View Full Version : Why Land Rovers are a piece of crap!
DMC3165
02-06-2013, 09:27 PM
So my other British car happens to be a 2008 Land Rover LR2 my wife drives. Five years ago we bought it new because I wanted to do something nice for her. When the lease was up she wanted to buy it because she liked the car so much. I was hesitant because they have the worst reputation for reliability. Not really in a position to get a new one or buy something else I decided to do it. Half way through paying it off and this car has gone through 3 deffective rearends to the tune of $5300. a piece. In two of the three instances the delaer split the cost with Land Rover corporate and we didn't have to pay after arguing with them like crazy. Except for the last time we were forced to cover half after the warranty ran out and we went through three months of arguing with them AGAIN because they already had replaced it twice under a year and a half before. Everytime this thing needs brakes its a $2000 brake job. As of now the car has just under 60,000 miles on it and is laid up again in my garage for the DUMBEST of reasons.
Yesterday my wife called and said the car was overheating. She stopped in a gas staton and found coolant leaking under the car. Being just a few miles from home I told her get a gallon of antifreeze pour it in and drive it home instead of paying a $400 tow. She did and made it home no problem. When she got home I discovered a small coolant hose from the head to the engine oil cooler had burst. It's in a bad spot just under the intake manifold but reachable. No big deal right. Wrong. Turns out to be a preformed hose in the shape of a "Z" that is permanently attached to a plastic fitting that goes inside the head. Naturally only the dealer has it. Except the dealer dosen't stock it. It's a three day back order, For a FU***** HOSE! Not as if we are talking about an electrical component or a engine part that is Land Rover specific. Nope just a hose that is Land Rover specific. If this was any other car it'd cost me three bucks in an auto parts store and it be back on the road. Nope not this thing. Just another shining example of why not to buy a Land Rover. A $32. part that will take you three days to get and lets hope its the right one. If not it'll be a week before i get this stupid thing back together. What a piece of crap!
pezzonovante88
02-06-2013, 10:09 PM
You did the right thing at the beginning by LEASING it. The wrong thing was to buy it, as you've found out by now. Land Rovers are beautiful, great vehicles in many ways, but when it comes to reliability, maintenance, maintenance frequency, and cost of ownership, they are about as bad as it gets. Did the dealer offer you a free/cheap loaner/rental unit while you wait for the part to arrive?
Rich W
02-07-2013, 02:08 PM
I knew Vintage Land Rovers are a challenge to work on, but I did not know the late model Land Rovers were a handful as well.
Attaching a few photos of the latest project I have been towing around, from place to place, to get it into a safe, running condition.
My sister and her boyfriend bought this late last year and it needed just about everything replaced on both axles, since it appeared
that one of the previous owners had attempted to "forge rivers and streams" with it and left a lot of water in the brakes, axles, etc.
Its a 1975 Land Rover (short wheel base) with a rare "clamshell" aluminum bed cap and a custom built roof rack. As Land Rover guys
know, this model has all aluminum exterior panels, but it still weighs over two tons. Oh yeah, and its Right Hand Drive with a 4 speed.
Its taken a while to get used to it, but I think I am starting to get the hang of shifting a RHD vehicle while driving on the "wrong side"
of the road. Brings back memories of driving my old girl friends Suzuki Samauri (a really short wheel-base) back in my college years.
Attaching a few reference photos (how its been seeing most of its recent miles) on one of my open flatbed trailers.
16385
16386
Luckily, most of the vintage Land Rover parts have been available, although some are not cheap. Lots of new parts on it now.
Later,
Rich W.
DMC3165
02-08-2013, 04:26 AM
This was the part I was waiting for. One of the most idiotic things I've ever seen. Thought it would take me 5 minutes to put it in. It took 3 hours just to figure out the plastic end needed an o ring and a plastic sleeve to guide it in place. Not fun. But at least its back together for now.
Nice truck Rich! I like the old Land Rovers they are really cool. I met a guy at a car show last year that had a late 60's or early 70's model fully restored and it was bad ass to say the least! Very similar model to the one in your pics.
DMC3165
02-08-2013, 04:31 AM
You did the right thing at the beginning by LEASING it. The wrong thing was to buy it, as you've found out by now. Land Rovers are beautiful, great vehicles in many ways, but when it comes to reliability, maintenance, maintenance frequency, and cost of ownership, they are about as bad as it gets. Did the dealer offer you a free/cheap loaner/rental unit while you wait for the part to arrive?
