PDA

View Full Version : wireless router slow down



Bitsyncmaster
09-09-2012, 06:27 PM
Sometimes when my son or daughter are at my house, my wireless router will slow down about 20 times less than the normal bit rate. I fix it by powering it down an on again. My kids have smart phones and have my router password.

Is it just a bug in my router?

Tillsy
09-09-2012, 07:26 PM
Sometimes when my son or daughter are at my house, my wireless router will slow down about 20 times less than the normal bit rate. I fix it by powering it down an on again. My kids have smart phones and have my router password.

Is it just a bug in my router?

Nah it's called BitTorrent and/or YouTube :giggle:

Ozzie
09-09-2012, 07:42 PM
...I was going to say as above, but if re-powering fixes it, then it may be getting overloaded prematurely.
Check to see if there is an updated firmware for the router.

Ours would occasionally hang (Router + 2 switches), and I'd have to get a step ladder (they are on top of tall cabinets) and reset each. But worse, when I wasn't home at it would lock up, my wife would call and I'd try to explain which one to reset (there are also some netdrives up there)...so to fix that, I wired a small 3 plug power cord, to an e-stop button, and it hangs down the side of the cabinets so as to ease access.:
http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=13105&d=1347230427

...and that solved the phone calls.

Bitsyncmaster
09-09-2012, 07:50 PM
Thanks. It's about two or three years old. I will see if I can find and update an how to load it.

OverlandMan
09-09-2012, 08:39 PM
...I was going to say as above, but if re-powering fixes it, then it may be getting overloaded prematurely.
Check to see if there is an updated firmware for the router.


+1 on firmware patches. If none are available I would consider trying a different WAP and see if that solves. In my experience, you get what you pay for. Those cheap $40 WAPs can be finicky.

Nicholas R
09-09-2012, 09:05 PM
Dont some routers or ISP's automatically throttle down your available bandwidth if you're downloading excessively? In one apartment I had, it would happen ALL the time.

Bitsyncmaster
09-09-2012, 09:10 PM
I did find an update from my 2.23 to 2.25. This is on my D-Link DIR-615. I was able to upload the update (had to plug my PC into the router) and it upladed the file OK. Will have to see if that helps when the Iphones are here.

Jeff K
09-10-2012, 01:36 PM
I would guess bittorrent and downloads. You can block them at the router level.

OverlandMan
09-10-2012, 06:58 PM
I would guess bittorrent and downloads. You can block them at the router level.

But he says power-cycling the WAP resolves the issue (though for how long wasn't specified). Which it would only do very briefly if the issue was bandwidth-related.

Bitsyncmaster
09-10-2012, 07:09 PM
But he says power-cycling the WAP resolves the issue (though for how long wasn't specified). Which it would only do very briefly if the issue was bandwidth-related.

I'm on DSL and the download speed is always 800 Kbit. It never changes when the router is not messed up. The problem shows up one or two times a day if my son or daughter are at the house. Powering the router down for 5 seconds and then back on will clear it until the next time my kids show up.

I guess the phones use some other communication protocol on WIFI. I think my son has a droid and my daughter an I-phone.

stevedmc
09-10-2012, 07:34 PM
Powering the router down for 5 seconds and then back on will clear it until the next time my kids show up.

I suppose you could put the router on a mechanical timer to shut it on and off a few times a day. You can get those things at Big Lots for about $5.

Dangermouse
09-10-2012, 08:25 PM
I do love that E-stop button. I'm sure it goes well with the decor. :)

Ozzie
09-10-2012, 09:15 PM
I do love that E-stop button. I'm sure it goes well with the decor. :)

Yeah, my wife is in the interior design business, so yeah that button breaks several decorating rules.
..but it is out of view, and she gets her internet access back at the push of a button (literally), so thus my bit of man-cave tech is tolerated.

OverlandMan
09-10-2012, 10:16 PM
I'm on DSL and the download speed is always 800 Kbit. It never changes when the router is not messed up. The problem shows up one or two times a day if my son or daughter are at the house. Powering the router down for 5 seconds and then back on will clear it until the next time my kids show up.

I guess the phones use some other communication protocol on WIFI. I think my son has a droid and my daughter an I-phone.

800Kbit is on the slow end of the broadband spectrum to say the least. It could be very possible that multiple users streaming audio and video could cause significant bottle-necking on that connection. If you have a cheap WAP and/or router that could also lend to packet collision and other LAN issues that could yield annoying latencies.

Not sure what's available in your area as far as bandwidth goes but I would research your options. Either that or do like some of the other folks are saying and throttle the bandwidth down on the problematic devices from your router (provided it has that capability).

