Log in

View Full Version : Frame & Body Seat "Cradle" Comfort



Jack
02-28-2013, 12:28 AM
I recall it being mention that the "cradles" or huggers whatever you want to call the part of the seat back and bottom that wraps around, was added due to complaints of testers sliding from side to side while test driving the original flat seat design.
I like the "cradle" on the seat back, but I LOTH the on on the seat bottom.
It's killing my hips.
The raised parts pocks right into my joint.
I recall my first 8 hour drive, waking up the next day think, why the heck do my hip hurt so bad, my girlfriend at the time said her hurt also. ;)
But as soon as we sat back down it was instantly clear what caused the pain.
Has anyone come up with anything to deal with this?
I'm really considering adding more foam to make it flatter.

LordFly
02-28-2013, 12:50 AM
I believe the proper name is a "bolster". I haven't really checked into it myself, but I've been told that a number of upholstery places, especially the ones that do a lot of custom work, could handle what you're looking for. Not sure what the cost is like, but if you've got the budget, they have all different densities of foam, they should essentially be able to make you a custom seat. Hopefully without straying too far from the original shape so that you can still use the regular seat covers.

kajcienski
02-28-2013, 12:52 AM
I recall it being mention that the "cradles" or huggers whatever you want to call the part of the seat back and bottom that wraps around, was added due to complaints of testers sliding from side to side while test driving the original flat seat design.
I like the "cradle" on the seat back, but I LOTH the on on the seat bottom.
It's killing my hips.
The raised parts pocks right into my joint.
I recall my first 8 hour drive, waking up the next day think, why the heck do my hip hurt so bad, my girlfriend at the time said her hurt also. ;)
But as soon as we sat back down it was instantly clear what caused the pain.
Has anyone come up with anything to deal with this?
I'm really considering adding more foam to make it flatter.

I might be wrong on this, but if you look at the large black brochure with black shiny car on cover, the car they did most initial photo-shoots with before production models - the seats had more pronounced "huggers". I believe this is the car that was up for sale a few years back as a late proto in the UK by/or related to the stainless guru Chris N. I heard that this seat design was done due to drivers sliding. So the production design was actually a step down from super pronounced "seat huggers". Can anyone confirm?

Jeff K
02-28-2013, 01:37 AM
Props to you, I couldn't take eight hours in any car

WelmoedJ
02-28-2013, 04:48 AM
Props to you, I couldn't take eight hours in any car

Car makers have to find a modus for seats in which most drivers feel being seated comfortably.
Unfortunately man's behind is never shaped alike and over the years this shape tends to "widen".

A slender youngster will probably feel comforable with the D's seats where many older and old drivers notice Jack's problem.
Of course one could advice to do trimming either to the seat or driver's bottom, but that a bit far off.

At my first drive in the D I had Jack's experience, but that was also caused by my other car (Pontiac) having more width between the "huggers".
Nowadays I have no issues with the D seat at I had to trim my bottom on doctor's advice. :)

Pick your choice: exercises usually are by far cheaper than rebuilding a seat. Not intended to flame (my a... survived 69 years of use :)).
I'm targeting 100!

LordFly
02-28-2013, 07:42 AM
I'm targeting 100!

I hope that years, and not lbs :hihi2:

Dangermouse
02-28-2013, 08:11 AM
I have found that taking my wallet out of my back pocket greatly increases the comfort in this car.

Jack
02-28-2013, 08:53 AM
Well I'm six foot even 180 pound, even if I lost another 30 and got back to my high school weight lol,That wouldn't change the width of my hip. My actual hip bone is what is making contact with the bolster. I'll probably that the seat out this Friday and see if my spilt black rubber fix needs tighten, I used aluminum bands. When I was 30 pounds heavier it took hours for the uncomfortableness to start, but now it happens just from 30 minute drives.

kenny
02-28-2013, 08:59 AM
Funny enough, this is one of the biggest issues I have with my car aswell.
FYI I am 12 stone
The bolsters are too close together and I cant get a comfortable seating position.
My Mk2 scirocco has an excellent bolster design similar to below.
http://home.comcast.net/~a_ayer/forsale/scirocco-2-seats-2.jpg

Dangermouse
02-28-2013, 09:11 AM
For those readers in the US, Kenny is 168lbs. :wiggle:

