Log in

View Full Version : Insurance Question



Dangermouse
03-26-2013, 09:09 PM
From a discussion on another forum, in another country, about car maintenance (in states that do not require inspections) and insurance.

The scenario was that if you crashed your car due to bald tires could/would your insurance company refuse to pay out due to your lack of maintenance (in effect your negligence) ? Presumable you would get a ticket from the police for the bald tires.

Say, in the above scenario, your crash resulted in a pedestrians death, again would you be liable?

Rich
03-26-2013, 09:36 PM
It will of course vary from country to country. Take Germany.

According to at least one entry on a forum there can be a violation written and some partial liability in an accident. In this case it was a question related to Germany and about tire tread depth specifically:


"Minimum tyre tread depth in germany - Collos25
The minimum in Germany is 3.0mm but if you are stopprd in one of there frequent checks you will not be permited to drive away if you are on the limit,also any accident be it not your fault you will be partially to blame if you have a vehicle defect.Also Germany enforces the correct tyre speed rating on vehicles."

In Germany there are random roadside safety inspections additional to the scheduled shop safety inspections. Note in this quote that failing a tire for tread depth ends your trip then and there.

So there is an enforcement barrier to driving with low tread depth AND there is a further possible exposure to liability should you somehow manage to have technically been on unsafe equipment.

Dangermouse
03-27-2013, 12:26 AM
Well I was thinking mainly about US states like the Great State of GA that I am in.

I've never heard if insurance being denied for that reason. Getting a ticket and perhaps a subsequent lawsuit from the victims family, possibly.

Shep
03-27-2013, 01:10 AM
Thinking about putting off that tire replacement are we? :tongue:

In all seriousness, it depends on what kind of legalese is in the policy, but from (somewhat limited) experience, when a claims adjuster finds out information like that which shows you were clearly negligent, they scour the legalese and usually find something they can use as a basis to deny a claim. If they're unable to find a definitive reason, they'll still consider it an at-fault accident, and may or may not deny the claim due to that. That being said, I can't say I've heard of the bald tires being reported to the insurance company. It's just not something you see very often, whether because the tires are too damaged to tell, or because no one checks them to find out, or because bald tires are just rare. I'm not quite sure why and I can't speculate either.

It's not as clear-cut of an answer as that though, especially since no two states are alike in terms of what they do/don't allow and how strict/lenient they are in what an insurance company is allowed to do. Each state has their own little quirks in that regard, and it's a very regulated industry, so it may be denied in some states but accepted in others. That's the downside to having the states regulate the insurance industry rather than the federal government.

I did come across another forum some odd years back where a guy had a set of racing tires on his car, and construction workers left some nails on the road. He went out to his car and found a flat tire, and made a thread asking for legal advice, and whether or not he could sue the construction company for the cost of the tires. After some back and forth, he posted pictures of the damage, and someone pointed out the tread was almost entirely gone, and his wear indicators were showing. He stopped posting in the thread at that point, obviously realizing it was like searching for a left-handed screwdriver.

LEVY
03-27-2013, 01:57 PM
From a discussion on another forum, in another country, about car maintenance (in states that do not require inspections) and insurance.

The scenario was that if you crashed your car due to bald tires could/would your insurance company refuse to pay out due to your lack of maintenance (in effect your negligence) ? Presumable you would get a ticket from the police for the bald tires.

Say, in the above scenario, your crash resulted in a pedestrians death, again would you be liable?

I don't believe your insurance carrier would deny a claim just because bald tires, however, you can be sued by the victim's family if the death was caused by negligence. In that case, your insurance should also pay for this if covered under your policy.

Keep in mind that insurance only pay for accidents in which you are found at fault, if this accident was caused by other's fault, they would not pay. So to answer your question, no, insurance should not deny payment, they can be sued for much more if they do it and they would not take the risk, they may try but they would settle out of court.

Now, bald tires and slick tires are not the same, insurance might deny the claim if you are using slick tires made for racing (on the track) and not for highway use, most insurance carriers would not insure your vehicle if it was modified for racing.


LEVY

Shep
03-27-2013, 11:59 PM
insurance should not deny payment, they can be sued for much more if they do it and they would not take the risk, they may try but they would settle out of court.The hell? Since when? That's not the way insurance works. If an insurance company denies a claim, they do so with a perfectly valid and legal reason, and negligence is such a reason. Somehow I cannot see someone refusing to change their tires until there's no tread left, getting into an accident as a direct result of their ignoring common sense, then suing the insurance company for not picking up the bill. Insurance should not be expected to pay for idiotic decision making, and I can pretty much guarantee they're not going to settle just because someone makes a lawsuit. There's plenty of room in the reserves for that.

LEVY
03-28-2013, 12:37 AM
The hell? Since when? That's not the way insurance works. If an insurance company denies a claim, they do so with a perfectly valid and legal reason, and negligence is such a reason. Somehow I cannot see someone refusing to change their tires until there's no tread left, getting into an accident as a direct result of their ignoring common sense, then suing the insurance company for not picking up the bill. Insurance should not be expected to pay for idiotic decision making, and I can pretty much guarantee they're not going to settle just because someone makes a lawsuit. There's plenty of room in the reserves for that.

Most accidents are caused by negligence, and insurance companies still pay!

When two vehicles are involved in an accident, more likely than not, one driver caused it due to some kind of negligence.
Belive me, I know what I'm talking about.
You claim to be working for an insurance company, then you should know better.

I'm not going to argue with you because I hate apples.

LEVY