I guess I'm spoiled with FIOS.

Shep
09-10-2012, 10:38 PM
Dont some routers or ISP's automatically throttle down your available bandwidth if you're downloading excessively? In one apartment I had, it would happen ALL the time.There are ways around it, but for to the untrained person, yes. Back when I only had Microsoft Works and used to download OpenOffice releases via uTorrent, it used to slow everything internet-related down to a crawl. Then I learned about port forwarding and higher port numbers, and no longer have that problem. Recently I downloaded a Vista recovery disk to repair a laptop and had that same issue (which was a moot download; that laptop had a recovery partition), and later discovered the port number it was set at wasn't what I originally set it to. Set it back, and no problems so far.

...what? Surely I'm not the ONLY one who uses bittorrent legally, right? I'm not paying $300 for Microsoft Office when OpenOffice is free and works just as well. Except now it's Alibre Office and I since got a new computer with Microsoft Office on it, but my point remains valid -- I pretty much guarantee it's bittorrent-related, whether your kids want to admit it or not (and chances are they won't due to questionable legality of their downloads).

David T
09-10-2012, 11:26 PM
What is happening is the router (or your local node) is throttled back during heavy usage and it does not reset back to the higher speeds when traffic is light. This can be because of the node you are connected to. When you restart the router it resets the settings back to the defaults. If it keeps happening you may have to contact your ISP. Trying the latest firmware may help but it is probably time for a new router. Google your router and see if others are having similar problems and how they fixed it.
David Teitelbaum

Dangermouse
09-11-2012, 12:12 AM
Shep, is it likely that they are using bit-torrent on their phones?

I think that they realize that Dad's Internet service is very slow (no of fence Dave) and would save any downloading for somewhere else. Anywhere else. Kids these days have no patience. (yes, get off my lawn)

With the bit rate quoted, just having three separate devices on the Internet could choke it. These routers seem to have a finite life (built in obsolescence anyone). Ours got to the point of having to be reset every day, so we trashed it and got another. Night and day.

I also find a periodic reboot of the router to extend the periods between crashes/lock ups. Don't know why, perhaps it clears out the cache.

Shep
09-11-2012, 12:24 AM
Shep, is it likely that they are using bit-torrent on their phones?Isn't it even more likely that their phones have 3G/4G? Dave just said they have smart phones, not that they actually connected them to wifi. With bandwidth that slow, even 3G would be faster. I'm sure the kids are smart enough to realize that and stick to their data plans over their wifi. They'll show up in the router if they've ever connected, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's been a recent connection.

Bitsyncmaster
09-11-2012, 05:56 AM
I think it happens even when the phones are not being used. Usually my laptop and my wife's laptop are connected all day long. I think if it happens again I will buy a new wireless router. Maybe it's the DSL modem since my power off turns both off at the same time.

Tillsy
09-11-2012, 07:33 AM
On a more serious note, it sounds to me like you are having an overlap of wireless protocols.

If you have a fast 802.11N network and an 802.11G device, likely one of those phones, roams onto it the entire network will start to considerably suffer.

That said, once they leave your network it should immediately recover back to full performance. If there was a bug in your firmware that was causing this to not happen the update you did should have corrected that.

You can get dual-band routers that will essentially provide two completely separate G and N networks that only allow corresponding devices on them and thus no degradation in performance. Alternatively you could set your N network to only allow N devices, and simply not allow the G devices online.

Cordless phones, microwave ovens, and Mr Fusion generators have serious impact on wireless networks as well.

Bitsyncmaster
09-11-2012, 07:46 AM
On a more serious note, it sounds to me like you are having an overlap of wireless protocols.

If you have a fast 802.11N network and an 802.11G device, likely one of those phones, roams onto it the entire network will start to considerably suffer.

That said, once they leave your network it should immediately recover back to full performance. If there was a bug in your firmware that was causing this to not happen the update you did should have corrected that.

You can get dual-band routers that will essentially provide two completely separate G and N networks that only allow corresponding devices on them and thus no degradation in performance. Alternatively you could set your N network to only allow N devices, and simply not allow the G devices online.

Cordless phones, microwave ovens, and Mr Fusion generators have serious impact on wireless networks as well.

Thanks.
Now that sounds like some good tech stuff. I don't know much about the working of WIFI but the router runs at 50 MB, and my landline phones are 2.5 Ghz.

RIUM+
09-11-2012, 09:39 AM
Your first check should be if it's your router or the ADSL connection that's slow. If you have two computers (or a computer & a laptop), try transferring a large file over the wifi network & seeing how fast it transfers. The next time things seem slow, try it again.. If the local network transfer's slower too, you can likely rule out your ADSL connection as the culprit.

