incompatible with coolant, i.e. you can only use water in your coolant lines while it's taking effect. We reassembled everything from where we left off excluding one of the exhaust manifold screws (again, stripped), then put this stuff and water in the coolant lines. Then we ran the engine, keeping it a bit above idle until the thermostat opened up. At this point, it starts smoking like crazy (naturally), but then the smoke disappears! Thinking we fixed it, we followed through with the rest of the instructions to the letter, eventually putting 50/50 coolant back into it.

Then about ten drives later I've run out of coolant again. Apparently the catalytic converter is capable of neutralizing minor amounts of coolant as it goes through the exhaust, and this "fix" only brought the amount of smoke back down to that level. So the head gasket wasn't fixed, and it sat in our side yard again until squirrels decided to make a nest where the battery used to be, and ate through some wiring. That's when I knew it was over my head, so I kept the spoiler and junked the rest (it was my first car, after all). Still have that spoiler hanging on my wall.

opethmike
08-30-2012, 12:12 AM
Turbo charger on a Saab 93. Absolutely the most horrifying job I've ever done on a car. Changing the gas tank on a Lotus Elise comes a close second. Third is changing the timing belt on a Lotus Esprit.

Nicholas R
08-30-2012, 12:18 AM
The engine swap wasn't really a repair job so the toughest DeLorean jobs I've done were definitely the evaporator twice, and the front frame extension. Evaporator is hard because it's so tight. Front frame extensions is tough because its simply a lot of work. The disassembly and reassembly of the front end is the easy part. The hard part is all the weld prep. Surface prep, and new front frame extension aligning. Then welding with the body on was certainly a challenge. An odd combination of stick welding and almost blind mig welding, lol. Would have TIG'd it if I could but would never have been able to get 2 hands in place on top. Would have been so much easier if I had the body off... which of course happened 6 months later...:angry::banghead: If only I would have known...


Most difficult non-Delorean projects; at least a dozen head gaskets on various cars; run of the mill stuff. Not difficult just a lot of work. Most difficult project was probably my buddy RJ's 73 charger. Catastrophic engine failure while driving on I-75. The presumed cause was loss of a piston rod bolt causing the piston to become disconnected from the crank, then the crank hitting the piston rod, bending and breaking it as well as the piston itself, then causing pieces to hit other pistons, breaking another piston rod, wreaking havoc in the crank case, destroying journals, sending pieces through the oil pan. A summer of locating a new suitable engine, doing a full rebuild on the new engine, and installing, and the car is back on the road.

dvonk
08-30-2012, 01:09 AM
mine is pretty tame by most standards, as i have yet to acquire adequate equipment to tackle really big jobs... but my most frustrating job was replacing a CV axle assembly on a 2001 Hyundai Elantra. its a pretty straight-forward job, but ill be damned if every bolt wasnt frozen. clearance for wrenches sucked, and of course the bolts and nuts all started rounding off, all this while the bolts were free-spinning in the hole. :swear1: it was a multi-evening project due to the frustration level.

in the end i remember i used a couple vice grips, a 3lb. sledge, PB Blaster, and a chain to get the bolts loose. i chained one vice grip to the shock tower on the frame to hold it still while hammering the other vice grip in the opposite direction. what a pain in the ass. of course, shortly after i finished the driver side, the passenger side boots ripped.

i sold the car, so someone else got to dick with it.


Worst job I've ever done: replace a cracked exhaust manifold on a '99 Jeep Cherokee...

man, i can sympathize--those pre-2000 4.0L exhaust manifolds suck. i read about them on the Wrangler forum; luckily my Wrangler is a 2000... the first year for the redesigned exhaust manifold.

DMCVegas
08-30-2012, 08:13 PM
Rubber hose connecting water pump and manifold pipe on Jaguar AJ6 engine.

I equate owning a Jag is a relationship like Pip & Estella's from Great Expectations; She's a beautiful car whose demanding repairs almost abuse you, but you keep coming back.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Spittybug
08-30-2012, 08:45 PM
Something as stupid as replacing the back 3 spark plugs of a Honda Odyssey... all blind and the leaning over the engine you have to do will kill your back in the morning. I had to be creative on the use of extensions, universal joints and the rest of the socket set. Being double jointed and being able to work while looking through a mirror would help tremendously.

