Log in

View Full Version : DMCTalk and Facebook



Dangermouse
04-10-2013, 05:31 PM
Is Facebook or DMCTalk your primary outlet for all things DeLorean? Why do you prefer one over the other?

I do not maintain a FB account per-se, but I have access to one. I sometimes use it to peruse a few DeLorean specific pages, and I have noted that certain people seem to be very active on those pages, that are not so active on here. For example, on a recent one that I was linked to, both Marc Levy and Steve Rice chipped in.


I’m also seeing more and more where a member here will post a picture on their FB wall and then just post a link to it here; or reference some D-related conversation that they have been having on FB.


Is FB replacing DMCTalk as the destination of choice, much like DMCTalk has done to the DML, or does anyone think that it will in the future? Is DeLorean knowledge being spread over too many websites? Will DMCTalk just become an agglomerator for DeLorean content on other websites?


Obviously I prefer here over there, I think because of my perceived permanence of this site (yes, I am aware of the irony of that statement in light of 2011). Perhaps “permanence” is the wrong word – historically searchable, more detailed perhaps. I prefer that when folks post a picture, there is some descriptive detail that goes with it. Frequently I see a picture of a car posted on a FB page, and while I may like the picture I want to know more – where/when was it taken, whose car is it, who did the work etc.


(As a side bar, it is odd to me that many members here keep their identity anonymous, to various extents, but on FB their full name, pictures, history are all available for all to see. I find myself wondering if posters there are also here under a different username).

Jeff K
04-10-2013, 05:38 PM
DMCTalk all the way. This is a focused and purposeful site , IMHO. Until you mentioned it, I don't use facebook for DeLorean stuff hardly at all.

thirdmanj
04-10-2013, 05:41 PM
DMCTalk is (or should be) mostly for technical assistance and a database of compiled DeLorean specific advice and info like you said. Off topic nonsense is pretty well contained I'd say. I think those that frequent this website and are annoyed with the off topic, Facebook style tangents that seem to occur, are so because the expect precisely the opposite of what a trivial social network like Facebook represents. They're here for facts, advice, assistance, to buy/sell and if able help by sharing their DeLorean experiences.

DMCflux
04-10-2013, 06:01 PM
dmctalk is (or should be) mostly for technical assistance and a database of compiled delorean specific advice and info like you said. Off topic nonsense is pretty well contained i'd say. I think those that frequent this website and are annoyed with the off topic, facebook style tangents that seem to occur, are so because the expect precisely the opposite of what a trivial social network like facebook represents. They're here for facts, advice, assistance, to buy/sell and if able help by sharing their delorean experiences.

agree

Iznodmad
04-10-2013, 06:03 PM
I use both. Lots more pics on FB. Very useful after a meet/gathering. There were and still are lots of pics from DCS on FB.

OverlandMan
04-10-2013, 06:25 PM
I don't use FB at all. I shut down my account 2+ yrs ago and never looked back. It was a giant time waste for me. At least this site can be constructive given its nature and helpful members.

MTDMC
04-10-2013, 09:59 PM
I don't use Facebook at all. Family and friends tell me I should have one. I don't need one anyway.

Ron
04-11-2013, 04:58 AM
...and I have noted that certain people seem to be very active on those pages, that are not so active on here. For example...Steve Rice chipped in.

Surely you jest!



DMCTalk is (or should be) mostly for technical assistance and a database of compiled DeLorean specific advice and info like you said. Off topic nonsense is pretty well contained I'd say. I think those that frequent this website and are annoyed with the off topic, Facebook style tangents that seem to occur, are so because the expect precisely the opposite of what a trivial social network like Facebook represents. They're here for facts, advice, assistance, to buy/sell and if able help by sharing their DeLorean experiences.

:thumbup:

=======

IMHO Facebook sucks in general, a good idea turned into a data-miner from Hell, to say the least.
They kept changing their privacy policies...and every time they did, you would have to drill down four/five levels (under "details", etc, buried in several pages) to undo where they reset a lot of your previous choices to defaults they like to prevent the BS, so I just quit using it and killed my account. (FWIW, they don't really "kill it". Pics, messages, etc were/are still available if someone "tagged" info, etc. There is a lot of shit on there that a lot of people will regret posting one day....)

OverlandMan
04-11-2013, 10:06 AM
IMHO Facebook sucks in general, a good idea turned into a data-miner from Hell, to say the least.
They kept changing their privacy policies...and every time they did, you would have to drill down four/five levels (under "details", etc, buried in several pages) to undo where they reset a lot of your previous choices to defaults they like to prevent the BS, so I just quit using it and killed my account. (FWIW, they don't really "kill it". Pics, messages, etc were/are still available if someone "tagged" info, etc. There is a lot of shit on there that a lot of people will regret posting one day....)

