PDA

View Full Version : DMC-12 values vs time - Hagerty



Rich
09-29-2012, 03:21 PM
Without endorsing the accuracy of this data from Hagerty here is a chart showing their estimated value of an '81 DeLorean since 2006.
Pay close attention to their Condition table, second image here.

13615 13614

Check it out. Hagerty's collector car valuation tool is found here:

LINK to Hagerty Car Price Guide (http://www.hagerty.com/valuationtools/HVT/VehicleSearch)

Have fun with it.

Dangermouse
09-29-2012, 03:34 PM
Interesting. So what caused the very noticeable uptick at the start of 2011?

To early for the EV.

25 year anniversary of BTTF?

Rich
09-29-2012, 09:13 PM
Probably the second one, something to do with the 25th anniv. of BTTF.

Or a statistical blip. Not sure what they use as their data sources.

Mike C.
09-29-2012, 09:20 PM
It seems VERY ambitious...

refugeefromcalif
09-29-2012, 10:39 PM
In tune with this thread but, out.?

I called my Allstate agent before I bought 6599.
I told him what I was paying for the car and would they cover 100% of that price.
He told me No. He said that I could insure it with Hagerty to have my Full purchase price insured.

Long story short, Hagerty wanted 3X MORE for the yearly premium then Allstate wanted.
Some of Hagerty's other stipulations were, I couldn't DRIVE the car to the corner store for bread/beer. I Couldn't drive the car to work. It could ONLY be driven/transported to car shows and the like.?

Since I've owned/driven 6599, I've broken Every stipulation that Hagerty said I couldn't do if I'd insured with them.
Allstate says, "I'm in Good Hands." :)
Granted, Not for the Full Value of what I paid.

One of lifes Risks...

George

Shep
09-29-2012, 10:44 PM
It seems VERY ambitious...Might be a "captain obvious" moment, but I'm betting all these values are directly taken from the agreed value of the ones they insure. In the beginning of 2011, either someone upped their insurance drastically, or a new "high roller" got insured under them, causing the spike. They do keep a record of the condition of each car they insure for claims purposes (things get restored back to "as insured" condition), so my guess is that each condition type they have in their system gets its own category and price point. Ambitious, perhaps, but in that case it's Hagerty that's getting suckered, not the buyers, since they're insuring a car for more than it's actually worth.

SamHill
09-29-2012, 11:10 PM
Seems to me that convincing owners that their car is more valuable than it is, or is an "investment" that will grow with time benefits Hagerty as the owner is willing to pay more to insure an item of higher value. Hagerty ain't the one getting suckered here. Not to say they aren't a good company, they are. But there's a reason why the insurance companies have all the big buildings. I take these figures with a grain of salt.

That "Hagerty index of cars" is really silly too. I can cherry pick cars as well as anyone else and make the numbers say what I want them to.

Shep
09-30-2012, 12:08 AM
there's a reason why the insurance companies have all the big buildings.Volume? We personally only occupy a third of one floor of the building we're in, but purely because we do not handle the same volume they do. Our agents do a significant amount of our business, but the "mainstream" companies don't have that luxury due to name brand recognition, which inherently means they handle more of their own business. The more policies a company writes without the assistance of agents, the more employees they have, and thus the bigger the building needs to be to house them all in. Seems fairly straightforward.

Anyways, in terms of who's getting suckered, my statement was from a claims point of view. Higher agreed value means not only higher payouts for covered total losses, but also less total losses. If I were to insure my DeLorean for $80,000, and I was in a severe accident that would cost $70,000 to fix, that's $70,000 out of Hagerty's pocket with the potential for further claims, as opposed to only $20,000 if I were to insure it for that much and a write-off preventing further claims. That being said, as you pointed out, the premiums for these insurance policies do increase with higher agreed value. I guess it's a matter of how many of these overinsured D's have claims on them.