On the Delorean, I hate anything under the dash (claustrophobia) and in the compartments behind the seats because of comfortable access. The accumulator is a PITA because of its location. I don't have to worry about distributor or clutch slave access anymore since the EFI conversion, but they were a PITA too. Mating the transmission back to the engine sucked until I broke the code and tilted the engine.

I could probably think of tons more, but really, isn't it the challenge of it all that makes it exciting?

Shep
08-30-2012, 09:57 PM
I equate owning a Jag is a relationship like Pip & Estella's from Great Expectations; She's a beautiful car whose demanding repairs almost abuse you, but you keep coming back.Amen to that. In a two-month period, we put more money into repairs on our '93 XJ6 than it was worth. I guess that's what you get when you take a weekend driver and make it a daily driver.


Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkReally? :facepalm:

DMCVegas
08-30-2012, 11:16 PM
Amen to that. In a two-month period, we put more money into repairs on our '93 XJ6 than it was worth. I guess that's what you get when you take a weekend driver and make it a daily driver.

I still miss that car. It wasn't too bad on prices to maintain. Turns out there's a parts warehouse here in Houston that sell Jag, Land Rover, and other Brit cars pretty cheap. They also sell conversion and improved parts for these cars too. Motorcars, LTD is the name down on Hempstead Hwy.

That and I found that Ford type F fluid is a good substitute for HSMO.


Really? :facepalm:

A coworker who is also a gear head recommended this app to me. It isn't compatible will all boards, but most. So glad I got it! Makes navigating do much easier on iOS.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Shep
08-31-2012, 12:01 AM
A coworker who is also a gear head recommended this app to me. It isn't compatible will all boards, but most. So glad I got it! Makes navigating do much easier on iOS.


Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkI meant the blatant advertising. It's quite annoying, actually. There's a setting to turn it off if I recall correctly, but I'm an Android man, so I don't know where it's located.

DMCVegas
08-31-2012, 12:36 AM
I meant the blatant advertising. It's quite annoying, actually. There's a setting to turn it off if I recall correctly, but I'm an Android man, so I don't know where it's located.

Ahhhh... It apparently doesn't animate GIFs when you view the site through the app as I just found out now logging in through Firefox, so I didn't catch that.

Yeah, I'll be turning that off.

timothymoore
08-31-2012, 12:52 AM
Toughest task to date for me, is the current job and that is swapping the 4.3 out of my S10 for a new one. removal of the old engine was a pain but we got it out. half a dozen ground wires here, some hidden clamps and bolts here on top of hardly any to get your hand let a lone a tool in there.

Morpheus
08-31-2012, 11:25 AM
My List:

Clutch slave / line replacement from under the car. Two different cars, two similar pains in the ass.

A/C Condenser without dropping the radiator. Clearance issues make this job tougher than it should be.

Broken Y Pipe bolt. The extractor broke and took with it a chunk of the surrounding aluminum. Had to carefully dremel out the broken extractor bits, then drill through the bolt and re-tap the hole. A slow, arduous process.

dmc6960
08-31-2012, 11:34 AM
Broken Y Pipe bolt. The extractor broke and took with it a chunk of the surrounding aluminum. Had to carefully dremel out the broken extractor bits, then drill through the bolt and re-tap the hole. A slow, arduous process.

I'll second this one. Even though the complete engine removal and rebuild took longer, the broken extractor 8 years prior was certainly the most difficult repair. This same problem happens over and over to people trying to get stuck y-pipe bolts out of the engine. Every time someone posts about the broken bolt BEFORE they stick an extractor in, at least we have time to stop them.

DeLorean03
08-31-2012, 12:19 PM
Rear wheel bearings on the DeLorean. I was at Cliff's with a full lift and many specialized tools that he had just for this job. Dude, THAT was a job. Went from about 8:30pm to 1am - a VERY thorough job.

