Log in

View Full Version : NBC News - Used Fisker Karma EV's are the new DeLorean as prices tumble



Rich W
05-14-2013, 04:50 PM
NBC News Business Article:

http://www.nbcnews.com/business/used-fisker-karma-evs-are-new-delorean-prices-tumble-1C9916866

Mark D
05-14-2013, 05:11 PM
Definitely some interesting parallels there.

thirdmanj
05-14-2013, 05:18 PM
I'm gonna get the jump on this... www.fkarmatalk.org

DMCVegas
05-15-2013, 12:07 AM
A greater DeLorean connection would be the fact that DMCH was bidding on the Delaware plant where Fisker builds/was building cars. They were going to take over GM's Kappa platform and badge engineer the Pontiac Solstice/Saturn Sky into a new "DeLorean" car. Can't say that there wouldn't have been any governmental financial assistance, but if there was it would have been much less than what Fisker got for EV funding. They also would have kept plant tooling the same, and most likely have retained as least *some* of GM's staff for the existing production line.

I don't however think that the Fisker Karma's story as a car will have as happy of an ending as the DMC-12's. Store a Karma and a DMC-12 side by side for 10, 20, 30, 40 years or so and see which one is cheaper to get back into the road. Along with the typical restoration items for any car that has been dormant, a PRV like any ICE just needs a fuel system clean up and it's ready to go. The Karma on the other hand needs new Lithium Ion batteries. Even with regular use, Li-Ion cells eventually are consumed and become useless. That being said:


What is the NOS Part situation with Fisker?
What is the replacement price on batteries?
Can generic Li-Ion batteries be substituted?


Even guys with Trailer Queens who never drive their cars like the idea of being able to whenever they want to. What is going to stop any Fisker from winding up as nothing more than a lump of automotive art in a museum? Once you answer that, you'll realize the collectability status and the long-term desirability of the car.

Rich
05-15-2013, 01:59 AM
Picking up on the NOS parts question just above.

The answers to two key questions will determine the fate of current and future Karma owners, same as it was in our case.

1. Did Fisker suspend production with a boatload of unused parts and unfinished cars that can feed the spares supply for some good long time to come?

2. Will a good number of those leftovers and maybe even some tooling or software, as well as documentation, be scooped up by one or two entities so there can be some order in the marketplace eventually and not a free-for-all on eBay for scraps of this and that? If there's a bankruptcy there will be an auction, so there will be a chance for consolidation.

Later on there could be vendors like ours and a support community but without something like the parts and consolidation situations that evolved after DMC Ltd went away that won't matter.

All the battery issues are important, too, adding a complication that almost no car collectors have to deal with.

Starglider
05-15-2013, 02:07 AM
Can generic Li-Ion batteries be substituted?

Yes, but it would be a significant engineering project to make them work properly/safely/reliably. A homegrown or small vendor project would almost certainly lose a good chunk of capacity due to less efficient packaging and less optimised software. Although if battery technology continutes to improve their should eventually be viable options with more capacity than the original.

NightFlyer
05-15-2013, 05:02 AM
Personally, I do not find the Karma to be "the most drop-dead gorgeous car that there is."

Body wise, it's essentially a 4 door Corvette Stingray with a trunk, a mutilated BMW front end clip, and a modified Aston Martin rear clip. Actually, I find it to be quite ugly.

I prefer Giugiaro and Bertone wedge designs - but that's just me. Maybe I'm just stuck in the '70's/'80's.

Starglider
05-15-2013, 09:28 AM
Personally, I do not find the Karma to be "the most drop-dead gorgeous car that there is."

Standard marketing strategy; repeat it over and over until the media parrots you and consensus makes it an 'obvious truth'.

Michael
05-15-2013, 09:33 AM
Fisker actually did a great job..until the government stopped pumping taxpayer money into it and it's time to stand on their own two feet.

There is your parallel with DeLorean

NightFlyer
05-15-2013, 02:21 PM
Fisker actually did a great job..until the government stopped pumping taxpayer money into it and it's time to stand on their own two feet.

There is your parallel with DeLorean

http://www.deloreancarshow.com/jzd/jzd01.htm

"In it's (sic) first six months in business, the last half of 1981, DMC earned 26,500,000.00 and was earning $5,000,000.00 per month when it was closed by Thatcher's government (see Authur Anderson audit accounts, a public record)."

According to John, DMC actually had the ability to be profitable. In a conspiracy theory kind of way, he blamed the conservative Thatcher government for shutting him down due to political gamesmanship with the rival liberal democrat / labor party.

That really doesn't make sense though - if John was being truthful/honest, then he should have been able to use the profit / "millions in cash in the bank, two years of dealer orders on the books and great public acceptance" to keep DMC going, or at the very least more private investors would have showed up at the door begging him to take their money. He also could have put more of his own money into his company. It also doesn't help that the accounting firm that John relies upon for evidence of DMC's financial success was severely corrupt and eventually dissolved in the wake of the Enron scandal.

As it was, weren't many dealers having trouble just selling the cars left on their lots towards the end at cost (with no profit)?

So yes, the Fisker tale does indeed sound very similar to that of DMC.