PDA

View Full Version : Car drives itself??



Jimmyvonviggle
02-17-2013, 12:27 AM
No it's not a DeLorean but an Audi.

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a8JR6j-e4bk

Cool yes, but couldn't they focus all this brainpower on something that is actually beneficial to mankind.

ccurzio
02-17-2013, 08:40 AM
Cool yes, but couldn't they focus all this brainpower on something that is actually beneficial to mankind.

Not every invention in the world is required to be some kind of miraculous life-saving blessing. Sometimes people like building cool things.

And you'd be surprised how many of the "cool" inventions end up spawning those life-saving ones. :)

Jimmyvonviggle
02-17-2013, 10:27 AM
Maybe you are right Chris, but I'm sure there will be a lot of freaked out people watching a car drive itself.

Ron
02-17-2013, 10:45 AM
And you'd be surprised how many of the "cool" inventions end up spawning those life-saving ones. :)

Sure, not all that far from being able to take you to the hospital...

Spittybug
02-17-2013, 11:00 AM
Just wait for the lawsuits (real or not) of damage caused by driver-less cars. Or how about big parking garages where wireless signals won't penetrate? Seems like yet another means for some to simply exonerate themselves from having to master a minor skill. Like parallel parking. Gear shifting (auto) I get. Not being able to park?????????

ccurzio
02-17-2013, 12:00 PM
I'd never go for this personally. Too much margin for error (handicapped spaces, "reserved" spaces, not a space at all), too easy to be liable in the event of an accident, and I would have issues trusting a car to drive while I was in it let alone having it fend for itself.

Nope. Nope. Nope.

Ron
02-17-2013, 12:15 PM
..then you don't want to know how most airliners land these days ;-)

ccurzio
02-17-2013, 02:50 PM
I'm well aware. I used to fly. :)

DashEight
02-17-2013, 03:23 PM
I'm sure these will happen in my lifetime. Google and BMW have their driverless cars that are very impressive. So long as they have a manual mode that one can elect to use. Hell even Luke Skywalker told R2 to let him cruise in manual mode to Yoda's.

DMCVegas
02-17-2013, 09:17 PM
..then you don't want to know how most airliners land these days ;-)

Yeah, but airplanes aren't navigated by the same class of unintelligent drivers.

In any case, driverless cars will never see the light of day. Why?

If driverless cars don't allow a vehicle to be operated in an unsafe manner, that means they don't speed. If they don't speed, they don't break the law. If they don't break the law, the don't get tickets. If they don't get tickets, local governments loose money. Between electric cars and increased fuel economy standards, states and the Fed have seen fuel tax revenues plummet. Trust me, they're not gonna let driverless cars or any other technology that threatens the loss of tax dollars see the light of day.

Dangermouse
02-18-2013, 12:08 AM
They will just raise the ad valorum tax on the car, or introduce a new "convenience fee".

Suddenly self-drive cars will need a special tag plate fee of $500.

They will get the money somehow.

(as an example, we had a drought here in GA a few years ago. We were all extolled to reduce our water consumption by 25% by the county water board. "it will help us and save you money" they told us. The residents were so successful in reducing their useage that the water board realized that their income would go down, so they raise the water rates by 25% to compensate :) )

DMCVegas
02-18-2013, 12:52 AM
They will just raise the ad valorum tax on the car, or introduce a new "convenience fee".

Suddenly self-drive cars will need a special tag plate fee of $500.

They will get the money somehow.

(as an example, we had a drought here in GA a few years ago. We were all extolled to reduce our water consumption by 25% by the county water board. "it will help us and save you money" they told us. The residents were so successful in reducing their useage that the water board realized that their income would go down, so they raise the water rates by 25% to compensate :) )

Agreed on all counts. Power companies are also in very similar situations thanks to CFL bulbs. Power demands are down so far that profits have actually fallen, and new fees are being introduced. Interestingly enough, Texas has a very unique solution to all of this that has been in effect for quite some time. Passenger vehicles are subject to high registration fees, but pickup trucks that consumers buy are a low, flat rate of about $54 for registration if I'm correctly recalling what we've been paying. So yeah, save about $200 a year on registration, but pay an additional $1,000 on fuel tax. The government reaps higher tax revenue every year, but people love it because it's less money up front.:drunk:

I don't personally don't think that the whole "Self-Driving" car concept will gain very much traction in the long term. Using both fuel economy as well as utilities such as what you cited, there is a huge incentive for a consumer: Monetary Savings. Buy a more fuel-efficient car to save money? Sure! Find ways to use less water or electricity? Sure! There are big financial incentives to be had for both consumers, and they're willing to take the plunge. Automated cars? Not so much. Many people already lament about the lack of manual transmissions in vehicles. Removing a person from the equation entirely and surrendering control isn't something that many people will want to do, or at least some of the most vocal.

