PDA

View Full Version : Amateur DIY auto mechanics, a dying breed



Jonathan
11-01-2012, 10:38 AM
Neat read:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-drive/car-life/why-amateur-do-it-yourself-mechanics-are-a-dying-breed/article4771263/

Likely a little skewed here amongst the DeLorean group. Well, certainly for your "play car," but I can see what he means with your daily driver. I'll dive into just about anything on the DeLorean, but doing the same on the Pontiac G8 worries me a bit.

Maybe time for a poll...

A) I do my own work on all my cars
B) I do my own work on my DeLorean, but not my daily driver
C) I leave auto repairs up to the professionals... and my check book

... or some other options like you do most of the work on your car, but not the real tricky stuff or things needing special tools or a lift?

tyb323
11-01-2012, 11:51 AM
Needs option for "Will do easier things (speedo cable swaps, fuel pump, etc.), leave complicated engine work to professionals" =)

Jonathan
11-01-2012, 11:53 AM
Needs option for "Will do easier things (speedo cable swaps, fuel pump, etc.), leave complicated engine work to professionals" =)

Agreed.

Mod: I see you set the poll up for us, can you make these edits in mid-flight??

Jimmyvonviggle
11-01-2012, 02:28 PM
I've done ;

The otterstat
Fuel pump/sender combo
Alternator
Plugs
Pulled out injectors etc

But for more complicated jobs I will leave it to someone else.


Ironically if it wasn't for the work I did on my D I would never have built up the confidence to redo the brakes on my daily driver.

Chris4099
11-01-2012, 02:48 PM
I like that article. Also, newer cars just don't need as much maintenance these days. My daily driver has been out of warranty for 3 years now. It's only needed a new crank sensor o-ring and oil pan gasket during that time (to fix a minor oil leak). The rest has been simple scheduled maintenance.

I think a lot of people see newer cars and get flustered easily. However, they aren't really that bad. Here's a pic of my car when fixing the oil leak. It looks really bad, but it was basic bolting/unbolting of parts. The how-to guild I used was pretty straight forward.

14464

Basically to get to a few bolts and crank sensor, I had to remove the front end and then put it into "maintenance mode" which allows me to pull the radiator/condenser/fan assembly out several inches to access the front of the engine. No need to drain the coolant or other time consuming work. Lots of clever engineering in cars these days!

Ron
11-01-2012, 04:12 PM
Agreed.

Mod: I see you set the poll up for us, can you make these edits in mid-flight??
NP!

Dracula
11-01-2012, 05:43 PM
What about an option of, "I work on all of my cars BUT the DeLorean." for the rest of us?

If my Cadillacs have an issue, I go for the wrench set. If it's the DeLorean, I reach for my phone and call DMCMW.

stevedmc
11-01-2012, 06:59 PM
I do all of my own work except troubleshoot K-Jet problems.

Dracula
11-01-2012, 07:13 PM
I do all of my own work except troubleshoot K-Jet problems.

I like French Toast because it's got carbs.

Spittybug
11-01-2012, 07:27 PM
Plugs, filters, oil, brakes, basic body work, common electrical, etc.... YES. But as soon as you start getting into "black boxes" or other black arts..... it's gotta go to the pros. (Usually after I at least give it a shot..)

Ozzie
11-01-2012, 07:56 PM
Good poll.

The only reasons that I don't work on my daily driver is because:
a) My daily drivers are typically still under warranty (I will do oil/filter(s), brake pads/bleed, coolant flush, and such, though), and if not...
b) I can afford to work slow, take longer on the D, on a weekend, but I don't have that luxury with the daily driver - it needs to be able to get me to work on Monday morning.

EDIT:
...and maybe a good follow up question to those that do some sort of work on their cars, is: why?
I do it to save money which is probably a common answer, but I find that I also enjoy working on cars, frustrating at times, but very rewarding at the end of a complete project.

jackb
11-01-2012, 10:23 PM
I voted D, but only because I don't do 100%, more like 95%. I know what's beyond my skill level.

I've done everything but the transmission on my truck (gauges, engine accessories, flooring, hvac, wiring, drum->disc brake conversion... ~$5,000 in parts of work, haha) and everything on the Delorean (the biggest things were wiring, exhaust, water pump and radiator)

The rare exceptions have included rebuilding the 4L80E transmission on my truck (although I've removed and installed them before, the rebuilding was too much for me), the timing belt on my Civic (I definitely could've done this, but had just moved so no tools, no garage... and I got a great price for it) and replacing the front wheel bearing on my Civic (I probably could've done that, but maybe not, and it would've been a tremendous PITA compared to dropping it off and getting it knocked out in a hour.

DMCVegas
11-02-2012, 03:02 AM
I don't think that the decline of the DIY mechanic is such a bad thing. There is a distinct difference between simply working on your own car versus actually knowing how to repair it. Most people honestly don't know what they're doing and cause more problems than what they actually fix. Over the years people have commented that American cars have become more reliable. Is that because of better engineering or because idiots have been locked out from tinkering with things under the hood? Any fool can turn a wrench, but it takes understanding and intelligence to know how to interpret readings from your troubleshooting to know how and what exactly to repair. Something that most people do not possess.

Having said that, the average mechanic can still wrench on their car without major hurdles, if any, to overcome.

DMCVegas
11-02-2012, 03:11 AM
Good poll.

...and maybe a good follow up question to those that do some sort of work on their cars, is: why?
I do it to save money which is probably a common answer, but I find that I also enjoy working on cars, frustrating at times, but very rewarding at the end of a complete project.

I work on my own cars for the same reasons, as well as I don't trust most mechanics. I had a differential blow out 2 days after taking it to wal mart for an LOF. I don't blame them for the failure at all. But they obviously didn't check the diff like they said they did. So for me it's piece of mind that the work gets done right. Unless I don't have the tools and somehow have a trusted mechanic to farm the work out to for those jobs, I do it all.

Dangermouse
11-02-2012, 09:46 AM
I voted for 'A' because 'D' didn't exist back then.

I do as much as I can, because I have struggled to find a competent local mechanic. particularly ones that are any good at troubleshooting.

It's so frustrating to book the car into a shop, arrange a ride there and back, and then have them not fix the original problem and always, always, try and up-sell you on some other thing - "Yes sir we can change the brake pads, but your rotors need changed and calipers replaced"; "sir, you should do all 4 brakes it the same time"; "Yes, we found out what was rattling, can you bring it back next week and we can fix it"

Or that doofus yesterday who wanted to sell me a $132 tire rather than simply fix a puncture.

The "friendly" ones with the Customer Lounge and Complimentary Shuttle are the worst. They have all that extra overhead to pay off. I did have a low budget "manuel", but he was too successful and expanded to a new location 10 miles in the wrong direction.

So I am a member of this forum and others and try to do as much as I can after research the "How-To"s. It's cheaper, more satisfying and usually quicker when you consider travel time and inconvenience

Jonathan
11-02-2012, 11:39 AM
Oh, heck ya. The trust factor is a HUGE issue and for sure why I tackle stuff myself.

The DeLorean of course is much harder to find someone you trust on it, if only because you can't assume the guy at the local shop, or GM/Ford dealership has ever worked on one. One way I look at it, is I'll try anything on the D if I can do it on my feet or leaning/laying in the car. I am not comfortable lying under it in my garage, when the best I can ever do is get it 13" off the floor, and that ends up being just a few inches from my nose. Not fun.

The big stuff though, yay, like since I moved to this small town in south western Ontario, I have taken him my fuel accumulator (which was sort of just to test out his services) and then the bigger job after that was a combination of exhaust manifold gasket replacement and CV joint replacement/final drive oil, etc. It went well and if I have other big jobs, it'll go back there. I'm on the fence at the moment whether I take him my front brakes rebuild, or do it myself. I'm leaning towards doing it myself.

I get you on the Wal-Mart/Mr. Lube oil change stories. I was out in Alberta most of the summer and took the Pontiac in for a LOF. Just kids in there, and honestly not looking much different than some sh!t job at McDonald's for some of them. I totally fear their honesty of whether they actually checked the transmission fluid level. They say they did, but how do you know. It's another one of those that you check when running, from below, with your finger poking into the side of the housing after the screw has been removed. The girl doing most of the oil change also checks your air filters. Great. So I get that you don't have my size in stock, so put it back please. But she didn't even make any effort to clean it out a bit, even if it was with a vacuum or whatever, and then she got the cabin filter in crooked. I get driving back 3,400 km to Ontario and get a nice whiff of windshield washer fluid in the cabin every time I use the wipers (as that is right about where the air intake is). Thanks sweetheart, but I'll do it myself next time.

DeLorean03
11-02-2012, 01:02 PM
Back in 2005, a shop that my family had done local business with for 10+ years charged me $600+ for a fuel pump change on my 94 Nissan Truck.

