View Full Version : Cell phone use by driver
Bitsyncmaster
11-18-2012, 05:43 PM
I'm a firm believer that the driver should never be using a cell phone hands free or not. Sure I have answered a cell call while driving but was it something that had to be done? No.
My bet it that the distraction has caused 30% more accidents.
Another thread suggested that if the driver lost cell service it would cause an accident because the driver would be looking why his cell phone stopped. Just proves my point.
Ozzie
11-18-2012, 06:00 PM
IMHO...this is not always a clear black and white issue.
There are some people that cannot drive and have a phone conversation at the same time, period.
Then again, a dramatic live event phone call to a driver, could distract even the best driver.
I generally do not make calls from a car, but will take them. However, that's all changed with my new car that has cellular phone Bluetooth features. I can make calls ("call home") and take calls (through car speakers) w/o ever having to take my eyes from the road or having to touch my phone.
Texting on the other hand, is what I think is the most dangerous thing to do with a cell phone, while driving - and I see people do it all the time.
Michael
11-18-2012, 06:04 PM
What's the difference... Talking on a phone or eating a cheeseburger and talking your passenger?
Bitsyncmaster
11-18-2012, 06:38 PM
Good points. Even changing the radio station is a distraction but the chatting on the phone for hours is just to much distraction. I really don't think the wife calling to pickup some milk on the way home is the problem but where do we set the line?
Jonathan
11-18-2012, 09:00 PM
Here is Ontario's law already making this illegal:
http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/distracted-driving/index.shtml
And here is a Public Service Announcement from the UK on the subject of distracted driving:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SC3x7K3EOTk
And here is the court's decision on the accident that killed a highschool friend of mine:
http://www.owensoundsuntimes.com/2009/02/25/woman-guilty-in-driving-death
Her husband, another friend of mine, lived, as did their child. Now with no mother. The community created a "Run 4 Youth" in her memory:
http://www.westgreypolice.ca/node/170
http://www.thepost.on.ca/2012/08/08/run-4-youth-takes-off-saturday-morning
I get that everyone is entitled to an opinion on various things in life. This is not one of them. Research says it is as dangerous or even more dangerous than driving while drunk. Eventually all governments will change their laws to reflect this just as they did with drinking and driving. They have not done it yet as some of them don't have the balls to stand up for themselves and the people that they serve. If someone thinks they have some magical gift no one else has that makes them a better driver and one capable of driving while texting or distracted, then they need to get their head out out of their ass. This is not debatable nor is it infringing on your right if you are told to put the phone down. You need to understand you're putting other's lives at risk with your selfish, entitled behaviour. This is why the governments need to have the courage to make a stand. Pass the law, yes, but a $100 fine isn't going to deter anyone. And that is what I see here in Ontario where people on their phones is happening at every corner. Make the fines as severe as the drinking and driving ones. $5,000 for your first offence, $25,0000 and 30 days in jail for your second, and so on.
Ultimately every single one of you will know some one up close and personal that has been killed from a distracted driver if this doesn't change immediately.
Kenny_Z
11-19-2012, 12:57 AM
I hate driving while on the phone. My family just doesn't understand that. Once I had to drive the Mustang home in a horrible storm. She's not a storm friendly car. In fact it's terrifying driving that car in the rain. I told my family this and told them I was going to be taking slow back roads and not to call me, I'd call them when I got home. So what do they do? Called me. Constantly. I finally had enough of my phone so I pulled off the side of the road and yelled at them. I then yanked out the battery and threw the phone in the back seat. In hindsight I should have done that in the beginning.
john 05141
11-19-2012, 05:15 AM
I drive a company car, and I cross the European highways frequently. I do have a very good handsfree system in the car, but guess what, I managed to wrongly take the GPS' instruction while on the phone, that is how distracting that is.
But I realy hate it when I see people driving with the call phone in their hands. It is now a penalty of 100€. I do not understand why they do not gave a higher penalies for driving witha cell phone. 500e and /or alternative penalies. Texting is actally even more dangerous. I do not read any text mesages while driving at all!! (only when standing still at the next traffic light) and I even think that is not a good idea.
Not too many Deloreans with hand free kits on board and you have no airbags!!!! think about that.