And of course as it's been mentioned many times before, there is the financial responsibility for an accident that is the result of a failed system. Hit a pedestrian now, and it's your fault. Hit one with one of these cars if the system fails, and suddenly you too could be suing other people from the car makers, insurers, software designers, component manufacturers, etc. And it does fail. Take a look here:

http://jalopnik.com/5648126/volvo-pedestrian-avoidance-crash-test-fails-spectacularly

My favorite quote there is this one from Volvo themselves regarding why things failed:
"The failure of the test was due to the dummy not being set up properly."

Really? Blaming the pedestrian that was hit from a collision that could have entirely been avoided. Nice job. Not to say that pedestrians are never at fault (I learned to drive in Vegas which has very unique laws regarding them), but how can you blame a pedestrian as the reason that your safety system failed? And even for those accidents where a vehicle could not stop in time, the manufacturer could still be sued if the driver/purchaser was misled about the capabilities. It's just a bad deal all the way around.

DMC5180
02-18-2013, 03:55 AM
Personally, I'd love to have the Choice of a car with an Autopilot. Especially driving long distances on the I-system. There are already cars out that feature cruise deceleration braking and speed matching when approaching slower vehicles in front of you. There are sensors that indicate vehicles approaching from your blind spots. The only thing left is setting up the already existing servo controlled steering (parking assist) capable cars with a navigation control. It could just be for Interstate travel. You might get an audible signal when your programed destination exit is approaching. Telling you to take control for local driving or maneuvering.

I drive enough miles already on Human autopilot. You know, those missing gaps of time when you don't remember that last 50 or 100 miles you just drove. Lets face it taking the Human Factor out of driving would save many more lives than any Human controlled safety initiative. Keeping Drunk, Texting, Drowsy or Generally Distracted drivers from potentially losing control and crossing the centerline hitting another car head-on would save lives. I'm not saying I'm for driverless cars where you are just a passenger, but something like a driver selectable auto drive feature would be a good thing. It wasn't all that long ago when DARPA challenged teams to build fully automated vehicles. The early versions failed miserably and had all sorts of junk mounted on them just to perform very basic maneuvers. Now we see the driverless GOOGLE cars with what amounts to a sensor pod on the roof thats it. Technology advances rapidly when humans are put to the challenge. I'm sure someone is already looking into a real Hover mode :biggrin:

DMCVegas
02-18-2013, 05:10 AM
The problem is that even now too much of the "human factor" has been removed from cars. What I mean by that is we're loosing communication with both our surroundings and the road itself. When we have that power steering rack that absorbs the bumps in the road and isolates feedback, we don't realize hazardous conditions below us that could impeed stopping distance and vehicle control itself. I dunno, I keep seeing more and more TPMS on cars that have ripped fenders from exploded tires. Rather than *listening* to our cars and being able to recognize sounds and vibrations that are out of the ordinary, we rely upon warning lights and assume that if nothing blinks or chimes it's all ok.

Anti-lock Brakes as an example are a great tool. Before they came along you had to have a skillful driver that knew how to pump brakes and steer in order to keep a vehicle from spinning out on wet surfaces. After ABS came along, the vehicle started doing this for you. Yeah it's great that it's saving lives, but it's also creating more dangerous situations because people think that because it helps them to safely stop it will always keep them safe. The more we disconnect people from the experience, and more importantly the responsibility of driving, the more dangerous things become because people are lulled into a false sense of security.

Everyday we all go through some sort of "human autopilot" as you say. The time period in which you might not recall what you were doing for that last hundred or so miles I'm sure you can equate the same amount of time to any aspect of your life. Do you really remember every 30 second increment of your life each and every single day? Of course not. But just because you don't have specifically detailed retention of times where there are no major events, that doesn't mean that you were not in fact alert during said time frame. Now unless you're talking about drowsiness, which is totally different. In that case you need to pull over. Just because a car exhibits any sort of self-driving capability, that doesn't mean you're excused from the responsibility of your vehicle. Many states hold legal registered owners responsible for accidents that occur in their vehicles when another person is driving it. It's for a good reason, and a computer is NOT an acceptable substitute. I don't want drowsy/sleeping, intoxicated, or distracted drivers to increase in numbers on the road. It will happen. Hell, you're even endorsing it.