DMCVegas
09-30-2012, 02:03 PM
Since I've owned/driven 6599, I've broken Every stipulation that Hagerty said I couldn't do if I'd insured with them.
Allstate says, "I'm in Good Hands." :)
Granted, Not for the Full Value of what I paid.

One of lifes Risks...

George

Not to be a dick, but you don't think that if you ever have a legitimate claim with Hagerty, an claims investigator might not actually Google you and your aliases to find this statement in order to deny a claim?

Not a fan of Hagerty myself (long story), but until I retire my DeLorean, I just carry liability only, and plan on getting a Ravelco unit installed. If I ever decide to keep her off the road for whatever reason, then I'll switch to collector insurance with my current insurance agent.

Dangermouse
09-30-2012, 02:26 PM
His point was that he actually went with Allstate, and since then has done all the things Hagerty wouldn't have allowed him to do , had he gone with them.

refugeefromcalif
09-30-2012, 02:34 PM
His point was that he actually went with Allstate, and since then has done all the things Hagerty wouldn't have allowed him to do , had he gone with them.

Yep. Allstate has been Good to me for many years so, I stayed with them for the D. Hagerty just had too many restrictions.
No matter what I paid, I bought a car that I intend to, Drive... :)

George

DMCVegas
09-30-2012, 02:36 PM
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-lWNAuulV3hk/UFCTH5AuHCI/AAAAAAAADk4/XvvPuCcUNAg/s1600/homer-simpson-doh.gif

Shep
09-30-2012, 05:27 PM
Not to be a dick, but you don't think that if you ever have a legitimate claim with Hagerty, an claims investigator might not actually Google you and your aliases to find this statement in order to deny a claim?Considering he has yet to post his last name, no, I don't think so. The DeLorean is a very special case; we're the only car where VIN numbers actually matter as far as I'm aware. Since they do, we post ours, but I have yet to come across any other car-based community that does that as well. Claims adjusters are not well versed in that kind of obscure trivia, and as such wouldn't think to google his VIN number. Since he has a vanity plate, then perhaps they may google that, but I strongly doubt they're going to take the time to google his vanity plate, come across his profile on here, and search through every single post he's ever made just for the small chance he may have admitted to doing something he shouldn't be doing. Their time is much better served by looking at the odometer reading and realizing he's put way too much mileage on it for it to have only been driven to car shows and club events.

Rich
09-30-2012, 05:45 PM
Meanwhile, back to the value data. This tells us that D's in good shape tend to stay priced more or less as they have been. Not appreciating or depreciating much. Am setting aside the blip for the concours condition cars in recent years.


....here is a chart showing their estimated value of an '81 DeLorean since 2006.
Pay close attention to their Condition table, second image here.

13615 13614

Check it out. Hagerty's collector car valuation tool is found here:

LINK to Hagerty Car Price Guide (http://www.hagerty.com/valuationtools/HVT/VehicleSearch)

Have fun with it.

Shep
09-30-2012, 06:03 PM
This tells us that D's in good shape tend to stay priced more or less as they have been.Small correction: are insured more or less as they have been. Their data most likely comes from the policies they write, not what's currently on the market. New policies, claims, and agreed value changes are all that factor into this. And unfortunately, they don't give a sample size for reference unless I'm missing something, so this may not necessarily be too accurate. ;)

refugeefromcalif
09-30-2012, 06:21 PM
Considering he has yet to post his last name, no, I don't think so. The DeLorean is a very special case; we're the only car where VIN numbers actually matter as far as I'm aware. Since they do, we post ours, but I have yet to come across any other car-based community that does that as well. Claims adjusters are not well versed in that kind of obscure trivia, and as such wouldn't think to google his VIN number. Since he has a vanity plate, then perhaps they may google that, but I strongly doubt they're going to take the time to google his vanity plate, come across his profile on here, and search through every single post he's ever made just for the small chance he may have admitted to doing something he shouldn't be doing. Their time is much better served by looking at the odometer reading and realizing he's put way too much mileage on it for it to have only been driven to car shows and club events.

