View Full Version : Anyone following the motorcycle VS SUV story in NY?
Michael
10-04-2013, 02:29 PM
Looks like this is going to be a pretty big rally call for all diehard motorcyclists. Bikers are banning together in support of this group that was having an "innocent" ride. It turns out this group was trying to close off the highway by blocking all traffic so they would have a clean stretch of road to stunt on. I guess one or two of them learned the hard way not to use your 400lb bike to try and muscle a 3500lb SUV around.
The video clearly shows one sportbike forcing his way into the SAME LANE the SUV was in an attempt to "move him around". The SUV maintained his lane so the sportbike got in front of him and slowed down causing himself to get rear ended and his leg broken(according to reports). This was when everyone stopped, the SUV as well as most all the cyclists. The video does not show what happened next, but according to the driver, the cyclists were turning into a mob and became aggressive. This was when the SUV driver decided his life and that of his family was in danger and got the hell out of there...running over at least one cyclist and bike blocking his path and paralyzing him.
I am not sure if his tires were slashed at this point or later on, but for some reason he stopped again after a few minutes of being chased where someone tried to drag him out of the car...and he again fled for his life. Finally he was forced to stop due to his tires and traffic and was dragged out of the car and beaten within an inch of his life.
Unbelievable turn of events here but being this guy was on his one year wedding anniversary with his wife and child...I have a hard time believing he was anything but an innocent bystander forced into a corner by a bunch of thugs, and he reacted. No charges are expected to be filed against the SUV driver, and a few cyclists have already been arrested, and a few more are being sought after.
Anyone who sides with the cyclists on this one are just blind to common sense.
ssaleen
10-04-2013, 02:42 PM
I think he should of hit them all. A group of dumbshits that because there was like 100 of them think they are bad ass's, if it was only one or a couple nothing ever would of happened. we don't need those kinds of people around.
louielouie2000
10-04-2013, 03:00 PM
When the story first broke, it appeared the motorcyclists were the victims. Having been nearly run down by many a distracted or aggressive driver while on my motorcycle, I immediately sided with the bikers. I can't tell you how many times I've been merged into on the freeway on my way to work. Almost always, it's due to a distracted and/or overly aggressive SUV driver (Prius drivers are the worst, though). Sometimes I wish I carried a crow bar with me to bash out the windows of those who almost kill me by not paying attention. For obvious reasons I don't do this, though. :biggrin:
Since the story has broken the tables have turned & it has become clear that the motorcyclists were in fact the aggressors. I've even read articles where this particular biker gang's behavior is starting to become a trend. It's pretty unfortunate when there are so many of us who are responsible, law abiding riders. Jerks like these probably endanger the rest of us on the road by causing automobile drivers to fear, and become even more aggressive with us.
DMCVegas
10-04-2013, 03:13 PM
The video in question that everyone keeps citing is the one that is left online. Lots of other videos were posted previously and then deleted that depicted the crap that the bikers were pulling. Driving on sidewalks, you name it. But not before others made copies and the uploaded them for preservation.
There are many different shots, but here's the first:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qk2LeimVOG0#t=31
Also the rider in question who was paralyzed has a suspended license until 2017.
Dangermouse
10-04-2013, 03:37 PM
I have no sympathy for the first dude who brake checked the RR and got hit. Karma right there.
Second guy with more serious injuries is trickier. If you believe the bikers, he was innocent and was just helping the first guy to safety. Is he really paralyzed? His family says so, but neither the doctors, police or hospital have confirmed. He has now hired Gloria Allred as his attourney (lucky he had her card in his pocket, eh?), so he will no doubt get a six figure sum from the RR drivers insurance company, irrespective of his "license legality" status at the time.
The bikers-fans are jumping all over the RR driver, saying he had other choices, which is all fine and dandy when you are sitting at your computer with a latte in your hand. Surrounded by angry guys trying to get in your car for who knows what intention, with your wife and toddler inside and all bets are off. Protecting your family comes first, and while I feel for the guy in the hospital bed, I look at all the other video of that mob and you just knew someone was going to get badly hurt.
DMCVegas
10-04-2013, 03:42 PM
Second guy with more serious injuries is trickier. If you believe the bikers, he was innocent and was just helping the first guy to safety.
Except for the fact that his driving privileges were revoked until 2017 in his home state, and he never even had a motorcycle endorsement. Seeing as how he shouldn't even have been there in the first place, and was illegally as such twice over, I'm sure that will give the insurance companies a loophole to getting out of responsibility.
sdg3205
10-04-2013, 04:18 PM
I've been a motorcyclist longer than I've been driving cars. I'm constantly embarrassed and enraged by the actions of other bikers. I can't tell you how many times I see bikers take advantage of their size, speed or critical mass to break the law and suit their "needs" only to complain constantly when drivers of other vehicles don't see them. "Not seeing" them is the least of their worries when they act like fucking morons, and this pack of riders are exactly that.
andyd
10-04-2013, 05:31 PM
I've been a motorcyclist longer than I've been driving cars. I'm constantly embarrassed and enraged by the actions of other bikers. I can't tell you how many times I see bikers take advantage of their size, speed or critical mass to break the law and suit their "needs" only to complain constantly when drivers of other vehicles don't see them. "Not seeing" them is the least of their worries when they act like fucking morons, and this pack of riders are exactly that.
