It's about time I chime in here. Though my opinion is well-known for being against BTTF cars, I will defend my reasons for thinking so, yet, I want to add two new points to this thread. First: my opinion.
I think that the conversions take a perfectly good car or, in some cases, excellent restoration candidate, and turns it into a joke.
Point #1: Most people don't remember the premiere of the DeLorean as a car and, instead, only know of the BTTF movies; since the last movie came out in 1991, that gives the films a decade of being relevant after the initial hype of the DeLorean died down. Since that defines their first exposure to the cars, you see more people viewing them as the BTTF time machine first and a real car second. As a result, the BTTF car appeals to their early memories and, in most cases, the reason that they wanted the car in the first place. Just look at the threads about people's first exposure or the reason they own DeLoreans. How many of those stories involve lusting over the car in the movie? That's why there's such a surge in people buying and creating "prop cars." If the going rate is around $50,000 for one, then it's not too out of line with a vintage muscle car. With regimes shifting and the auto industry failing to produce any other iconic machines that people could lust after in their childhood, they contribute to the destruction of functional DeLoreans.
Point #2: People are always apt to say that a prop car can be undone, but how many cars have you ever heard of being reverted to stock. It doesn't seem to matter if it's a good or a poor conversion, they tend to stay in that state as opposed to receiving the proper restoration that they needed that prompted their alteration in the first place.

