Ah, crap. Oh well, worth a shot. What were you thinking of making the replacements out of? I saw you mention the hard craft store foam - if you mean the green crap it is just that... Lol. It will flake everywhere and if your girlfriend puts her feet on the kneepads, they will crush and deform permanently

Might be a cool exercise to have some sheet metal bent into the right shape and put some padding on, then the vinyl. I don't know if that would be prohibitively expensive, especially with the need to weld in studs. Good luck!