NO they didn't. When the warranty was still in effect they would give us loaners all the time. Nice cars too, Jags and LR4's one time we even got a Range Rover sport!. But unfortunately nowadays we just have to wait until the part arrives.
Rich W
02-08-2013, 02:23 PM
Nice truck Rich! I like the old Land Rovers they are really cool. I met a guy at a car show last year that had a late 60's or early 70's model fully restored and it was bad ass to say the least! Very similar model to the one in your pics.
Growing up in the 60's and 70's, the primary interest in the Land Rover came from watching Wild Kingdom with Marlin Perkins and Jim Powers.
Attaching a couple photos of vintage Land Rovers on the Plains of Africa. The Wild Kingdom TV Show was on every weekend in those days.
16408
16409
Later,
Rich W.
Tamir A.
02-08-2013, 02:59 PM
Chris - I sympathize with you buddy. My GF has a 2003 Range Rover HSE. Beautiful freaking car, but damn have I had to help her out with a crazy amount of problems. The automatic steering wheel goes on the fritz a ton of times, making it scary to drive since it gets locked in place in the lowest position. Finally got that fixed with some junk yard parts. Lots of coolant issues since for some damn reason they decided to utilize a ridiculous amount of plastic parts in the engine bay, and like your hose issue, most of them need to be replaced if you replace one plastic component. But at the end of the day, she loves the car, has over 90K miles on it and doesn't mind paying the high costs to maintain.
Rich - That is an awesome Land Rover! Those are big out here in Cali, and I think they are pretty cool. And I feel like they would be the proper Zombie Apocalypse car to be in if the shit hits the fan.
T.
Dangermouse
02-08-2013, 03:32 PM
Growing up in the 60's and 70's, the primary interest in the Land Rover came from watching Wild Kingdom with Marlin Perkins and Jim Powers.
Attaching a couple photos of vintage Land Rovers on the Plains of Africa. The Wild Kingdom TV Show was on every weekend in those days.
.
Growing up in the 70's and 80's, the primary interest in the Land Rover came from listening for them approaching and recognizing the tail lights.
Attaching a photo of vintage Land Rovers on the Plains of Belfast. The Wild Kingdom was relived every weekend in those days.
http://www.scuzi.eclipse.co.uk/tangi/2.jpg
Jacko
02-08-2013, 03:36 PM
This was the part I was waiting for. One of the most idiotic things I've ever seen. Thought it would take me 5 minutes to put it in. It took 3 hours just to figure out the plastic end needed an o ring and a plastic sleeve to guide it in place. Not fun. But at least its back together for now.
Nice truck Rich! I like the old Land Rovers they are really cool. I met a guy at a car show last year that had a late 60's or early 70's model fully restored and it was bad ass to say the least! Very similar model to the one in your pics.... Talk about a weird hose ... this one is from my '96 Jaguar XJS and it has six different hoses made in one piece and cost $126.00. There is another hose on the car that is affectionately referred to as the 'bastard hose' and this ain't it! Must be an english thing. 16410 :screwy:
Rich W
02-08-2013, 04:18 PM
http://www.scuzi.eclipse.co.uk/tangi/2.jpg
The above model looks much closer to be ready for the Zombie Apocalypse or the next Road Warrior movie.
DMC3165
02-08-2013, 06:00 PM
Well as it turns out we have a bigger problem. After installing the hose and refilling the cooloing system The car started blowing smoke which smelled an awful lot like antifreeze. In addition it would not build any temperature and we could almost watch the coolant level drop in the expansion tank as it burned it off. The Long and the short of it we're Fu****! Called the dealer and they said a head gasket job by itself without incidentals would run about $3K. so tack on another grand to that. If it's a warped head or a cracked block they are numbers that are so far over my head I can't even think about it.
Fortunately My younger brother is an A-Tech for Mazda. He does this kind of stuff on a daily basis. So he'll be coming over for dinner later and then we'll go outside and see what we're dealing with. Providing we're not buried under 10 feet of snow here. So neddless to say we won't be using the rover anytime soon. Oh well pics and updates to follow!
ramblinmike
02-08-2013, 10:31 PM
As a result of this thread I'm going to go outside and kiss my corolla.
bikergurl2000
02-08-2013, 11:35 PM
What's even funnier is how people in the USA drive vehicles like hummers and land rovers for nothing more than trips to the market and dropping off the little mates at school. Vehicles such as this were designed for far more intense use.