DMC3165
09-02-2012, 04:35 AM
Don't know if this quite qualifies but I did a clutch and a tranny rebuild on a Mack tractor. The trans was about 2500 lbs and was an absolute nightmare to get out and stand on its nose so I could seperate the back end of the casing. Timing the gears was another pain as well as getting the shafts to line up for reassembly. In the process of reinstalling the trans we discovered where the motor mounts bolt to the frame (the back motor mounts are on the sides of the trans in Mack trucks) I discovered a crack in the chassis. So the trans had to come back out again. After the crack was repaired I finished the reinstall and took the truck for a test drive only to discover a repeated CLUNK, CLUNK, CLUNK, in the trans. I missed one broken tooth on one gear when doing the partial rebuild. So the whole job had to be done AGAIN! it was the worst two weeks of my life while on a job. For the rest of the 15 years I ws in trucking I never did another rebuild again. And I never will!!!!!!
:tantrum:

vwdmc16
09-02-2012, 05:02 AM
Worst overall for was head gaskets on a Jaguar XJ8, the supercharged v8, Had to do the manifold twice as It has serious leaks around the blower., Im sure there has been something worse but i just blocked permanently from my memory.:shhh: But it was probably something I did on a Porsche 928 with the 32v engine.


On my car changing the motor mounts w/o pulling the engine, this was so hard because you have to remove the Cat and my cat has nuts and bolts attaching it ( had to drill out the original threaded bolts) so its super hard to reach in behind to hold and thread the nuts on.

ramblinmike
09-02-2012, 06:11 AM
Mating the transmission back to the engine sucked until I broke the code and tilted the engine.

I've gotta ask - how else would you get the two back together. I HAD to tilt the engine back to get the input shaft to go back into the crank. There was no other way to do it. I couldn't get the trans high enough to get it in. I kept hitting the frame.

Mike C.
09-02-2012, 06:17 AM
The WORST:

Front brake failure on my friend's Ford Ranger. Good news: it broke down at his brother's work. Bad news: It was 40 degrees outside and raining. Now, a front disk brake job doesn't sound THAT tough, does it? Not really... but story gets more interesting.

So we removed and installed new calipers, disks, bearings, and did the bleed out, all while wearing a plastic grocery bags on my head. My friend and I get done, and drive the truck back to the house. About a week later, the Ranger has a brake problem.... what are the odds? Still cold outside, but not raining. Best thing is the truck made it home, but loses all brakes. Pedal goes straight to the floor. So crawl under, and find the brake line is rusted. By rusted, i mean rotted through in 2 places. He bought the truck in Ohio for $3k. So we have a 4x4 high mileage ford ranger that was purchased for cheap... one word: RUSTY!!! Luckily, he was not on the highway when this went out!!!

Easiest thing to do for access: Pull the bed. Hosed everything with WD40, let it soak for a few hours. Let me say, I spent the next 8 hours with an impact wrench, grinder, torch, and a hardware sizing guide... because everything under there was FUSED. Finally got the bed off at 9pm, and evaluated the brake line. Turns out a good 4 ft section was in bad shape. Found out the factory bent piece going from rear drum to rear drum was also staring to fail.... tried to bend a piece from the auto parts store, but ended up being too short. Bought a longer piece. re-bent, and borrowed their flare kit. Guess what? Parts missing from the flare kit. Cannot flare the fittings. It was now 330 in the morning. We decided to crash and would brainstorm in the morning.

Next day was a Sunday. Options were to go and get a flare kit while we were at a junk yard picking up new bed hardware. Since there were multiple sized brake fittings for rangers, we brought one of the old ones with us to the yard. Ended up finding a totaled truck that had the wrong sized brake lines, but the right bed hardware... so grabbed all of that. Went to another one, and found the rear end brake line that was the correct diameter and had the right fittings, so I pulled that. (5 bucks!!!) Went and looked for another ranger to get the full brake lines, and we found one... but the problem is this place just drops the cars flat on the ground. You couldn't fish the lines from under the truck. Even better, no forklift available to move the truck for access.

Got an idea... both he and I worked at Coca Cola repairing equipment, and we carry stainless steel line couplers and compression fittings. I took the tubing cutter out of my box, sectioned the entire rear brake line for the truck, and bought those (3 bucks for the entire lengths!!), and also snagged all brake hardware, in case we needed doubles. I wasn't coming back...

So got back, cut out all the rotted pieces from the main lines, got the couplers, and made compression fittings. Our lines fit perfectly, so we snugged em down, put the new rear line in place, bled out and tested the system... seemed to be holding pressure. Tied up gas tank and did a couple of emergency stops with the brakes to make sure the compression fittings would hold, and sure as hell... it was perfect. Brakes lasted longer than the truck.

What could have been a simple repair was nothing but a huge, rusted pain in the ass. Rust will make any simple project the worst thing you have ever done.