While the "Human Factor" is not fail-safe, it is a lot more reliable and has a higher amount of reliability. Again, take this video for example:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lcJ9xgBZJdI

Again, that is Volvo's own Passenger Avoidance technology in action, and it failed. If that were a real person they would have been injured and possibly killed. The only reason that the car stopped was that the driver took over. This is a clear example of an automated system failing and a life endangered by it. Even if this were a highway only situation, there are still dangers posed by broken down vehicles, lane closures, and other hazards that a driver can see coming that a computer cannot. And still states are passing legislation that says a licensed driver must be present at all times to take over operations of the vehicle. While Nevada and California have autonomous vehicle legislation in place that states a qualified driver isn't responsible for constant control of a qualified vehicle, they are not exempt from any other laws.

Flying cars ain't ever going to happen either. People have too many problems with 2 dimensional navigation when it comes to horizontal merging. If they can't check blind spots now to vertically change lanes, there is no way they're gonna look above and below their car.

Dangermouse
02-18-2013, 10:57 AM
What that Volvo driver needed is Volvo's automated braking system, ably demonstrated here:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNi17YLnZpg

oops.

I guess to make a Volvo omlette you must brake a few eggs (:) ). These are part of the development of advanced safety systems. I'm not sure if in the pedestrian avoidance system above, is the car supposed to swerve out of the way (and hence into oncoming traffic, other pedestrians) or slam on the brakes and get rear ended?

Everything is becoming more automated. ADS. Steer and brake by wire. Blind spot monitoring (where the guy in the car beside you sees an orange light flashing in your mirror and thinks you are indicating to turn into his lane). Interesting times. I think by 2015, all new cars must have back-up cameras. Will the same be true for automatic braking/pedestrian avoidance at some point, and will it be possible for the driver to deactivate it. If you do, and you have an accident, will you be more liable because of it. Because of course your insurance required "snapshot" device has recorded that you turned it off.

If your car has automated parralel parking system, can you use that when you take your test? If not, why not? Because other cars won't have it and you need to know how to parallel park? You can take your test in a car with an auto box, and aren't limited to driving a stick shift in the future.

Could a convicted DUI driver get his/her license back with a stipulation that it is only valid for self-drive cars?

DMCVegas
02-18-2013, 06:15 PM
Because of course your insurance required "snapshot" device has recorded that you turned it off.

That's a very interesting subject that is being tested in the courts. It has been decided in some states that said data cannot be used against a defendant unless consent is given as this can be construed as a violation of a person's Fifth Amendment rights against incriminating one's own self. Unlike say a subpoena for telephone records or something of the like, those records are property of a 3rd party and not subject. However when you own a vehicle, you also own the rights to the data contained within the the Event Data Recording equipment.

http://dritoday.org/feature.aspx?id=350

Voluntary sharing of information such as with "Snapshot" type of recording software that insurance companies provide as an incentive for lower rates are just that: Voluntary. One can opt-out at any time from their program which of course means that a policy reverts back to the standard rate schedule. But you also have to sign a waiver that explicitly states that the 3rd party recording device and associated software is the exclusive property of the insurance company. This is how they skirt the law to use the data against you.



If your car has automated parralel parking system, can you use that when you take your test? If not, why not? Because other cars won't have it and you need to know how to parallel park? You can take your test in a car with an auto box, and aren't limited to driving a stick shift in the future.

Good question. Quite possibly you may have answered your own question there with the auto versus stick shift example. We'll just have to see what legislators come up with.



Could a convicted DUI driver get his/her license back with a stipulation that it is only valid for self-drive cars?

As of right now, absolutely NOT. California clearly states that a drive MUST be behind the wheel at all times of an automated vehicle, and only an individual with a license may have that privilege. The reason being is that you must be able to take over operation of the car incase the automation system fails or the vehicle is in a situation where the limitations of the system are exceeded. Nevada goes a step further stating that not only do 2 people need to be present any time the automated system is activated, but that ONLY a Licensed Nevada driver with a special Autonomous endorsement on their Class C or above license can get behind the wheel of one of these vehicles. Which themselves require special licensing and geographic restrictions at this time.