The DeLorean, me doing it, cost about $100.

After that, I never went back to that shop, and the only time I ever trusted a shop after that was after some THOROUGH searching, networking, talking to others around town, and took my truck to a shop in 2008 for replacing my water pump. Other than that, I have done my own work on both my vehicles since 2005 - with 2 exceptions:

1. Aforementioned water pump job on truck
2. Transmission/rear shocks/TABs/oil seal near where transmission and engine mate on DeLorean (Thank you DMCMW!)


Besides, women love a man that works on his own vehicles.

Delorean Industries
11-02-2012, 01:26 PM
There will come a point in this market where parts are no longer sold to the public and if you want your Delorean fixed you will need to go to one of three companies DMC, DPI or Grady. Honestly I am surprised this has not happened yet. It is the next step to sealing the market permanently and perfectly legal. I would have trouble going along with this as I never would say no to money. But slinging parts is a PITA with very small margins these days and I'm more concerned with my staff restoring cars so it will be interesting to see where things go.

You can see the beginning of this happening already:
Engines components are in shop only along with a few other select items with other vendors. The list will steadily grow to the point where owners will be required to send their cars in for repair. Even we are guilty of it at DPI. Windshields, doors, anything engine related minus an exhaust system, clutches and flywheels, brakes and our new frames are in house only.

Nicholas R
11-02-2012, 01:53 PM
I'll do pretty much anything and everything myself. The cost is certainly a factor, as well as the fact that I know the jobs are done correctly (or if they weren't I know whose fault it is). Thus far there are no cars I wont touch. Heck, my dad prefers me to work on his C5 Corvette over anyone else now. The only one I would say is my mother's Lexus, mainly because she still has a warranty on it.

Still, as cars become more and more sophisticated this may change. I wonder if my working on cars will shift from being both a hobby with old cars and as an enjoyable cost savings on newer cars, to just a hobby on old cars. As hybrids, electric cars, etc. all become more prevalent, I really wonder if I'll keep up. Chances are that I wont.

Jonathan
11-02-2012, 03:05 PM
There will come a point in this market where parts are no longer sold to the public and if you want your Delorean fixed you will need to go to one of three companies DMC, DPI or Grady. Honestly I am surprised this has not happened yet. It is the next step to sealing the market permanently and perfectly legal. I would have trouble going along with this as I never would say no to money. But slinging parts is a PITA with very small margins these days and I'm more concerned with my staff restoring cars so it will be interesting to see where things go.

You can see the beginning of this happening already:
Engines components are in shop only along with a few other select items with other vendors. The list will steadily grow to the point where owners will be required to send their cars in for repair. Even we are guilty of it at DPI. Windshields, doors, anything engine related minus an exhaust system, clutches and flywheels, brakes and our new frames are in house only.

I don't really agree with some of this Josh. Now granted, I don't have access to any top secret information or conversations, but I would find it hard to believe what you've said here coming true.

I have bought quite a number of parts from DMCMW (and the DMCH network including Florida and Northwest for a couple odds and ends), and not once was I ever responded to with "well yes, we have that part, but we won't sell it to you unless your car is here in our shop and we install it for you." I understand some parts are NLA, but I was never suspicious that secretly there is indeed a big box of those parts in storage, waiting for you under the right circumstances. I've bought various things for my car from just about every section of the parts manual, and at no time did I think I would get better access to parts if my car was in a DMCH bay.

Part of why I think your theory isn't going to happen is just due to the simple truth that the DMCH network does not stretch far enough in terms of physical distance and coverage. At best I can drive to Midwest in 10+ hours. Another owner here in Ontario is 5+ hours further north than I am. Or what about an owner in Edmonton? And that is just remote parts of Canada. What about owners in Australia? Or the odd guy in Singapore, or even Peurto Rico?

What makes owning these cars attractive to many of us is that they are relatively affordable. If the rule of 25k or 30k became the rule of 125k, I would think very few people would be involved in the hobby. I know there is a finite amount of cars to make money from, and selling those parts with low margins isn't super advantageous, so to make money with this brand, that's likely at least part of the reason why Houston is branching out into things related to the DeLorean, but not solely selling parts and fixing cars.

And just putting this out there, and like I said, I don't know of all the behind closed doors conversations, but I see "DeLorean" as the DMCH network including Houston and the other 5 franchises as one group... and all the other vendors in another group. I don't think there would need to be any conspiracy about monopolies or anything like that or what you mentioned would be legal, as I don't think Stephen and James and the others are necessarily phoning up every vendor they can think of to see if they "would be onboard."