DMC3165
02-09-2013, 12:22 AM
What's even funnier is how people in the USA drive vehicles like hummers and land rovers for nothing more than trips to the market and dropping off the little mates at school. Vehicles such as this were designed for far more intense use.
I have a hard time believing that, being that mine just blew up from getting groceries and dropping off the kids at school. Maybe the designers should go back to drawing board.
bikergurl2000
02-09-2013, 01:25 AM
It is always important to check fluids and make sure a vehicle is in top notch shape before spending an arvo on safari. The car never would have overheated had someone identified the leak before the car overheated.
Michael
02-09-2013, 08:59 AM
I have a hard time believing that, being that mine just blew up from getting groceries and dropping off the kids at school. Maybe the designers should go back to drawing board.
I think you are responding to a bot.
DMC3165
02-09-2013, 07:27 PM
As it would figure we are now covered under 3 feet of snow here. I desperately need to use my D for the for the forseeable future while the LaRo gets an overhaul. But I have to wait until some of this crap melts so I don't end up destroying the D in the process. I was considering renting a car for a bit but that could get $$$$. I need this like I need a hole in the head right now.
Does anyone else use there D's this time of year? I remebered a thread about this a while back but i think it was on the old site. Was thinking me and the wife will share the Altima for the next week until some of the snow melts then I'll haul the D out of storage and due my spring PM service early. Thank god I have that thing 3165 always bails me out when I need it!
I'm thinking we'll fix the Rover run it for a few months after we fix it then get rid of it. Gonna get killed on the depprecation but I hate this thing now. It's a big pain in the ass and I just want it gone.
grayghost
02-09-2013, 09:29 PM
Ive been in a similar situation with the rearends in a rover my wife's rover before we got married and were dating. I looked long and hard for an affordable stock rearend and after a week with no results I measured the total width of the axle and went to the local pull your part junkyard and got a ford disc brake rearend for 125.00 moved some things around and viola a fixed rover for under 500. After that experince I looked around on forums and found out how bad her particular rover was and all the various associated problems. We got rid of it last year for a new jeep put a lift on it and some mud tires and the wife loves it more than the rover. But when we traded it in The dodge dealership technician was quite impressed with some ingenuity and safely bypassing some of the electronic features on the rover. I would not bat an eye to buying an old carbed rover or something with mechanical injection but when the computer became involved they turned to pure and utter junk.
DMCVegas
02-10-2013, 12:18 AM
Interesting to read everything about the Land Rover. The wife wants a Range Rover eventually, and I'm a Jag fan that just can't kick the British car habit. Jaguar takes the cake on bastard hoses too. Create a good hose that is vulcanized, and then weld extra hoses into it with heat and compromise the rubber to create failure points.:facepalm: Anyone who criticizes DeLorean repairs, especially water pump hoses and the VOD has obviously never worked on an AJ6 engine to try and accomplish the same repair.
When we used to have our old Jag, I ordered parts from a place called Motor Cars Ltd. down here in Houston. They'll ship parts next day, have seriously competitive prices on new and used since they also have their own junkyard. And best of all is they also manufacture improved parts for ones that commonly fail, as well as retrofit kits for things like the suspension, etc. Awesome customer service too and prompt shipping. They kept me sane throughout the ownership of that car, and confident enough that I'll buy more.
http://www.motorcarsltd.com/
http://www.blackdogmanufacturing.com/
Dangermouse
02-10-2013, 03:10 PM
The above model looks much closer to be ready for the Zombie Apocalypse or the next Road Warrior movie.
That was simply a standard issue police car back in the day. And, no, the officers didn't get to take them home after their shift. :)
opethmike
02-11-2013, 02:38 PM
I think you are responding to a bot.
He is responding to yet another account piloted by Steve Rice.
thirdmanj
02-11-2013, 02:51 PM
He is responding to yet another account piloted by Steve Rice.
How do you KNOW these things?! "Magic Crystal Internets Ball"?
opethmike
02-11-2013, 02:53 PM
How do you KNOW these things?! "Magic Crystal Internets Ball"?