Ron - from what I recall when I shut down my acct 2+ yrs ago, there were 2 ways to quit. The first way was likely what you mentioned above, where they actually keep all your data and if you login with your old creds, it re-enabled the acct automatically. The 2nd way took me longer to find. It actually killed the account from what I could tell. Now did I get confirmation that everything was actually removed (pics, text, settings, etc.)? No and I'm sure their reply would be, if you posted it to our system... you gave us the right(s) to said data for said time period --> which could be indefinite... who knows.

Jonathan
04-11-2013, 10:12 AM
Good chance this turns into a rant, but oh well, here goes...

+1 on FB sucks... and is a time waster... and good idea gone wrong, etc.

Yes, I enjoy seeing what my niece is up to since they live in Phoenix and this is a good way to see pictures or whatever. The trade off though, for me, with getting a bit of the good, is getting all the Facebrag, 'my life is the best" garbage. I get that your kids are the best, that your family vacation to Disney World was the best, that you bought a new car, blah, blah, blah. I wonder if maybe not everything is quite as 'perfect' as these images and statuses make it out to be?

So I can see the wonderful picture of your terrific cottage for the weekend, candlelit dinner, sunset, etc. but what about the picture from the other weekend there where she threw the plate of spaghetti across the room while you two argued about bills? Might not be that exact example, but your life isn't a fairy tale either, no ones is. But on we go with '1-upping' anyone else on your 'friend' list.

I don't think much of it is intentional either. And most people don't intentionally look through other people's pages looking to see who has a better life, but it does happen, even if you don't recognize it. And it might not have been where you see your high school friend on some glorious two week trip to France, and you're thinking, 'man, I haven't even gone away for the weekend somewhere in years'. Or kids versus no kids, for example. Sure, I see the cute baby photos. That is great. I'm thrilled for you. Where's the photo of you staring into the bathroom mirror with bloodshot eyes after getting no sleep for the last month? Does the person without kids remind themselves that it's not so rosey on the other side even though those images aren't shown?

Moral of the story is I see too much comparing on FB. Who has what, went where, had what for dinner (which the photos of your dinner thing, really, is this what we do now?) One thing always remains true... if it looks like it doesn't add up, it doesn't. If you look and see new car, great vacation, big house, blah, blah, blah, my bet is that their bank account statement would tell you a different story. It is so easy to borrow money nowadays that anyone can have anything they want. Nice new Ferrari. Let me know when the repo man comes to take it away and I'll let you borrow my bus pass.

... sorry, rant almost over :)

But ya, time waster, that's a big one. Round and round in circles, looking at the same things and nothing is changing. But you're connected to all these people though right? I don't think so. Connected, yes, but not in touch. If all your communicating is done on the keyboard in your room, this isn't keeping people in touch. Sure, if you're up on the International Space Station for 6 months, then ya, this is a great way to keep in touch. But if no one is meeting up, calling the person, seeing them on the weekend because you can type something quick with your thumbs on your phone, I don't think anyone's communicating skills are getting better. Worse actually. Spelling to say the least, but what about that whole reading the body language part? How do you do that when texting or FB messaging? Ooh, she didn't use a smiley face in her message, I bet she's mad at me? Dumb. Oh, and good look on your first job interview Mister Generation Now teenager, because when you have no idea how to present yourself or communicate to the hiring manager sitting across the table from you, you're not getting the job. Sorry, you can't look down at your phone while sitting at that table even though it seems this is a-okay when four of you go out for dinner and are at a booth all thumbing away but not talking to the people right beside you. Dumb. Figure it out please.

As for DMC stuff, I said the same thing the other day to our ODOC group. More of a technical forum for local owners to get their cars going as we have a couple new ones. FB is a lot of fanboys and other people who might have great BTTF knowledge, but don't know anything about getting your car working. Yes, the forum is what that was meant to do, but like a few others said, gets over taken at times with the social scene/non technical. Not sure what or if there needs to be a solution to which one is for what purpose, my default is to go see someone, pick up the phone, or email someone. Not always practical though of course.

And FB DMC stuff personally... I have put my 'DeLorean" FB profile in the iGarbage can a couple times, deactivated, not deleted as Ron points out. I made it because I tried to keep my 'real" one or the one that is personal and not only DMC related to just that, personal stuff. I think when our family dog died and I put a few sort of 'tribute' photos together, I thought to myself that maybe random car people I have never met don't need to see this? I know you can change settings in some ways to customize this, but my solution instead was no one is on my FB unless I have met you in person, at least once. Not very many exceptions to that, well Dave and Julee were on there before I met them in person, but that's different :)

Good question Dermot...

Facebook = crap
DMCTalk = less crappy

Have a great day!!