There is obviously a ton of business decision making and marketing to go into what might shape the future, but I seriously doubt it is going to turn into a "parts for sale by privledge" only situation. That would just mean a lot of people enjoying their cars right now likely wouldn't be able to afford to going forward. Isn't all of that more or less what DeLorean One was all about? I don't think anyone in the DeLorean community would want to see that repeat itself.

Dracula
11-02-2012, 03:06 PM
Still, as cars become more and more sophisticated this may change. I wonder if my working on cars will shift from being both a hobby with old cars and as an enjoyable cost savings on newer cars, to just a hobby on old cars. As hybrids, electric cars, etc. all become more prevalent, I really wonder if I'll keep up. Chances are that I wont.

This is the problem I have with cars today. I can't do anything with the computer systems; troubleshooting them is near-impossible when all you get is a "Check Engine" light and have no means to read it.

Otherwise, I prefer to stockpile parts for cars that I own and are no longer made. Eventually, I'm going to need a barn full of categorized Cadillac parts just to keep them on the road. One such example is a piece called the "Climate Control Programmer" and it's used to run the fan speeds, temperature sensor, and HVAC system. Unfortunately, this part was only used from 1971 through 1973 in the form I need. Now I'm looking for someone who can rebuild my old one to use as a spare.

Even with parts like this that are long obsolete, it's still easy to diagnose and repair the cars so long as there are no computer systems that would prevent the car from running due to a bad chip or something similar. I'll keep these cars on the road for years to come, as parts stockpiling may become necessary, but it's a great art form.

Chris4099
11-02-2012, 03:48 PM
This is the problem I have with cars today. I can't do anything with the computer systems; troubleshooting them is near-impossible when all you get is a "Check Engine" light and have no means to read it.

I find it to be exactly the opposite. You just need an ODBII scanner. Less then $60 these days (or rent for free at Autozone). As cars evolve, so do the tools used and the ODBII is nothing new now (been standard on all new cars for the last 15 years). Granted if the computer throws an error code, you still need to have some skills to troubleshoot. Since the dawn of cars, knowledge of some sort is needed to repair them. As time goes on new knowledge is required, but that's all. Nothing else is preventing you from working on newer cars.

stevedmc
11-02-2012, 04:02 PM
There will come a point in this market where parts are no longer sold to the public and if you want your Delorean fixed you will need to go to one of three companies DMC, DPI or Grady.

Steve Rice gets a lot of his parts at AutoZone. But he will admit, that it sure is nice to be able to call up a vendor for Delorean specific parts such as angle drives and dust caps.

I'm planning to install a new lower steering column in my car, maybe even this weekend. I didn't get it from a Delorean vendor. I believe in learning to survive on my own because frankly, one day there may not be any vendors around at all.


Edit: I'm in no way attacking Josh. I met him a few weeks ago and think he is a really cool guy. Honestly, a lot of my do it yourself survival is simply because I can't afford to pay someone else to do the work. If I had the money, my car would probably be in Josh's shop for a frame off restoration.

Victor
11-02-2012, 04:53 PM
Good poll.

The only reasons that I don't work on my daily driver is because:
a) My daily drivers are typically still under warranty (I will do oil/filter(s), brake pads/bleed, coolant flush, and such, though), and if not...
b) I can afford to work slow, take longer on the D, on a weekend, but I don't have that luxury with the daily driver - it needs to be able to get me to work on Monday morning.

EDIT:
...and maybe a good follow up question to those that do some sort of work on their cars, is: why?
I do it to save money which is probably a common answer, but I find that I also enjoy working on cars, frustrating at times, but very rewarding at the end of a complete project.

I am very much like that too. And I totally agree, It's very rewarding to complete a project _ even the simpliest one.
Also, I find very few good mechanics around. I personnaly have to travel quite a long way to go to the several ones that are competents _ and honest too (that's another thing you have to be on the lookout for - honesty.

Shep
11-02-2012, 04:55 PM
I have bought quite a number of parts from DMCMW (and the DMCH network including Florida and Northwest for a couple odds and ends), and not once was I ever responded to with "well yes, we have that part, but we won't sell it to you unless your car is here in our shop and we install it for you." [...] I've bought various things for my car from just about every section of the parts manual, and at no time did I think I would get better access to parts if my car was in a DMCH bay.Stage II and III upgrade kits (http://dmctalk.org/showthread.php?4962-Engine-upgrades-cost&p=70482&viewfull=1#post70482)?