I have mystical superhero powers.
thirdmanj
02-11-2013, 04:03 PM
I have mystical superhero powers.
Oh yeah? That's hella cool. You should use them to find risqué pictures of "bikergurl2000" on the internets. ;)
opethmike
02-11-2013, 04:22 PM
Oh yeah? That's hella cool. You should use them to find risqué pictures of "bikergurl2000" on the internets. ;)
.....and I just went blind.
thirdmanj
02-11-2013, 04:28 PM
.....and I just went blind.
:hysterical:
Oh yeah? That's hella cool. You should use them to find risqué pictures of "bikergurl2000" on the internets. ;)
16484
refugeefromcalif
02-11-2013, 06:36 PM
16484
I've always preferred Blond chicks...
:tongue:
George
DMC3165
06-21-2013, 03:08 PM
Hey all it's been a few months since I posted about this but my Land Rover was toast! Block was warped and needed new pistons anyway. So we've decided to cut our losses and trash it. I have a guy in Jersey who's gonna buy it for parting out.
On the plus side I replaced it with this. Needless to say my wife is thrilled! She's wanted one since they came out. It's been a rough year for her so far so this helped cheer her up.
Roman Legion
06-21-2013, 04:16 PM
Hey all it's been a few months since I posted about this but my Land Rover was toast! Block was warped and needed new pistons anyway. So we've decided to cut our losses and trash it. I have a guy in Jersey who's gonna buy it for parting out.
On the plus side I replaced it with this. Needless to say my wife is thrilled! She's wanted one since they came out. It's been a rough year for her so far so this helped cheer her up.
Too bad, I know a guy who knows a guy who knows this other guy in Jersey who could have got you a great deal on a slightly used 6000 SUX, it still has the factory sticker on it.
http://robocoparchive.com/info/car8.JPG
tgraham
06-21-2013, 05:01 PM
What a piece of crap!
Ha! How am I not seeing this until now?! (probably because my presence here is so sporadic). Anyway, you need an OLD Land Rover - something made before Ford overhauled everything. Believe it or not, the reputation for the newer ones that Ford developed is that they "don't break" (I suppose that statement is relative) ;)
I've worked on tons of Land Rovers and have owned my '94 Defender for the past 12 years/90k miles and drive it all of the time. It's not as posh as the other models (my wife avoids riding in it at nearly all costs), but I think it's a great vehicle. Sure, bits break from time to time, everything must be ordered (many times straight from England), it leaks (water in and oil out), but it's never let me down. And since it's not loaded with a ton of electronic systems, I can fix anything on it without access to $20k diagnostic computer.
Anyway, it's probably a marque that's a bit like the DeLorean - it takes a certain "mentality" to own one long term. But, everything said, I don't think the new Land Rovers will still be on the road in 20 years. And if so, it will take someone whose level of stubbornness/insanity puts me to shame!
Travis
Delorean02378
06-21-2013, 05:09 PM
Ha! How am I not seeing this until now?! (probably because my presence here is so sporadic). Anyway, you need an OLD Land Rover - something made before Ford overhauled everything. Believe it or not, the reputation for the newer ones that Ford developed is that they "don't break" (I suppose that statement is relative) ;)
I've worked on tons of Land Rovers and have owned my '94 Defender for the past 12 years/90k miles and drive it all of the time. It's not as posh as the other models (my wife avoids riding in it at nearly all costs), but I think it's a great vehicle. Sure, bits break from time to time, everything must be ordered (many times straight from England), it leaks (water in and oil out), but it's never let me down. And since it's not loaded with a ton of electronic systems, I can fix anything on it without access to $20k diagnostic computer.
Anyway, it's probably a marque that's a bit like the DeLorean - it takes a certain "mentality" to own one long term. But, everything said, I don't think the new Land Rovers will still be on the road in 20 years. And if so, it will take someone whose level of stubbornness/insanity puts me to shame!
Travis
I was wondering when you'd pipe in on this thread! Travis and his dad have more Range Rovers / Land Rovers than your local dealership does. I'll have to say, the Range Rovers / Land Rovers are worked on by Travis less than our Deloreans are.