I haven't posted my last name on this forum but, this isn't the only forum that I post on.
On another forum I Have posted my last name, Including a pic of the vanity plate that I have on my mini van With my last name.
I have Vanity plates on All my cars. :) Most people ask me to explain what they mean?
People ask "What does 1DER Y mean"? I have too sound it out, then Explain...

Anyroad, I Didn't go with Hagerty because of their restrictions, and I Didn't title/register my D in Alabama as an Antique because of the same thing.

George

DMCVegas
10-01-2012, 03:24 AM
Considering he has yet to post his last name, no, I don't think so. The DeLorean is a very special case; we're the only car where VIN numbers actually matter as far as I'm aware. Since they do, we post ours, but I have yet to come across any other car-based community that does that as well. Claims adjusters are not well versed in that kind of obscure trivia, and as such wouldn't think to google his VIN number. Since he has a vanity plate, then perhaps they may google that, but I strongly doubt they're going to take the time to google his vanity plate, come across his profile on here, and search through every single post he's ever made just for the small chance he may have admitted to doing something he shouldn't be doing. Their time is much better served by looking at the odometer reading and realizing he's put way too much mileage on it for it to have only been driven to car shows and club events.

Well honestly, you don't have to search through every single post. You could easily build a profile, and besides that the entire site here has it's own search engine for users and posts. Skip tracers have gotten very well versed when it comes to locating debtors as an example, through social media and other means. In a high-stakes claim that could run many thousands of dollars in costs, it might just be worth an insurance company's time and money to perform a brief investigation into such things. Because people use the same usernames consistantly across many boards, and in turn start listing different e-mail addresses as well, it's not that difficult to track someone down. Look at "Rowdy Gowdy" who claimed he owned all these expensive cars and trucks. Within a few minutes of searching I found that mommy and daddy owned a used car dealership, and he was simply driving around company inventory. You'd be surprised whats out there...

David T
10-01-2012, 12:43 PM
If you were to hire a professional car appraiser he would not give much weight to Hagerty's values. What matters more is recent closed auction sales. That is a more accurate indicator of the market, what people have paid for a particular car in an "Arms Length" transaction. Most of the auctioneers print reports of their auctions to sell to appraisers just for that purpose. You also have to look at the report. There is always a "blip" when someone with more money that brains overpays for a car. It happened with the Amphicars and skewed the values badly. Classic cars tend to 'bounce" at the 25 year mark or if someone closely associated with the car dies, in this case, JZD. The way appraisers rate a car is they take what a 100 point perfect car is worth and start deducting for any defects. That is why having a Concours can help set values for a car Marque. Knowing what a perfect car is creates a starting point or a benchmark for comparison.
David Teitelbaum

Rich
10-01-2012, 09:13 PM
Small correction: are insured more or less as they have been. Their data most likely comes from the policies they write, not what's currently on the market. New policies, claims, and agreed value changes are all that factor into this. And unfortunately, they don't give a sample size for reference unless I'm missing something, so this may not necessarily be too accurate. ;)

Here is what Hagerty says about their price data sources in case anybody wants to know.

LINK: http://www.hagerty.com/valuationtools/About-our-prices (http://www.hagerty.com/valuationtools/About-our-prices)

They claim to use Auctions, Dealer sales, peer-to-peer sales and asking prices as inputs.

Nothing is mentioned about using data from their underwriting. And, after all, how would their underwriters know what condition a customer's car is in so as to correctly value it before writing a policy? The customer proposes the value to them.

Seems like their input sources are along the line of what David T recommends.

Rhsxo
10-01-2012, 09:50 PM
I got it! It was my cars appearance on Wheeler Dealers! That's what drove up the price. Your all welcome. :)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wheeler_Dealers#Series_8_.282011.29

Rich
10-01-2012, 10:59 PM
I got it! It was my cars appearance on Wheeler Dealers! That's what drove up the price...

It's hard to argue with the correlation. Whether it is the causation is a bit harder to say, but, why not?

Had not seen that W-D summary before, so thanks for the link.

We see that for this series the DMC-12 paid back 3X the average return on investment. Not only that, it topped all of the cars in terms of ROI, including the Jag E-Type, even after bearing the burden of travel and importation expenses of the D. Buy low, sell high.

Thanks for the donation to a worthy cause - DeLorean resale values.

Shep
10-02-2012, 12:23 AM
Here is what Hagerty says about their price data sources in case anybody wants to know.

LINK: http://www.hagerty.com/valuationtools/About-our-prices (http://www.hagerty.com/valuationtools/About-our-prices)

They claim to use Auctions, Dealer sales, peer-to-peer sales and asking prices as inputs.I stand corrected then.


how would their underwriters know what condition a customer's car is in so as to correctly value it before writing a policy? The customer proposes the value to them.And also provides pictures of its current condition as a prerequisite. I just got a Hagerty policy myself a few months ago, and they required pictures of everything, including exterior, interior, trunk, engine/drivetrain, and the "permanently-attached enclosure" i.e. garage it will be stored in. They then look at the pictures and determine if it is indeed worth what the customer is claiming its worth. There is, of course, room for higher-value exceptions (e.g. Stage or SPEC engine on our D's). And if a DeLorean is underinsured, then it's the owner's loss and thus not a problem for Hagerty.

SoCalDMC12
10-02-2012, 02:32 AM
FWIW: I was just on NADA.com researching the value of an '86 944 Turbo. While there I checked out Delorean values:

http://www.nadaguides.com/Classic-Cars/1983/Delorean/DMC-12-Gullwing/2-Door-Sports-Coupe/Values

Seems to jibe with Hagerty. (Of course, they could both be a bit optimistic...)

DMCVegas
10-02-2012, 11:28 AM
I stand corrected then.

And also provides pictures of its current condition as a prerequisite. I just got a Hagerty policy myself a few months ago, and they required pictures of everything, including exterior, interior, trunk, engine/drivetrain, and the "permanently-attached enclosure" i.e. garage it will be stored in. They then look at the pictures and determine if it is indeed worth what the customer is claiming its worth. There is, of course, room for higher-value exceptions (e.g. Stage or SPEC engine on our D's). And if a DeLorean is underinsured, then it's the owner's loss and thus not a problem for Hagerty.

You also cannot allow anyone under the age of 25 to have access to the vehicle, nor the garage where it is stored. When I was 21 and first got my car, I considered storing it for maybe a year or so to complete it's restoration, and contacted Hagerty about a policy. Being 21 they said that I could in fact take out a policy with them, but I couldn't have access to the vehicle what so ever. Specifically the woman on the phone told me that I would have to lock the vehicle up and give the car keys and garage keys to someone over the age of 25. Nevermind the fact that I owned the car, and had claim to the structure it was in.

That left a very negative impression of me with Hagerty that never went away. I'd rather store the vehicle uninsured than give those assholes a single penny. Young people you dismiss today will be your customer's tomorrow, and I've also always steered people away from them every chance I get. Especially after State Farm said they offer comparable policies and WILL cover a DeLorean as a collector car.

cybercusp
10-02-2012, 03:46 PM
I started to go with Hagerty..I filled out the form and received a phone call from underwriting where I was told that, basically, if I drove the car it wouldn't be insured. She said I could take it to a car show, or "to get ice cream", but that was it.

Shep
10-02-2012, 07:38 PM
FWIW: I was just on NADA.com researching the value of an '86 944 Turbo. While there I checked out Delorean values:

http://www.nadaguides.com/Classic-Cars/1983/Delorean/DMC-12-Gullwing/2-Door-Sports-Coupe/Values

Seems to jibe with Hagerty. (Of course, they could both be a bit optimistic...)"Please Enter Your ZIP Code. Your ZIP Code is used to provide you with information specific to your location." :umm:


You also cannot allow anyone under the age of 25 to have access to the vehicle, nor the garage where it is stored. When I was 21 and first got my car, I considered storing it for maybe a year or so to complete it's restoration, and contacted Hagerty about a policy. Being 21 they said that I could in fact take out a policy with them, but I couldn't have access to the vehicle what so ever. Specifically the woman on the phone told me that I would have to lock the vehicle up and give the car keys and garage keys to someone over the age of 25. Nevermind the fact that I owned the car, and had claim to the structure it was in.

That left a very negative impression of me with Hagerty that never went away. I'd rather store the vehicle uninsured than give those assholes a single penny. Young people you dismiss today will be your customer's tomorrow, and I've also always steered people away from them every chance I get. Especially after State Farm said they offer comparable policies and WILL cover a DeLorean as a collector car.I don't know how long ago this took place, but that certainly has not been the case for years. :eek7:

I just checked every single form in my policy, and there aren't any ages listed period. As far as they're concerned, if you're three years old and manage to have a driver's license, you're covered. Here's the only spot I could find with the number 25 in it:

I "Your covered auto" means:
1. Any "antique vehicle" or "classic vehicle" shown in the Declarations
2. Any "antique vehicle" or "classic vehicle" on the date you became owner during the policy period, provided that it replaces one shown in the Declarations and you ask us to insure it within thirty days after you become the owner. This automatic coverage for replacement vehicles does not apply to Part D - Coverage For Damage To Your Covered Auto. An endorsement must be issued to fully cover any additional vehicles you acquire.

J. "Antique vehicle" means a motor vehicle 25 years or more of age that:
1. Is maintained primarily for use in car club activities, exhibitions, parades, other functions of public interest or for a private collection; and
2. Is used only infrequently for other purposes.

K. "Classic vehicle" means a motor vehicle of unique or rare design and of limited production that is an object of curiosity and:
1. Is maintained primarily for use in car club activities, exhibitions, parades, other functions of public interest or for a private collection; and
2. Is used only infrequently for other purposes.

L. "Regular use vehicle" [NOTE: this is what is not covered] means a motor vehicle which is used for regular driving to work, school, shopping, errands, or for general transportation and is not an "antique vehicle" or "classic vehicle."This is verbatim transcribed off of my own policy, and is countrywide legalese. Occasional drives to and from work are fine as long as they are not regular occurrences, which is exactly how I'll be driving it. Daily drivers are not allowed, however this is the nature of collector car insurance -- if it's driven on a regular basis, it's not really a collector car, it's a normal use auto.

Hopefully this also clears up some misconceptions about what use Hagerty allows.

SoCalDMC12
10-02-2012, 11:52 PM
"Please Enter Your ZIP Code. Your ZIP Code is used to provide you with information specific to your location." :umm:


So... enter your zip code...

Shep
10-03-2012, 12:20 AM
So... enter your zip code...I meant why does it matter what my ZIP code is? If it changes the data, then none of us will be viewing the same statistics. If it doesn't, then why is there no option to ignore the prompt? Not too fond of this site either way.

DMCVegas
10-03-2012, 01:28 PM
I don't know how long ago this took place, but that certainly has not been the case for years. :eek7:

I just checked every single form in my policy, and there aren't any ages listed period. As far as they're concerned, if you're three years old and manage to have a driver's license, you're covered. Here's the only spot I could find with the number 25 in it:

It honestly doesn't matter to me if Hagerty has changed their policies or not, I'll never go with them at all because they soured me with my experience with them so badly. And I'm not saying this simply to win an internet argument at all costs by ignoring any policy changes. Allow me to paint a larger picture for you.

When I first called up, the woman was very pleasant and enthusiastic, until we got to the part regarding my age. This was her, not me. When we got to the part where I would have to prevent myself from even accessing my own car, I was too stunned to say anything really, but state that this statement didn't make any sense. She at that point said something along the lines that it was *I* who chose to buy the car, and that I had to "...accept certain responsibilities..." and just started talking down to me as if I were a child. That pissed me off beyond belief, so I just thanked here said that I would check around to compare policies and prices. She then interrupted me with her closing line and hung up on me.

As you can imagine, I was not happy. BUT after cooling down for a few minutes, I then called Progressive Insurance at that time to see about quotes for instead making my DeLorean a daily driver. I spoke with a very friendly man on the phone, and gave him all of my information. Good credit, no accidents, but the quote was over $2,600 ever 6 months! The phone rep said that didn't sound right, and asked permission to try and run things again to get another quote. He did and the price was the same. He advised me with ideas as to why the quote might have been so high (sports car belonging to someone who had just turned 21 in a 24/7 free liquor town), and then said two things to me: 1. He advised me to please check around, that someone must be able to give me a better rate, and 2. If because this was a unique car and I was at a young age that was affecting the prices, to please check back with them every 6-12 months to see how quickly prices would be coming down. Once you hit 25 or get married (whichever happens first), insurance premiums plummet, and he said that they would really like to have me as a customer. We ended the call, and at the time I ended up going with someone else.

Now let me explain something I've learned about customer service. I can tell when I'm dealing with a person who is just having a bad day, and someone who just outright either isn't good at their job or just plain doesn't care. None of this applies to my interaction with Hagerty, and I'll tell you why. They say that the eyes are a window into the soul. As such so is customer service the window into the soul of a company. Good customer service isn't simply about being nice and giving you a warm feeling. If I wanted a warm feeling, I'd simply piss in my pants and save on the wait times, trust me. Good, truly valuable customer service isn't something that identifies with you, but rather truly has your best interests at heart. Don't try to identify with me, don't try and "speak my language", and above all don't try and make me feel good at any cost. If you can't give me what I want or need, I'm not going to be happy. But I sure as hell will respect you for being honest.

Along these lines, Progressive Insurance was being honest. They straight up said that they would not be the best choice for me, and not only explained why, but offered to help me and gave me a warm welcome to return. Hagerty by contrast was only there to kiss my ass in order to get my money. And when they suddenly realized that they wouldn't be striking a deal with me, treated me like dog shit. Like I say, good customer service is a window into the soul of a company and will tell you how they treat their customers in the long run. Progressive seemed like they really did care, and if I ever had to file a claim sounded like they would work with me. Hagerty on the other hand were just a bunch of douche-nozzles that when things didn't go their way would throw up barriers to make shit as hard for you as possible. How a company trains it's employees to work with customers will tell you how they really feel about their customers. U-Haul's infamous "Dumb Shit Memo" is a prime example of this.

Has Hagerty's policies changed in the 10+ years I've dealt with them? Perhaps they have. But since that same guy still owns the company, I doubt very seriously that their attitude towards customers has actually changed all that much. And it was his attitude that he instilled into his employees that cost me as a customer.

When I one day switch over to specialty insurance, I'll either go with our current insurance provider (State Farm), or Grundy. But to hell with Hagerty.

Morpheus
10-03-2012, 02:24 PM
^ Quite a few of us FL owners have had very good luck with Heacock Insurance. Their policies are reasonably priced, and their mileage restrictions are very liberal. Miles better than Hagerty.

http://www.heacockclassic.com/

cybercusp
10-03-2012, 02:26 PM
I went with Heacock. For me they were cheaper than Hagerty, friendlier, and more responsive. They had a policy issued that day, and I liked the milage I'm allowed.

Shep
10-03-2012, 07:45 PM
It honestly doesn't matter to me if Hagerty has changed their policies or not, I'll never go with them at all because they soured me with my experience with them so badly.So you're holding a decade-long grudge against a company who has very obviously changed vastly since then for something that has not applied in years, in particular against an individual who probably quit years ago? Sorry for being blunt, but that's just stupid. It's been ten years. Times have changed, and there isn't anything about your experience that still holds true. Just because the owner is the same does not automatically mean that the company as a whole is the same. Saying as much is a logical fallacy if I've ever heard one.

