View Full Version : Suspension Warning: Heninger & Associates Lower Ball Joint Failure
Drive Stainless
09-30-2016, 11:17 PM
This message is from Bill Robertson, which I've agreed to post on his behalf since it concerns safety:
Byrne Heninger installs Volkswagen Beetle/Bug ball joints in his lower control arms. They are high quality ball joints, Made in Germany, that a Volkswagen mechanic friend of mine is familiar with and has used himself (Uro Parts). There is absolutely nothing wrong with the quality of Byrne's ball joints -- problem is their orientation. As Byrne installs them there is high likelihood they eventually break. It's not a question of "if" -- it's a question of "when" (my "when" happened this morning, fortunately at slow speed in my own neighborhood within walking distance of the service truck).
VW Beetle/Bug front suspensions are very different from our front suspensions. Control arms point towards the front of the car, not the sides of the car. VW ball joints are directional -- the ball is only captive on two sides. There is very little movement towards the captive sides, and tremendous movement towards the non-captive sides (nothing holding the ball). Orientation notches indicate, *ON A VOLKSWAGEN*, front to rear. If you install a VW ball joint sideways *ON A VOLKSWAGEN* it will eventually break.
Byrne (or more likely a mechanic on Byrne's behalf) very dutifully installs his ball joints with the orientation notches front to rear, as all Volkswagen literature tells you to do. Problem is: our control arms are 90 degrees different from a Beetle/Bug. Orientation notches need to be rotated accordingly -- side to side. As supplied by Byrne, every time our suspension goes up and down the ball joint hits the part of the socket with very little movement. Eventually metal that holds the ball captive bends enough that the ball pops out and the joint separates, folding your wheel underneath the car. Problem is exacerbated by the fact that there is no metal on the other two sides to hold the ball.
I installed my replacement ball joint "sideways" by Volkswagen standards, which is "frontwards" for our control arms. After lunch I will pop out and rotate the other one.
Again: if you are running Volkswagen ball joints, and if the orientation notches are front to rear, your ball joints are experiencing undesigned stresses and likely will eventually separate.
Orientation notches should point along the axis of the control arm.
Volkswagen control arms point towards the front of the car, so their orientation notches should point front to rear.
Our lower control arms point towards the sides of the car -- orientation notches should point side to side.
Bill.
4641746418
FABombjoy
09-30-2016, 11:47 PM
My arms, which I believe were delivered slightly after Bills have the correct orientation.
It's a quick check that anybody with these LCAs should do immediately!
Chris 16409
10-01-2016, 03:11 AM
Can some one post a picture of our control arm with these VW ball joints installed correctly?
FABombjoy
10-01-2016, 09:40 AM
Can some one post a picture of our control arm with these VW ball joints installed correctly?
One blindly shot cellphone flash photo coming up:
46419
Notches pointing towards rotor = OK!
Jonathan
10-01-2016, 10:19 AM
This message is from Bill Robertson, which I've agreed to post on his behalf since it concerns safety:
Just a brief aside...
Why didn't Bill post this himself? Did I miss something? I might have been asleep at the wheel...
sdg3205
10-01-2016, 11:12 AM
Just a brief aside...
Why didn't Bill post this himself? Did I miss something? I might have been asleep at the wheel...
I was wondering where the captain had disappeared to as well.
Drive Stainless
10-01-2016, 06:41 PM
He said he is banned.
Rich_NYS
10-01-2016, 08:10 PM
He said he is banned.
Why for?
Soundkillr
10-01-2016, 10:24 PM
Bill is not banned, he is moderated. I only bring it up because he claimes he is banned (and knows better) Please move on from Bill Talk. Nothing to see here...
Patrick C
10-01-2016, 11:21 PM
The Heninger ball joints are installed correctly in 1880. I bought these arms back in February/March.
Chris 16409
10-02-2016, 02:25 AM
Since we are doing show and tell, I snapped a picture of mine too. Looks good:
46431
A Van
10-02-2016, 03:56 AM
Definitive ball joint information
http://www.deloreaneurotec.uk/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=2198&hilit=Ball+joint
The original designer of the suspension stated to me it has loading in all directions.
In the thread above it compares 3-4 different joints against stock, and certainly some VW do not fit properly, despite that they may look ok.
Apologies the thread is rather long, but it goes into great detail about the different joints.