I doubt that someone with a suspended or restricted license would be able to use an autonomous car since it does still require a legal, unimpaired operator.

Dangermouse
02-18-2013, 08:12 PM
I guess my comments were more about an automotive future 5 or 10 years down the line. I think that the Snapshot is but the thin end of the wedge. The insurance companies offer it as a benefit to the driver and when/if there is enough acceptance (in the insurance companies opinion of course) they then make it a compulsory requirement to get insurance from them. They take their data to each states Insurance Commissioner, which they own, and demonstrate that (in their small subset) it saves lives/money. Viola.

Back on topic. Again, in 5 or 10 years when we are on Google Car V8.0, would NY taxis not be a great application for driverless cars? Get in, use your smart phone to beam your destination to the car (or even say " take me to the next performance of "Cats") and the car would calculate the quickest route along dedicated lanes. You could relax in the back watching The Bachelor Series 37 brought to you by these sponsors.

DMC5180
02-18-2013, 08:59 PM
The Pro's and Con's of an autopilot for cars is an interesting topic for discussion. One thing is for sure the Auto Industry is advancing in this direction whether we like it or not.

Btw, I always like it when people cherry pick supporting evidence that says "see it failed" therefore it will ALWAYS fail every time. We don't Live in Utopia. Testing is just that "testing". Think of the untold failed tests that have lead to major successes. It took a lot of research to develop Airbag Systems, Anti-lock braking, Active suspension and untold countless other advancements. Vehicle crash testing research to develop a car that absorbs the impact around the occupants. Which doesn't prevent them from death in every instance, but certainly improves the likely hood of survivability. Did you happen to see the Recent Police Video of the guy T-boning an unoccupied police cruiser set up as a road block. The was traveling well over 100 mph at impact. Yeah the driver is dead and good riddance to that idiot. But there was also a 5 year old child strapped into a child safety seat. The child survived with only scratches. The point is development testing allowed for the child to live. Yeah I know I just cherry picked a point of reference to support my statement. If you haven't seen the Video, you should. It was on our local news this weekend. The impact was so fast you could not even make out what the object was that hit the cruiser. It looked like a missile.

DMCVegas
02-18-2013, 11:00 PM
I guess my comments were more about an automotive future 5 or 10 years down the line. I think that the Snapshot is but the thin end of the wedge. The insurance companies offer it as a benefit to the driver and when/if there is enough acceptance (in the insurance companies opinion of course) they then make it a compulsory requirement to get insurance from them. They take their data to each states Insurance Commissioner, which they own, and demonstrate that (in their small subset) it saves lives/money. Viola.

Possibly. All it takes are some well-placed rumor e-mails to get sent around, and people could also revolt against it in a HUGE way and force legislators to go the opposite way on any potential regulation if that were a factor. Or at the very least cause enough of a massive boycott to where the backlash could potentially cause financial harm to the corporations. Just look at High Fructose Corn Syrup and Lean Textured Beef (aka "Pink Slime") and what has happened to the related corporations. Even past events like TiVo's Janet Jackson boondoggle, or even poison Halloween candy. Scare enough people, and you can ruin anything.



Back on topic. Again, in 5 or 10 years when we are on Google Car V8.0, would NY taxis not be a great application for driverless cars? Get in, use your smart phone to beam your destination to the car (or even say " take me to the next performance of "Cats") and the car would calculate the quickest route along dedicated lanes. You could relax in the back watching The Bachelor Series 37 brought to you by these sponsors.

Good luck on that. Live drivers ensure security of vehicles against vandalism and damage as either a deterrent or at least a witness. More importantly Unions are gonna have lots to say about putting thousands of people out of work in favor of automated machines. And I would have to actually side with them 100% on this. This isn't like assemblyline robots that took the place of menial jobs that resulted in more employee injuries than they were worth. People already are willing to pay more for domestically produced products, so you can bet a good chunk will still opt for the human-manned vehicles. Not to mention that a simple strike line would block all of the vehicles and shut them down.




The Pro's and Con's of an autopilot for cars is an interesting topic for discussion. One thing is for sure the Auto Industry is advancing in this direction whether we like it or not.

It really remains to be seen. It's too dangerous for manufacturers to approve cars as fully autonomous, and they never will. At the same time while many consumers express interest in these kinds of vehicles, whether or not they intend to buy one still remains to be seen. Just look at the Smart fortwo: gas prices went up, and smart had 30,000 reservations for their cars. Prices fell, and the overwhelming majority abandoned their reservations and cash deposits.