BTW, bite your tongue on the Ford Comments :smile:
DMC3165
06-21-2013, 06:35 PM
Too bad, I know a guy who knows a guy who knows this other guy in Jersey who could have got you a great deal on a slightly used 6000 SUX, it still has the factory sticker on it.
http://robocoparchive.com/info/car8.JPG
Epic Win!:worship:
DMC3165
06-21-2013, 06:49 PM
BTW, bite your tongue on the Ford Comments :smile:
Sorry Kirk I hate to say it but the Ford SI6 that powers my LR2 is junk. A good friend of my brothers that was helping us with the rover also works for Volvo. They are using the sane SI6 motor in some of their cars and are having nothing but trouble with them also. They are replacing pistons because they start using oil under 20K miles. Ours started using oil too, but the dealer said it was normal. BS! I called them on that a few years back and they Said there's nothing wrong. Now I found out it's a known problem with this engine and because the warranty was up when the head gasket blew they told me there was nothing they could do. This car in 60K miles went through 4 alternators due to a coolant leak, 3 rear ends due to a design flaw acknowledged by Land Rover and finally an engine. It's a tough lesson to learn but I'll never buy another Land Rover again.
Roman Legion
06-21-2013, 07:44 PM
Sorry Kirk I hate to say it but the Ford SI6 that powers my LR2 is junk. A good friend of my brothers that was helping us with the rover also works for Volvo. They are using the sane SI6 motor in some of their cars and are having nothing but trouble with them also. They are replacing pistons because they start using oil under 20K miles. Ours started using oil too, but the dealer said it was normal. BS! I called them on that a few years back and they Said there's nothing wrong. Now I found out it's a known problem with this engine and because the warranty was up when the head gasket blew they told me there was nothing they could do. This car in 60K miles went through 4 alternators due to a coolant leak, 3 rear ends due to a design flaw acknowledged by Land Rover and finally an engine. It's a tough lesson to learn but I'll never buy another Land Rover again.
Too bad you couldn't just get a 2005-2007? 4.6L Mustang GT engine, never had a single problem with that Ford engine. :yesss: I know my dad has been through several Ford cars and all of them were crap engine-wise. I'm not a big Land Rover lover, I like the older ones and the ones currently in service with the British Armed Forces, but that's it really.
tgraham
09-13-2013, 04:47 PM
So, after my (mostly) tongue-in-cheek post a while back... My Defender let me down yesterday ;) I have to give it a modicum of credit... at least it waited until I was in my driveway to totally crap-out, though it could have waited until I was at the TOP of the hill and not halfway up it. I suspect the torrential rain that we had got some key Lucas bits wet. Hopefully they'll dry out along with the interior (it's time to re-seal the roof).
Luckily I'm driving something reliable today: my DeLorean!
BTW, bite your tongue on the Ford Comments :)
Oh, don't get me wrong... Ford did a ton of great things for the marque. They transformed the products into very refined vehicles and, believe it or not based on this thread, stamped-out the quality issues (just like they did for Jaguar), but by doing that they obviously introduced complexity and modernity. They had to do it to sell more cars, and it certainly worked. But complexity and modernity (mainly computers) are not terribly conducive to keeping a car on the road for a really long time. There are tons of 1960s-era Land Rovers on the road today. In 2063, I'll bet there are zero Evoques.
So the moral of this story is: computers suck.
Travis
pezzonovante88
09-13-2013, 07:53 PM
There are tons of 1960s-era Land Rovers on the road today. In 2063, I'll bet there are zero Evoques.
So the moral of this story is: computers suck.
Travis
+1. Cars nowadays are disposable. I'm in the car business and I often wonder what the used car market is going to be like in the future.
DMCMW Dave
09-14-2013, 11:58 AM
+1. Cars nowadays are disposable. I'm in the car business and I often wonder what the used car market is going to be like in the future.
A lot of very pretty, well preserved cars that don't run due to failed antique ECUs that nobody can repair.
DCUK Martin
09-15-2013, 09:26 AM
http://www.topgear.com/uk/james-may/james-may-saving-the-defender-2004-01-01
tgraham
09-15-2013, 04:11 PM
Well, after a couple of days of sitting, the Defender is as good as new (or as good as it was last week). Eventually I'll get around to the diesel conversion, which will ensure that this never happens again!
http://www.topgear.com/uk/james-may/james-may-saving-the-defender-2004-01-01
Nice article, Martin. And he's spot on with the female bit... my wife HATES riding in the Defender.
Travis
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.