Jan
thirdmanj
11-19-2012, 07:03 AM
It dangerous either way. Hands free, or not, it makes no difference because your attention to driving has been compromised. It's the same as if you were engaged in a conversation with a passenger, you still wouldn't be paying full attention to the road. Now some people are better at splitting their attention than others, but it doesn't change the fact that their attention is still diverted. Outlawing it wouldn't really solve the problem, just give the authorities one more reason to pull you over, and try to ticket you. It's kinda like helmet laws, it should be common sense to wear one, but alas, many legislatures determined that was not the case. It'd be nice if no one used their phones while driving, but it's a futile battle, it's just too prolific. As a matter of fact a good friend of mines colleague was piled into by a texter-driver yesterday, and severed at the waist. Of the two, texting and driving is far worse than talking and driving.
Bitsyncmaster
11-19-2012, 07:10 AM
What is going to happen is there will be a record of your cell phone use (time, location, duration, who you contacted) and they will use that info in civil law suits. But if you kill someone, that's something you have to live with the rest of your life. It's just not worth the risk.
thirdmanj
11-19-2012, 07:15 AM
What is going to happen is there will be a record of your cell phone use (time, location, duration, who you contacted) and they will use that info in civil law suits. But if you kill someone, that's something you have to live with the rest of your life. It's just not worth the risk.
It's possible, but that'll open up a huge can of worms concerning civil liberties. The "Big Brother" aspect of that scenario is kinda scary. But any more on this tangent and its going to get political... I agree though Dave, it's just not worth it.
Dangermouse
11-19-2012, 09:59 AM
Two things should never, ever be done in a moving vehicle - texting and having sex. Neither will end well.
I have an aftermarket Jabra BT hands-free device in my car, that I will only use when it is safe to do so. I won't make calls, and usually only take them from close family members. To a certain extent, it is no different to talking with a passenger, but the big difference is that a passenger can see when traffic is busy (or weather is bad) and you are paying close attention and will (hopefully) stop talking. The guy on the other end of the phone doesn't see that.
However, like all aspects of driving, only experience (and to a lesser extent - age) can tell you when it is "safe to do so". Which is why many teenagers (the prime texting demographic) text and drive as they feel immortal and have been brought up to be competent multi-taskers in every scenario. If they can do homework, be on facebook, watch a movie and chat, all simultaneously, then why not text and drive a 2 ton machine at the same time. Those "LOL's won't write themselves.
Every part of driving a car is a risk assessment. You are constantly playing the odds. Is it safer to take that call or drive at 80mph? It all depends on the external scenario. Georgia has a phone law that is slanted towards the inexperienced, but is probably the thin edge of the wedge (No texting by anyone, and no phone usage by the under 18s, including hands-free)
The other thing many people fail to realize, in the car or in the house, is that just because the phone rings, you don't have to answer it!
Spittybug
11-19-2012, 10:36 AM
I'm going to agree and disagree.
I agree wholeheartedly about hand held phones, texting and being otherwise distracted. Having to manually dial the phone, hold it, get "Italian" with the other hand (ever watch people with phone in one hand and the other one coming off the wheel to gesture as they speak?) is simply a recipe for disaster.
Receiving calls or making them via hands free is however safe for the majority of people. It's no more of a distraction than speaking to your passenger (without the need to look at them either), having unruly kids in the backseat, eating, etc. There are TONS of bad habits that take away a driver's attention - I've seen people shaving, putting on make up, even reading the paper spread across the steering wheel! In most cases, people are able to "split" their attention between the rigors of safely driving and the cerebral aspect of conversing.
As an example; I have a friend that is an air traffic controller. Mellow guy. I was driving around with several of his family members in a car going to dinner in Norman, OK. The radio was on and there were at least 3 distinct conversations going on in the car, with most people involved in more than one. As apassenger, Iwas uncomfortable with all the distraction and wanted shut everyone up! NONE of them was the least bit flustered or distracted. My friend was doing the driving and I can honestly say that he didn't miss a beat while holding multiple conversations and the radio playing, never mind it being night and busy roads. Crazy. I think it's all a function of what your brain is comfortable with. Me, if I need extra focus (finding someplace or navigating a lot of road signs or parking space hunting) I have to turn off the radio and concentrate. Then again, knock on wood, I've never had a car accident in 34 years of driving either.
What is going to happen is there will be a record of your cell phone use (time, location, duration, who you contacted) and they will use that info in civil law suits. But if you kill someone, that's something you have to live with the rest of your life. It's just not worth the risk.
It's already common practice. I know of at least five guys in our relatively small Fire & Rescue department who have seen it in court when testifying in serious injury cases -- Simply a matter of printing off what is already recorded.
Jonathan
11-19-2012, 11:42 AM
Which is why many teenagers (the prime texting demographic) text and drive as they feel immortal and have been brought up to be competent multi-taskers in every scenario. If they can do homework, be on facebook, watch a movie and chat, all simultaneously, then why not text and drive a 2 ton machine at the same time. Those "LOL's won't write themselves.
And one other very important reason why young people feel immortal, take dangerous risks, etc. is that their brains have not fully developed yet. Many people don't realize this. You ever wonder why so many X-sports and otherwise crazy stunts are tried by teenagers and young adults? They haven't necessarily had their brains develop enough to give them this reasoning to make the better decision. Very much applicable to this invincible feeling of texting when driving. Unfortunately, instead of just killing themselves like they would if they were jumping of the roof of the house to do a cannon ball into the swimming pool and it didn't go well, they wipe out your neighbor and her family with their out of control sedan.
http://www.education.com/magazine/article/Middle_School_Brain_Development/
The other thing many people fail to realize, in the car or in the house, is that just because the phone rings, you don't have to answer it!
Whoo hoo!! Hallelujah!! Someone else that gets it!!!! Yee haw!!! You're right, don't answer it! It was not that long ago that cell phones weren't in the pockets of every single person up and down the street. If you are running out, doing some errands, going to the mall or the bank, and you'll be back in an hour... I'LL TALK TO YOU THEN!! lol Man, I don't get how people want to be bothered when they are walking through the mall, or my favorite is at dinner. I remember sitting down in a booth at a restaurant and beside me were four young people. Likely two couples. I looked over and all four were thumbing away on their phones... AND NOT TALKING TO EACH OTHER!!! Nice going. Who on your phone is possibly more important than the person who made the effort to be sitting with you IN THE FLESH?? My Dad had a rule years ago at his business... no one on the phone is more important than someone standing in person at your register with cash in his hands. The phone can wait. Somewhat similar to this discussion. Enjoy/concentrate the moment you are in. Many people think multi-tasking is a good thing, when in effect, it is just a good way at doing neither thing well.
Hahahah... now, if you don't mind, I need to go find my walker so I can go yell at the kids to get off my lawn!!! lol
thirdmanj
11-19-2012, 01:43 PM
Hahahah... now, if you don't mind, I need to go find my walker so I can go yell at the kids to get off my lawn!!! lol
Chad? Is that you, Chad?! :lol:
stevedmc
11-19-2012, 03:02 PM
Steve Rice usually drives better when he is texting.
Dangermouse
11-19-2012, 03:57 PM
Two things should never, ever be done in a moving vehicle - texting and having sex. Neither will end well.
Let me add a third thing, one that you wouldn't think needed to be spelled out.
http://keysnews.com/node/21349
"Florida Highway Patrol troopers say a two-vehicle crash Tuesday at Mile Marker 21 on Cudjoe Key was caused by a 37-year-old woman driver who was shaving her bikini area while her ex-husband took the wheel from the passenger seat".
DMCMW Dave
11-19-2012, 05:23 PM
"Florida Highway Patrol troopers say a two-vehicle crash Tuesday at Mile Marker 21 on Cudjoe Key was caused by a 37-year-old woman driver who was shaving her bikini area while her ex-husband took the wheel from the passenger seat".
Probablyt lucky it wasn't the other way around. . .
OverlandMan
11-19-2012, 06:28 PM
This poll needs a 4th option - "Mobile device usage while operating a motor vehicle should be/remain legal"
As much as I hate texting and driving, I hate big brother laws even more. I think we're on the edge of going political...
DeLorean03
11-19-2012, 08:53 PM
I would be VERY interested to see the texting while driving resulting in a wreck statistics for both young and older drivers. Since younger drivers get slaughtered by insurance companies due to simply their age, I would love to see how the statistics play out for texting between the two demographics. Bet you it's darn close.
DeLorean03
11-19-2012, 08:53 PM
Probablyt lucky it wasn't the other way around. . .