Unless you've omitted anything, it was just one phone call over a decade ago. HDTV's didn't exist, nor did Facebook or Twitter, hell even MySpace wasn't around ten years ago. The economy was booming a decade ago. 9/11 and thus the wars in the middle east weren't around a decade ago. Clinton was in office a decade ago. Internal artificial hearts weren't around a decade ago. That DVR in your cable box? That wasn't around a decade ago either. Windows 2000 was the latest Microsoft OS a decade ago. XBox wasn't around a decade ago. For cryin' out loud, World of Warcraft wasn't even around a decade ago! And you honestly expect me to believe this is anything but an unjustified grudge? Back when it happened, it may have been reasonable, but now that it's a decade later and you have not mentioned any other interaction with Hagerty since then it's just ridiculous.

Dangermouse
10-03-2012, 10:29 PM
10 years is nothing.

A coworker of mine claims he hasn't been to the movies since they upped the price to $1 (he's in his 70s)

SoCalDMC12
10-04-2012, 01:24 AM
After 10 years, I'd be inclined to give a company another chance, but they'd have to show me that they've made changes to their practices... earn my business back.

BTW: Just to be clear... 9/11 happened 11 years ago, the first single-tuner cable DVR came out ~2002 (I designed the user interface), President Bush was in office, and the Jarvis heart came out in 1982. :-)

SamHill
10-04-2012, 08:43 AM
Hagerty has been pretty good so far. $427/year for $25K agreed value seems fair.

DMCMW Dave
10-04-2012, 10:45 AM
Hagerty has been pretty good so far. $427/year for $25K agreed value seems fair.

As a vendor, we've obviously done a few claim jobs for their insureds and they have been great to work with, as has State Farm. Geico took a bit more effort but they still covered everything.

Shep
10-04-2012, 10:53 PM
10 years is nothing.

A coworker of mine claims he hasn't been to the movies since they upped the price to $1 (he's in his 70s)Did you tell him this was to coincide with the addition of color and/or sound to movies? :giggle:


Just to be clear... 9/11 happened 11 years ago,
the first single-tuner cable DVR came out ~2002 (I designed the user interface),
President Bush was in office,
and the Jarvis heart came out in 1982. :-)- After the aforementioned phone call, which was my point.
- 2002 is ten years ago, still within range.
- Redacted; you are correct good sir! :)
- I meant the first all-internal artificial heart. Jarvis still requires an external battery pack at all times, but the first self-contained artificial heart that is able to operate on its own for a time without an external battery pack is the AbioCor, which was first used in 2001 (again, after the aforementioned phone call). Life isn't very fun when you have to lug around a heavy battery all the time, and it lasted plenty long enough to allow bathing oneself, something which is complicated mixing electricity and water as the 80's Jarvis requires.


Geico took a bit more effortOut of curiosity, was anyone you did claims work on insured with Progressive, Nationwide, or Allstate?

DMCVegas
10-04-2012, 11:58 PM
So you're holding a decade-long grudge against a company who has very obviously changed vastly since then for something that has not applied in years, in particular against an individual who probably quit years ago? Sorry for being blunt, but that's just stupid. It's been ten years. Times have changed, and there isn't anything about your experience that still holds true. Just because the owner is the same does not automatically mean that the company as a whole is the same. Saying as much is a logical fallacy if I've ever heard one.

I suppose that would be any less stupid, nor no less of an "illogical fallacy" than if I had a positive experience and maintained a blind loyalty without checking up on revised company policies to my own detriment. On average it takes 6 months to gain a new customer, and typically only seconds to lose one. The healing period in order to regain those lost customers is much, much longer and certainly not even a guaranteed thing. The impression that a company leaves upon a customer, be it current or prospective, is a great one that lasts a good long time. My experience with Hagerty was in fact a horrible, and offensive one. As I stated the call to Progressive insurance was a positive one. I never became a customer of theirs then, now, nor have plans to ever become one in the future, but they made such a positive impression upon me that I have continued to recommend the as service provider to others.