Btw, I always like it when people cherry pick supporting evidence that says "see it failed" therefore it will ALWAYS fail every time.

Who in the hell said that?! The point being made here is that a truly autonomous vehicle is NOT a reliable substitute for a human driver. The "Human Factor" as we've been referring to it here, while not perfect either and prone to error is a helluva lot more reliable than an automated system. Automated systems are severely limited in their abilities. Not only can they NOT account for everything that I human can, they have no Logic circuits that can account for auto correction and recalculations. From recognizing an upcoming collision and avoiding it by moving into an emergency lane, to recognizing an imminent collision and sacrificing a vehicle into another inanimate object rather than hitting another person, to making the ultimate decision to not drive at all. That that last one especially is key.

As I have said before, lots of safety innovations have helped save lives, but they've also taken their fair share and caused even more property damage by lulling drivers into a false sense of security. Take a look at this video as an example:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3IxroxDO8g8

4WD does NOT automatically enable a vehicle to drive on ice. Especially if you don't have locking differentials. I know this, you may know this, but most people don't. How many who don't have an autonomous vehicle would decline to drive in extremely dangerous conditions because of their lack of confidence of their driving skills, but suddenly wouldn't hesitate to march out into a snow storm or dense fog under the false assumption that their "self driving car" will keep them safe? And that is the point that I am making. It's not a perfect world, no. But this has the potential to make it worse.



...The was traveling well over 100 mph at impact. Yeah the driver is dead and good riddance to that idiot. But there was also a 5 year old child strapped into a child safety seat. The child survived with only scratches. The point is development testing allowed for the child to live.

And with that...


http://www.ronanlyons.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/helen-lovejoy.jpg

First off, this has absolutely jack shit to do with the topic at hand. No amount of safety innovations will save a passenger with standard restraints in this situation so it's a moot point. A Child Seat installs into almost any vehicle and isolates it's cargo from the impact itself. Again, moot point. Second, trying to inject children into your argument for the purpose of exploiting unfounded fears about their safety is a tired, last-ditch effort to try and win an argument. Right behind Godwin is Hellen Lovejoy, and both equally nullify your words.

Dangermouse
02-18-2013, 11:51 PM
No, I agree that the taxi thing will never happen. Unions are way too strong for that.

But it would be a good application.

ccurzio
02-19-2013, 07:32 AM
Get in, use your smart phone to beam your destination to the car (or even say "take me to the next performance of "Cats") and the car would calculate the quickest route along dedicated lanes.

If you say that and the car doesn't drive you straight into the Hudson River, the system has failed.

Dangermouse
02-19-2013, 09:11 AM
If you say that and the car doesn't drive you straight into the Hudson River, the system has failed.

A google car, hence Google maps, not Apple Maps.

But I get your point.

DMCVegas
02-19-2013, 10:48 AM
No, I agree that the taxi thing will never happen. Unions are way too strong for that.

But it would be a good application.

Actually, I don't think it will be a good application at all. It sounds great on paper: You've got it where it just goes between addresses, but that's just a residential aspect. In an urban environment, things are totally different. I say this as someone who spent years driving the access roads and alleys in Las Vegas going from resort to resort where I traveled the same hidden arterials as taxi cabs. Private driveways are what are used to access the taxi lanes where drivers queue up for fares, and you have fluctuating queues for taxi stands that have random entrance points throughout the day. You also said something else that is key:


A google car, hence Google maps, not Apple Maps.

It's not just the accuracy of maps that we might have to be concerned with. You can have the most accurate map in the world, but entrances to parking garages, taxi lanes, delivery zones, etc. are simply not going to be shown on a map. You have to have a human available to read signs, even not DOT approved ones on private property, to guide the vehicle. Another concern is non-electronic vehicle guidance, like when a human has to temporarily direct traffic. It could be law enforcement for a special event or emergency situation. It could also be a flagman on a construction site, a dock worker helping move a cargo truck, etc. There is just no way that we can have one of these cars be fully automated. Especially a taxi. And this data just can't always be inserted into a map.