*trying so hard to not lol in real life*
I can honestly count the number of times I have talked on the cell phone while driving on one hand. Four times. I always made it a practice that whenever someone gave me a call, I would pull into a parking lot and call them back, then continue driving when I was done with the conversation. I had heard horror story after horror story of drivers talking on their cell phone, having a near-fatal accident, and winding up with permanent brain damage because of it, so I made it a point to never answer while moving. Unfortunately, four times I had to answer the phone, and each time I could barely focus. The first time I missed two turns in a row with GPS barking at me to turn. The other three times I was on straightaways, but I honestly have no idea how the hell anyone can drive and talk at the same time. Passengers are one thing, but they have the traffic to keep them occupied, and generally are making small talk, not "talking with a mission". When someone calls me, and will not quit, they always call to find or share some particular information, or to tell me to do something. There is a "mission" to their call.
The problem with this is that you have to focus on this "mission" because it involves you, otherwise they wouldn't have called you. With a passenger, you can usually just "nod and agree", paying attention only when you need to, and for the most part not absorbing any information. Sometimes they ask you questions, but usually it's just small talk that you don't have to focus your entire mind on. Case in point: when I drove my grandmother around town, she would ask "why don't we go to the drive-thru?" It's a simple question that doesn't need much thought. Someone on the phone might tell me "I'm going to get groceries, so I'll be home around 6:00, so-and-so has rehearsal tonight, so they'll leave at 7:00, you need to do this and that by 6:30, what time can you get home?" That takes a ton of thought. I have to process all of that information, then figure out what the correct answer is and say it.
I honestly feel that all cell phone use while driving should be outlawed period. I have seen my fair share of drivers, some of which are middle aged, who use the cell phone on one hand, making a left turn with the other, or who run red lights, or who don't go on green, or who make sudden lane changes and nearly crash into other drivers (myself on occasion), or who drive erratically, who drift in and out of their lane (often into oncoming traffic, at which point I start driving on the shoulder and stay back so I fare better if they get reamed -- it's honestly scary how often this happens, and how many close calls there are), or who don't realize other drivers ahead are stopping and slam on the brakes, or who suddenly slam on their brakes because they realized at the last second that they need to make that turn. It is shocking just how much bad driving people can get away with, and I'll be perfectly honest, if someone had an accident for every time they did any this, our highways would be littered with the mashed-up bodies of cars galore.
Let me add a third thing, one that you wouldn't think needed to be spelled out.
http://keysnews.com/node/21349
"Florida Highway Patrol troopers say a two-vehicle crash Tuesday at Mile Marker 21 on Cudjoe Key was caused by a 37-year-old woman driver who was shaving her bikini area while her ex-husband took the wheel from the passenger seat". Key word: ex-husband. Who in their right mind a) shaves while driving, but more importantly, b) would put their life in the hands of someone they divorced?! Talk about a double dose of stupid.
Jonathan
11-19-2012, 11:54 PM
Probablyt lucky it wasn't the other way around. . .
Daveeeeee.... hehehe....... did you mean:
a) switch who was driving?
b) switch who was shaving?
or... c) switch who was doing the shaving?
LOL, sounds like whatever these two were doing it should have been in a hotel room... or the lobby of the divorce lawyer's office...
Bitsyncmaster
11-20-2012, 05:43 AM
What drives me nuts are the people on the cell phone and their speed keeps changing from 40 MPH.....45.....50....45....40..... all the time swerving all over the road lane.
Mike C.
11-20-2012, 09:17 AM
Texting should be illegal, because it requires eyes to be off the road.
Cell phone usage: some people can do it, some people cant. I think hands free is the way to go.
Morpheus
11-20-2012, 12:03 PM
After enjoying a car with Bluetooth functionality, I can honestly say that taking calls while driving isn't a big deal in my case. I don't typically MAKE calls while driving, voice activated dial or not. Texting is just asking for trouble.
I must say though, it sucks to be listening to a great song and it's interrupted mid-guitar solo by a call. :rolleyes1:
Jonathan
11-20-2012, 12:13 PM
I must say though, it sucks to be listening to a great song and it's interrupted mid-guitar solo by a call. :rolleyes1:
Man, there are some funny ones on YouTube along these lines...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zyXSDIgY9aA&feature=related
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.