Gregadeth
10-03-2016, 05:30 AM
My LCAs haven't been installed yet, but ball joints appear to be in correct orientation.
46452
Since we're on the topic of LCA/ball joints, I was wondering a couple of things:
1) Should there be a gap between the ball joint and the LCA pad? (see below pic) It looks like it may not be seated all the way in. Is there a clip that goes in this area?
2) The ball joint is really difficult to move by hand. Is it supposed to be this way, or could it be that it needs more grease added? There is no grease fitting though.
46453
Andrew
10-03-2016, 10:16 PM
Earlier tonight I confirmed that 5052's ball joints are the correct orientation. IIRC I purchased them in the summer of 2015.
A Van
10-04-2016, 09:52 AM
http://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161004/152ea8533597e270bffbabc0627f4f14.jpghttp://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161004/b6927a2fd523cecc2ca5d2154decfd24.jpghttp://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161004/92342ec91aee3d813040d5cf6e217136.jpg
spikeygg
10-04-2016, 11:28 AM
http://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161004/152ea8533597e270bffbabc0627f4f14.jpghttp://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161004/b6927a2fd523cecc2ca5d2154decfd24.jpghttp://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161004/92342ec91aee3d813040d5cf6e217136.jpg
Very interesting collection of data here. I just wish there were some verbiage here to explain what we're looking at... It seems to suggest that the DCMH version of the ball joint is superior to the VW one but there are no comments/explanation. Also, it looks like the DCMH ball joint in the photo has a nipple but none of the ones on peoples cars have the nipple. Is no one using the DCMH version?
Dangermouse
10-04-2016, 11:37 AM
You need to read the eurotec thread that Al referenced a few posts above this for all the detail.
spikeygg
10-04-2016, 11:46 AM
You need to read the eurotec thread that Al referenced a few posts above this for all the detail.
Ha-ha, I actually read the first page of it last week and I didn't realize that it was 24 paged long! I'm guessing that's what you are referring to...
FABombjoy
10-04-2016, 11:56 AM
Could someone with uninstalled Heninger arms confirm the taper dimensions?
Dangermouse
10-04-2016, 12:08 PM
Ha-ha, I actually read the first page of it last week and I didn't realize that it was 24 paged long! I'm guessing that's what you are referring to...
Yes, when those guys do research, the doooooooo research :)
jamesrguk
10-04-2016, 05:25 PM
I really don't understand why you would fit anything other that the DeLorean EuroTec ball joint which was researched and manufactured specifically for this application.
Skimp on some parts by all means but not on critical components such as this.
J
Mark D
10-04-2016, 05:37 PM
I really don't understand why you would fit anything other that the DeLorean EuroTec ball joint which was researched and manufactured specifically for this application.
Skimp on some parts by all means but not on critical components such as this.
J
I've been thinking exactly the same thing reading through this thread. At this point there's no other option that even comes close. The DMC EuroTec guys did their homework on this one and all the other crossover/modified parts are risky at best.
The VW joints in particular have the wrong taper height and the snap ring groove is an after the fact machining that doesn't have the proper amount of material supporting the snap ring. I started this thread (linked below) about 5 years ago right when the parts were becoming available. This particular post is the cliffs notes version of the 24 page EuroTec thread. I still recommend the full read if you're remotely interested in the amount of work that was done to make the ball joints possible.
http://dmctalk.org/showthread.php?2408-Ball-Joint-Discussion-Revisited&p=32567&viewfull=1#post32567
And again, many thanks to the guys who put in the R&D time and effort to have exact spec reproductions made.
spikeygg
10-04-2016, 07:42 PM
I've been thinking exactly the same thing reading through this thread. At this point there's no other option that even comes close. The DMC EuroTec guys did their homework on this one and all the other crossover/modified parts are risky at best.
The VW joints in particular have the wrong taper height and the snap ring groove is an after the fact machining that doesn't have the proper amount of material supporting the snap ring. I started this thread (linked below) about 5 years ago right when the parts were becoming available. This particular post is the cliffs notes version of the 24 page EuroTec thread. I still recommend the full read if you're remotely interested in the amount of work that was done to make the ball joints possible.
http://dmctalk.org/showthread.php?2408-Ball-Joint-Discussion-Revisited&p=32567&viewfull=1#post32567
And again, many thanks to the guys who put in the R&D time and effort to have exact spec reproductions made.
Nice work Mark. I read the 24 page one backward to get the jist and find the vendor but your post is very concise for others that want a recap.
tommyrich
10-05-2016, 01:28 PM
I really don't understand why you would fit anything other that the DeLorean EuroTec ball joint which was researched and manufactured specifically for this application.
I replaced my ball joints with the EuorTec ones last year. I did the research and reached the same conclusion. However, I remember that the process of obtaining the ball joints was not straightforward and they also took a long time (by spoiled Amazon Prime Customer Standards) before I received them (from Europe). That may have changed by now.
Tom
DeLoreanGo Arran
10-05-2016, 01:59 PM
Easy enough - just click here and press "buy": http://www.deloreanclub.uk/lower-ball-joints-pair.html
Everything is sent out same-day. If you opt for the cheapest service it can about 2 weeks to get to the USA, but if you opt for the quickest service, as many have, you could see them within 24 hours of ordering - I sent some 2 weeks ago to the US that got to the customer within 23 hours of ordering. Although granted, this is a little bit expensive if you are only ordering one thing, the "up to approx 2 week" service is fine for most.
We've sold a few hundred of these now.
tommyrich
10-05-2016, 07:41 PM
Easy enough - just click here and press "buy"
I was right, it is much easier now!
Thanks!
Tom
Ryan King
10-07-2016, 01:31 AM
VW ball joints are dangerous. Only way to go is through the DMC-UK guys. They did the research, and know what they're doing.
Learn from my experiences.
465144651546516
And...if you can afford it. Hire the Brits to come out and install them for you. :tongue_stick:
(Pictured - Dan Stacey & Alan Hammond)
465174651846519
Lwanmtr
10-07-2016, 07:52 AM
How does the ones from the Euroguys compare to what DMC has...or is that another NLA thing? Just curious in case I end up needing those when I get my suspension gone through up at DMCNW
PJ Grady Inc.
10-07-2016, 09:16 AM
I replaced my ball joints with the EuorTec ones last year. I did the research and reached the same conclusion. However, I remember that the process of obtaining the ball joints was not straightforward and they also took a long time (by spoiled Amazon Prime Customer Standards) before I received them (from Europe). That may have changed by now.
Tom
We stock the Euro-tech ball joints so you needn't have waited and could have saved the freight but who knew!
Rob
Mark D
10-07-2016, 09:35 AM
How does the ones from the Euroguys compare to what DMC has...or is that another NLA thing? Just curious in case I end up needing those when I get my suspension gone through up at DMCNW
DMCH and related vendors used to supply their own reproduction ball joints but those had a sketchy manufacturing process and high failure rate. More info about those ball joints in the thread I linked to above if you're interested. The old style DMCH reproduction ball joints can be identified by the multicolored heat discoloration on the body of the joint.
Shortly after the DMC EuroTec ball joints became available DMCH started carrying those instead. My guess is they scrapped their remaining stock of the failure prone parts. If you were to order from them now just be sure to ask and confirm you will be receiving the EuroTec parts.
As Rob noted above he also carries the good ones and I think DPI also uses them as well.
Patrick C
10-07-2016, 09:44 AM
VW ball joints are dangerous. Only way to go is through the DMC-UK guys. They did the research, and know what they're doing.
Learn from my experiences.
465144651546516
And...if you can afford it. Hire the Brits to come out and install them for you. :tongue_stick:
(Pictured - Dan Stacey & Alan Hammond)
465174651846519
Were these mounted incorrectly like Bill's? I could see that putting stress on them and snapping them if they couldn't move side-to-side.
DMCMW Dave
10-07-2016, 11:41 AM
As Rob noted above he also carries the good ones and I think DPI also uses them as well.
Yes - I concur that at this time, DMCH, DMCH-related shops, are all selling the same "UK" ball joint.
FABombjoy
10-07-2016, 12:16 PM
My LCAs haven't been installed yet, but ball joints appear to be in correct orientation.
Would you be able to measure the taper dimension of the joints in your uninstalled control arms?
A lot of this thread is predicated on the H&A arms having VW ball joints, but AFAIK that isn't 100% confirmed at this point.
FABombjoy
10-07-2016, 01:31 PM
We stock the Euro-tech ball joints so you needn't have waited and could have saved the freight but who knew!
Put 'em on the website! :spank:
Lwanmtr
10-07-2016, 04:39 PM
Great, Ill be sure to ask, but it sounds like I wouldnt be getting the bad stuff, so good news :)
Patrick C
10-07-2016, 08:20 PM
I brought this thread to Byrne Heninger's attention via email. His response was: "We have been using the ball joint configuration for over eight years. without incident. thank you for your interest. Byrne"
kenny
10-08-2016, 07:20 PM
I brought this thread to Byrne Heninger's attention via email. His response was: "We have been using the ball joint configuration for over eight years. without incident. thank you for your interest. Byrne"
As a mechanical engineer (who has nothing against ANY vendor) I am concerned about Byrnes reply, I know of the UK clubs research which has been done over a few years, and am shocked that he would not at least take an interest in it. His joints may well be fine but he should at least review the data....
Tillsy
10-10-2016, 07:45 AM
We stock the Euro-tech ball joints so you needn't have waited and could have saved the freight but who knew!
Rob
Exactly - so fix your website!
Say it loudly... say it proudly... our ball joints have nipples!
Patrick C
10-10-2016, 08:10 AM
I ended up buying a set of the UK ball joints last week from the U.K. club. The total cost for a PAIR was $97.13 including shipping. Not bad at all.
spikeygg
10-10-2016, 08:28 AM
I ended up buying a set of the UK ball joints last week from the U.K. club. The total cost for a PAIR was $97.13 including shipping. Not bad at all.
Lol, me too before the news came that everyone carries them. No one advertises that they have the "good UK built ones" so...
Patrick C
10-10-2016, 08:32 AM
Lol, me too before the news came that everyone carries them. No one advertises that they have the "good UK built ones" so...
The US vendors seem to be selling them for $89 EACH. Plus shipping. Basically a 100% markup compared to buying straight from the U.K. Club.
FABombjoy
10-10-2016, 11:00 AM
For posterity, these are how my H&A ball joints are sitting in the knuckle:
46595
There is no exposed taper - the hardware is flush with the knuckle. They have an allen key recess as opposed to the flats. Seems like the flats appear on the guaranteed to fail VW joints.
To be on the safe side I have a set of the Euro joints on the way but I'm not sure there is imminent danger with the currently installed units.
A Van
10-11-2016, 05:04 PM
It's what is inside the arm , the the taper lock is critical.
It depends if those balljoints are the same dimensions as OEM.
Which I very much doubt they are.
FABombjoy
10-11-2016, 11:37 PM
Further observations:
The ball joints on my car are made by Febi, marking "109", not sure if that means anything. A cursory search reveals nothing of interest.
I pushed down the rubber cover and there is no gap between the knuckle taper and balljoint. These units do not seem to match the "VW" balljoint cross section posted earlier. Maybe they are VW parts but they seem to be different.
Of the 4 ball joints given on the sheets, which is supposed to match the cross sectional drawing for "VW"? None of the given diameters seem to correlate to that drawing.
Darren C
10-12-2016, 06:26 AM
Ok Guy’s
This thread is painful to read.
There is only ONE option, and that is the OEM design joint; anything else on here is just Groundhog Day and frankly naive and placing you and other road users in danger.
Take the time to read the DeloreanEurotec thread in full, not just speed read and glance at the nice pictures. Everything you need to know is there to help you.
FABombjoy
10-12-2016, 10:37 AM
not just speed read and glance at the nice pictures
I think that is unnecessarily insulting.
Most people are aware of the Eurotec LBJs, and a few of us in this thread have already ordered a set, myself included. In my experience it is unwise to insult your customers and I would suggest choosing a more appropriate tone.
Nevertheless, that 24-page thread is far from comprehensive. Understandable given that a source for proper joint was located part-way through the analysis phase. But it is 5 years old and filled with off-topic banter, broken links / broken photos, etc.
While I am waiting for my replacement LBJs, I have a few remaining driving events for the season which fuels my own interest in analyzing the parts currently installed. I will continue to do so on my own and if any other H&A LCA owners wish to trade information, you are free to contact me privately.
Darren C
10-12-2016, 10:56 AM
This is why I don’t usually bother with posting on US forums.
If you take my genuine observations and comments as an insult when I’m trying to help you and others, what’s the point?
jwrayth
10-12-2016, 10:57 AM
There is only ONE option, and that is the OEM design joint; anything else on here is just Groundhog Day and frankly naive and placing you and other road users in danger.
I'm running reinforced OEM LCAs' and the Amsteer balljoints so really just an observer on this thread, but..
I think the only possible exception here is that since we are talking about aftermarket LCAs' has anyone measured/verified that Byrne had his manufactured the same as stock? If it's manufactured to a different spec then that would make for the case of using a different balljoint. Though there is no data on his LCA as detailed as the Eurotec balljoint review so it's a hypothetical point at best for now :)
Delorean Industries
10-12-2016, 11:08 AM
This is why I don’t usually bother with posting on US forums.
If you take my genuine observations and comments as an insult when I’m trying to help you and others, what’s the point?
Because America. We generally look down on the uk after bailing you guys out of back to back world wars.
FABombjoy
10-12-2016, 11:21 AM
If you take my genuine observations and comments as an insult when I’m trying to help you and others, what’s the point?
You have 2 posts now and I don't see any "genuine observations" that are scientifically relevant. Here is why you are insulting:
This is why I don’t usually bother with posting on US forums.
What's the implication here? Can you explain why this wouldn't be taken negatively?
This thread is painful to read.
Why painful? Can you contribute in a useful manner that isn't referencing a 5 year old 24-page rambling thread filled with occasional moments of scientific research?
Take the time to read the DeloreanEurotec thread in full, not just speed read and glance at the nice pictures.
Why do you think we (or I) haven't read it in full? Is it because we still have some questions surrounding our unique set of circumstances?
Here is what I see and why I continue to ask questions:
24-page Eurotech thread:
-5 years old
-Measurements featuring a small sampling of available LBJs which fit in OEM LCAs
-Information gathering phase halted once commercial unit located
This thread:
-Owners of non-OEM LCAs
-LCAs featuring LBJs which do not appear to conform to measurements given in the Eurotech thread
FABombjoy
10-12-2016, 11:24 AM
If it's manufactured to a different spec then that would make for the case of using a different balljoint. Though there is no data on his LCA as detailed as the Eurotec balljoint review so it's a hypothetical point at best for now :)
Yes, this is the issue. For better or for worse, Byrne works in a vacuum and we don't have the full details. 2 of us have Eurotech LBJs en route, so we will be able to answer the fitment issue soon. It is also possible that he has located a suitable cross-reference as the Eurotech thread is far from being a comprehensive study.
Darren C
10-12-2016, 11:53 AM
Luke Short and to the point.
1, If you have a non OEM LCA, you are reliant on the knowledge and skill of whoever made it, to ensure that it is fit for purpose.
2, Due to the design of the OEM ball joint and its method of operation, its resistance to forces in all directions, its lubrication and quality of material used; it follows that non OEM LCA’s SHOULD ONLY be made to accept the OEM joint only, unless $millions are invested in safety testing of an alternative joint.
3, Nice shiny ooooo and ahhhh response provoking non OEM LCA with god knows who’s ball joints fitted should be avoided at all costs.
4, The road to "Verschlimmbesserung" Hell is paved with good intention.
For the record, I say things as I see them. If I want to insult anyone I'll call them a C*nt directly. So please do not be offended so easily.
Delorean Industries
10-12-2016, 01:00 PM
Millions in safety testing? Measuring steering and suspension geometry is a cake walk here in the US. No less than 100 qualified ball joint manufactures in North Carolina alone in the racing industry will tell you exactly how and why a joint should be used. Not to mention how it will react under load with tons of real world testing. Plus of course simulated CAD load testing on top of that. Free source in most cases here.... This isn't rocket science......
FABombjoy
10-12-2016, 01:12 PM
For the record, I say things as I see them. If I want to insult anyone I'll call them a C*nt directly. So please do not be offended so easily.
BUT I don't actually know who you are, nor your credentials, and you seem to have a need to be taken at face value without question. Your tone is juvenile as was your private message declaring how bored you are with this conversation. Then its topped if off with "don't be offended so easily" aka blaming me for the fact that you don't know how to interact with people in a reasonable manner.
unless $millions are invested in safety testing of an alternative joint.
If this is true, what was the point of the first half of the Eurotech thread? A prelude to spending $millions when a candidate was found? I'm pretty sure if you worked for a major automotive company and requested "millions" for your ball joint budget you'd find yourself out on the street pretty quickly.
So again, anyone interested in LITERALLY MURDERING people with ball joints, please feel free to join me offline.
DMCVegas
10-12-2016, 02:09 PM
http://i1.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/164/809/WhoopsNo.gif
Chris 16409
10-12-2016, 02:18 PM
Yes, this is the issue. For better or for worse, Byrne works in a vacuum and we don't have the full details. 2 of us have Eurotech LBJs en route, so we will be able to answer the fitment issue soon. It is also possible that he has located a suitable cross-reference as the Eurotech thread is far from being a comprehensive study.
Luke let us know what you find. I am intersted to know if the UK ball joints even fit in Byrnne's arms. Back when I bought his arms I asked if I could buy them without balljoints so I could install the UK ones. He wouldn't sell them like that. I've driven my car for three years and 15,772 miles on Byrnne's arms. Knock on wood, I have not had a problem yet.
Ryan King
10-12-2016, 05:40 PM
Knock on wood, I have not had a problem yet.
You knocking on the parcel shelf?
A Van
10-12-2016, 06:12 PM
I'm running reinforced OEM LCAs' and the Amsteer balljoints so really just an observer on this thread, but..
I think the only possible exception here is that since we are talking about aftermarket LCAs' has anyone measured/verified that Byrne had his manufactured the same as stock? If it's manufactured to a different spec then that would make for the case of using a different balljoint. Though there is no data on his LCA as detailed as the Eurotec balljoint review so it's a hypothetical point at best for now :)
I don't think that's so much the issue James, the question is after the recent failure is whether the balljoint fitted in the Byrnes LCA fits the taper correctly in the OEM Upper Arm.
And whether rotation of the balljoint matters ( it doesn't)
And also another owner of Byrnes LCA raised the question of there being no snap ring in place.
Darren knows his stuff being ex NASA, ESA , Consultant at Bentley and now Rolls Royce
axh174
10-13-2016, 02:00 PM
Luke let us know what you find. I am intersted to know if the UK ball joints even fit in Byrnne's arms.
Chris, when you say "UK" ball joints, are you referring to the ones that deloreanclub.uk and delorean.eu sell, like these (http://www.delorean.eu/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=19_28_95&products_id=95018)?
If so, I bought a set of these alongside my Byrnne LCAs and they fit in just fine (well, technically one did. The other control arm has a ball joint hole that wasn't machined quite right and I had to Dremel off some flash to get the ball joint to press in fully).
Or am I misunderstanding your concern?
-Kevin
VIN2234
Chris 16409
10-13-2016, 02:13 PM
Chris, when you say "UK" ball joints, are you referring to the ones that deloreanclub.uk and delorean.eu sell, like these (http://www.delorean.eu/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=19_28_95&products_id=95018)?
If so, I bought a set of these alongside my Byrnne LCAs and they fit in just fine (well, technically one did. The other control arm has a ball joint hole that wasn't machined quite right and I had to Dremel off some flash to get the ball joint to press in fully).
Or am I misunderstanding your concern?
-Kevin
VIN2234
I was referring to the ones sold by the UK Club. Do we know what ball joints Ed is Selling? If I recall, he had reproduced his own.
Rich_NYS
10-13-2016, 02:19 PM
How many ball joints are there? Darren said there's only one option......
A Van
10-13-2016, 02:44 PM
Ed's are made to exact same specification , OEM dimensions
spikeygg
10-13-2016, 03:27 PM
I was referring to the ones sold by the UK Club. Do we know what ball joints Ed is Selling? If I recall, he had reproduced his own.
Ed's are made to exact same specification , OEM dimensions
Who is Ed?
Ryan King
10-13-2016, 04:37 PM
Who is Ed?
Ed Uding - DeLorean Europe.
DeLoreanGo Arran
10-13-2016, 06:26 PM
Chris, when you say "UK" ball joints, are you referring to the ones that deloreanclub.uk and delorean.eu sell, like these (http://www.delorean.eu/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=19_28_95&products_id=95018)?
Just to clarify - delorean.eu lower ball joints are not the same as deloreanclub.uk lower ball joints. And delorean.eu is not in the UK ;) - although granted, for a while they did sell the UK ball joint there too (not anymore).
The "good" ones referenced in this thread are the ones that we sell - known as the "UK balljoints" and "EuroTec balljoints". Sold by us ( http://www.deloreanclub.uk/lower-ball-joints-pair.html ), PJ Grady, DMCH, and Josh Bengston. Ed from DeLorean Europe did sell them for a while, but has now had his own made.
The others I know about are Hervey's - which are allegedly a VW cross reference that has been modified (and doesn't quite match dimensionally) - and the ones that DMCH used to sell but don't anymore (these were also made to OEM dimensions but were prone to premature failure). I don't think we've got to the bottom of whether the OP's ball joints are the same as Hervey's, but it seems possible to me that since the LCA is "different" to OEM, then the ball joint could be too.
How many ball joints are there? Darren said there's only one option......
Something lost in translation. By this he means his opinion there is "no other choice". His point being, of the 3 on the market at the moment, 1 is new to the market and the same price as the UK ones (or he's not aware of Ed's ones), and the other is a cross reference intended for a VW beetle.
chris williams
10-13-2016, 06:44 PM
Quote Originally Posted by Darren C View Post
There is only ONE option, and that is the OEM design joint; anything else on here is just Groundhog Day and frankly naive and placing you and other road users in danger.
I'm running reinforced OEM LCAs' and the Amsteer balljoints so really just an observer on this thread, but..
The US vendors seem to be selling them for $89 EACH. Plus shipping. Basically a 100% markup compared to buying straight from the U.K. Club.
Just to echo some of the above comments and give a bit of variety, I do think these are 'probably' the best ball joints out there for the OEM LCA's (cant comment on re-manufactured ones) but to try and help on the costs you can always buy them direct from the manufacturers as a lot of UK owners do by contacting the manufacturers direct, the details are on this link: http://www.deloreans.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?tid=3646
For added interest I had them make up a set of track rod ends (tie rods ends) as per a set of OE ones that I sent them and they also sell these now, as I believe are sold by other vendors also should you prefer to support them. Another great product very well made and deigned for the car as per original spec.
Chris
DeLoreanGo Arran
10-13-2016, 07:31 PM
to try and help on the costs you can always buy them direct from the manufacturers[/url]
Direct link: http://www.amsteer.co.uk/Delorean%20Car%20Parts/Delorean,%20AM381,%20Lower%20Balljoint
Although since that price is "per joint" and higher, it's only cheaper if you buy 1.... Most owners want 2, which is why we list them in pairs. Happy to sell them singly though should anyone want only 1...
We also stock the other 2 products that Amsteer do (track rod ends and upper ball joints), also at a lower price than buying direct.
Darren C
10-14-2016, 04:37 AM
Chris,
Please do not perpetuate your personal fued between DOC & Eurotec on this US based website.
Please do not quote me using cut and pasted quotes from other members that are not my words or opinions.
My comment on “only one choice” is in reference to an OEM specification joint in comparison to a joint with alternative dimension or design used in another vehicle that is similar but not exact, which is leading to possible failure.
As a dedicated Delorean owner working for the common good of all fellow owners, I spent many, many hours investigating these non OEM joint failures and by chance (part way through the investigation) and the help of other UK owners came across the original supplier. I dealt with their manufacture engineers, and they even found the original DMC drawings in their archive from which they had originally made the joints supplied to the factory.
With my help the joints were made again. I spent more hours testing the first joints and gave the thumbs up for them to be manufactured and supplied to Delorean owners regardless of what club or country they belong.
I am a fully paid up member of DOC and an active Eurotec member. It just happens that the key persons involved in bringing these OEM joints to the market are part of Eurotec club and this is the reason why they sell them.
Chris you are entirely free to sell these joints through DOC, but I do think that actively telling folks where the joints are made and encouraging owners to buy them from DOC (at a price that is not necessarily cheaper) and not from Eurotec is just sour grapes and life is too short for all this nonsense.
Darren C
10-14-2016, 05:36 AM
Just to clarify my last post.
I understand DOC don't sell the ball joints but they actively direct members to the manufacturer of the Eurotec joint rather than Eurotec themselves.
The new ball joint is made to an old 1980's in house OEM specification drawing.
Thanks
chris williams
10-14-2016, 06:14 AM
No Feud Darren, I was just responding to a posting from some one who made a comment about the mark up on a product and directed them to the supplier that had been mentioned in a previous posting. Also to make the point that they also made other great products that were far superior (In my opinion) to other products available, If anything increasing sales. I buy parts for my cars (and for other peoples I do occasional work on) from lots of places inc the Eurotec forum/SpecialT/Ed. However any buyer should also factor in possible import charges/and VAT reductions for overseas sales.
The quote from you was to back up the point that they were the best choice for OE arms (again in my opinion) based upon the work/research you had done. Like yourself I have done many hours work developing new parts (with manufacturers) that are sold through various sources Spax/HEL brake and clutch lines and like yourself made this information available to all to benefit everyone.
However like a lot of people my funds are limited and always try to point out the options for others to hopefully help people save a few $ if possible. There is no personal feud, not from me anyway. X ref's to both forums are placed on both forums and I recently commented (on the DOC forum) on what good value injectors were from the Eurotec forum. As you wrote we don't sell those parts so there was no benefit to us, and as I wrote at the start it was to point out the options if any one was unhappy with paying a mark up to any vendor.
Chris
DeLoreanGo Arran
10-14-2016, 07:05 AM
to try and help on the costs you can always buy them direct from the manufacturers as a lot of UK owners do by contacting the manufacturers direct
comment about the mark up on a product
like a lot of people my funds are limited and always try to point out the options for others to hopefully help people save a few $ if possible.
point out the options if any one was unhappy with paying a mark up to any vendor.
Sorry if my reply to your points wasn't obvious before Chris, I will try and clarify, it isn't cheaper buying direct from Amsteer, wherever you are. They, like every other vendor, sell all of their products in singles, we sell them in pairs. So you have to do some maths when comparing.
I attach comparison baskets with shipping to the USA - prices here shown in pounds, but you get the idea. £11 ($13.50) more to buy direct. There is no import tax (and no VAT) into the USA. The savings within the UK and the EU are even greater, because VAT is then added to the Amsteer direct price (e.g. shipped within the UK it is actually over £28 MORE to buy direct...).
46665 46666
Apologies to the OP - just fact checking :)
chris williams
10-14-2016, 07:24 AM
Sorry if my reply to your points wasn't obvious before Chris, I will try and clarify, it isn't cheaper buying direct from Amsteer, wherever you are. They, like every other vendor, sell all of their products in singles, we sell them in pairs. So you have to do some maths when comparing.
I attach comparison baskets with shipping to the USA - prices here shown in pounds, but you get the idea. £11 ($13.50) more to buy direct. There is no import tax (and no VAT) into the USA. The savings within the UK and the EU are even greater, because VAT is then added to the Amsteer direct price (e.g. shipped within the UK it is actually over £28 MORE to buy direct...).
Unlike what your trying to point out, I never at any point mentioned that it was. As I wrote it was more to point out that it was the best product available at the moment for the OE arms (agreeing with Darren) and replying to a comment about the mark up on the item and directing them to the web site that showed the higher price. (cant do right for been seeing to do wrong :slap:) And they do sell them at a lower price than advertised, but again your trying to take it all the wrong way. Anyway this is taking it all off topic and I'm sure now one feels that is helpful.
Apologies if anything's taken the wrong way but it's not the intention.
Chris
axh174
10-14-2016, 05:51 PM
Just to clarify - delorean.eu lower ball joints are not the same as deloreanclub.uk lower ball joints. And delorean.eu is not in the UK ;) - although granted, for a while they did sell the UK ball joint there too (not anymore).
The "good" ones referenced in this thread are the ones that we sell - known as the "UK balljoints" and "EuroTec balljoints". Sold by us ( http://www.deloreanclub.uk/lower-ball-joints-pair.html )
Sorry, my bad. I was under the impression they were the same ball joint since they look so alike. Good to know there's a difference!
For what it's worth, the ball joints I ordered and installed in my Byrnne LCAs are the "good" ones, the UK ball joints from deloreanclub.uk (just checked my receipts). Again, the LCA that was well-machined accepted the UK ball joint without any issue. The other LCA had a ridge of flash that I needed to dremel down before it would accept the ball joint. I used one of those giant "c-clamp" ball joint replacement kits that you can rent from Advance Auto Parts and a not unreasonable about of elbow grease.
-Kevin
VIN2234
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.