PDA

View Full Version : Jalopnik Used car face Off - D vs B



Dangermouse
03-18-2013, 02:50 PM
More crap about the D being heavy.


http://jalopnik.com/used-car-face-off-visions-of-the-future-with-gullwing-454595133

Rich
03-18-2013, 10:36 PM
Thanks for posting that reference for us, along with the *sigh* heavy note to go with it.

Well, Jalopnik writers aren't known for their quantification skills or accuracy.

Mr. Estrada proves the point.

For the record a Bricklin weighs in at a generous 3,470lb, which is 760lb heavier than a Delorean at 2,710lb, outweighing it by nearly 30%! Not sure how it is that Mr. Estrada imagined the D was heavier than the B unless it was the feel of the (non-power assist) steering in the D at parking speeds.

Sure, the (aluminum 2.85L) PRV only manages 130HP stock vs the 150HP from the Bricklin's (iron 5.7L) V-8. Yet the power/weight ratio still favors the D, which rates a 21lb/hp vs 23lb/hp for the B - the Delorean is 10% better/faster on that score.

So while the Delorean is heavier than its nearest relation at the time, the Lotus Esprit S-2 at 2250lb, it's a LOT lighter than the Bricklin is.

Grabbed the weights out of Wikipedia in case somebody cares to correct them. You get the idea.

dustybarn
03-18-2013, 11:17 PM
http://www.geschwendtner.de/Chriss/Delorean/DMC%20Comparison%20Overview%20small.pdf

Moreover, the D was lighter than a 280ZX and about the same as a 911. Neither was considered a heavyweight at the time.

Michael
03-19-2013, 08:47 AM
These are the same people who claimed a top sped of 80.....real journalism there.

Jonathan
03-19-2013, 10:29 AM
I don't read this Jalopnik website regularly, but will check out their articles on DeLoreans when I see a link to it. Everyone can form their own opinion, but from what I have seen, if this sort of reading material was for sale as a magazine, it would be found in the rack right above the bubble gum in the check out lane at the grocery store... with all the other garbage.

DMCVegas
03-19-2013, 01:50 PM
Jalopnik has it's moments. They have interesting industry news, and some REALLY great investigations like the one where they found Barrett-Jackson lied to save their own credibility. (http://jalopnik.com/5739333/president-kennedys-ambulance-is-a-fake) Most of the time however, it's a one-sided site. Good luck commenting on anything, because not only is it moderated for content, but it's also moderated for opinion. So if your's doesn't match up with theirs, you won't be heard. Especially if you come across a story where the author is incorrect and have the gall to correct them. I honestly am tied for approvals on Jalopnik comments and FARK Headline submissions.

All in all I like the site for industry news as well as pieces on odd cars that I previously didn't know existed. But I pretty much have to leave it at that as a (mostly) non-interactive site that I still occasionally fact-check.