Mike C.
04-11-2013, 11:11 AM
I've been on this site since 03 in one form or another, and I have a FB account, with alot of you on it.

Honestly, I RARELY make D posts on FB and use it to look at pics of the cars and the work people have done.

Alot of people just upload their pics here instead of here on the DeLorean site, which is still good, but alot of people are missing some great work you all have done on your cars.

The good thing about this site versus FB is we're concentrated on one topic (mainly).


If people would like a section in the photos such as an "Owner's Garage" to which every owner could start their own thread and upload their pics, tell their stories, etc... we can possibly do that. This way you don't have to search all over the site, you can just go into your thread and add a 'reply' to add more updates, etc, plus people's questions about the work you've done can be right there. Just a suggestion.

thirdmanj
04-11-2013, 11:22 AM
LoL, irony. Off (DMC) topic about FB on DMCTalk...but contained in the appropriate category.

Dangermouse
04-11-2013, 02:30 PM
Surely you jest!

Verily, I jest not, his post even had the word carburetor in it!!

And don't call me Shirley


LoL, irony. Off (DMC) topic about FB on DMCTalk...but contained in the appropriate category.

No irony here. Entirely On Topic in the open discussion area.


I must admit that I wondered if what I was missing, if anything, by not being on FB regularly. (The answer is “not much”)

But it’s interesting that some owners seem to have a personal FB page as well as one dedicated to their car and/or DeLorean stuff in general. Is that to shield friends/co-workers/relatives from their nerd-dom?

One thing I was surprised about is the amount of BTTF Fan Art that is created. Forum member SIMid has a FB page where he posts about a half dozen every day. No idea where he gets them from.

In relation to the comments about OT tangents above, I think one of the issues that DMCTalk has to deal with is that it is a single model car forum and there are only so many questions that can be asked, which may lead to some of the OT posts. I am a member of forums for my DD cars and I visit there exclusively for giving and receiving tech advice. I never visit the “Fireplace/Open Discussion” areas as I have no interest in getting to know them particularly. I’m not in a local “Minivan Club” if such a thing exists as I know that the owners/membership is most transitory. But due to owners clubs, tech sessions, DCSs etc, many owners on here actually know each other in real life, which can lead to a certain level of chattiness and “in-jokes” that might seem distracting to the casual/new visitor. In a certain way, I think this maintains the forum as a vibrant community that people enjoy visiting. The mods do a great job of splitting these off if they go too far off course but I guess “Open Discussion” can become a bit Facebooky

thirdmanj
04-11-2013, 02:43 PM
Verily, I jest not, his post even had the word carburetor in it!!

And don't call me Shirley



No irony here. Entirely On Topic in the open discussion area.


I must admit that I wondered if what I was missing, if anything, by not being on FB regularly. (The answer is “not much”)

But it’s interesting that some owners seem to have a personal FB page as well as one dedicated to their car and/or DeLorean stuff in general. Is that to shield friends/co-workers/relatives from their nerd-dom?

One thing I was surprised about is the amount of BTTF Fan Art that is created. Forum member SIMid has a FB page where he posts about a half dozen every day. No idea where he gets them from.

In relation to the comments about OT tangents above, I think one of the issues that DMCTalk has to deal with is that it is a single model car forum and there are only so many questions that can be asked, which may lead to some of the OT posts. I am a member of forums for my DD cars and I visit there exclusively for giving and receiving tech advice. I never visit the “Fireplace/Open Discussion” areas as I have no interest in getting to know them particularly. I’m not in a local “Minivan Club” if such a thing exists as I know that the owners/membership is most transitory. But due to owners clubs, tech sessions, DCSs etc, many owners on here actually know each other in real life, which can lead to a certain level of chattiness and “in-jokes” that might seem distracting to the casual/new visitor. In a certain way, I think this maintains the forum as a vibrant community that people enjoy visiting. The mods do a great job of splitting these off if they go too far off course but I guess “Open Discussion” can become a bit Facebooky

Thirdmanj "Likes" this.

Dangermouse
04-11-2013, 03:36 PM
http://www.survivingcollege.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/i-see-what-you-did-there.jpg

ssdelorean
04-11-2013, 04:36 PM
18083

Sammy
04-11-2013, 04:42 PM
Verily, I jest not, his post even had the word carburetor in it!!


I don't get it.

Dangermouse
04-11-2013, 05:18 PM
I don't get it.

a case in point




which can lead to a certain level of chattiness and “in-jokes” that might seem distracting to the casual/new visitor.

Ron
04-11-2013, 05:52 PM
Verily, I jest not, his post even had the word carburetor in it!!

And don't call me Shirley I was thinking about the "that are not so active on here" part....
:hss: