FRAMING JOHN DELOREAN - ON VOD
www.framingjohndeloreanfilm.com
-
Senior Member
Stuck gauges at 6:00 or 12:00
If you have been following some recent posts the problem of stuck gauges which require vibration to get them unstuck has come up again.
When I first designed my fuel gauge ECU I bought a spare set of gauges to use for testing and calibration. The new gauge would move very slowly from any large sensor change. After many hours of my use of this new gauge one day it seemed to loose all that slow movement and now responds instantly. The calibration did not change just the speed of the movement. I can peg that gauge at 12:00 or 6:00 and it never sticks. What I did today was look very closely at the needle and if I move the pointer to either 12:00 or 6:00 and drive it full (83 ohms) or empty (6 ohms) I can see the needle does overshoot to about the 12:00 or 6:00 position. I would need to do a fast video and slow it down to see the exact overshoot.
I'm guessing if that slow movement is only working a little it is the cause of the sticking needle. It must be mass of the needle and it's magnet causing the overshoot.
I was just thinking if there was anything I could do with my ECU to help or prevent this problem. Maybe set half full on the gauge before moving to the true sensor reading. That would reduce some of the momentum.
Last edited by Bitsyncmaster; Yesterday at 04:32 PM.
-
Dave,
My car has the original fuel pump and fuel sender. The fuel indicator needle will "stick" occasionally (usually about once a month). It sticks in the six o'clock position. A bump to the binnacle l will knock it free. My car has many of your products, but I unfortunately do not have your fuel gauge ECU. I?m trying to understand what is causing the needle to radically jump to empty such that its momentum carries it beyond the empty position and ultimately it gets stuck at 6 o?clock. In my mental model of the gauge it seems that the rapid removal of power might cause this. When the car is turned off there would be a quick voltage drop because of the other loads on that circuit. Likewise, when the car is started, the same drop occurs when the key is moved to crank the starter. Would you have an understanding of the gauge internals? My only experience is with older British Smith fuel gauges that use dual coils to position the needle. I have attached a simplified sketch of the circuit. As you can see a large capacitor has been shown in red. This was added to provide a dampening effect to active fuel senders (no baffles in these gas tanks). Note that it takes a large capacitance value to provide any significant dampening. When this is done, not only is the movement dampened, but the fuel needle on the Smiths gauge moves slowly to the empty position when power is removed. I know the DeLorean gauge works differently, but do you think that putting a similar capacitor on the DeLorean fuel sender could prevent the stuck needle syndrome?
Ron
Fuel gauge smoothing super capacitor.JPG
Last edited by DMC-Ron; Today at 07:02 AM.
-
Senior Member
Good idea to check on power off. I just checked with 6 ohms on sender turning the 13.5 volts off and the needle does not move at all. Now with 83 ohms it does move a little from full to a little under full. This is just using stock resistance on my fast moving bench gauge.
My guess a large capacitor would drive a little voltage backwards into the loads on gauge green power wire. I just tested driving 2.5 volts backwards. That would also drive the other coil in the gauge since they are internally connected inside the gauge. That 2.5 volts (reversed) does drive the gauge to 6:00. On my bench gauge after the voltage is removed the gauge will move back to a little below empty after a few seconds. I don't want to try a higher reverse voltage for fear of damage to my bench gauge.
If someone has a large capacitor connected on their car, they could comment if the gauge moves to 6:00 when they turn the key off. I think a normal gauge with the slow movement my not see much change turning the key off.
I will run some of these tests with my ECU driving the gauge.
Edit:
Just tested with my ECU and it does bounce my fast bench gauge on power up and power off.
In my car it bounces on power up but none on power off.
Don't know if I should fix that power up bounce. Maybe that prevents the stuck gauge. I've not heard any complaints yet.
Last edited by Bitsyncmaster; Today at 08:37 AM.
-
Senior Member
My bench test was incorrect. I was just removing the power to the ECU. Removing and applying both it bounces on power up and no bounce on power off.
Now most people run the ECU power on the fuel pump power so my testing does not do that. I run my ECU on the same power as the gauges.
I added a software change to set half gauge on power up. Not sure if I will incorporate that change into new units.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules