View Full Version : One car on two Insurance Policies?
Dangermouse
05-14-2013, 03:24 PM
As I mentioned in another thread, I have two youthful drivers that will shortly be added to my auto policy for two daily drivers. This will, in effect, triple my insurance costs. One way to reduce this cost is to add a third and even a fourth car to my “fleet”. Four cars and four drivers would result in at least a 10% reduction, assuming the 3rd and 4th cars are liability only.
Rather than actually buy another car, and its associated extra space and maintenance/tax issues, I am looking at my D. It is presently insured on an agreed value collector car policy with different company. Is it possible to legally add it to my main car policy as a 4th car, liability only, in addition to my collector policy?
I have googled this and there seems to be split opinion, between yes and no, with many claiming it would be Insurance Fraud to hold two policies, and others that it would be Insurance Fraud just to make duplicate claims for the same car.
I have a much higher opinion of members here than those on Yahoo Answers, so I bring it here.
I can have two life insurance policies, I can have primary and secondary medical insurance, so can I have two auto policies on the same car?
http://www.insure.com/car-insurance/stacking.html
Dangermouse
05-14-2013, 04:05 PM
Well, there's a website I haven't seen before and one I need to read cover to cover. Thanks Ron!!
Roman Legion
05-14-2013, 04:15 PM
Your insurance thread got me thinking about how much insurance will cost when I get my D or if progressive even insures them. I went to get a quote online, but it doesn't seem to list the Delorean under 1981 makes. Why must insurance be so irritating? :angry_whip:
refugeefromcalif
05-14-2013, 07:48 PM
Your insurance thread got me thinking about how much insurance will cost when I get my D or if progressive even insures them. I went to get a quote online, but it doesn't seem to list the Delorean under 1981 makes.
I did the same online search with Allstate, (And others), when I was planning on buying my D. No luck, No such vehicle found under DeLorean, much less any year.
I finally called my Allstate agent and ask if they would insure a DeLorean. He told No Problem.
CALL your agent and see what they have to say. You might be surprised and, hopefully Not disappointed if they'll cover it. (Depending on the value you want to cover it at).
George
Two things:
1) I've heard it both ways, some insurance companies allow cars to be placed into two policies, even in two different companies, whereas others do not. It may be in the verbage provided with each policy, although I do not know offhand of a way to get said verbage without actually issuing a policy or working for the company in question. There are actually services that exist which can run automated checks on each applicant to see if they already have insurance for any vehicles instantaneously, and provide information on coverages, number of claims, known vehicles at the specified address, etc., so you can't always trust that omitting that information will prevent them from knowing about it. (These services are regulated and require a legal insurance entity to view, so they're not available to everyone.) Your best bet is, as George said, to call your agent and ask them. If they do not know the specifics, they will call their respective companies and do the legwork for you to figure that all out. If you don't have an agent, you'll need to do your own legwork.
2) Insuring is one thing, but claims is another. If insured under two companies, filing a claim under only one of them is no problem at all. Filing a claim with more than one company is where it gets tricky. If the total payout is less than the combined limits for both companies, then one of them isn't going to pay full price, which makes for a fun week spent playing phone tag with cuss words at work, figuring out who gets shafted :swear1: Do yourself a huge favor: if you know and have written documentation (important for claims) that they allow vehicles to be insured under two policies, make the more expensive policy as bare-bones as you can coverage-wise, getting the state minimum limits, and set the policy with the other company up to have the coverages you really want. This will save you a lot of headaches and will ensure that you still save money with the bare-bones policy, but are still covered under the full-fledged policy.
Dangermouse
05-16-2013, 09:18 AM
In my scenario, I would continue with my agreed-value collector policy and then add the car as a 4th car, liability only, on my main auto policy. Any future claims would be through the collector policy only. If this is permitted, and depending on my other car selections on my main policy, I could potential save a $ amount on my main policy comparable to my entire collector's policy premium, essentially making my D policy free.
I am presently making my agent do all the legwork, and I have run a bunch of options past her (heck, I've paid them enough over the years :) )
If adding cars brings your rate down, maybe all you need is a little creativity...and a good neighbor. :drummer:
In my scenario, I would continue with my agreed-value collector policy and then add the car as a 4th car, liability only, on my main auto policy. Any future claims would be through the collector policy only. If this is permitted, and depending on my other car selections on my main policy, I could potential save a $ amount on my main policy comparable to my entire collector's policy premium, essentially making my D policy free.
I am presently making my agent do all the legwork, and I have run a bunch of options past her (heck, I've paid them enough over the years :) )Very good! Let us know how it works out :)
NightFlyer
05-17-2013, 02:26 PM
Your insurance thread got me thinking about how much insurance will cost when I get my D or if progressive even insures them. I went to get a quote online, but it doesn't seem to list the Delorean under 1981 makes. Why must insurance be so irritating? :angry_whip:
Progressive was the first insurer I used for my D - but only because I wasn't old enough to utilize one of the collector/specialty car insurance providers (ie: Hagerty, Grundy, etc). Back in 2003, for a 24 year old male with an impeccable driving record, it was $660/6 months for regular full coverage on the D through Progressive.
Best price I've found recently is an declared/agreed value policy from State Farm - $90/year for regular full coverage at a declared/agreed value of $25,000. Thinking about upping my declared value.
NightFlyer
05-17-2013, 02:34 PM
I can have two life insurance policies, I can have primary and secondary medical insurance, so can I have two auto policies on the same car?
Short/simple answer: unless there is a state law forbidding it, you can do whatever the insurance company is willing to do for you.
Short/simple answer: unless there is a state law forbidding it, you can do whatever the insurance company is willing to do for you.Good point, it may actually vary by state, so if they allow it in this instance, they may not in another, and vice versa. Good to know for future reference :)
(By the way, life insurance more or less pays you money in general without regards to what it's spent on, whereas vehicle insurance will only pay for specific things relating to any claims you have -- e.g. accident repair, new vehicles, liability -- which have set prices that the insurance company pays for. Getting more money for a life insurance policy doesn't matter since the money can be used towards anything, whereas getting more money for an auto claim means you're making a profit on having an accident, which depending on jurisdiction may constitute insurance fraud. The money is intended to cover damages to your auto, not giving you a surplus of it. Food for thought :) )
NightFlyer
05-18-2013, 02:16 AM
The only issue that I could foresee is that most vehicle insurance policies contain "other insurance" clauses (in fact, I'm not personally aware of any that don't), whereby the policy is only actually effectuated after the other policy(ies) covering the same vehicle (if one(s) exists) have paid out to its limits first. Some companies' clauses go so far as to void the policy all together if other insurance is effective, under a fraud in the inducement theory.
In a scenario where you have two different companies insuring the same car with two distinct and separate policies, both with standard "other insurance" clauses, each company would call for the other company to pay out on its policy first up to the actual losses realized / damages incurred before the other policy would become effective and kick-in. This results in massive litigation and legal fees incurred between the two insurance companies and policy holder to resolve, thus the reason that many companies have adopted the void (and voidable) clause(s).
Under no circumstances would one be allowed to ever legally profit from an auto accident, no matter how many policies they had or premiums they were paying.
In a battle between the insurers scenario, most jurisdictions that I'm aware of would first determine whether or not there was any fraud intended by the policies' holder. If yes, then the policies' holder will more likely than not end up facing criminal charges in addition to having to pay the insurance companies' legal costs and fees. If not, then the policies' holder would have to pay both deductibles and the court will order that each insurance provider cover 1/2 of the claims found to have merit, or according to the percentage of coverage offered by the competing policies if they are different.
Now, one might ask how an insurance provider would know about the existence of a second (or third, etc) policy with another company. Usually they won't unless you make a claim(s) with the separate companies over the course of your ownership of the vehicle with multiple policies. In states requiring proof of insurance in order to register a vehicle, they can also check the state registration records.
So, if you were going to do something like this, I would suggest only ever using one policy to satisfy proof of insurance registration requirement and that same policy under which to make all claims.
However, if you were going to do this, I'd have to ask WHY and to what benefit?
Best advise is to consult your insurance agent and be fully upfront about all your intentions with them. Also, shopping around doesn't hurt either and don't be afraid to pit insurer against insurer in looking for the best value for your dollar.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.