Now if there was a perfect application for autonomous vehicles, it would probably be BRT, or Bus Rapid Transit. It's basically light rail without the rails where you run busses instead. You can have dedicated lanes, as well as mixed-used where the busses can exit the lanes and go back into regular traffic. Busses can influence traffic lights to stop opposing traffic for less interference, and you can also use guidance systems for individual bus stops in regular traffic to help dock the busses (which is an already proven technology we've had for at least 9-10 years now). In the right settings, self-driving busses, and even trains I think would benefit greatly from the technology here.

Shep
02-23-2013, 02:01 AM
For what it's worth, I don't think passenger vehicles will be truly autonomous any time in the next century. Way, way too many issues requiring vast advances in artificial intelligence and computing power before it can even become feasible, not to mention the liability and legal issues that arise from it (if a car drives itself into an accident with no occupants, who's to blame?) Have you seen the computers these cars are using? The pure wattage required by these setups would leave a sizable dent in the environment if this went mainstream (gas demands, emissions, etc.) I don't know about you, but I'd rather have my daily driver get 30 MPG under my control than 20 MPG under a computer's control. Then you get into the sensors required by these setups: GPS, a plethora of cameras, radar/sonar/lasers, what happens if one or more of the sensors go bad? Or GPS satellites shit on themselves due to a solar flare? As flawless as we try to make these cars, the fact of the matter is that things go bad. When they do, usually we can drive to a mechanic, or for the more serious mechanical problems, pull over to the side of the road and call a tow truck. We, as humans, are under control during these times, and can make good judgment on how to handle the situation appropriately.

What happens when a driver has a stroke at the wheel? It's practically guaranteed that there will be an accident as a result. This doesn't happen often, but when it does, the implications are literally life or death. Now you've replaced humans with a computer. When the computer goes bad, what happens? Same damn thing, accident is practically guaranteed. The human body is an extremely reliable machine, and "sudden failures" rarely happen when driving. Usually it's doing other tasks, since only a fraction of our time is spent driving. Again, now the human is a computer that does nothing but drive. ANY "sudden failure" causes an accident. Until computing power, energy efficiency, artificial intelligence, and weight are all vastly improved, I don't see this becoming anything more than a proof of concept. They'll need to design at minimum three setups, each independently capable of driving the car individually, to compensate for an undetected failure of one of them. The other two would "outvote" any bad decisions the failed system would make, and it's fairly easy to throw an idiot light when this happens too frequently.

That all being said, I do see one practical reason to make these proof of concepts: innovations. Taking a look at the technology used, asking "what did we invent in doing this?", and implementing those inventions as small-scale autonomy. Earlier in this thread, automated emergency braking was mentioned. Whether this was inspired by a concept autonomous vehicle or developed independently is irrelevant, the fact is that every concept autonomous vehicle I have seen to date has utilized this technology. Backporting it to the mainstream passenger vehicles of today isn't terribly difficult. Blind spot monitoring? Basically a scaled-down version of having awareness of surrounding cars, also on autonomous vehicles. It's innovations like this that making these proof of concepts can initiate. I've often wondered about adding a camera that is able to see and decipher road signs, given a clear visual path (i.e. no cars in the way). Speed limits (even temporary ones) could be displayed on your speedometer next to your actual speed, detours could be spotted and planned around, "Do Not Enter" signs could signal an alert telling you that you may be going the wrong way, this is something that future autonomous cars will undoubtedly have as technology advances further, and may also be backported into mainstream passenger vehicles. Untold technologies could be added to make cars that much safer. Now, as DMCVegas said, signs on private property are the furthest thing from standardized, but those on public roadways generally have consistent standards that can be deciphered.

But in the meantime, it's always sweet to see autopilot at work in a car :popcorn:


Now if there was a perfect application for autonomous vehicles, it would probably be BRT, or Bus Rapid Transit. It's basically light rail without the rails where you run busses instead. You can have dedicated lanes, as well as mixed-used where the busses can exit the lanes and go back into regular traffic. Busses can influence traffic lights to stop opposing traffic for less interference, and you can also use guidance systems for individual bus stops in regular traffic to help dock the busses (which is an already proven technology we've had for at least 9-10 years now). In the right settings, self-driving busses, and even trains I think would benefit greatly from the technology here.Downtown Cleveland has a setup where this could be useful. The buses have the center lane on one of the streets, and all the bus stops are in the center as well. Granted, everyone hates them and they're rarely used, but considering the dedicated lanes and dedicated lights, I can see this being implemented, combined with automated emergency braking to avoid accidents. Still need a driver to take/enforce tolls and drive the rest of the route, but beyond that it's a fairly straightforward setup.