David T
02-28-2013, 10:14 AM
There isn't a lot you can do to modify the seats. You can try a seat cushion or you could replace the seats with maybe a set of Recaros.
David Teitelbaum

DMCMW Dave
02-28-2013, 12:13 PM
Something to check - the bottom of the seat is covered underneath by a rubberized membrane that actually supports your butt. It is not unusual for this membrane to split. If sitting in the seat feels like you are sitting on a bucket, check the membrane (You may need to remove the seat to see it). If it is torn you have two options - have a upholstery guy fix it, or stack a bunch of dense carpet foam on the floor under the seat (not elegant but it works for a while).

Jeff K
02-28-2013, 12:25 PM
I'm pretty fit, but my back hurts after a few hours of sedentary positioning.

At my office I get up every 15 minutes or so and stretch and walk around a bit.

When I had my seats done, I had the seats stuffed with extra padding in the seat bottom.. makes a big difference.

Jeff

dmc6960
02-28-2013, 12:49 PM
When I was modifying my seats for cooling I needed to reinforce the seat bottom so it would not bottom out as much. My rubber membrane was fine but still sagged significantly under moderate weight. I took two 10" rubber hold-down straps, removed the s-hooks, and zip-tied them to the bottom of the seat. It worked well to keep the bottom supported yet still have some give for when necessary. In my application they were also used to hold the lower cooling fan in place.

http://dmctalk.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=10830&d=1338960125

refugeefromcalif
02-28-2013, 08:18 PM
I'll add my .02 here. Oh, I'm 6'2", 135 lbs.

I drove my car home from DMC Florida to the tune of 700+ miles. It's been/was More comfortable, (on a long drive), then my 2012 Grand Caravan.
My old 2005 Grand Caravan I drove to Calif. and back 4 times. Not a problem being comfortable with it. The new one, My butt was Hurting after 150 miles. The leather seats in it are Hard.
The seats in my D are Just Right for a long drive, (Provided I take my wallet out of my pocket)... :tongue:

George

EdR5150
02-28-2013, 08:22 PM
...or stack a bunch of dense carpet foam on the floor under the seat (not elegant but it works for a while).

Defintely not elegant. I tried that for awhile. If you slide the seat back or forward, all that foam shifts out of place, and doesn't go back into place easily. If you have another driver with a different seat position, or need to access your storage compartment, this is not the solution for you. I finally settled on the uphostery shop, and my back feels a lot better.

Farrar
02-28-2013, 08:33 PM
I always take everything out of my back pockets before a long drive. So far, the D's seats have been the most comfortable on a long journey of any I have sat in for that length of time.

Jack
02-28-2013, 09:48 PM
I'll add my .02 here. Oh, I'm 6'2", 135 lbs.

I drove my car home from DMC Florida to the tune of 700+ miles. It's been/was More comfortable, (on a long drive), then my 2012 Grand Caravan.
My old 2005 Grand Caravan I drove to Calif. and back 4 times. Not a problem being comfortable with it. The new one, My butt was Hurting after 150 miles. The leather seats in it are Hard.
The seats in my D are Just Right for a long drive, (Provided I take my wallet out of my pocket)... :tongue:

George

DUDED! 6'2" & 135 lbs.
Dont take this the wrong way but how big are your hips. LOL
Because my femur-Bursa rest at the apex of the bluster, which is what is causing my discomfort.
Check out my diagram just want tofigure out what/where the sweet spot is for hip size to seat.
16892

SS Spoiler
03-01-2013, 01:37 AM
I found that if you shim the front of seat with as many washers as you can it felt better. It tips the angle of the bottom and supports your legs. For long trips a couple of large bath sponges put behind your back, under/beside your legs relives pressure spots.

Paul Cerny 2691
Kalispell, MT

refugeefromcalif
03-01-2013, 07:33 PM
DUDED! 6'2" & 135 lbs.
Dont take this the wrong way but how big are your hips. LOL
16892

Don't know my hips but, I've never had bigger then a 30" waistline.
I'm one of those Odd people that has a hard time Gaining weight, Losing it is Too easy? My Top weight 20 years ago was 160 lbs.

Anyroad, I've found the seats in my D, Very Comfortable on extended drives. :cool:

George