View Full Version : Health Insurance BS. (Not ACA related)
Ikeaboy1
11-10-2013, 05:50 PM
I've been fortunate that the overwhelming majority of my life has been without the need for health care services. But in the last few months I've had some issues arise that required hospitalizations, medications, screenings, etc. A nasty business, being sick. Fortunately, I've been patched back up and worse case is that I have a manageable condition, best case is that I have nothing and it was a hell of a fluke. They're still trying to decide. But I'll be ok, either way.
So then comes my insurance. Carefirst, for those interested. To cut to the chase, even though the hospital where I sought emergency treatment accepts my insurance, the doctors operating within the ER do not. The scans, blood work was covered. But the actual doctor was not. To the tune of $1,600 or so. Fortunately, the doctors agreed this was BS and accepted what little carefirst was willing to pay and let me walk away.
After my hospitalization and discharge, I was ordered to follow up with a specialist for a diagnostic surgery. Called the insurance. Yep, that surgeon is a participant. Had the surgery. Surprise! The anesthesiologist operating there was not a participant. Another $1,600. This time, they didn't offer to pay a dime. The surgery is covered, but I was supposed to be awake, evidently. So I'll be making some phone calls tomorrow.
Anyone have any experience with this sort of BS? Now that I've been burned, I know to watch out for it. But damn, what a scam this feels like.
Spittybug
11-10-2013, 06:21 PM
This happens all the time. It's "the game" that the doctors and the insurance companies play. It doesn't take too many out of network bills like that for a doctor to make up for the lower amounts he gets from the prearranged insurance contracts.
Really the only thing you can do is get it in writing prior to going in for surgery. Make it very clear on the forms they make you sign that you are only authorizing the "use" of facilities, labs and contractors that accept your insurance. WRITE IT. Make it their problem up front. The check in people don't want to have you go elsewhere since it is a competitive business. Get copies of what you sign. So, when the inevitable occurs and you get bills that your insurance company denies, you have proof. At that point, give them a copy of such and tell them point blank that you aren't paying. Also include the cease and desist language so that can't bother you without a damned good reason.
I am writing requesting that you stop contacting me by phone.
According to the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, [15 USC 1692c] Section 805(c): CEASING COMMUNICATION: You must cease all communication with me after being notified in writing that I no longer wish to communicate with you.
Therefore, I demand that you stop calling me at home, work, or any location. Also, you are forbidden to contact any third party contacts. Doing so may result in legal action against you.
In accordance with the federal FDCPA, now that you have received this "stop calling" letter, you may only contact me to inform me that you are terminating further collection efforts which I will only accept in writing.
Be advised that I am well aware of my rights and I know that any future contact by you or your company violates Section 805(b)2 of the FDCPA.
Sincerely
For your current situation, just write and tell them that you did not authorize their use. PUSH BACK. Keep copies of all of your attempted resolutions with them. They know how difficult and costly it is to try and sue you for it. They will try and negotiate a lower number with you. Then they will sell the receivable and an agency will try to collect from you with threatening letters. Send them the same cease letter. Don't forget your surgeon that IS in network..... his office knows damned well the anesthesiologists aren't. You contracted with HIM for the surgery, who he subs out to is HIS responsibility.
You never really "win" in these situations, but I have been 100% successful in not paying such bullshit. They just count on you to roll over and pay up. Don't. None of this of course exonerates you from your deductible or other legitimate co-pay.
dmcerik
11-11-2013, 12:04 PM
In 2009 I was hospitalized with H1N1 Swine Flu for 4 days. Every doctor that visited me billed me. I think I had 5 different doctors stop by to do one thing or another. I didn't really have a clue what was going on since I was just trying not to die at that point. For around 6 months after I got out of the hospital I was still getting bills in the mail from different doctors. But my actual hospital stay was "covered". Instead of $22,000 for my plush 4 day stay I only paid $2000.
When I look back at all the insurance crap I'm just thankful that I can look back.
Erik
sdg3205
11-11-2013, 01:32 PM
I must say its stories like these that make me so happy to have Canadian universal health care.
It's NOT a perfect system by any stretch, but it sure is nice knowing you won't be billed when you walk out, or having to choose between two treatments based on cost or coverage. I'm lucky in that I don't typically get sick (flus and colds etc, but when I do, I get really sick (or badly injured) and end up at the hospital.
rddmc
11-11-2013, 03:01 PM
I've been fortunate that the overwhelming majority of my life has been without the need for health care services. But in the last few months I've had some issues arise that required hospitalizations, medications, screenings, etc. A nasty business, being sick. Fortunately, I've been patched back up and worse case is that I have a manageable condition, best case is that I have nothing and it was a hell of a fluke. They're still trying to decide. But I'll be ok, either way.
So then comes my insurance. Carefirst, for those interested. To cut to the chase, even though the hospital where I sought emergency treatment accepts my insurance, the doctors operating within the ER do not. The scans, blood work was covered. But the actual doctor was not. To the tune of $1,600 or so. Fortunately, the doctors agreed this was BS and accepted what little carefirst was willing to pay and let me walk away.
After my hospitalization and discharge, I was ordered to follow up with a specialist for a diagnostic surgery. Called the insurance. Yep, that surgeon is a participant. Had the surgery. Surprise! The anesthesiologist operating there was not a participant. Another $1,600. This time, they didn't offer to pay a dime. The surgery is covered, but I was supposed to be awake, evidently. So I'll be making some phone calls tomorrow.
Anyone have any experience with this sort of BS? Now that I've been burned, I know to watch out for it. But damn, what a scam this feels like.
First determine whether you signed a permission form for that particular anesthesiologist to treat you, my guess is that you did. If you did not, you likely have a stronger case to negotiate down the charges. If you gave written permission, request in writing that some financial consideration be given and request that a payment plan be arranged for charges. The doctor would much prefer a lump sum payment to monthly payments.
Keep in mind that the doctor has sailed on this ship before and probably has a collection service retained to collect unpaid charges. These collection service gets a portion of the charges collected. Try to settle the issue before the charges are turned over to the collection agency. The collection service will try to get a court judgement which will then result in a payroll garnishment. Not good.
Good luck.
Rod
10921
Ikeaboy1
11-11-2013, 09:12 PM
Good advice, all. I appreciate it. I'm going to reach out to the anesthesiologist to see if we can come to
An agreement. Few things make me madder than when someone gets the best of me, but I have to keep it in perspective. Being sick made me appreciate being healthy more than I ever had. I'm a really lucky person.
And ACA has caused my plan to be canceled, too. It will terminate the end of this month. I'd rather not have the thread locked, so that's all I'll say regarding ACA .
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.