View Full Version : General car appraisers
jfirios
03-01-2013, 06:50 PM
Does anyone know of an appraiser in the LA area that can give me a decent estimate on the value of my car. The guys at DMC cali think it should be in the 35-40 range based on all the upgrades they did and all the custom work I put into it. Would like to get a professional look mostly for me but also for insurance purposes.
Jonathan
03-01-2013, 07:26 PM
I don't have a California reference for you, but wanted to ask the group one thing:
Where do the values come from that these supposed certified appraisers use?
The reason I ask is because when I had my car first appraised a few years back, in a nutshell, the guy basically said to me "what do you want the value to be?"
I was like, huh? I told him how much I paid for it, how much had been put in to it with parts and labor and all that jazz and that is more or less the basis for the value.
I was kind of shocked in that it sounds like most appraisers are not looking your car over in great detail, noting all kinds of features and conditions and then going back to their vast database and comparing it to known values for similar cars. It's not anything close to that. To me, the complexity of it is this:
1) What do you want the value of your car to be?
2) Would you like to pay my fee with cash or check?
It's BS from my angle, but maybe others have different experiences...
DMCMW Dave
03-01-2013, 07:56 PM
It also depends on what you are trying to find out.
--What can I sell it for? (i.e. Retail with the right buyer and some time)
--What can I sell it for in a hurry? (i.e. wholesale to a dealer)
--What would it cost to replace in the same condition if totaled? (Find another nice one and do your upgrades over again)
Generally for an agreed-value insurance valuation you want the third one.
The high and low on this can be $10K apart. True custom work will usually have zero value to a buyer but the replacement cost is still there.
It's BS from my angle, but maybe others have different experiences...
Exact same thing for property appraisals here.
AND, guess who does appraisals for the county tax commission....Talk about BS!
David T
03-02-2013, 12:43 PM
Any good appraiser is going to ask who he is preparing the appraisal for so he knows if he is aiming high or low. As pointed out that can mean a difference of as much as $10K. Appraisers use several methods to determine a price. One method is to research what recent auctions have sold for. Another is to take what a car would be if it was perfect and reduce the price based on it's condition compared to the "perfect" car. Another is to look at recent advertised listings and adjust. Some will just guess and be close because of experience. Credentials mean a lot in that business, it adds to credibility so if you are paying for it you want to know what credentials they have. By now most insurance companies do not require appraisals unless you are trying to put a very high # on it. Most are fine with a couple of pictures. You should not have to spend for an appraisal and if you do it can cost you over $150 or more if a lot of travel is involved. Maybe DMCCA can write you up something if you send them some pictures. In the LA area you should have no trouble finding at least a few appraisers.
David Teitelbaum
jfirios
03-02-2013, 03:42 PM
I know all the guys at the dmc shop in cali. and they all know my car very well. Don said it should be at least 40 for all the work that I had done to it. So i think that is a good starting point.
Any good appraiser is going to ask who he is preparing the appraisal for so he knows if he is aiming high or low. As pointed out that can mean a difference of as much as $10K. Appraisers use several methods to determine a price. One method is to research what recent auctions have sold for. Another is to take what a car would be if it was perfect and reduce the price based on it's condition compared to the "perfect" car. Another is to look at recent advertised listings and adjust. Some will just guess and be close because of experience. Credentials mean a lot in that business, it adds to credibility so if you are paying for it you want to know what credentials they have. By now most insurance companies do not require appraisals unless you are trying to put a very high # on it. Most are fine with a couple of pictures. You should not have to spend for an appraisal and if you do it can cost you over $150 or more if a lot of travel is involved. Maybe DMCCA can write you up something if you send them some pictures. In the LA area you should have no trouble finding at least a few appraisers.
David Teitelbaum
IMO, the appraiser should do the things you mentioned, except who he is preparing it for should make no difference whatsoever.
The question should be- What would the total cost to replace it with one in the same condition be. Period.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.