Unless you've omitted anything, it was just one phone call over a decade ago.

And that is quite a curious statement to me. The question here I would have to pose to you about your response is this:

Do you have my best interests at heart to try and convince me to give Hagerty a second chance? Or are you trying to attack me and/or my statement in order to defend your own choice to go with them, because my words somehow have posed a threat to the possible accuracy of your own judgement? Just honestly curious.

David T
10-05-2012, 02:51 PM
Each insurance company has it's own rules and policies and they also vary from State to State. Add to that they also change them over time and you can see it is hard to compare directly. I got Hagerty a while back and my rates are much lower than what they are quoting now to new owners and the rules are also a little different. Before buying or renewing you are best served by getting quotes form several insurance companies. Find the one that best suits your situation and how you intend to enjoy your car. Hagerty is among the more popular and they seem to be pretty good at paying out on claims but they are certainly not the only game in town. Stay away from the companies that do not offer classic insurance and/or will not pay out on "Agreed Value". If they "Blue Book" you on a loss you will not be happy! You have to do your homework, you CANNOT just compare what the premium is and let it go at that.
David Teitelbaum

Shep
10-06-2012, 01:36 AM
Do you have my best interests at heart to try and convince me to give Hagerty a second chance?I'm not entirely certain what you mean by this statement. Could you rephrase that please?




Or are you trying to attack me and/or my statement in order to defend your own choice to go with them, because my words somehow have posed a threat to the possible accuracy of your own judgement? Just honestly curious.I don't need to "defend" anything. I know not everyone is going to like my decisions nor agree with them, and I am fine with that. Frankly, I work for a completely different auto insurance company not mentioned yet, and chose to go with Hagerty purely for price and coverage. What bothers me is this statement you made:
I've also always steered people away from [Hagerty] every chance I get.Then in the very next post stated this:
Has Hagerty's policies changed in the 10+ years I've dealt with them?I'm sorry, but when the last time you dealt with a company was more than a couple years prior, and you're still steering people away from them, this is entirely unjustified. It's one thing if you continually deal with them on a regular (or even occasional) basis, but that is not the case here.

DMCMW Dave
10-06-2012, 01:17 PM
Out of curiosity, was anyone you did claims work on insured with Progressive, Nationwide, or Allstate?

Not yet.

I was pleasantly surprised by Geico, I had heard bad things from body shops. I've actually seen body shops with a sign at the front desk saying "No Allstate Claims Honored".

We seen State Farm, Hagerty, and Geico. All worked out fine, Geico was probably slower to pay than the others (took more reminding on our part) but covered everything eventually.

DMCVegas
10-07-2012, 10:18 PM
I'm not entirely certain what you mean by this statement. Could you rephrase that please?

There is no other way that I could possibly rephrase this at all. Re-read it again if you don't understand.



I don't need to "defend" anything...

Then why pray tell have you decided to reinforce your stance so heavily by going after me on this subject? You certainly take exception to both my stance on Hagerty, as well as the reasons behind it. What I want to know is why. Quite frankly I've explained all that I need to, and need no further justification for anything I've said. Hell, I didn't even need to state a single thing in the first place. A bad experience is far different than an insult, and insulted I was. As such I advise people to avoid the same trouble that I did, and also make them aware of that vast number of other choices for classic car insurance that are available to them. What is wrong with that either? Even if someone disagrees with either my principals or experiences, they should be made aware of other alternatives out there.

DMCVegas
10-12-2012, 05:03 PM
And just in case someone comes across this archived thread, here is another owner who has confirmed Hagerty's policies against people under 25.

http://dmctalk.org/showthread.php?5434-Insurance&p=77438&viewfull=1#post77438