This is the problem I have with cars today. I can't do anything with the computer systems; troubleshooting them is near-impossible when all you get is a "Check Engine" light and have no means to read it.I know this isn't true for most makes, but at least with my '01 Civic, all you need to read the code is a paperclip, jumpering two of the OBDII pins together, and the Check Engine Light, Transmission Light, and SRS light all blink long and short patters that are easily deciphered into a trouble code. Twice when I did this, it was just the gas cap not being closed all the way, saving me from making a trip to AutoZone. Our '93 Jag (pre-OBDII) lworks by setting the key, pressing a button, and the odometer will read out the error code, for example "FUEL FAIL 13". Some newer cars (e.g. 2010 Ford Focus) can display the trouble code on the radio or the instrument cluster in a similar manner, with more verbage and a less-limited set of characters. That being said, there are some cars (e.g. 2002 Ford Explorer) that I have yet to learn of an "easy" way to get trouble codes. Usually though, this is due entirely to the fact that the Check Engine Light never comes on, so there's no need to figure out how to read it.

Google around for your car, there may be something similar.

stevedmc
11-02-2012, 04:58 PM
I know a lot of things are available. My assessment was based off of what will happen when the NOS door eventually slams shut. A lot more will become difficult.

Yeah. Thats gonna suck when some of the NOS parts are no longer available.

Delorean Industries
11-02-2012, 05:21 PM
Yeah. Thats gonna suck when some of the NOS parts are no longer available.

It should be interesting.

Kenny_Z
11-02-2012, 10:48 PM
I work on all my cars. Old, new, Delorean. A car is a car. It's a hunk of metal that makes explosions to turn some gears to turn rubber tires. I've jumpered a check engine light with a paperclip. I've rebuilt almost everything except a transmission. A couple of weeks ago I used the rubber ball from a paddle ball game to plug a leaky freeze plug so I could get my Monte 30 miles home at 3am. It worked better than I expected. I didn't get above normal operating temps all the way home. Well, until the ball dislodged when I pulled in my terribly bumpy dirt road driveway.

That being said, if I was rich I'd still work on my own cars. I'd probably do even more work since I'd have a dream garage with all sorts of toys. It's my way to relax and destress. Yes...throwing tools, yelling, and cussing at the cars destresses me.

I was sorry to hear that DPI stopped selling engine upgrade components. Not that I was planning to upgrade Red's engine anytime soon but I liked knowing that the option was there. I understand the parts business isn't a money maker but there are some of us that work on these cars because that's our hobby. I don't want a crate engine, I want to get dirty and build my own. I don't want someone else to rebuild Red's suspension, I will be doing that.

You know those guys that go to car shows with their chests puffed out with some Camaro or Mustang they had a shop build? I ignore them. Yeah, the craftsmanship on the car is to be admired but it's just a car at that point. A trophy to stare at. I want to see the car that a person loves enough to turn their own wrenches on. Yeah, she's not perfect but she's got the personality that only a true gearhead can give her. They can tell you every little thing wrong on that car. Even if you can't see the door ding they can and they will point it out. That's true love.

Shep
11-02-2012, 11:54 PM
Even if you can't see the door ding they can and they will point it out. That's true love.I've gotta remember that quote next time I say that those pants really do make her ass look big :biggrin:

Jonathan
11-03-2012, 01:05 AM
I don't really agree with some of this Josh...

Holy moly!! I didn't start all of that chaos, did I? That definitely was not my intention.

I do prefer the omelette guy over the French toast though. Load me up on mushrooms, ham, jalapeƱos and lots of cheese and we're good till lunch for sure.

AugustneverEnds
11-03-2012, 10:45 AM
I work on the DeLorean, my 1988 BMW 325is and most of the work on a 2004 Chevy Silverado. Either because of my kind-hearted nature :hysterical: or sheer stupidity (depends on which day you ask) I also find I spend a lot of my spare time doing preventative maitenance on my sister's '06 Nissan Altima, my mother's '06 Jeep Libery and a relative's 1989 Jaguar XJ6 (the realm of Lucas, Prince of Darkness). AdvanceAuto is one of my best friends as they will scan the OBDII on the newer cars for free. For the Bimmer, the BMW CCA has the answers and obviously for the DeLorean I have the best resource, this very forum and everyone on it. Thanks all :rock_on: