Log in

View Full Version : Spare Tire Solution in some New cars



Dangermouse
10-31-2012, 02:40 PM
I am looking after my cow-orkers wife’s 2012 Kia Soul for a few months. It’s parked outside my office window and I noticed that it had a flat tire this morning – looks like a drywall screw in it. Tires are premium :clown: Nexen 195/65 -R15. My plan was to put on the spare and take the original to a repair shop.

Opened the trunk and lifted the carpet and was greeted by this

http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=14458&d=1351704857

WTF – no spare, fullsize or donut. Just a small compressor and a single-use can of what I presume to be tire sealant (by Dunlop no less).

Not even a jack or tire iron. You will note that there is a wheel sized hole in the floor but after looking on their website, there doesn’t even appear to be an available option to buy a spare.

Just underlines what many D owners are doing – jettisoning the spare and carrying a can of Fix-a-Flat

Dracula
10-31-2012, 02:48 PM
It reminds me of the days when cars came with "space-saver" spares and the inflation can. It's getting more and more of a trend that, if the car needs a tire replaced, you'd better call a tow truck. This is most noticeable in the event that, if you get a tear in the side-wall, you can't repair it with a can of fix-a-flat.

Mark D
10-31-2012, 06:11 PM
And the label says you only get 6 miles at max speed of 50mph? That doesn't seem like much.

Chris4099
10-31-2012, 06:49 PM
My last 7 nails/screws in the tire involved me putting the compressor on the tire, pumping it up and driving to the tire shop. They leak so slowly now, I haven't even needed the tire goo yet. Been about 12 years since I actually put a spare on a car. My current daily driver didn't come with a spare either, but with run flats. They were so expensive I just got regular tires when they wore out. No problems since. As long as you keep them properly inflated (all cars now have pressure monitoring systems to alert you if you are running low), the risk of a blowout or sidewall failure are pretty low. No point in lugging around dead weight.

Notifier
10-31-2012, 07:03 PM
And the label says you only get 6 miles at max speed of 50mph? That doesn't seem like much.

That label is confusing, does it mean you can only drive 6 miles on the "fixed" tire or (according to step #5) have to pull over every 6 miles to re-inflate the tire to 32psi? I drove 132 miles today, I would have to stop 22 times on the side of some very narrow roads to check the patch job. THAT'S SAFE! But then I guess it's a good thing every gas station has a repair shop attached to it. Oh, wait... Then it appears that they want you to paste the "Max 80k/hr 50mph" sticker to the center of your steering column as shown in step #4?

I believe the reason why many manufacturers are going to this type of system is to cut down on the overall vehicle weight = better fuel economy.

According to the Dunlop web site, the sealant only has a shelf life of 5 years. I wonder how many dealers told their customers to replace the sealant every 5 years? Looking at the price, it's anywhere from $25-30 to replace the sealant online (dealer probably charges an additional $20). What used to be a 15 minute tire change and quick stop at your nearest automotive place for a plug job or tire replacement; now you blow out a tire and now have to wait for a tow truck, have the car towed to your nearest mechanic (hopefully you're not hours from home), have them replace the tire... Now you're talking several hours and a lot more money for a tire!

StainlessSteelDream
10-31-2012, 07:06 PM
Lotus does it now too; so there's a DeLorean tie-in someplace in there.

http://cars.about.com/od/lotus/ig/2010-Lotus-Evora-photo-gallery/2010-Lotus-Evora-tire-repair-kit.htm

Dangermouse
10-31-2012, 07:59 PM
I recall that the Dunlop can has a use by date of 2017

I think the manual had a much higher range than 6 miles. I'll look at it tomorrow.

Citizen
10-31-2012, 09:05 PM
My 2012 Challenger came with a full size spare. I don't remember ordering it special. Okay, it's not the same as the Michellens I have on the car itself, but still a full size rim.

Thomas

...

Shep
10-31-2012, 10:41 PM
Not even a jack or tire iron. You will note that there is a wheel sized hole in the floor but after looking on their website, there doesn’t even appear to be an available option to buy a spare.If I were you, I'd get a new spare from [insert auto parts/discount tire company here] and put it in the wheel well. It won't be OEM, but surely it gives you more peace of mind than a can of tire sealant. Serious damage to the tire (e.g. a blowout) isn't going to be fixed by a can of tire sealant, and if I recall correctly, sidewall gashes aren't either. If it has a space for a spare, put a spare in there. It's just a matter of finding the right ratio for the speedometer.

Dangermouse
10-31-2012, 11:34 PM
As I said, it's not my car, but if it was, that's exactly what I'd do. Would need to find a way to strap down the jack so it doesn't rattle around.

The wheels are simple 15" steelies so I'd probably just get a full sized spare.

David T
10-31-2012, 11:35 PM
The space-savers used to come with a canister that was inflated to around 200 PSI that you used to fill the space-saver. Now you get the space-saver and you have a compressor. At least the doughnuts (as used in the Delorean) are inflated! I have a kit that they sell in the auto stores. It has some rope looking stuff, glue, and tools to install it. It works and lasts for a long time. Better than the Fix-A-Flat but you need a compressor. As for the spare tire in the Delorean, it is over 30 years old. Some owners have reported that they tried to use it and it didn't last 5 miles before shredding. If you are going to carry the spare you might consider getting a new tire. The original also doesn't hold air unless you remount it using Camel Bead Sealer on the bead.
David Teitelbaum

Shep
11-01-2012, 12:08 AM
Would need to find a way to strap down the jack so it doesn't rattle around.I don't remember what car it was, but one of the cars I or family have owned had the jack secured to the spare tire itself. I know my '95 Oldsmobile Achieva had a bracket in the trunk that the jack and spare tire screwed down into (hole right through the middle of the jack), but I think there was one where the jack was attached directly to the spare somehow. 2010 Ford Focus maybe? Can't find a picture of that particular setup, but I know the 2010 Ford Focus has a doughnut spare.

Dangermouse
11-01-2012, 10:03 AM
And the label says you only get 6 miles at max speed of 50mph? That doesn't seem like much.

OK, now having read the instructions (for the so-called Tire Mobility Kit), that label is a little misleading.

They want you to drive the car for 6 miles to distribute the sealant. Then pull over and check the tire pressure and inflate as necessary.

Then you can drive up to 120 miles on the repaired tire

Oh, and you can’t use this kit below 22F


And don’t forget to attach that sticker to the steering wheel so you don’t drive too fast.:shhh:

Rad Dad
11-01-2012, 10:41 AM
I read a recent article that listed several cars now being sold without a spare tire and no provision for a spare as an accessory. Both Mercedes and Cadillac were among them. I don't know if that means all models or just certain ones. In any event, I guess my 'no spare' DeLorean and Crossfire were ahead of the curve.

Dangermouse
11-01-2012, 11:29 AM
Many of those upmarket cars run on "run-flats", technically negating the need for a spare.

Notifier
11-01-2012, 12:53 PM
And don’t forget to attach that sticker to the steering wheel so you don’t drive too fast.:shhh:

So that really is a sticker!?! My guess is some moron was driving way to fast on his repair and sued the pants off the company after he blew the tire out again. So now they want you to paste that sticker to the wheel so you don't forget and limit their liability.

Dangermouse
11-01-2012, 01:02 PM
Yes it is a sticker, and the manual advises you to stick it somewhere visible where you can see it while driving.

Shep
11-01-2012, 01:53 PM
Many of those upmarket cars run on "run-flats", technically negating the need for a spare.Mercedes and Cadillac among them, I believe.


Yes it is a sticker, and the manual advises you to stick it somewhere visible where you can see it while driving.Wait, it actually does?! I thought you were kidding about that. That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard. I swear, lawsuits these days are getting more and more ridiculous...

Ozzie
11-01-2012, 08:14 PM
When I was researching/shopping for cars in late Summer, I found out that most higher mpg Hyundais and Kias are doing this. Lots of owners are surprised to find this out, as you have, at the wrong time - a co-worker checked his new Sonata when I told him this, and sure enough, just like your picture.

They do sell a compatible donut spare if you look around (from similar but older models), but they won't bundle it in the newer cars, for the near negligible mpg gains and probably minor cost savings.

Spittybug
11-01-2012, 08:43 PM
I have a 2006 Honda Odyssey Touring edition. It is the only one in the line that came with the PAX run flat tire system. What a piece of crap! No ability to opt out at purchase.

At ~18,000 miles the first set were bald. Since they are special sizes, you can't replace them with ANY standard tire. Each PAX tire (made by Michelin and available ONLY via Honda... and not all the dealers have the specialized equipment) costs ~$450 installed.

When this first happened to me I pitched a fit, wrote to the President of Honda America and actually got myself a free replacement set. When I needed the next set less than 20K later, I said screw this and proceeded to replace the PAX system with aftermarket rims to accommodate standard tires. I'm still on that first set of replacement Coopers ~60K later! I bought a spare for the car.

The concept of run flats is fine if they don't cost 4x a normal tire. Add in the fact that being restricted to getting a replacement at only certain Honda dealers and it was FAR less reliable of a situation than de-PAXing as I did.

Dangermouse
11-01-2012, 09:03 PM
Took the car to the local Firestone shop to get the flat repaired and the guy refused to patch it as it was "too near the sidewall". See what you think.....

Luckily for me they had a Firestone tire in my size for only $132. Once again - WTF!

F$&/ker! $132 to fix a flat, effectively.

Took the car to NTB - "yes sir, no problem sir, we can patch that"

Never going to Firestone again!!!

http://img.tapatalk.com/d/12/11/02/asa3aga8.jpg

Shep
11-01-2012, 11:17 PM
Took the car to the local Firestone shop to get the flat repaired and the guy refused to patch it as it was "too near the sidewall". See what you think.....

Luckily for me they had a Firestone tire in my size for only $132. Once again - WTF!

F$&/ker! $132 to fix a flat, effectively.

Took the car to NTB - "yes sir, no problem sir, we can patch that"

Never going to Firestone again!!!And the moral of the story is: never go to a shop that has a vested interest in screwing you out of your money :bang:

Looks like a common deck screw, 2" tops. I know it's a shop owned by a tire company (who inherently want more business for the tire), but that's along the lines of those "worn exhaust bearings" kind of shops. Even if the screw were perfectly horizontal, sticking straight toward the sidewall, I doubt it would reach. :ehh: WTF indeed.

Dangermouse
11-07-2012, 11:05 AM
And the moral of the story is: never go to a shop that has a vested interest in screwing you out of your money :bang:


No, the moral is "Never go to Firestone"

I called in at NTB on my way back from Firestone to confirm it was repairable, but I didn't have a ride that day, so didn't get it fixed.

Discovered that there is a Kaufmann Tires store just around the corner (which I never go past). Took it there yesterday and they fixed it for FREE !!! No issue, no "you'd be better with a new tire, sir"

Awesome.

Byrne H&A
11-07-2012, 04:59 PM
A 145/80/15 / @$ 89.00 from Volks Wagon is as close as I found to replace a dry wall 33 year old OEM tire. NOTE the width of the tire in the well is 1/2" higher than the depth of the well.

Shep
11-07-2012, 07:04 PM
No, the moral is "Never go to Firestone"Exactly. Firestone manufactures tires, and they have a vested interest in selling you their tires rather than repairing any tire (especially one that's not their brand, which also for corporate politics), thus screwing you out of your money.

kings1527
12-14-2012, 03:43 PM
Took the car to the local Firestone shop to get the flat repaired and the guy refused to patch it as it was "too near the sidewall". See what you think.....

Luckily for me they had a Firestone tire in my size for only $132. Once again - WTF!

F$&/ker! $132 to fix a flat, effectively.

Took the car to NTB - "yes sir, no problem sir, we can patch that"

Never going to Firestone again!!!

http://img.tapatalk.com/d/12/11/02/asa3aga8.jpg

That's shady, right there. That screw is nowhere near the sidewall! Glad you got it taken care of for free elsewhere...

Alex
6575