SDG, I absolutely agree. I am also an avid motorcyclist, and ride daily into London (UK). Sadly I no longer really ride for pleasure, just so I dont have to use public transport. It's just too economical and conveniant not too. (Not to say I dont enjoy it, I do, but this is a by-product of its practicality).
I hadn't heard of that incident at all over here.
But those guys are idiots! You slow down deliberately in front of a "Chelsea tractor" to make your point??! You're absolutely coming off! Legally in the right (technically), or otherwise.
And (IMHO) the reason (over here) people drive SUV's is because "might has right". I understand that perhaps the RR is not such a big vehicle over your side of the pond, but its a damn sight bigger than a CBR!! (Or whatever you ride, wearing jeans, and your badass black visor, and watch over your shoulder as the guy takes you off!!! :icon_smile_duh: )
Thats point one.
And the Mob Rule stuff afterwards??!! WTF?!! As Dermot said, family, fear, 200 angry guys??!! GTFO of the situation!! I'm with the SUV guy. All the way.
andy
DeLorean03
10-04-2013, 05:49 PM
This kind of situation is why you make sure you know where your local police station is. If I had been the driver, I'd either have known that or purposefully done something a bit extreme to get people calling the cops to come to me.
Sad to see this stuff. Worst case sceanrio: CWPs are worth their money. Too bad this happened in NY. That's as far as I'm commenting on this one.
Kenny_Z
10-04-2013, 06:38 PM
I'm surprised at how much attention this is getting. It is definitely not helping the public image of bikers. It's unfortunate since most of the outrage at what this group of bikers did is coming from the motorcycle community. Maybe it will make people more aware of motorcycles on the road.
I do not blame the SUV driver at all. He was protecting his family. I can't imagine what was going through his mind knowing he had a toddler in the car and felt trapped by a group he perceived as aggressive.
Michael
10-04-2013, 07:02 PM
Alright...everyone agrees with me...this is how it should always be
It's hard to follow the mindset some of these riders seem to have. I have been riding since the mid 90's and have put around 100k on two wheels. One thing you live by on a bike....100% defense 0% offense...100% of the time. Just a few weeks ago a guy here was on a Sunday ride when a civic crossed the center line and hit him head on...he was decapitated. The woman driving the civic was most likely texting or something stupid. This happened on a two lane country rd that has a speed limit of 45, and these idiots are actually trying to play macho with a freaking Land Rover on a 3 lane highway? ...how's that working out for ya anyway?
dmcjohn
10-04-2013, 08:19 PM
Sad to see this stuff. Worst case sceanrio: CWPs are worth their money. Too bad this happened in NY. That's as far as I'm commenting on this one.
If the driver was allowed to have a concealed weapon, the bikers would have too. I can't imagine any scenario where the presence of guns would have somehow improved the situation. That's as far as I will also comment!
I agree with everyone's assessment that the driver was not at fault, must have been a horrible situation to find himself in.
John
DeLorean03
10-04-2013, 08:30 PM
If the driver was allowed to have a concealed weapon, the bikers would have too. I can't imagine any scenario where the presence of guns would have somehow improved the situation. That's as far as I will also comment!
I agree with everyone's assessment that the driver was not at fault, must have been a horrible situation to find himself in.
John
What you're stating is not fact. The two are completely mutually exclusive.
How about this: if he did and they didnt - well - I could see how things would prolly have played out differently.
"If..."
We'll PM it from here if you want to talk some more.
dmcjohn
10-04-2013, 09:27 PM
You now have a PM on the topic!
Michael
10-04-2013, 10:50 PM
This just keeps getting more and more disgusting:
Citing a number of law enforcement sources, the Post reports the unidentified “narcotics officer” came forward on Wednesday night, four days after the beating that left Alexian Lien bloodied on the ground as his family watched in horror from their black Range Rover.
“It is does not appear that he got involved at the scene,” one law enforcement source said of the off-duty cop.
Another source told the Post he “didn’t want to blow his cover.” But he was apparently not investigating the group of bikers that he was with.
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/10/04/report-off-duty-undercover-cop-stood-by-as-angry-bikers-beat-ny-dad-in-front-of-family/
Dangermouse
10-05-2013, 08:03 AM
Reading what Ms Allred said yesterday, and I doubt she is doing this pro-bono, she is sniffing around and laying the groundwork for a suit. Surprise, surprise. She is muddying the waters about the injured bikers legality - all this "he wasn't on his bike when he was hit by the RR "at top speed" ". Really, he was hit by a 5000lb vehicle at 155 mph+? Stirring the emotions somewhat there, I think.
But thinking about it last night, the real instigator of the whole thing was the first biker who brake checked the RR. There is a direct chain of events between him choosing to slow dramatically in front of the RR and his Kruz buddy getting run over. No one is saying that he (the first biker) had other choices, such as not being such a dick. Will Allred go after him and his bike insurance, or the RR owners presumably deeper pockets? Mmmm, that's a tough one.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.