Since you've already updated the router, check if there's any driver updates for your computer's wifi card too (their phones should auto-update).

I've seen this kind of problem crop up a few times... Despite being certified as wifi-compliant, some chips just don't work well together in certain locations with certain types of interference. My sister's iPhone crashes many routers if she stays connected o them for too long, which is just plain weird. Changing the wireless router's channel usually helps. Decreasing the Beacon & DTIM Intervals usually fixes it, but according to its manual your router doesn't have that option. :(

OverlandMan
09-11-2012, 12:36 PM
On a more serious note, it sounds to me like you are having an overlap of wireless protocols.

If you have a fast 802.11N network and an 802.11G device, likely one of those phones, roams onto it the entire network will start to considerably suffer.

That said, once they leave your network it should immediately recover back to full performance. If there was a bug in your firmware that was causing this to not happen the update you did should have corrected that.

You can get dual-band routers that will essentially provide two completely separate G and N networks that only allow corresponding devices on them and thus no degradation in performance. Alternatively you could set your N network to only allow N devices, and simply not allow the G devices online.

Cordless phones, microwave ovens, and Mr Fusion generators have serious impact on wireless networks as well.

I agree in that using legacy wireless (a,b,g) devices on a wireless n network will slow things down while said legacy devices are active; however, wireless g operates in a range from 6-54Mbits/sec and wireless b from 1-11Mbits/sec (both @2.4ghz frequency) BOTH of which are faster than his ISP connection of 800KBits/sec.

A dual band solution would be ideal inside his home LAN if he needs to support legacy wireless; however, at the end of the day, his internet will still be 800K unless he upgrades.

When it comes to WAPs/routers/switches, etc... you get what you pay for. Cheaper stuff always seems to give me headaches.

Spittybug
09-11-2012, 12:56 PM
"You get what you pay for" seems to be a common theme here.

I have gone through 4 - 5 wireless routers in 10 years. I've had Linksys, Cisco, Vizio and at least one other. What I see happen is the router seems to stop detecting and connecting with the devices. My Vizio is starting to do it now. Wake the computer up or turn on wifi on the Android phone and it doesn't always connect. Sometimes after several minutes it will, but sometimes I have to reboot the router. The devices "see" the router, but don't connect. I have Comcast cable at ~20 download speed, so when it's running as it is supposed to, it is very fast and able to accommodate multiple users doing data intensive things no problem.

I've heard that it is a case of cheap (<$75 is what I've always paid) routers run hot and can hurt themselves. So my question is, what must one spend or look for, and ideally what brand?

OverlandMan
09-11-2012, 01:06 PM
"You get what you pay for" seems to be a common theme here.

So my question is, what must one spend or look for, and ideally what brand?

I too have purchased several cheap ones over the years (less than $75). About 6 months ago I bought a $200+ Netgear for a guy I do some side work for. He said its run like a champ w/o issue ever since. I replaced an old WRT54G Linksys circa 2005 that had prob been there all that time. I know 6 months is a small sample size but still seems to have solved his prior issues (range, speed, overall network performance).

I've used some fancier enterprise level ones for business applications before as well. For instance ones that interface/authenticate with Active Directory. Those are around $400-500 or higher. Totally overkill for a home network.

Bitsyncmaster
09-11-2012, 06:52 PM
First test looks promising. My daughter was only here about 1.5 hours without my speed changing but I had her go on face book with her phone and she said it was running a lot faster.

Bitsyncmaster
11-03-2012, 04:11 PM
That router update fixed my problem. It's been weeks now with no problems.

Shep
11-03-2012, 06:13 PM
That router update fixed my problem. It's been weeks now with no problems.Good to hear! :thumbup:

By update, do you mean upgrading the router firmware, wireless card driver, the router itself, or your connection with your ISP? I'm curious since I saw all of those suggested.

Bitsyncmaster
11-03-2012, 07:18 PM
Good to hear! :thumbup:

By update, do you mean upgrading the router firmware, wireless card driver, the router itself, or your connection with your ISP? I'm curious since I saw all of those suggested.

I had to down load the new firmware from the Internet. Then I had to upload the firmware into the router box via Ethernet cable connection. They would not let you do it WIFI.

Shep
11-03-2012, 08:09 PM
I had to down load the new firmware from the Internet. Then I had to upload the firmware into the router box via Ethernet cable connection. They would not let you do it WIFI.Usually an Ethernet cable is required. I believe it's to minimize the effect of wifi interference and/or man-in-the-middle attacks, since a botched firmware can effectively "brick" the router, i.e. it only becomes useful as a brick since wifi does not work and neither do firmware updates.