Log in

View Full Version : LED Flicker?



lazabby
02-24-2013, 11:03 PM
At nighttime when I'm driving down the road I notice that the tail lights on some cars seem to have a high speed flicker. Since they all appear on newer cars, are these caused by LED tail lights? My wife can't see it. The flickering annoys me to a small degree.

Jimmyvonviggle
02-24-2013, 11:48 PM
This seems to be a standard reaction, at least on many cars, when a bulb on the front is burnt out on the same side. This lets the driver know inside the cabin as they hear that irregular clicking.

Dangermouse
02-25-2013, 12:24 AM
I don't think that is what he means.

I think Shannon is talking about some sort of high frequency flicker, but you bring up an interesting point - if a car has standard bulbs at the front and side, but LEDs at the rear, will the LEDs do the slow freq flash we associate with a bulb-out signal.

I have never noticed the high freq flicker, but I have noticed that some are really really bright at night.

lazabby
02-25-2013, 11:28 AM
This seems to be a standard reaction, at least on many cars, when a bulb on the front is burnt out on the same side. This lets the driver know inside the cabin as they hear that irregular clicking.

This isn't a slow blinking due to a bulb being out. This is a high sppeed flicker. I'm trying to find out if this is the nature of LED bulbs. I don't notice it on older cars with incadescent bulbs. I'm wondering if it's LED buls in newer cars.

jangell
02-25-2013, 12:32 PM
This isn't a slow blinking due to a bulb being out. This is a high sppeed flicker. I'm trying to find out if this is the nature of LED bulbs. I don't notice it on older cars with incadescent bulbs. I'm wondering if it's LED buls in newer cars.

This may not be the case for LED bulbs, but with things like old LED calculators (the ones that use 7 segment displays), they don't actually turn on all the LEDs at once. Instead, they very quickly turn each segment (that's supposed to be on) on and then off again. This happens so fast that you aren't able to processes the flashes and see a single constant image, in the same way you don't see your TV flicker even though it's being redrawn 24 or 25 or 30 times a second (twice that for interlaced TVs or 50/60 FPS content), and is why persistence of motion works (as in, why you perceive TV as motion instead of as a series of high-speed still images). You can actually see it by holding said calculator in your hand and waving it in front of you; since the LEDs are only on for a very brief instant, they don't blur like the rest of the calculator does when you wave it. The reason they implement it this way is to make it drive the LEDs, since it avoids needing to power them all at once. (NASA also used this trick to cancel out oscillation from a vibrating seat that made a readout too blurry to read during launch; they simply made the display blink in sync with the the oscillation so that it would appear stable: http://gizmodo.com/5880850/how-nasa-solved-a-100-million-problem-for-five-bucks )

I haven't noticed this happening with LED tailights, but then I haven't looked that closely either.

-- Joe

Dangermouse
02-25-2013, 02:29 PM
I was aware that domestic LEDs switch on and off at twice mains frequency (i.e. 120Hz) but didn't know about DC. I had assumed they were always on.

This is a question for one of our resident LED experts, Ozzie of Dave M.

jangell
02-25-2013, 03:00 PM
I think the mains frequency is just that plugged-in clocks sometimes use the AC frequency as their clock, rather than having a quartz clock built into it. I read an article on this once, but I can't seem to find it now. But AC is converted to DC to drive the LEDs anyway, so it's not something strictly specific to AC.

Also, I believe one of the reasons they cycle through the LEDs on a calculator and alarm clock is so that they can have fewer wires to binary-to-decimal converter chips. So, a microcontroller would turn on one of the BDC chips, with the pins set to display a number, then turn it off and go to the next chip, and so on. Or use one BDC chip for all of the digits, and switch the common ground off on all of the digits but the one it wants to address at that time, looping through all the digits quickly so it looks like they're all on at once.

I'm a pretty basic hobbyist with electronics at this point, so I might have the details wrong, but I think it's basically right.

That said, none of this would apply to an LED bulb, since you're not trying to display some specific pattern (like a number); assuming you have enough power, you should be able to turn all the LEDs on at once. Maybe they're just trying to limit the power drain -- although would that really exceed the power of a conventional bulb? I'm not totally sure.

Lets go with your idea and wait for someone who knows what they're talking about. :)

-- Joe

Farrar
02-25-2013, 03:27 PM
It's called multiplexing -- the same reason that back in the 1980s when you pointed your videocamera at your alarm clock the numbers would appear to flicker when you played the tape back. Saves I/O pins by controlling multiple LEDs but leaves a faint strobe effect.

Spittybug
02-25-2013, 06:11 PM
I think that Shannon has superhuman eyeballs that see things faster than the rest of us. :yoda:

Bitsyncmaster
02-25-2013, 08:17 PM
It's called multiplexing -- the same reason that back in the 1980s when you pointed your videocamera at your alarm clock the numbers would appear to flicker when you played the tape back. Saves I/O pins by controlling multiple LEDs but leaves a faint strobe effect.

Your probably right.

Don't know what the reason would be to do it unless they are trying to save power.

Shep
02-25-2013, 11:22 PM
Don't know what the reason would be to do it unless they are trying to save power.Any chance they're doing this to lengthen the LED taillight's lifespan? If the LED's are rated for a certain number of hours, I'm thinking they might be flickering them on and off quickly to effectively double the lifespan. That would allow them to use cheaper bulbs and/or have fewer warranty repairs on the taillights, wouldn't it? Or am I thinking about this backwards?

lazabby
02-26-2013, 12:13 AM
I think that Shannon has superhuman eyeballs that see things faster than the rest of us. :yoda:

Where's the "like" button?

Bitsyncmaster
02-26-2013, 02:24 AM
Any chance they're doing this to lengthen the LED taillight's lifespan? If the LED's are rated for a certain number of hours, I'm thinking they might be flickering them on and off quickly to effectively double the lifespan. That would allow them to use cheaper bulbs and/or have fewer warranty repairs on the taillights, wouldn't it? Or am I thinking about this backwards?

Would not think so. LEDs are rated at 30,000 hours life.

Starglider
02-26-2013, 06:50 AM
Don't know what the reason would be to do it unless they are trying to save power.

It's not that, it's pulse width modulation voltage regulation. The LED strings are rated to operate at a specific current and hence voltage; the car electrical system voltage will be somewhat higher and can vary by a couple of volts depending on whether the engine is running, RPM, alternator and battery condition, load etc. Old style voltage regulators worked by analog control of the supply voltage through a power transistor, but that's relatively lossy. Modern PWM voltage regulators just switch between fully on and fully off rapidly to achieve the desired average voltage. My guess would be that in this case the smoothing capacitor (that you'd see in say a laptop power supply) was omitted to save money.

Ozzie
03-01-2013, 11:27 AM
Would not think so. LEDs are rated at 30,000 hours life.

True, but....
a) as the OEM of LEDs say in fine print "...in ideal lab conditions". As I stated in my 2012 DCS Tech Session, as a counter example, the engine bay (heat and vibration) of a Delorean is the farthest place of an ideal lab condition. :)
b) an LED bulb also consists of internal electronics, and most of the time, they are the weak link
c) funny thing about that rating is that the LED doesn't stop working after that time, the rating is for up to 70% of the initial light output - the LED can still generate photons/light after that time - point being that they really don't fail.


With that said:
I have seen two LED bulbs on my car flicker after different amounts of usage. This usually indicates a failure in the LED package. Also a "failure" in an LED is really characterized by a reduction in photon emissions (light output), an LED very rarely ever just stop working. So again the weak link is really the electronics (the "driver" in LED parlance), that typically fails. Why it blinks I do not know, but based on my experience, those electronics in the older and lower quality LEDs are very susceptible to heat and extreme voltage variations.

Specifically the failures that I have seen on my car, in about two years of running LEDs, are

Rear tail light
As I wrote in my blog (link in my signature), I bought high quality LEDs to replace the brake lights (Superbrightleds.com), but cheapo ones for the parking lights (ebay). After about 2 years one of the cheapo LEDs started to blink. Replacing it, fixed the issue which indicates that it wasn't the wiring or socket, but the bulb.

Engine Bay light:
As stated, this possibly is the worst environment for an LED bulb, it runs hot in there and there is a rich spectrum of transmitted potentially damaging vibration that make it to the LED package. Again, a cheapo brand lasted about 5 months in that location for me (I was at a car show, engine bay door up, and the bay light LED was blinking - some people thought it was a 'feature'). That was one of the first LED mods I did to my car, and better quality LEDs (SMD types) are now available. I have had a SMD LED in that same location for several years now and it works great.


...oh, and finall: Visible vs Video
I know that this thread started as a visible observation, but remember that LEDs are not in synch with video recordings. It's kind of funny to see a review of a modern luxury vehicle with super expensive LED front parking light, blink as if malfunctioning, on the review videos. Of course our eyes in real life can't see this effect, but these LEDs blink like a disco ball on those videos.

lazabby
03-01-2013, 11:38 AM
True, but....
...oh, and finall: Visible vs Video
I know that this thread started as a visible observation, but remember that LEDs are not in synch with video recordings. It's kind of funny to see a review of a modern luxury vehicle with super expensive LED front parking light, blink as if malfunctioning, on the review videos. Of course our eyes in real life can't see this effect, but these LEDs blink like a disco ball on those videos.

I have found this thread a bit amusing. Until this last post no one has really answered my question. If I'm understanding the posts correctly, it appears that the LEDs are not steady lights like an incadescent and that they do flicker like a high speed strobe. I know I can't be the only one noticing this when I'm driving at night. It's actually a bit annoying. Does anyone else notice it?

Farrar
03-01-2013, 12:06 PM
I have found this thread a bit amusing. Until this last post no one has really answered my question. If I'm understanding the posts correctly, it appears that the LEDs are not steady lights like an incadescent and that they do flicker like a high speed strobe. I know I can't be the only one noticing this when I'm driving at night. It's actually a bit annoying. Does anyone else notice it?

All the time. I've noticed that some towers (broadcast, cell phone) in my area are going to LEDs. When I look quickly from one place to another while driving at night, the flicker trails are obvious.

andyd
03-01-2013, 12:07 PM
Yep, I notice it.

Only when the vehicle is moving- not noticable staionary. Quite annoying!!

a

jangell
03-01-2013, 12:10 PM
I have found this thread a bit amusing. Until this last post no one has really answered my question. If I'm understanding the posts correctly, it appears that the LEDs are not steady lights like an incadescent and that they do flicker like a high speed strobe. I know I can't be the only one noticing this when I'm driving at night. It's actually a bit annoying. Does anyone else notice it?

As I understand it, LEDs do emit constant light. If you hook a single LED (the bare electrical component) up to ~2v it will emit a steady stream of photons.

Now, it is also common for the LED drivers (the electronics that control if the LED is on or off, not the LED itself) to rapidly turn LEDs on and off for various reasons. One is to control brightness, or to fade them on and off (LEDs only have one intensity, so to "dim" them you haut turn them on and off really fast, leaving the on for shorter periods of time relative to how long they're off to make them dimmer). Another is to simplify the electronics by turning specific LEDs on and off in sets (multiplexing). Yet another can be to reduce power consumption, which, which is the only reason I can see them doing it for LED lights on cars -- multiplexing like in a calculator doesn't apply as you just want all the bulbs on or you want them all off.

I think this is why it's been tough to get an answer to your question, because it isn't necessarily clear why they seem to be multiplexing the LEDs, unless it is to reduce power consumption. But LEDs are supposed to be more efficient than incandescently, so why would you need to do this? Perhaps it's because LEDs emit a relatively small point of (often quite bright) light and you want to cover a larger area, which means you need multiple LEDs, and you can get 1 watt or greater LEDs (which in turn emit much more light, as would be necessary for a car light), and getting a bunch of those together can add up pretty quick.

-- Joe

jangell
03-01-2013, 12:11 PM
Yep, I notice it.

Only when the vehicle is moving- not noticable staionary. Quite annoying!!

This MAY be the "waving an LED calculator" effect I mentioned earlier, or at least it would be consistent with it.

-- Joe

Ozzie
03-01-2013, 12:29 PM
As I understand it, LEDs do emit constant light. If you hook a single LED (the bare electrical component) up to ~2v it will emit a steady stream of photons.

Now, it is also common for the LED drivers (the electronics that control if the LED is on or off, not the LED itself) to rapidly turn LEDs on and off for various reasons. One is to control brightness, or to fade them on and off (LEDs only have one intensity, so to "dim" them you haut turn them on and off really fast, leaving the on for shorter periods of time relative to how long they're off to make them dimmer). Another is to simplify the electronics by turning specific LEDs on and off in sets (multiplexing). Yet another can be to reduce power consumption, which, which is the only reason I can see them doing it for LED lights on cars -- multiplexing like in a calculator doesn't apply as you just want all the bulbs on or you want them all off.

I think this is why it's been tough to get an answer to your question, because it isn't necessarily clear why they seem to be multiplexing the LEDs, unless it is to reduce power consumption. But LEDs are supposed to be more efficient than incandescently, so why would you need to do this? Perhaps it's because LEDs emit a relatively small point of (often quite bright) light and you want to cover a larger area, which means you need multiple LEDs, and you can get 1 watt or greater LEDs (which in turn emit much more light, as would be necessary for a car light), and getting a bunch of those together can add up pretty quick.

-- Joe

Joe,

Yes, LEDs produce a constant stream of photons, they do not by themselves flicker. You are also correct that the flicker effect is electronics driven, they are pulsed in applications. I am also like you not sure why they do make them pulse on an application that requires a constant (not dimmable) applications, perhaps it is to extend their life (limiting thermal peaks?). Occasionally I am in contact with technical folks at LED OEMs, I'll ask them that question directly when I get a chance.

Good discussions.

lazabby
03-01-2013, 12:32 PM
All the time. I've noticed that some towers (broadcast, cell phone) in my area are going to LEDs. When I look quickly from one place to another while driving at night, the flicker trails are obvious.

Yes that's exactly what I'm talking about. I haven't noticed on towers but on cars. Welcome to the elite superhuman club!:worship:

Ozzie
03-01-2013, 12:36 PM
Yes that's exactly what I'm talking about. I haven't noticed on towers but on cars. Welcome to the elite superhuman club!:worship:

Watching movies, at a measly 24 frame per second, must really suck for you guys.
:)

Farrar
03-01-2013, 01:50 PM
Watching movies, at a measly 24 frame per second, must really suck for you guys.
:)

I figured that's why people used to call movies "flicks."

You can see the flicker when you move your eyes from one portion of the screen to another, or away from the screen to find that piece of popcorn you just dropped.

Getting back to LED modules: I figured they multiplex to save pins, but that's just a reckoning based on intuition.

jangell
03-01-2013, 01:59 PM
Getting back to LED modules: I figured they multiplex to save pins, but that's just a reckoning based on intuition.

In the most basic sense, though, wouldn't you just wire all your LEDs up to the power (say, through a voltage regulator) and be done with it? What would you actually need the electronics for? Since there's no dimming or selective operation of the LEDs, and the switch to turn the LEDs on/off is already handled by another part of the car it seems like you wouldn't need to save any pins at all, because no pins (on a microcontroller or other IC) would even be needed.

I'm leaning towards a bunch of 1 W LEDs drawing too much power compared all at once when enough of them are used to cover the area of a tail light so they need to multiplex them to save power, but I haven't done the math to prove this. I'm also not an electrical engineer; I'm just a hobbyist with a few Arduinos lying around and a little knowledge, which we all know is dangerous (see the Dunning-Kruger effect (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning–Kruger_effect)). :) Also, I'm curious about why they'd do it that way.

-- Joe

Farrar
03-01-2013, 02:14 PM
It may very well have something to do with saving power, or extending LED life via duty cycle, or saving pins on the PCB, or a combination of those. I wish an electrical engineer would show up and rescue this thread... :P

jangell
03-01-2013, 02:19 PM
It may very well have something to do with saving power, or extending LED life via duty cycle, or saving pins on the PCB, or a combination of those. I wish an electrical engineer would show up and rescue this thread... :P

Yeah, where are those guys? :D

Sorry, I forgot that it was mentioned that it might extend the life, and saving pins on the PCB is something I didn't think of before, although I don't quite entirely understand what that would mean; I figured you'd have more on the PCB if you had to add an IC to multiplex.

-- Joe

Farrar
03-01-2013, 02:26 PM
A single IC to multiplex might take up less real estate than a whole bunch of resistors -- most LEDs run at between 3v and 5v.

Check out the back side of this unit, which runs 6 high-intensity LEDs.

http://d114hh0cykhyb0.cloudfront.net/images/uploads/3022-xHP4-led-festoon-base-bulb-back.jpg

jangell
03-01-2013, 02:28 PM
Ah -- that explains a lot. I figured I was probably overlooking something important. Thanks!

-- Joe

Mark D
03-01-2013, 04:05 PM
My guess for the LED's being pulsed/multiplexed is that it's necessary to achieve the dual brightness characteristics of tail lights. You want half brightness with the normal running lights on, and full brightness when the brakes are applied. Rather than have a series of resistors to attempt to drive the LED at different outputs they multplex them so it's easier to control.

jangell
03-01-2013, 04:09 PM
That's a good point that I hadn't thought of -- I was thinking of separate brake lights and tail lights like the DeLorean, and forgot that many modern cars combine the two. I personally hate it when the turn signal is combined with the tail light/brake light, and especially red turn signals; it can be subtle, but it is easier to miss the turn signal with those setups.

-- Joe

Starglider
03-01-2013, 05:19 PM
A single IC to multiplex might take up less real estate than a whole bunch of resistors -- most LEDs run at between 3v and 5v.

Resistors aren't ideal anyway because the supply voltage varies. A string of high-power LEDs may take a 12v nominal voltage for max efficiency but a PWM regulator is needed to give that. That module pictured has capacitors damping the flicker, cheaper ones omit them. Did anyone read my earlier post?

jangell
03-01-2013, 05:27 PM
Did anyone read my earlier post?

I did, but completely missed the significance of it or simply didn't read it correctly. I really had no idea how voltage regulators worked, but it does make a lot of sense that you'd see the flicker if it was done via PWM, and I've used PWM to simulate analog outputs from an Arduino, so I understand the principle and how smoothing capacitors could be used to avoid the flicker, although I didn't put two and two together until now. Sorry for missing that before and further dragging this thread out. Thanks for the info!

-- Joe